10 ms·
“Internet in space” will transform the satellite imagery industry
- xrayarx 4y agoThe topic seems to be a worthwhile rabbit hole
- aml183 4y agoJoe is one of the most knowledgeable person in the world on satellite imagery. He’s a must read.
- georgeg23 4y agoThis author? According to his LinkedIn he's only been in the space industry for exactly 2 years. This article also reads as very superficial.
- aml183 4y agoIf you work in the space, he is one of the most well respected people.
- m2fkxy 4y agohe's at least very communicative and pedagogical, and has a refreshing view of EO. reading him, Aravind, and Payload (thanks for it) is a good way to set you up on what's going on in the space-based EO industry.
- georgeg23 4y agoOK makes sense, this Payload Space blog is 1.5 years old. So Joe would be pretty experienced by those standards. Payload is also super SDA focused.. seems like an echo-chamber for the DoD.
- aml183 4y agoInteresting, would you prefer we cover more commercial space?
- campchase 4y agoStop snoopin and send me a connection request, George!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- executive 4y agohttps://www.cnbc.com/2022/12/16/maxar-selling-to-private-equity-investors-advent-bci.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/12/16/maxar-selling-to-private-equ...
- rektide 4y agoThere were some comments yesterday on tracking subs, talking about the throughput requirements. It made me think about another bit of orbital infrastructure: in-orbit inference engines on satellites, so processing on vast gobs of data can happen without beaming the reams of data down. But yeah, seems like interoperable space protocols are starting up. BACN-Mesh works. Maybe not quite so important & I forget the name but I feel like there were some command protocols starting to emerge into semi-standard form as well.
- theptip 4y ago> in-orbit inference engines on satellites, so processing on vast gobs of data can happen without beaming the reams of data down. It’s a good idea, and I bet folks like Cloudflare that already operate Edge Compute platforms will have a head-start here.
- jvanderbot 4y agoThe bottleneck for orbital edge isn't software, it's hardware that can tack into an optical terminal and tolerate radiation. The edge analogy breaks down because the consumer isn't on the edge, the sensor is, and it's just a problem of doing heavy compute next to the sensor, then sending back a summary data product. After that, networking is well understood.
- theptip 4y agoIoT sensor aggregation is already a major edge-compute use-case, it's not just for reducing latency for end-users. In this analogy you're just co-locating the edge compute on the same LAN as the sensor. All of the orchestration, runtime, and framework concerns from existing edge compute systems still apply. Edge compute isn't solved; it's an area under active and aggressive development. The Cloudflare Workers wasm runtime for example. And if you're selling satelite edge compute, what's your control plane? You need a config store etc. Put differently; if I'm a satelite operator writing first-party software to run on my satelites, sure, there's no framework code to write, and I can just tailor the software to my satelite platform's hardware. However, if I'm selling colocated compute with ultra-low latency to third parties, then I need to build something that (IMO) looks very close, if not identical, to a current-generation edge-compute platform.
- qqumut 4y ago[flagged]
- orbital-decay 4y agoRemote sensing is severely limited by latency and throughput of the downlink, as it needs to push mountains of data in a tiny window when the satellite is passing over the ground station once in a while. "Internet in Space" will help to remove (or reduce) this limitation.
- nradov 4y agoIn a conflict with a near-peer adversary, the attrition rate on reconnaissance satellites in LEO is going to be high. So, it will also be important for satellites to downlink their data quickly before they get knocked out.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- strangattractor 4y agoHad a dinner conversation with a person who had worked for military intelligence back in the day. At one time a receiving station was located in Antartica. For Polar orbit satellites this insured reception once per orbit. Since it was so cold the only reliable media for storage they could use was paper tape.
- inetknght 4y ago> Since it was so cold the only reliable media for storage they could use was paper tape Sure hope that tape never froze...
- campchase 4y agoConvenient
- treis 4y agoThat doesn't really make sense given we have buildings and heaters.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> we have buildings and heaters These can fail and give off a heat signature.
- georgeg23 4y agoThis guy is really drinking the space militarization Kool aid that the SDA is churning out. It's sad to see another young generation getting sucked into the military industrial complex
- m2fkxy 4y agoin Earth observation, defence money is ultimately the one funding your ventures.
- Invictus0 4y agoCan we maybe focus on the technology and not ideology?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- georgeg23 4y agoEngineers play one of the most pivotal roles in war and loss of human life, and many don't even realize it. Something that needs to be reflected on more.
- jimmaswell 4y agoOn reflection, if my side doesn't militarize space then another side will dominate and make the rules. Might as well work with my side on it and also get scientific advancements out of it. Even in the advanced age of Star Trek we needed defensive capabilities.
