6 ms·
Association between influenza vaccination and risk of stroke in Alberta, Canada
- benevol 4y ago[flagged]
- christophilus 4y agoWithout specifics, this is just spam.
- grey-area 4y agoFlagged for unsubstantiated conspiracy theories which unfortunately seem prevalent at the moment.
- zeristor 4y agoThe study: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpub/article/PIIS2468-2667(22)00222-5/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpub/article/PIIS2468-2... mentions that the Hazad Ratio is reduced: "Adjusted for demographics and comorbidities, recent influenza vaccination significantly reduced the hazard of stroke (hazard ratio 0·775 [95% CI 0·757–0·793])." I had to look up what a Hazard Ratio is: https://statisticsbyjim.com/probability/hazard-ratio/ https://statisticsbyjim.com/probability/hazard-ratio/ So many improvements seem to be quite meagre, I am not sure how to understand a HR but it looks to be a huge help.
- kuhewa 4y agoOne interpretation would be 1.000 - 0.775 = 22.5% decease risk of stroke after recent flu vax.
- ysleepy 4y agoAnd of Alzheimers. I wonder at what age flu shots provide overwhelming benefits. 40? 50? I'm still reasonably young and don't bother, but maybe I should start getting them. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35723106/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35723106/ Also discussed here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31899781 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31899781
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Alex3917 4y agoNow that the evidence seems pretty clear that it reduces your risk of dying from cardiovascular events by ~30%, you should probably just get it every year: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5256393/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5256393/ It's like bike helmets. I didn't always wear them as a kid because they were uncomfortable, they weren't that effective, and we didn't know how bad head injuries were. But now that they're extremely comfortable, extremely effective, and we know how bad head injuries are, it doesn't really make sense to wear them any less than 100% of the time.
- jtbayly 4y ago100% of the time? I don’t think I’ve ever thought about it, but you’re right. Everybody should be wearing bike helmets all the time to protect against head injuries. Really, we should change the name “bike helmets” to something else if we want people to change their thinking and behavior. Perhaps “personal safety devices”?
- zmgsabst 4y agoWe should mandate them! If we just stopped one of the 1.5 million brain injuries each year — mandating permanently wearing helmets for the entire population is worth it! https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK459300/#_article-31648_s4_ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK459300/#_article-31648...
- criddell 4y ago> If we just stopped one of the 1.5 million brain injuries each year — mandating permanently wearing helmets for the entire population is worth it! I don't think most people would agree with you. If we passed a law in the US mandating no car can be capable of traveling faster than 25 mph, we would save 30,000 lives per year. But we don't do it because driving at higher speeds is worth the trade off in lives.
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoNot trying to be funny, but it's important that in a study like this, you take into account that other causes of mortality might rise, therefore reducing the number of eligible people to die for a stroke, or killing someone faster than an eventual stroke.
- charbull 4y ago100%
- daveguy 4y agoQuite a few comorbities were controlled for. In statistics controlled for means "no, this isn't the reason you're seeing this number." Rather than making vague and unsubstantiated claims. Why don't you tell us what mortality might have risen that you believe confounded the results? And back it up with a study. These are the factors that were chosen a-priori: age, sex, anticoagulant use, atrial fibrillation, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, diabetes, hypertension, income quintile, and rural or urban home location. So unless you have some magical mystery comorbitiy, it was controlled for and therefore your comment is vague confusion peddling.
