9 ms·
Idaho murders: Suspect was identified through DNA using genealogy databases
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sn_master 4y agoWhat I was surprised to learn is that even fingerprints contain DNA, not just bodily fluids. "The researchers found that archived latent prints indeed contained DNA and, using optimized methods, they were able to recover at least a partial DNA profile 90% of the time. One sample even produced a full profile." https://nij.ojp.gov/topics/articles/dna-our-fingertips https://nij.ojp.gov/topics/articles/dna-our-fingertips
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- javajosh 4y ago>What I was surprised to learn is that even fingerprints contain DNA, not just bodily fluids. A single skin cell contains all your DNA. However it's not enough to sequence. Call me an old cynic, but this smells like parallel reconstruction to cover up the real story.
- smitty1e 4y agoThese days, skepticism is always in order.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cjensen 4y ago"However it's not enough to sequence" I'm not sure what you mean by that. The nice thing about DNA is you can make more of it if you don't have enough. [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polymerase_chain_reaction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polymerase_chain_reaction
- javajosh 4y agoHow do you ensure that you don't amplify the wrong sample? That would seem to be the crux of the matter, especially for a sample from a fingerprint. Seems like most of the time you'll end up sequencing non-human DNA, given the disgustingness of the biological environment. EDIT: ...or another persons DNA. Note that in general you aren't sequencing against a desired match, but generating a target for some future sequence (obtained from a suspect) to match against.
- dylan604 4y agohow can there be a wrong sample? if the sample leads to someone that they can prosecute, it can't be wrong. only guilty leave DNA samples at crime scenes. this is known.
- kenmacd 4y agoPretty sure this is sarcasm, but for general interest I'll mention the Phantom of Heilbronn (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phantom_of_Heilbronn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phantom_of_Heilbronn), "responsible" for multiple murders, but really just an employee at the company that made the cotton swabs that got used for DNA collection.
- dylan604 4y agoYes on the sarcasm, but even better on you for posting an interesting link for a reply.
- asdff 4y agoIf you take a sample at a crime scene and its a match to your suspect, then there's no question what it is. If you sequence non human DNA you won't get a match. If you sequence the forensic lab technician's DNA by accident when taking the fingerprint sample you still won't get a match to the suspect.
- candiodari 4y ago
- ROTMetro 4y agoIronic that the original purpose of fingerprint matching itself is subjective pseudo science, just like bite mark comparisons, ballistic comparisons, and shoe and tire prints. But that doesn't stop them from being used.
- sn_master 4y agoBite mark was proven false, but what's suspicious about matching fingerprints?
- giantg2 4y agoI don't know how true it is but I've heard that they haven't done any studies to find out how likely it is that two people have the same prints. I have also heard that there is no objective criteria for things like number of matching points to determine a "match". But maybe the original commenter has additonal info, or other people have info to refute it.
- mc32 4y agoThe only things I can think of is that partials can match other fingers’s fingerprints and the temporal aspect —when was the print left, in the act of committing the crime or before or after? Still it’s not pseudoscience like lie detectors, bitemark and bloodsplatter analyses.
- tedunangst 4y agohttps://sites.rutgers.edu/fingerprinting/ https://sites.rutgers.edu/fingerprinting/
- thrwawy74 4y agoSpeaking as a non-expert, it sounds too good to be true with the regular reports of false-positives and false-negatives from DNA testing. I'm with this person: They did something illegal to save lives.
- vba616 4y agoIt seems reasonable that DNA evidence should not be used to convict someone alone, but if it's used as a starting point to find other evidence, well and good. Couldn't that other evidence be perfectly legal but not publicized yet?
