6 ms·
The Moon or even something in LEO make several orders of magnitudes more sense than Mars given our current technological and geopolitical capabilities. I get i
by Dalewyn 4y ago
The Moon or even something in LEO make several orders of magnitudes more sense than Mars given our current technological and geopolitical capabilities.
I get it, colonizing other planets is romantic and awesome. I love science fiction too. But we are in the realm of reality, not fiction, and we have to learn how to crawl before we can walk, let alone run.
Let's figure out how to get permanent LEO human habitation going first, then figure out how to do that on the Moon. Then we can talk about colonizing other planets.
So far we've gotten short-term LEO habitation figured out, albeit with issues concerning expenses and trying to justify it all to the taxpayers.
- randallsquared 4y agoPermanent (self-sufficient) LEO human habitation doesn't make sense because there's no source of material there. Mars has the major benefit that we know that there are raw materials and enough sunlight to turn those materials into various required inputs like methane. LEO definitely doesn't have that, and it's less clear whether anyplace on the Moon has that than it is Mars. Mars is further away in travel time, but not much further in fuel costs, and it's far better than the Moon for living off the land.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoIf you break you neck in LEO you could be in a real hospital in a few hours. From the moon it's a couple days, comparable to like an arctic base dueing a storm. From Mars your family will only get ashes because your body will have been deconposing for months. There is steel, aluminium and oxygen on the moon,'it can host heavy indstry and peoduce ships, space stations, equipment. It can host a space elevator today,'made of normal kevlar. You could build an aircraft carrier and lift it into orbit.
- drevil-v2 4y ago> You could build an aircraft carrier and lift it into orbit No you can’t. You still need to spend the same amount of energy per ton to escape earth’s gravity. An elevator does not magically violate laws of physics Edit: As pointed out below I probably misunderstood the comment I was replying too. My bad
- c22 4y agoThe comment you're responding to is suggesting a space elevator on the moon, so you only need enough energy to escape the moon's gravity.
- throwaway777845 4y ago[dead]
- moloch-hai 4y agoI know somebody who broke his neck in Antarctica and was airlifted out. He's fine now.
- frontman1988 4y agohow does one manage to break their neck in Antarctica?
- moloch-hai 4y agoAll it took was not watching where he was walking. There are hazards outside. Concrete, railings, and painted lines are scarce.
- bratbag 4y agoSo no different than if you broke your neck during the age of discovery on earth? We shouldn't be judging these things by the standards of generally risk averse people on this discussion board. It won't be people like us going.
- gibspaulding 4y agoThe difference today is that the astronaut with the broken neck would be front page news for every minute of the hours/days/weeks it took to get them home, and far longer if they die. Bad press is bad for funding, especially in a democratic country.
- kwhitefoot 4y ago> the astronaut with the broken neck would be front page news for every minute of the hours/days/weeks Only while the thing is rare.
- im3w1l 4y agoA brave explorer dying the martyr death to advance humanity. Give him a hero's funeral and give generous pensions to his relatives. Suddenly it sounds like a sales pitch. Well, to some.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> It won't be people like us going. Is it gonna be disposable lower-class people? In age of doscovery shipowners and governments assumed a 50% death rate from scurvy for their sailors on a major voyage. TThe past is fireign land, executions were a public holiday and children came to watch. We used to gove cocaine to children to stop them crying.
- mlindner 4y ago> Is it gonna be disposable lower-class people? This meme comes from people who've watched too many bad sci-fi shows and don't have a good grasp of history. The people going to space will be the intersection of those who can afford it and those who want and are capable of going. The first people who traveled the oceans were not the lower class. They were the upper class who could afford to fund or pay for the journey by pooling money or independently pay for it. The poor you refer to didn't come until much later in the age of discovery.
- m4rtink 4y agoMany inland Antarctic bases are effectively unreachable for months in Winter. Flying a plane to the station in total darkness many thousand of kilometres in -80 C is a good way to end up with more people killed than you are trying to save.
- kibwen 4y ago> Mars is further away in travel time, but not much further in fuel costs, and it's far better than the Moon for living off the land. The prospect of an inhabited Martian colony living off the land is dismal, for anything except extremely far-future timeframes (thousands of years or more). Any extraplanetary colony is going to be invariably tethered to Earth and highly dependent on imports for survival. The moon has the advantage of not just being closer, but having a launch window of "whenever you feel like it", in contrast to Martian launch windows that occur 26 months apart.
- sobellian 4y agoOn the other hand, I'm curious how the delta-V numbers hold up for landing on the Moon, where aero-braking is impossible. Launch and landing require by far the most delta-V between either of the two bodies, much more than the difference between lunar transfer orbit and Martian transfer.