- georgeg23 4y agoBefore you do that, you might want to understand the other side, and how ignorance contributes to an unnecessary arms race. We in the US have driven most provocation in space. The military budget is more than the next nine countries combined (including China). Whether it be the Strategic Defense Initiative, unilaterally leaving the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty, Prompt Global Strike, hypersonic missiles, the US is developing escalatory weapons tech then justifying it with delusions that the same exists in other countries, like those weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. Weaponization of space has always been touted as the ultimate high ground, but we seem to have forgotten the lessons and mistakes of raising the stakes, https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_Defense_Initiative https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_Defense_Initiative In an age of nuclear weapons, new "disruptive" strategic technology development can be extremely dangerous and destablizing.. this is not a game humanity can afford to play.
- Invictus0 4y agoSo sat-to-sat connectivity will enable 1) software updates on the sats so that you can do your post processing in space, 2) you can rapidly downlink in a parallel manner. Seems like a big step forward for the defense industry.
- m2fkxy 4y agotechnically, downlink-while-imaging is not necessarily reliant on sat-to-sat networks, or did I miss something?
- Invictus0 4y agoI was just guessing at what he would write in part 2: if you can disseminate the data rapidly to a network of adjacent satellites, eventually one of those will be in view of the ground station, and if those satellites also have the high-throughput laser capability, then you can really downlink faster.
- m2fkxy 4y agoyes, it sure would be an accelerator.
- milgrim 4y agoSoftware updates for satellites have been possible for a long time.
- campchase 4y agoMy name is Joe Morrison, and I’m ready to be roasted on here again. Please feel free to ask me anything or challenge any of what I’ve written!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- punnerud 4y agoFirst thank you for the article. Looking forward to Part II. Two questions: How do see the chances for other competitors to be able to catch up with SpaceX/Starlink? And are there some other challenges than congestested space and congestested frequency spectrum, when there will be several competitors in space?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> How do see the chances for other competitors to be able to catch up with SpaceX/Starlink? Not the author, but Starlink’s parallel competitive threats are usually exaggerated. They have cheap capital and they own their own trucks. That helps. But it’s not a blocking advantage. Their existing fleet is only a marginal competitive advantage to a new sensor suite; there is little evidence they build better birds than anyone else (versus their rockets, which are in a class of their own). > congestested frequency spectrum Lasers.
- georgeg23 4y agoAn order of magnitude lower launch costs to LEO (about $1K/kg now for Falcon 9) and another two magnitudes with Starship.. is a blocking advantage. Constellations don't make sense otherwise, see history: https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Starlink#Background https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Starlink#Background Keep in mind lasers don't work to the ground unless there are no clouds and stable atmosphere. RF 10-30 GHz work fine to ground and are directional enough that spectrum can be reused and multiple beams formed with one phased array. The real limitation is ITU regulation on total power flux density on the ground for all constellations in these frequencies.
- phkahler 4y agoI figure the market for "low" resolution imagery will be destroyed when Starlink decides to add something like a fixed wide angle 100 megapixel cameras to every satellite. There are a lot of options for what to do from there, but getting continuous global imagery would suddenly be possible.
- ge96 4y agoCapture the Earth's surface state from giant sphere "pano", run simulations off of it
- campchase 4y agoCould be. I still think the juice won’t be worth the squeeze (is there an example in the history of comms satellites where they felt it was worth going after the much smaller EO market?). But the rumor in the industry is that they’re comin for everything. And they did just announce a new satellite platform for hosting payloads (including optical).
- bagels 4y agoPlanet Labs captures ~30 megapixel images (usually though, these are quoted in terms of pixel size, eg. 5 meters per pixel) and has hundreds of satellites on orbit. I don't know about Digital Globe's capabilities, but they are also in this business as are others. Would 100 megapixels make a big difference in availability?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Would 100 megapixels make a big difference in availability No. Everyone talks a big game about SAR and resolution because it’s easier than latency. People don’t pay for resolution, they pay for immediacy. (The folks who do pay for resolution typically have their own birds. There simply aren’t many use cases for occasionally needing hyper-resolution photos of what something looked like a few days or even hours ago.)
- astrange 4y ago
- layer8 4y agoSounds like near-realtime Google Earth is still way, way off.
- fnands 4y agoIf you don't mind ~3m resolution you could pay Planet labs for a roughly once a day (weather dependent) Google Earth. However, large parts of google earth uses aerial (i.e. non satellite) imagery. So yeah, way of. Also, if you do a quick back of the napkin math, it's a lotta data.
- hoseja 4y agoI've had a thought, why isn't there a "Blue Marble Livestream"? Like actual image of the entire Earth, from like 20000 km orbit. Is there one actually? Will there be one in near future?