4 ms·
> The ultra-rich therefore spend relatively small shares of their income on goods and services that directly provide jobs and incomes to others, instead accumul
by WalterBright 4y ago
> The ultra-rich therefore spend relatively small shares of their income on goods and services that directly provide jobs and incomes to others, instead accumulating stocks, bonds, art, trophy real estate, and other assets.
Investing in stocks does provide jobs and income to others. When you buy stocks, the money goes to finance the business.
When you buy art, the money goes to the artist.
And so on.
Consider if an artists creates a painting, and sells it to a rich dude for $100,000. Who is harmed by this? I don't understand all the "inequality is bad" axioms that people seem to accept uncritically.
- 0xEFF 4y agoMost assets, both stocks and fine art, are bought and sold between relatively rich people not from the person or company who originally issued the asset. Consider a house, the builder sells it once, but it gets bought and sold on average every 7 years subsequently.
- WalterBright 4y agoLet's say Richie Rich buys a painting from Willy Wealthy for $100,000. Now Willy has an extra $100,000. What's he going to do with it? There's an entire industry of artists making art to sell to the Richie Riches and Willy Wealthies of the world, and this has been going on since antiquity. Why do you think all that medieval Italian art was created? It was rich Italians patronizing the artists. The same with real estate. In the meantime, while someone owns a house, they gotta pay others for insurance, repairs, maintenance, taxes, etc. Even buying the house will cost you 6% going to the starving real estate agent. Owning a house is very expensive, not counting the purchase price.
- nerdponx 4y agoThe money does flow back into the economy, but it's extremely diluted in that the surplus obtained by any individual "downstream" of great wealth is small. Meanwhile, the people spending all that money are the same people setting things up to ensure that surplus flows back to... themselves. So the wealthy people spend money, the people who manufacture their stuff and provide their services get as little surplus as possible without inciting them to riot, and the remainder goes right back to some other wealthy person, and then the process repeats. There's no guarantee that surplus/welfare/utility flows along with the money, and it should be obvious to any observer that it definitely does not in practice. The tired old argument that wealth accumulation doesn't really exist because the money all eventually goes "back into the economy" has always been an insulting hand-wave that is neither a principled model nor in agreement with basic facts about the economy.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhat is missing from your comment is the wealthy get that way by creating wealth, not by taking it from others. (This is why the economy grows - wealth creation.) The government, on the other hand, gets money by taking it.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> What is missing from your comment is the wealthy get that way by creating wealth, not by taking it from others. Its missing, because it is mostly not true. The wealthy predominantly get wealthy by getting other people to create wealth, and taking it from them via contracts relying on imbalances of power and econonic coercion (in a fairly benign modern capitalist system; is less benign, less modern, emerging (or pre-) capitalist systems, the coercion is often jist direct threat or application of force rather than the economic coercion of the inherent precariousness of the working class in capitalist society.
- WalterBright 4y agoWell, that's definitely the Marxist point of view of things. Everybody in a business is creating the wealth of the business, and they get their share of the created wealth in the form of pay and benefits. Unsurprisingly, their compensation is in proportion to the value they add (i.e. the wealth their contributions create). It is not a system based on forcing anyone. The cooperation is voluntary, with their compensation set by supply+demand.
- aaomidi 4y agoWhen choice for one side is hunger vs giving up labor, and the other side is a tiny bit more profit, or a tiny bit less profit - that’s not a choice. Power imbalance does not make for informed consent.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf you were right, everyone would be working for minimum wage. But they aren't. Only 1.5% work for minimum wage.
- gnicholas 4y agoWhen houses are sold, realtors get a percentage of the gross sale price (not just the gain), staging companies are brought in, painters and handymen are hired, and title companies, mortgage lenders, and assessors all get work. The local government also gets paid, in the form of transfer taxes. These don't apply to all big ticket items, but since you mentioned houses, I thought I'd flesh out the picture on who benefits from buying/selling activity. It's worth noting that all of these people get paid, regardless of whether the home seller made money or lost money on the home (or how much). So in a strong market, they will get a small share of the gains. But in a down market, the seller may make nothing, while these service providers all get paid.
- WalterBright 4y agoBuying existing art means paying vig to the auction houses, appraisers, curators, restorers, insurers, and security people.
