17 ms·
On ‘Plant-Based’
- hobbitstan 4y ago‘Plant based’ initially meant vegan, but vegan is a dirty word for some people, likely because a lot of the early vegan meat alternatives were ghastly. As a vegan, I see a lot of labels boasting ‘plant-based’ but no mention of it being vegan or not, often not even on their website. That alone means I will not purchase. It’s either not vegan OR they’re scared to put that 5 letter word on their product. Market it as plant-based all you want but mention if it’s vegan or not somewhere, even on your website.
- namdnay 4y agoI personally like the “plant based” term, because for me “vegan” was always defined as a negative (vegans dont eat this and dont eat that), whereas plant-based just means what it says. In my experience in shops in the UK at least, there will always be a little “vegan” logo stuck on the packet as well
- ummonk 4y agoThis strikes me as the start of a euphemism treadmill, given that the etymology of "vegan" is no more negative than "plant based".
- catach 4y agoOver time, the flavors we associate with words usually comes from the contexts in which they are used, which can easily overpower their origins.
- ummonk 4y agoExactly, and I think the same context will become associated with "plant-based" if it is consistently used as a substitute for "vegan".
- catach 4y agoAh, I see now what you mean by "euphemism treadmill", and I agree that the framework is valid. If the term has a chance of avoiding the treadmill I suspect it'd be due to the awkwardness of identifying as such. "Vegan" can apply to both food and the people who consume just that food, but I don't see people calling themselves "plant-based" anytime soon. The tribal aspect of the context is potentially greatly diminished by removing that explicit identity.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Accacin 4y agoI'm in the UK too, and find the plant-based phrase generally useful. For example, some double cream said 'plant-based' alternative and also had the Vegan logo. I've never really thought about it, but I assumed 'plant-based' was for products like cream that would have dairy and non-dairy alternative. Saying 'vegan' might imply it's only for vegans where plant based just means 'non-dairy' and might be billed as more inclusive. I'm not too concerned about it also possibly including eggs, as I always check for vegan icon or read ingredients.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoVeganism is an extreme and therefore it tends to attract people who are seeking extremes. This brings a rather negative image because there's always a part of intolerance and/or unreasonableness in extremes. I think most people will think that, for instance, not eating honey or eggs is too extreme.
- colechristensen 4y agoMost people, when made aware of how almost all of the eggs they consume are produced, would be a little uncomfortable at least. Mind you I still eat plenty of eggs, but I entirely grok a person not wanting to consume the output of industrial egg production. I try to buy eggs with adjectives added to the label about how nice they are to their hens knowing full well that these are of limited benefit. Honey, on the other hand, I don't understand a moral objection to, but also who cares if somebody doesn't want to eat honey?
- FeistySkink 4y agoA bit more info about bees: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VSYgDssQUtA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VSYgDssQUtA
- sheusndudn 4y agoHoney and eggs are not comparable. Maybe honey is extreme, but watch a youtube video of them shredding male live chicks that won't lay eggs so aren't useful is the closest thing to hell i've ever seen.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoThere is a difference between being against cruelty against animals and not eating any eggs. Hens will lay eggs. That's what they do naturally and if those eggs are not fertilised they will rot and decay. In veganism you cannot eat those eggs no matter how pampered the hens are. That's obviously a personal decision, which I respect, but it should also be understandable that many people find this extreme (and not eating honey even more extreme).
- FeistySkink 4y agoSome cow milk producers label cow milk as plant-based. What exactly is it supposed to mean?
- layer8 4y agoDo you have a photo of that? It’s somewhat hard to believe, and I didn’t find anything by googling.
- CivBase 4y ago> but vegan is a dirty word for some people, likely because a lot of the early vegan meat alternatives were ghastly Probably more to do with stereotypes of vegans themselves - ie. condescending, arrogant, self-righteous hippies. As a non-vegan, I think a lot of vegan food is actually really good. But as a rule of thumb I avoid vegan dishes that use substitutes for traditionally non-vegan dishes.
- mathieuh 4y agoI recently became vegan, and I compare it to being straight-edge (i.e. not taking drugs). I don’t think there is a moral aspect to taking drugs, and I disagree with the way straight-edge people invent one and talk down to people who take drugs. However, I do think there is a moral aspect to using animal products when other options exist. But, I also wasn’t vegan for most of my life, so I don’t think it’s for me to tell other people they are immoral, because that probably won’t get me very far in convincing them. Not sure if anyone else has had any thoughts like this, I’d be interested to hear how they reconciled this in their own minds, it’s still unresolved for me personally.
- stcroixx 4y agoWhat exactly is unresolved? You want to convince others eating meat is immoral but feel that your meat eating past removes any standing you have to do that? Why should the general argument be diminished because of one persons behavior? If you were trying to convince me, that wouldn’t matter for me personally.
- imw 4y agoIn my experience, what does work is to lead with joy. I've found so much new life and enjoyment in my cooking since I went vegan. Cooking delicious food and sharing it with people is sometimes the best we can do.
- inkcapmushroom 4y agoYes, convince them to try roasted brussels sprouts or chicken fried tofu. That will change minds far quicker than preaching will.