- petodo 4y agoWhy not link study directly? https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpub/article/PIIS2468-2667(22)00222-5/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpub/article/PIIS2468-2... I may be reading it wrong, but when I look at chart "Table Characteristics stratified by having ever received any influenza vaccination" the Never received influenza vaccine group has much less diseases - Atrial fibrillation 0.67% vs vaxxed 2.12%, Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease 1.52% vs vaxxed 4.1% and so on and then we reach "Any stroke event" 0.52% vs vaxxed 1.25% while not that much hiugher average age 48.34 vs 38.98 (unvaxxed). So even if they suposedly lower the risks within the vaxxed group, by joining the vaxxed group your risk actually grows compared to staying in unvaxxed group and I don't really see odds for both comparable groups. > Due to the nature of this research using administrative data across a population, participants of this study did not agree for their data to be shared publicly, so supporting data are not available. I would take any study coming from authoritarian Canada, which froze bank accounts of people opposing COVID lockdowns, with big grain of salt. Also even according CDC flu vaccine efficacy is only 40 to 60% and that's assuming it works at all, if they don't match the correct variant you are somewhere around 0% efficacy, might as well take placebo with same effect. https://www.cdc.gov/flu/vaccines-work/vaccineeffect.htm https://www.cdc.gov/flu/vaccines-work/vaccineeffect.htm
- padolsey 4y agoRight under the chart you reference, the study states that these figures are confounded: > [...] this crude observation was confounded. Adjusted for age, sex, comorbid illness, and socioeconomic status, recent vaccination (within 182 days) was associated with a reduced hazard of stroke
- sigmoid10 4y agoIt's scary how many people don't know the difference between raw data statistics (which are almost always worthless) and a multivariate regression with control variables (which can actually tell you something about the data). Everyone can read a paper and look at numbers, but to understand what is really happening you do need some formal education that most people simply seem to lack. Even people with this kind of education sometimes step into pitfalls, but normal people drawing conclusions from these things is like running through a minefield while blindfolded.
- jonatron 4y agoFlu vaccine increases risk of shingles: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/irv.13055 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/irv.13055
- IHLayman 4y ago“There was a slight increase in risk of HZ in people receiving influenza vaccine in the first 1–15 days after vaccination.” That’s kind of overselling it, isn’t it? The OP study says that stroke chances are lowered for 6 months. I think many people would take that trade off.
- jonatron 4y agoFigure 4D in the stroke study shows how small the hazard is for younger people, and how small the difference is. The shingles study shows the shingles IRR is higher for people under 65. As another comment says "I wonder at what age flu shots provide overwhelming benefits.", that is the reason why I posted it.
- jimmygrapes 4y agoI actually got shingles 2 days after flu vaccination in 2017. I had chicken pox twice as a kid and the common idea (old wives' tale?) at that time was if you got chicken pox you wouldn't get shingles. I don't know that the vaccine contributed or not, but it's an odd coincidence. Luckily it was a mild case handled by amoxicillin.
- rawicki 4y agoIt’s actually the other way around. Going through chicken pox as a kid increases the chance to have a shingles as it is caused by the same virus being dormant in your body. When infected the first time you can have chicken pox as an adult. Amoxicillin is an antibiotic and can be given for the risk of opportunistic infections but it doesn’t treat a viral disease by itself.
- 4y ago
- sfusato 4y ago[flagged]
- ransom1538 4y agoI get the flu shot and get the flu each year. It's tradition.
- belltaco 4y agoIsn't it supposed to reduce the severity if you do get the flu?
- ceejayoz 4y agoYes, and a lot of people call other diseases flu when they get them.
- ransom1538 4y agoYes and other people don't know about the Rapid test. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rapid_influenza_diagnostic_test https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rapid_influenza_diagnostic_tes...
- chadash 4y agoIn the second article that you cite, it says "once changes in the size and the age structure of the population are neutralized, a downward trend of influenza mortality appears". i.e. adjusted for population size, influenza deaths went down significantly between 1959 and 2016.
- sfusato 4y agoIf you call the downward trend "significant", how would you call the upward trend of flu shots given each year then? > In other words, adjusting for age effects, influenza mortality risk significantly decreased by an average of 2.02 % per year between 1959 and 2016 Also, what would happen if we would normalize for better treatments, better vaccines available with each passing year? Or that shouldn't be taken into consideration?
- chiefalchemist 4y agoThe annual flu shot is a guess. Due to manufacturing lead time and distribution the prediction for which strain will be the dominant strain in the future is made (afaik) approx a year earlier. The point being, its possible any give year's jab is not the ideal jab given the strain that ended up the actual dominant. Point being, the study should account for that, or at least explain the significance (or insignificance) of the match / mismatch. That is, is the jab creating an immune response that mitigates stroke. Or is the jab creating an immune response that mitigates flu and less flu means less stroke. Otherwise, this feels like correlation.