- wfleming 4y ago> When you buy stocks, the money goes to finance the business. Only if you’re buying directly from the business, which you’re usually not. Usually you’re just buying from another shareholder (could be another individual, a mutual fund, a hedge fund, whatever). The proceeds may indeed end up filtering into the rest of the economy (I may sell you the stock to pay my mortgage, the hedge fund pays their traders), but the money doesn’t fund the business of the traded company.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf you cannot sell your founders shares, they're worthless. Companies issue more stock to sell and raise capital all the time. > the money doesn’t fund the business of the traded company. Not directly, but indirectly it does. It makes the stocks valuable so the company can create shares and people will buy them. You know, like those stock options employees get.
- wfleming 4y ago> Companies issue more stock to sell and raise capital all the time. Sure, but that’s still a small fraction of most trades most of the time. When companies sell stock (long after their IPO) the sales kind of have to be dripped out as a small percentage of the trading volume of the stock or it would negatively affect the price (more than considered acceptable). If a company or its insiders are most of the sellers by volume (again, if a company has been public a while), that’s a bad sign for the company. > Not directly, but indirectly it does. Also yes, but I would quibble that this is moving the goal posts from your original statement :). “The money goes to finance the business” seemed like a pretty direct declarative statement that didn’t touch on the nuance of “buying stock -> pushes price up -> makes debt cheaper for company/makes further stock sales attractive”. I get the point you’re making and don’t entirely disagree. But in a proud HN tradition it read as a confident and straightforward declaration that describes the (IMHO) minority case, but not the more common case and sweeps important nuance aside. Please don’t take that to mean I thought your thoughts or understanding were also lacking in nuance, I didn’t. But I figure there will always be people coming through these threads who don’t know the nuance, they’ll read the highly upvoted top comments and move on, thinking they’ve improved their understanding, and they will be led astray, so I was responding to the words as-written.
- MuffinFlavored 4y ago> Investing in stocks does provide jobs and income to others. When you buy stocks, the money goes to finance the business. could somebody expand on this please? as far as I understood it, companies like Apple don’t issue shares very often. How does the share price going up go to their business unless they issue more shares (diluting existing shareholders)?
- toast0 4y agoDoesn't Apple use stock based compensation and doesn't that involve issuing stock?
- WalterBright 4y agoI don't know what Apple does. Of course, Apple could buy it on the market and hand it to people to exercise their options. But the usual thing is the company creates the stock and hands it out.
- zeusk 4y agoEvery company maintains a treasury of stock; SBC comes out of that but it is indeed newly issued shares that dilute the holdings. However, with Apple and similar companies - they buyback A LOT more of the stock than they issue in SBC.
- 015a 4y agoRich people don't predominately buy art from artists (for $100,000). They spend $100,000 on art from some art dealer, or other rich people; who paid $80,000 for it from someone else; that someone else paid $60,000 for it; and twenty steps down the line is either an actual artist who made pennies, or the artist is dead and no one involved had anything to do with its creation. This is a similar phenomena as the stock market. "Why does the stock market exist" is an interesting question. The textbook answer would be: it allows companies to sell pieces of themselves to the public in order to raise capital. The caveat to this answer is, 99.99...9% of transactions on the stock market every day do not land money back in the company's checking account; the money lands with the person who owned the stock previously. Because of Federal Reserve Guaranteed Inflation, that person probably, usually, over long enough periods of time, paid less for it than the current buyer, and five million exchanges down the chain for this physical stock certificate is the company, during their IPO (or when they release more stock), who made just a bit of money. There's nothing intrinsically negative in what I described above; its just "markets". In fact, here's the counter-argument to the point the article makes about it being negative: Why would I, as an Investor, purchase a slice of the pizza delivery app Sliceline at IPO if I cannot make a return on that investment? Framework, the company making fully upgradeable and repairable laptops, needs funding; why would I invest in them if not to see a return on investment? I'm a homeowner; maybe I shouldn't purchase a painting from a struggling local artist; after all, it probably won't see a return on investment. I intentionally slid down the slope of examples there to prove a point. Imagine you Have Money; maybe a lot of money, let's call it N dollars. How you spend that N dollars communicates your morals, ethics, and values; it defines