4 ms·
> The company wouldn't employ you if you weren't providing them more than you cost them. This is a stabilizing (therefore desirable) feature in the system, not
by sokoloff 4y ago
> The company wouldn't employ you if you weren't providing them more than you cost them.
This is a stabilizing (therefore desirable) feature in the system, not a bug. I want that (and work hard to ensure that) my company receives more value from me than I cost them. That makes them want to retain me in a stable relationship that benefits both of us. I don't want their surplus to be too great, but I want there to be a definite, undeniable surplus on their end.
The alternative is far worse: if you are costing the company ore than the value you're providing, a rational company should fire you to improve their company. That they haven't means you're working for incompetent leaders in the best case (and leaders who are about to fire you in a worse case).
- Terretta 4y agoNot just stable, "I very evidently more than pay for myself" is how you get raises above inflation. In general, show you more than pay for yourself in a month, you can write your own raise.
- Balgair 4y agoGosh I wish that was true.
- lumost 4y agoThis assumes the company knows how to value your work. I started my career in operations working at companies that pioneered working in public clouds. What this meant was long weeks, missed sleep, and thankless work. I saved the companies millions per year through improved resource allocation, high uptime, and fast deployment cycles. Invariably, company management viewed the above as an expense to incur only as long as infra was percieved as a problem. In my third year of experience I had a banger of a year at a startup and could rightfully claim 3 million per year in savings. In uncertain terms it was implied to me that I wasn’t expected to stick around for the second year but I was given a 2% raise out of kindness :shrug: Management generally views themselves as valuable, and finds people like themselves as valuable. I got wise to this and transitioned fields.
- germinalphrase 4y agoInto management or into a field with less management?
- lumost 4y agoAn adjacent field that was higher value. I’ve made a bit of a career transitioning fields and now work on a mix of ml and database internals at a large tech company.
- ianai 4y agoExactly my experience in ops as well across very different industries. Ops feels like a stain on my career at times, bizarrely. The past was no picnic, but I know there was better respect towards the workers in decades gone by. I remember a “how to get rich” book from back then talking about not hiring or contracting the absolute cheapest bid, believe it or not. It preached making sure your side of the deal didn’t come at an unfair cost to another side. Believe it or not. The long timers in LV who had worked in both the mob days and corporate america/modern had a strong preference for working for the mob. That should tell it all.
- Terretta 4y agokey word "evidently" ... you have to ensure it's evident to the evaluators, or find different evaluators .. maybe even make yourself the evaluator by starting your own thing // I didn't say this was easy. I said it was how.
- mox1 4y agoThat’s easy to say when you take home 300k and the company generates 600k of revenue per employee. It’s totally different when you are making $18 / hour and the company calculates your value at $19. Screw up a little bit your done. Push you to work extra for free and they just doubled your net value!
- smeej 4y agoBut this assumes your only option is employment, which is exactly the opposite of my point. If, as another commenter said, I'm generating $600k of value and only being paid $300k, it's easier now than it ever has been for me to reduce my effort and generate, say, $450k, and still get to keep $300k of it working for myself. I can reduce my output my 25% without reducing my income. That's not to say it's easy, just easier than it ever has been, and people are figuring that out.
- sokoloff 4y agoThe other commenter posited $600K of revenue, which is not value. The absolute cap on direct value would be revenue times contribution margin percentage. If the CM% for your company is 60%, they're making a CM of $360K on the marginal $600K of revenue while paying you $300K. If you reduce that $600K to $450K of revenue, the CM becomes $270K while paying you $300K, meaning a rational employer should fire you.
- smeej 4y agoYou're missing the whole point again, which is that by leaving the company, you don't have to produce as much revenue or value for you, yourself, to RETAIN the same amount of money as income. Yes, a company should fire you of you reduce production by 25% and require the same payment. But the whole point is that all these people are figuring out they don't need the company for their income as much as the company needs them for the revenue they produce.
- quadrifoliate 4y agoYou want the company to make more revenue from you than you're costing. I agree with this, and try to keep this balance myself in my job. > The alternative is far worse: if you are costing the company ore than the value you're providing, a rational company should fire you to improve their company. That they haven't means you're working for incompetent leaders in the best case (and leaders who are about to fire you in a worse case). I think the big problem comes from this largely overlooked next part. Companies are rarely rational. Some leaders will keep people on staff just to show that they are a big team. Some leaders have cronies. Some are just super incompetent themselves; and seem to use the Dilbert Principle [1] as a guiding light by promoting their incompetent cronies or flatterers to high positions. Often, they will snare workers in a lot of make-work tasks while awarding huge bonuses to themselves. Anyone in management is rarely fired -- you will often see managers who have been at the same job for 20 years coasting by just as much as, if not more than their employees. It seems to me that the overlooked part of "quiet quitting" is due to workers noticing this sort of problem in their management; and taking that into account while deciding how long they work. And, oddly enough I don't think this is at odds with what you said -- basically, the more irrationally a company seems to behave, the more they will get people who want to coast since they realize the irrationality. I feel like a good way to right the ship is to promote a lot more rationality into management; and quickly get rid of managers who seem toxic, prone to cronyism, or having a lot of attitude about "these people work for me". ---------------------------------------- [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dilbert_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dilbert_principle, says (semi-humorously) that the most incompetent people usually get promoted to management to prevent them from doing more damage in IC positions