- dashmeet 4y agoAnother variable that causes issues in the results is the effectiveness of the vaccine and the evolution of the virus over years with retained immunity. For example: A flu shot from years ago can protect against a flu from this year or in the future. So even if the flu vaccine isn’t effective in its current year, the immunity lasts for many years to those antigens. The strain of flu that’s currently dominant can fluctuate to newer or older variants. Controlling for this is even more confusing A guess this year could help in future years
- chiefalchemist 4y agoMaybe. Reference link(s), please.
- petodo 4y ago"However, vaccination was associated with a reduced risk of stroke overall across all ages and risk profiles with the exception of individuals without hypertension." https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpub/article/PIIS2468-2667(22)00222-5/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpub/article/PIIS2468-2... ROFL So, if you are normal (un)healthy person and you DON'T HAVE HYPERTENSION then this amazing flu vaccine won't lower your risk of stroke at all, this study applies only to people with hypertension.
- icegreentea2 4y agoYeah, it's actually kind of nuts how much higher your baseline risk of stroke is with hypertension that even though only ~10% of their study population has hypertension that the effect (vaccination correlated with reduced risk of stroke) just shows up on a the global analysis.
- tptacek 4y agoThis would be a better dunk if hypertension wasn't the dominant risk factor in all strokes, but it is, so you haven't actually made a point here.
- petodo 4y agoI've made point, the headline reads "Flu vaccine lowers risk of stroke", which is very different from "Flu vaccine lowers risk of stroke for people with hypertensia". The linked article does not mention this hypertensia fact at all, there is not a single mention of hypertensia in it and it is not clearly communicated anywhere in study besides one small fine print, that their findings actually affect only very narow group of people.
- tptacek 4y agoYou've managed to add "in the cohort of pts likely to have strokes" to the headline, which is not an interesting wrinkle. That's the population you'd most hope to see the effect in.
- 4y ago
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI'm not a medical expert but isn't this obvious? Severe infections are hugely stressful for the body. Influenza vaccination leads to fewer severe infections which leads to lower risk of a multitude of diseases.
- ceejayoz 4y agoIt’s still nice to have evidence to back up obvious things, because sometimes we find counter-intuitive results.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI agree. My comment wasn't meant to criticize their work but the anti-vax critics.
- zmgsabst 4y ago[flagged]
- dang 4y agoPlease don't cross into personal attack. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- Dig1t 4y agoThe anti-Vaxer threads were flagged and are dead, presumably because someone considered them dangerous. I fear that doing so mostly just emboldens them and helps their cause. Censoring like that makes me, and probably others, suspicious. The better thing to do would just be to help them understand the statistics and provide links + explanations for how they are misinterpreting the data.
- tptacek 4y agoConvincing suspicious vaccine-skeptics of the value of vaccines is not the goal here. We're not a public health service; we're a forum for curious conversation. Tedious rehashes of antivax arguments aren't curious; they're just tedious.
- jtbayly 4y agoBut there are a lot of curious things about vaccines, and plenty of those curious things are reasons why somebody might not be excited at the prospect of getting one.
- tptacek 4y agoIf they're the same "curious" arguments over and over again, the conversations aren't "curious" in the sense the guidelines refer to.
- jtbayly 4y agoI for one find constant links about the benefits without any freedom to actually discuss the trade offs incredibly tedious. I’m a scientific individual, but I don’t appreciate getting nagged. Edited to add: I find the repetition of silly debates tedious, too. Like open source licenses, android, iOS, etc. But that doesn’t mean I don’t learn things from some of those debates. Also, I want to know all the information and know that I know it. I currently know that attitudes like yours are keeping me from learning all there is to know about various vacccines. Because any information that could be interpreted negatively is verboten. Edited to add one more thing: I was speaking about interesting scientific articles that reveal and discuss the downsides. You implied that I was talking about arguments under those articles being interesting. You do see the difference between those things, right? Banning information because some people react badly to that information is what I’m objecting to.