- asdff 4y agoThese reports are not regular to be honest... "Think of it this way: There are many thousands of paintings with blue backgrounds, but fewer with blue backgrounds and yellow flowers, and fewer still with blue backgrounds, yellow flowers, and a mounted knight in the foreground. When a forensic analyst compares alleles at 13 locations—the standard for most labs—the odds of two unrelated people matching at all of them are less than one in 1 billion." 1 In the past, there were issues with not getting these 13 sites sufficiently covered and losing statistical power. Today, to get around issues of certain markers dropping out for different reasons and to continue to ensure high statistical power, the FBI uses 20 markers now and samples must have a sufficient number of markers covered to be considered. 2 1. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/06/a-reasonable-doubt/480747/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/06/a-reaso... 2. https://www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2016/12/nist-research-enables-enhanced-dna-fingerprints https://www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2016/12/nist-research-...
- tinus_hn 4y ago> the odds of two unrelated people matching at all of them are less than one in 1 billion. Sounds like on a world with 7 billion people for each crime there are on average 7 people that can be convicted using the incontrovertible evidence delivered by the DNA lab.
- 4y ago
- daemonk 4y agoIt's difficult, but not impossible. There are plenty of whole genome amplification methods out there for single cell DNA-seq.
- asdff 4y agoYou won't be collecting a single skin cell though, you will be collecting millions in that speck and there's plenty of redundancy there. Plus you don't need to cover the entire genome, just some variant sites that can give you enough statistical power to be confident in the identity of the sample.
- whycome 4y agoWas the article headline updated to include the “Police say”? Because it’s good to see that police statements aren’t just accepted as fact and also need to be verified
- vba616 4y agoAn obvious question that perhaps has been researched - I'm curious how many different individuals' DNA would normally be found using current methods at a given site? Surely they don't just take a sample from a likely location and assume it's the perp?
- Gibbon1 4y agoThere was a case a couple years ago in Santa Clara county where the DNA of a hopeless drunk that a paramedic treated ended up under the fingernails of a murder victim that the paramedic also treated a couple hours later.
- asdff 4y agoYou don't even need a fingerprint, you can detect DNA in the air 300 yards away: https://www.science.org/content/article/dna-pulled-thin-air-identifies-nearby-animals https://www.science.org/content/article/dna-pulled-thin-air-...
- whycome 4y agoIn the future we will have surveillance cameras and surveillance dna sniffers.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- google234123 4y agoDoes that mean that this guy used a service or was a close family member found?
- m4jor 4y agoFrom my understanding, you dont even have to do it directly. If any family member does it, you are still toast.
- pfdietz 4y agoThe genealogical technique can work even if only distant relatives have done it.
- _eht 4y agoWell, I suppose you still have to do the murdering…
- chromatin 4y agoThink bigger: just being an enemy of an unfriendly state, potentially in your own country 25 years hence, who knows?
- null_object 4y ago> Think bigger: just being an enemy of an unfriendly state, potentially in your own country 25 years hence, who knows? I don’t understand the logic of the supposed threat you’re talking about: if you’re so worried about some future dystopian authority that throws its ‘enemies’ into prison without them committing any crime, why would they need a relative’s long-ago stored DNA to do it?
- swader999 4y agoA foreign adversary hacks the ancestry database and creates individually targeted genetic attacks.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chromatin 4y agoUnfortunately, my in-laws did one of these services, which means my children are now potentially identifiable to some future unfriendly regime. This is a disaster for human rights advocates of the future.
- sacrosancty 4y ago[dead]
- bryan0 4y agoWhat’s the use case here? A state wants to find all members of a certain family, so they get DNA from the population and compare against a genealogy database? Seems like there would be more straightforward ways to achieve this?
- sva_ 4y agoA bunch of people could be doing political activism at some location and be tracked down. Such scenarios don't seem too far fetched and the way these things will be abused in the future will probably be much more perverse, in ways we can't even imagine today.
- nelox 4y agoPhilip K. Dick had some ideas: The End of Genetic Privacy in the Blade Runner Canon - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9731365/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9731365/
- sofixa 4y ago> Such scenarios don't seem too far fetched They kind of do though. > A bunch of people could be doing political activism at some location and be tracked down Considering political activism is usually in groups out in the open, how practical would be to find the people participating via DNA tests (of what? maybe if they spit on the ground?), compared to the already existing and used phone geolocation and face recognition? Yes those can be protected against by not carrying a phone and wearing a mask/balaclava, but one can also take steps not to leave any DNA residue of use. So I think it's pretty far fetched, and if you're concerned about your government abusing political activists (within reason of course, coup plotters are also technically political activists but not the type one wants to protect) there are better things to do than to focus on one specific impractical avenue of recognition that could lead to abuse.