what your future looks like, and at large enough values of N, progressively starts defining what the future of our society looks like. A recent tweet, which I haven't found but you can search for, paraphrased: "In ten years, my husband's salary has increased 90%, while mine has increased 18%. I've spent most of that time curing cancer; he's been optimizing ad click rates." What we're talking about is a phenomena I'd label as The Assetization of Everything. The vast majority of the monetary expenses wealthy individuals and corporations make is viewed through the lens of return on investment. Its very rare to see a corporation, or even wealthy individuals, say "we believe in X, we believe X is good for our society, so we are giving X $10M". "Investors" would ask: Wait, are you getting stock? Is it a loan? Can you write it down on your taxes? What's going on? Yet, anyone is totally able to do this. Its not because of some law, though corporate fiduciary duty isn't helping. Federal Reserve policy did accelerate it, but its not the cause. The cause is Cultural. It can't be fixed. We, the world, are approaching the endgame of this very quickly. It won't be pretty. We are not allocating even adjacent orders of magnitudes enough resources toward solving problems that represent existential threats to, at minimum, our way of life; maybe society as we know it; possibly civilization; unlikely, but, the human race. Its not going to start with any of the traditional culprits though; AI, global warming, killer virus, whatever. It'll start with something that seems rather inane: it'll get harder and harder to find investments which generate returns. Put another way: deflation; we had an era of ridiculous prosperity where we could have allocated resources to stave off the coming actual crisis, but we didn't, and now no one wants to invest in solving them.
- CoolestBeans 4y agoThe problem with purchasing assets in an environment like this is that you are transferring money from one cash hoarder to another. The velocity of money is low. In the stock example, companies are also wealthy entities that hold cash when interest rates are cheap. For example, in 2017 (when rate targets were just above 0%) Apple had hundreds of billions in cash in Ireland and other tax haven nations. When Abenomics began in Japan and the Bank of Japan introduced zero interest rates and quantitative easing and yield curve control, one of the first things that happened was that companies started building huge money stores. When inflation remains stubbornly low, there isn't a strong need to get rid of your cash because it isn't losing a lot of value and you take little risk. You may as well hold on to it. You're right that these economic activities are better than nothing but they aren't the kinds of activities that puts a generation of people to work and start building the kind of wealth that supports a family.
- WalterBright 4y agoYou could imagine that a cash hoard is passed around rich people, but there's going to be someone in the chain who is going to spend it on something other than art. Because rich people simply do not hoard cash. They do not have Scrooge McDuck cash vaults. > companies started building huge money stores. They don't have Scrooge McDuck cash vaults, either. Their money "store" is all invested. > You may as well hold on to it. Even if the money is deposited in a bank, it doesn't stay in the bank. The bank loans it out. That's how banks make money. You deposit money, they loan it out to someone who pays them interest.
- zeusk 4y ago> Even if the money is deposited in a bank, it doesn't stay in the bank. The bank loans it out. That's how banks make money. You deposit money, they loan it out to someone who pays them interest. Not really, they'd rather buy treasuries and deposit at the FED for a risk-free 4-5% return and it shows in FRED data; roughly $2.5 Trillion dollars are currently held at just Fed's overnight repo facility. In return when banks do want to lend it out, poor people (often with bad or average credit) get ludicrous interest rates like 15-25%. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RRPONTSYD https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RRPONTSYD
- nly 4y agoWhen you buy Microsoft stock, no money goes to Microsoft. Microsoft only raise capital when they issue new shares or sell reserved shares themselves. Stock markets are a secondary market.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe stock would be worthless if there was no secondary market.
- epgui 4y agoI'm not sure what "axioms" you're referring to, but "inequality" is usually not considered bad. What is more often considered bad is "inequity", which is what prevents a lot of people from earning a good, decent life. Some people work very hard in life and don't make any major bad decisions, and still have a hard life. Other people work little and have a good life. There's both inequality and inequity in this picture, but they're not the same thing. What people object to is not mere inequality: inequality is expected to exist anywhere money exists. What people object to is "excessive inequality", or distributions of wealth where the Pareto coefficient is "too extreme". The reason why this is bad is because it effectively makes the "American dream" impossible for nearly everyone, in the extreme case.