5 ms·
I found myself agreeing with every word of this article. The penultimate paragraph summarizes it well: > People call Twitter an indispensable public space beca
by lapcat 4y ago
I found myself agreeing with every word of this article. The penultimate paragraph summarizes it well:
> People call Twitter an indispensable public space because it’s the “town square”, but in the real world there isn’t just one town square, because there isn’t just one town. There are many. And the internet works when you can exit — when you can move to a different town if you don’t like the mayor or the local culture.
> Disagreement in society is necessary for progress, but it’s most constructive when it’s mediated by bonds of trust and affinity and semi-privacy.
- adesanmi 4y agoSame here. The biggest annoyance for me was whenever people use the “town square” analogy, especially as a Brit. The idea that my “town square” is owned by a private American company is a nightmare.
- wardedVibe 4y agoFor what its worth, for a number of decades, American town squares have in many places been shopping malls, which are privately owned. There are several states where protestors can be thrown out of malls[0], free speech be damned. I'm frankly glad they're struggling. [0] https://www.mprnews.org/story/2015/12/22/protests-first-amendment-public-space-vs-private https://www.mprnews.org/story/2015/12/22/protests-first-amen...
- Thorentis 4y agoGo to the average British town square and tell me how many logos you can spot of American owned companies.
- nonethewiser 4y agoPeople don't want actually want that though. They want everyone on twitter. Not a small circle of 200 people.
- danShumway 4y agoI don't have super-strong opinions on network size necessarily, but assuming that what you say is true, and that this isn't a generational/cultural preference that might evolve over time, it still doesn't strike me as a particularly powerful critique? The argument here isn't that small towns are preferable, the argument is that they are better, and that they lead to overall healthier social groups. I don't want to exercise. I want to eat sugar, I don't want eat whole foods. I might as well say, "when are these doctors going to realize that eating healthy and exercising isn't what people actually want to do?" Whether or not smaller communities are healthier can be debated, but whether or not people want to have smaller social networks is kind of orthogonal to that debate. You can advocate for something that is healthier and that will make your life better and that will overall make you happier if you put in the effort to pursue it, while acknowledging that people are not generally biologically inclined to want to do that thing. In fact, most healthy things that we advocate for in life are not things that we instinctively want to do and are things that require conscious effort and conscious denial of behaviors that we might prefer -- that is in many ways the norm, not an exception.
- Sakos 4y agoI've experimented with something similar. Back when I still had a Facebook account, I unfollowed all of my friends (and purged my list to the bare minimum) and joined a bunch of local/regional groups. It infinitely improved Facebook as a tool for connecting with other people.