- dboreham 4y agoHmm. So it went: <DNA at crime scene -> <magic DNA database> -> <DMV database> -> White Elantra ?? Why didn't they just say "we're looking for this guy", vs "we're looking for a white Elantra"? Any time I see LE seemingly making an unlikely breakthrough, I suspect they constructed the apparent evidence to cover up use of illegal mass surveillance tech. e.g. those times when the mass murderer "happens to be pulled over for having a broken tail light".
- bryan0 4y agoI think it was more parallel than that: while we’re running crime scene dna against genealogy dbs, let’s also look for hits on an a white Elantra at the scene. Notice they also said the Elantra was a dead-end last week, so at that point they probably already matched the owner with the dna and knew where they were.
- dboreham 4y agoSome more detailed reporting today reveals that you're probably right: they first identified the set of people or vehicles in the area/time. Then they collected DNA and cross-checked the DNA with the set of area/time suspects. That led them to the suspect. Everything after that was just waiting to see if he would incriminate himself further? or perhaps just to make the movie plot more interesting?
- superfrank 4y agoI'm pretty sure the white Elantra was a tip from the public and its discovery wasn't related to the DNA at all. IIRC, a night shift gas station attendant was going through tapes on the night of the murder to see if they could help and something about the Elantra stood out.
- djmips 4y agoThat story I've heard as well but could it have been planted? It sounds a bit fishy.
- Eric_WVGG 4y agoGenealogy is a network, so on a related note: I was reading the article and found a couple of the names interesting and distinctive, and did a cursory search — all of the victims have active social media accounts that are still publicly available for anyone to peer into. Ghoulish. If I was a parent I wouldn't even know where to begin with drawing the curtains over my late children's lives. Unless they wanted to leave some kind of living testament? As an industry, we're not thinking about things like this, because we don't like difficult, nuanced questions.
- doc_gunthrop 4y agoThe infamous Golden State Killer was found using a genealogy database as well. Veritasium made a YT video about it.
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- Ccecil 4y agoSome people are commenting a lot about parallel reconstruction and such. Here are a few key points from a long time North Idaho resident and someone who has spent quite a bit of time in the town. -DNA was probably used for sure to narrow things down...once you find any sort of special DNA grouping it shouldn't be too hard to narrow down even if you don't have a database with a hit (i.e. Pennsylvania dutch or similar). Then once you have an actual suspect...you find some garbage or discarded item and do a more direct test for certainty. But I suspect filtering by genetic markers and white Hyundai gets you a lot closer than it might seem. -Some are skeptical about the car being randomly identified...but this town is very small. There are not a lot of entrances/exits from the area. When I saw the location of the murders my first thought was "this person could very well be living in Pullman" since the nearby road leads directly there. It is very hard to not be forced to drive past cameras or businesses when attempting to leave the area. -Idaho (particularly North Idaho) took a considerable amount of the homeland security money 20 or so years back and spent quite a bit on license plate scanners, highway cameras...etc. You pass at least 3 license plate scanners I have seen just between Coeur d'Alene and Spokane. I suspect there are more of these we don't know about or are harder to see as well. If there was one of these on each of the 3 or so main routes in/out of town it would be very easy to add this to the list of ways they built the case. -It would be super easy for this person to stalk these girls in the area. Lots of random people, college town, more than one of them worked in the restaurant industry. In the next few weeks I suspect there will be a lot more reports from the area about this person being around creeping people out while they were working. -Also, I want to reiterate how small this town is. You can quite literally explore the entire town in a car within a half hour. Pullman is essentially right next door with little more than some fields and the state line in between. Pullman is equally as small. When the students go home...the town is very empty.