- colechristensen 4y ago> The crude incidence of stroke was higher among individuals who had ever received an influenza vaccination (1·25%) compared with those who had not (0·52%; table). However, this crude observation was confounded. Adjusted for age, sex, comorbid illness, and socioeconomic status, recent vaccination (within 182 days) was associated with a reduced hazard of stroke (hazard ratio [HR] 0·775 [95% CI 0·757–0·793]). I doubt that the result of this paper is valid. The crude results have more strokes for people who vaccinated, but they used statistics to demonstrate that vaccination helps. Well there are a lot of choices to make when correcting for factors, and it’s quite hard to evaluate truth that way. The thing which sticks out particularly is correcting for cormorbid conditions. If you do that, you could very well just be pushing out sick people. Two kinds of people will vaccinate more: people who are sick and get encouraged by doctors they see more often, and people who pay more attention to their health. If you “correct for” people with comorbid conditions you might have a larger influence of healthy people who pay attention to their health. In other words, it is plausible that the actual results of the study are “being the sort of person who vaccinates is associated with lower incidence of stroke” not because the vaccine has any effect but because general things people who try to take care of their health do tend to prevent a few strokes (like going to a doctor who notices high blood pressure and getting treatment)
- zeristor 4y agoYes, this is quite a big deal additional studies to check various aspects would be warranted to confirm this.
- jtbayly 4y agoPlus, it’s possible that the group that has comorbidities is the larger group. The “correction” could then hide the fact that encouraging people to get the vaccine will result in more people having strokes overall.
- refurb 4y ago> I doubt that the result of this paper is valid. Agreed. Or at least highly suspect. Correcting for confounding factors is not an exact science. There is a large degree of "art" to it. When the raw data says "inverse effect" then you "adjust for confounding factors" and it says the opposite, that should be viewed with suspicion.
- textech 4y agoPerhaps people who get the flu shot are generally in better health or exercise more?
- dilap 4y agoIt's the opposite. The absolute occurence of stroke was higher in people who got the vaccine, but other risk factors were also higher; adjusting for those, they found a "less-higher than expected" amount of stroke, which they attribute to the flu vaccine. If you have a lot of faith in these sorts of statistical adjustments and the assumptions behind them, then you may find this result compelling.
- notjes 4y agoFunding: None. Those are good people I guess.
- gus_massa 4y agoNote that they don't have a double bling randomized control group. We know this type of studies create a lot of false positive, for example there are many studies without a double blind randomized control group that "proved" that ivermectin was useful against covid-19. The problem is that it's very difficult to compensate for all the other variables. They even get more strokes in the vaccinated group than in the unvaccinated group. This is not so surprising, because old people and ill people are more encouraged to get the flu vaccine. After correcting for the age, they even get less strokes in the vaccinated group than in the unvaccinated group. It's difficult to get all the variables that are important to be sure they are not forgetting to make more adjustments. For example, people without access to a good medical system (because they live far away from a city or are too poor to take a day to get t the doctor) are probably less vaccinated, less checked and have probably more health problems. Correcting for all the unknown unknowns is too difficult. So the trick is to use a double bling randomized control group, to try to avoid other factors that select who is vaccinated od who not.
- t0bia_s 4y ago"...less checked and have probably more health problems." More checks = more possibilities to find some kind of problem. So statistically, in wealth countries diagnoses are higher in measured numbers.
- voisin 4y ago> We know that upper respiratory infections often precede heart attacks and strokes. Preventing or reducing the severity of influenza provides a protective factor particularly for stroke So it is really just a secondary benefit to protecting against the flu. One could say that wearing a mask reduces stroke risk for the same reason, or washing hands thoroughly. Anything that reduces the chance of getting the flu.
- underdeserver 4y agoThis strengthens the hypothesis that a lot of conditions with unknown origins actually stem from dormant viral infections or their leftovers, like how EBV causes MS.
- fpiacenza 4y agoYou can reduce your risk of stroke by increasing the risk of dying by other means.