4 ms·
> It makes it feel very propaganda. That's exactly what it is. These corporations absolutely do tune the output of these AIs to exclude any wrongthink. We nee
by matheusmoreira 4y ago
> It makes it feel very propaganda.
That's exactly what it is. These corporations absolutely do tune the output of these AIs to exclude any wrongthink.
We need the ability to run this technology on our own computers as soon as possible.
- JeremyBanks 4y ago[dead]
- dinkumthinkum 4y agoWould it be better to get these answers from intelligent sources than a pattern matching prediction algorithm?
- coffeeblack 4y agoThe difference is the cost per unit of answer.
- blagie 4y agoIn many cases, the pattern-matching algorithm does better than intelligent sources. For example, in my area of research, if I ask GPT for a lit review, GPT is about as good as a newly-minted PhD in a junior research position. There will be errors and issues, but it's not a bad starting point. Right now, if I'm writing something non-proprietary, I'll sometimes ask GPT for a few drafts first. Outside of my area of research, it's fantastic. Recently, I was doing something which touched on an obscure area of biology. The ability to talk an AI with the background of a newly-minted Ph.D who sometimes makes errors was gold. I needed to verify information provided, but as a first-pass of what to look for or where it look, it was really rather good.
- throwaway14356 4y agoThat was a cool bit of insight. That there is someone to talk about an obscure subject on demand is pretty cool.
- coffeeblack 4y agoThat was the initial reason why Open AI was founded (the driver back then was again Elon Musk), to prevent AI tech being only in the hands of large corporations that have a financial interest in a certain type of AI. Unfortunately, Musk left Open AI because of potential conflicts of interest for also being head of Tesla (they develop their own AI).
- matheusmoreira 4y agoAnd yet this corporation is artificially limiting the potential of this technology because it offends people or copies their work or whatever. I want true output, unfiltered and with zero restrictions. No "company tuning" to make it less controversial.
- l33tman 4y agoTo be fair, this only works for simple commands like "Show me 3 arguments for and against bla bla". As soon as you ask "which of X and Y is better", there will be bias. Should it relate to the number of web pages suggesting X is better? Or should it be able to track arguments down to first principles? It also needs to ask you questions back to figure out what is best for YOU personally, or at least ask you to specify more context. I don't envy the tuners of chatgpt..
- matheusmoreira 4y agoBias is okay if it comes from the source material used to train the AI. What I don't want to see is corporations special casing stuff they deem unacceptable.
- qualudeheart 4y agoWait till someone makes ChatGPT clone with Meta`s OPT-175b. Eleuther can do it.
- coffeeblack 4y agoThere is no “true” output. It all depends on the input. But what seems dangerous is to let ideology influence the output. Not sure how bad it currently is at Open AI. I’ve never been able to get an obviously ideological answer from ChatGPT.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> > It makes it feel very propaganda. > That's exactly what it is Kind of odd that it does it with the question inverted, too. Propaganda for... Both sides of tbe fossil fuel vs. renewables argument?
- matheusmoreira 4y agoThat's not what the post I replied to said. > Whenever I ask anything unaligned with mainstream progressive US culture, I can get an answer, but I can't get one without a disclaimer.
- daveguy 4y agoIt kind of makes sense that GPT would produce propaganda on both sides. These models are trained on internet data. A lot more propaganda than nuanced and factual debate on the internet, no matter the topic or position. It's the same concern with image generation producing pornography. There is a lot more dreck on the internet than quality content.
- generalizations 4y ago> Kind of odd that it does it with the question inverted, too. Except that it doesn't. I ran both questions multiple times, and while it usually includes a token caveat that fossil fuel might have a place, it always strongly suggests that renewables are superior to fossil fuels.
- dumpsterlid 4y ago[dead]
- cauch 4y agoBut what happens when you ask to any unbiased energy experts? I think it is just a factual reality that finding arguments to pretend that fossil fuels are superior to renewable is just more difficult, simply because fossil fuels are indeed problematic. I think the problem of "political neutrality" is that "political neutrality" is different from "unbiased" and "rational". It is easier to find conspiracy theories that are right-wing than to find conspiracy theories that are left-wing (they exist, but for 1 on the left, there are 10 on the right). "political neutrality" would mean that the AI would be biased and would give more credit to a right-wing conspiracy theory than to a left-wing conspiracy theory in order to "avoid rejecting more often theories that are right-wing than theories that are left-wing".
- darthrupert 4y agoOr could it be that one spectrum of any political debate is just wrong, and the language model is capable of revealing that? Fossil fuels vs renewables is clearly such a case, but perhaps this will work on more difficult issues as well?