- ben_w 4y agoOTOH, we can build a lunar space elevator with existing materials because of the lower gravity (even despite the longer distance to L1). Not sure, can we manage that with Mars?
- randallsquared 4y agoMars' moons make a stationary space elevator extremely challenging, even though known material processes are sufficient.
- ben_w 4y agoGood point. They're so small I forgot about them.
- oblio 4y agoBy lunar space elevator I assume you mean an elevator from the lunar surface to the point where lunar gravity is practically 0?
- BariumBlue 4y agoLEO does have export potentials: mainly tourism, r&d, and manufacturing of specific goods. Many countries import the majority of food / material inputs, but output high quality manufacturing, technical, and entertainment goods.
- bckr 4y ago> Permanent (self-sufficient) LEO human habitation doesn't make sense because there's no source of material there Whole books have been written on the raw materials available in space, both from the moon and from Near Earth Objects.[] Mars is a bad idea that needs to go away before we lose the opportunity to perform the actual next step, which O'Neill and others mapped out decades ago. [] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mining_the_Sky https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mining_the_Sky
- lindsaywaterman 4y agoI think of starship works well permanent LEO habitation is next. Once space access is cheap enough…space hotels are an obvious first move to commercialization.
- Isinlor 4y agoIt's not about current capabilities, but future capabilities. > But we are in the realm of reality, not fiction, and we have to learn how to crawl before we can walk, let alone run. In either case, the main challenge, is rapid rockets reusability. Nothing comes even close to the second place. The costs of delivering one kg of materials to space must go down by 10 to 100 times.
- tsimionescu 4y agoAs the article points out, that's not even in the top 100 things. Having a self-sustaining living space is by far the biggest problem (one where all of the waste we produce can be reused to create new drinkable water, air and food, and to reliably continue to do so between Mars launch windows). The second biggest is probably avoiding contamination of Mars, if we actually care about exploring one of the biggest mysteries of life - has it arisen only on Earth? Are there other modes of life possible, and what do they look like? The third biggest challenge is human psychology and physiology - could we actually get a group of ~100 people or however many we need initially to live and be productive for the years-long space mission (including travel time to and from)? What do we do when at least one of them inevitably gets sick on Mars? Each of these problems is fractally more complex than I make it out to be, and none of them would be fixable if rockets were very cheap. And these are just problems for a limited time Martian outpost, similar to a trip to the ISS. Thinking about an actual colony with some prospect of perpetual habitation being in orders of magnitude more issues, some of which may not even be solvable without biologically altering humans to make a new Mars-adapted species of hominid.
- Isinlor 4y agoNone of issues you listed matter at all if launching stuff to space is cost prohibitive. Without cheap space access they are not even worth properly researching. > One where all of the waste we produce can be reused to create new drinkable water, air and food, and to reliably continue to do so between Mars launch windows. None of that is as big of an issue if you can launch often and a lot of stuff. In the limit you don't need to recycle anything and everything has multiple spares. You can also launch outside direct constraints of Hohmann transfer orbit. Again, payload limitations and time are the main reasons we use Hohmann transfer orbits. > The second biggest is probably avoiding contamination of Mars, if we actually care about exploring one of the biggest mysteries of life - has it arisen only on Earth? Are there other modes of life possible, and what do they look like? We will not avoid contamination. It's impossible to do. Where humans go our microbiome will follow. I personally think we should intentionally seed all celestial bodies with life as soon as possible anyway. If we find life in our solar system (especially life independent from Earth) we should become a lot more aggressive with space settlement, because it would make "great filter" ahead of us hypothesis a lot more likely. Settlement outside solar system should become one of humanity priorities as a matter of survival. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter > The third biggest challenge is human psychology and physiology Going to Mars can be a suicide mission and you will still find people who will be willing to go. Not a showstopper for the willing. > Thinking about an actual colony with some prospect of perpetual habitation being in orders of magnitude more issues First things first.
- mlindner 4y ago15 days of continuous darkness followed by 15 days of continuous sunlight is rather difficult to deal with operationally, biologically and mechanically. This causes lots of mechanical stresses. Also there's micrometeorites that you need to protect against in LEO or on the Moon. The temperature extremes on Mars are nowhere near what they are on the Moon or in LEO. In LEO further you have no gravity and no materials so the only going there is bringing whatever you want to do there with you. There's no resources that can be used. With no gravity also many things simply can't work. For example you can't run any pumps that pump liquids built in a normal manner. You can't rely on gravity to separate or settle liquids.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]