5 ms·
What is the justification for being able to change the terms after the votes have taken place?
by Gigachad 4y ago
What is the justification for being able to change the terms after the votes have taken place?
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoRight? That seems pretty antithetical to democracy. At least where I live, when the senate doesn't like a bill, they send it back to Parliament with recommendations. They can't just tack on whatever they feel like and ascend it from there.
- nonethewiser 4y agoSeems pretty typical of a republic though.
- 58028641 4y agoThe legislature agreed to the changes.
- phpisthebest 4y agoI have asked this repeatedly. Maybe you can answer it Outside of the quote from the governor where she makes this statement, WHERE is this agreement? Under what authority was the agreement made, WHO in the legislature agreed to it? Under what authority did this person(s) make the agreement I ask because currently the NY legislature is not in session, and no vote could have taken place which is normally how one gets an "agreement" from a legislature
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lbotos 4y agoI like you have seen that line parroted, and I thought this would be the place that shows the state of affairs: https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2021/s4104/amendment/a https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2021/s4104/amendm... Hasn't been updated yet.
- ceejayoz 4y agoIt reads like either a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signing_statement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signing_statement sort of scenario, or that there's been an agreement with leadership to push through an amending law as soon as possible.
- phpisthebest 4y agoGiven that the original law was passed with a veto proof majority, what happens if the actual members of the legislature simply refuse to pass an amending law?
- kwiens 4y agoThe governor told the legislative sponsors that they had to accept these changes or she would veto the bill. It was accept this reduction, or nothing.
- kevingadd 4y agoDidn't it pass with a veto-proof majority?
- kova12 4y agoRepresentatives won't be picking the fight against governor since there's a chance that said governor might veto something else with their name on it. One hand rubs another in other words.
- Jon_Lowtek 4y agoCan the original sponsors just change the bill, between the bill passing the senate and the governor signing it, without having such amendments voted on by the senate and assembly?
- scifibestfi 4y agoThe government's #1 excuse for anything they want to do without having to actually justify it: "Safety"
- fear_and_coffee 4y agoThe government's will mysteriously synched with corporate interests
- richbell 4y agoThe word of the day is "Regulatory Capture". (Yes, I know that's two words, "don't @ me" as the youths would say.)
- hyperhopper 4y agoJust say "phrase"
- joshspankit 4y ago“The only safe way to do _____ is for our competitors to have to play by our rules, on our turf, and with us making sure they don’t do anything we consider unsafe.”
- RobotToaster 4y agoAnd what is "safe" just happens to be exactly what their corporate "donors" want.
- Buraksr 4y agoMy understanding is that it is more a consequence of politics than the system... Sure you have a veto proof majority on this bill, but what about what comes next? The governor is able to stop "tyranny of masses" by their veto power. Almost no bill in our partisan age is able to pass with a veto proof majority. So the governor has the ability to prevent good outcomes for specific members of their party in the legislature in the future. Sure a budget that makes the party and governor look good will pass, but members who "step out of line", will find that they can't "bring home the bacon" in terms of what is allocated to their district. So could the bill be pushed through unmodified despite an governor's veto? Of course. The system expressly allows this given a 2/3rds vote. But the legislature needs to weigh their options: 1.) Have all members push the bill forward anyways 2.) Have just enough members push the bill forward 3.) Accept the governor's revisions and move the bill forward 4.) Drop the bill As a representative it is hard to tell which of 1/2 you are choosing in the moment. The issue is that 2 may paint a target on your back. The members of the party opposing the governor are less incentivized to care about the veto. So do you want the governor to hold a grudge with "1 of X" representatives of their own party who sided against them? Granted the legislature is about 2/3rds democrat, so for a break with the governor to happen maybe half the democratic legislature would have to break with the governor. 3 Is appealing over 4, since you are able to claim victory for now. Something was passed after all, and the name of the bill alone is usually enough to make a good ad come re-election. and if the issues really are so severe, this is just another victory for the future you.
- unity1001 4y ago> "tyranny of masses" That's democracy. If you water down or prevent the democratic will through ANY means to empower the will of the minority over the majority for ANY reason, then you end up implementing the governance of an elite. Minority rights of the people are a different matter - they would be guaranteed by the civil law governing human rights in a country - they dont have anything to do with the democratic will.
- jamiek88 4y agoNo. We live in representative democracies not absolute democracies and these table thumping maximalist positions rarely make good conversation or policy. They get retweeted though.