- tootie 4y agoI think "vegan" also implies a lifestyle whereas you can favor plant-based food without being a full-time vegan.
- drewg123 4y agoIf you're not buying it because of the case where they're scared to label something which is vegan as such, then you're part of the problem and you're hurting veganism. What matters is reducing climate impact, reducing animal cruelty, and the health benefits. What doesn't matter is your feelings about labels. By boycotting such products, you're reducing their market, potentially causing them to drop their plant based offering, and making it more difficult for people to eat vegan. That, in turn, reduces the number of vegans and hurts everybody.
- hobbitstan 4y agoIf they go out of their way avoid saying it’s vegan then I won’t waste my time on it as it may not actually be vegan, despite the listed ingredients. It’s suspicious.
- californical 4y agoWhy would they be scared to label it if it’s actually vegan? I can understand someone who feels morally about something not wanting to take a chance on something that the producer isn’t willing to back with a proper label
- drewg123 4y agoI think its as the GP says "vegan is a dirty word for some people". Between a lot of vegans being meme-level obnoxious about their veganism, and early plant based products being horribly bad (Boca burger, I'm looking at you), veganism has tended to get a bad name.
- lopis 4y agoPlant-based never meant the same as vegan, unless you're only talking about food. Plant-based is rarely used outside of food.
- weakfortress 4y ago> a lot of early vegan meat alternatives were ghastly I think most people dislike vegan food because vegans eat it. Not because of the food. Vegans have done a number on their appearance to the public. Most people seem to have the same experience: how do you know someone is a vegan? Don't worry they'll tell you! (and chastise you for wanting to eat a steak) When I was in college every holiday, like clockwork, a brigade of vegans would descend on campus and hand out flyers explaining how problematic it was eating meat. You do that enough times and people just avoid anything associated with you out of spite.
- derbOac 4y agoI've tended to see the term "plant-based" as synonymous with "vegan and/or vegetarian", used when there's variability or uncertainty about which of those more specific terms would apply. "Meatless" would also suffice but I think "plant-based" is used to emphasize what is present rather than absent. But I think the essay is right the term has become vaguer than that even, and my own understanding of it doesn't quite make sense.
- solardev 4y agoIt's totally a marketing gimmick. Some of the "plant-based" brands mixed real meat in with the plant stuff: https://www.foodnavigator-usa.com/Article/2019/06/13/Tyson-unveils-blended-burgers-plant-based-nuggets-Alternative-protein-could-someday-be-a-billion-dollar-business-for-our-company https://www.foodnavigator-usa.com/Article/2019/06/13/Tyson-u... The marketers like "plant-based" because it's both in vogue and definitionally meaningless, much less precise than "vegan" (which itself is already imprecise, i.e., whether to include bugs killed in agriculture, or sugar processed with animal byproducts, etc.).
- chc 4y agoNone of the examples in that article appear to use the term "plant-based" on their products, so it seems even those brands were respectful on the term. If anything, that seems like it makes the opposite case of "plant-based is definitionally meaningless."
- solardev 4y agoThey were released at the same time as the height of the plant-based craze. Plant-based is not a legally protected term the way that, say "organic" is (neither is "vegan", for that matter). Different marketers and/or third-party certifiers will use that term how they wish. And "made with plants" is already awfully similar, enough to cause confusion in the media: https://www.meatpoultry.com/articles/21460-tyson-introduces-new-plant-based-blended-products https://www.meatpoultry.com/articles/21460-tyson-introduces-... Tyson was intentionally muddying the waters with the Raised & Rooted brand, which initially contained meat and eggs and eventually became completely plant, but under the same brand name and very similar packaging. It caused a lot of controversy at the time for violating the spirit -- if not the letter -- of "plant-based". Here's another example of a plant-based product with with real cheese: https://target.scene7.com/is/image/Target/GUEST_351013af-154d-48f3-ac63-3b4f35303fac https://target.scene7.com/is/image/Target/GUEST_351013af-154... (although I think they later changed the packaging on that to be clearer). I'm not saying things just to be a pedantic a-hole; as someone who's been vegan for a long time, seeing the plant-based products (especially frozen ones) hit the freezers but also hide animal ingredients was a very frustrating and confusing time. It's gotten a bit better now, I guess with enough consumer backlash, but for a couple of years there there were quite a lot of insidiously labeled products that you really had to scan the ingredients & allergens for no matter how they used the word "plant" on the front. What I'm saying is that it's ultimately a marketing term, not a strict definition of any sort. Nobody is enforcing plant-based violations. You have to look at the ingredients rather than the front of the packaging if you want to figure out what it actually has.
- bin_bash 4y agoI think "plant-based" is a better term than "vegan". "Vegan" describes a person or food. "Plant-based" can only describe the food—you wouldn't say "Bob is plant-based", you'd say "Bob eats plant-based food." If you order "vegan buffalo wings" you're attaching yourself to the vegan subculture and the baggage that comes along with that. Ordering "plant-based buffalo wings" just means you're ordering cauliflower.
- riffraff 4y agoBut why doesn't the menu say "cauliflower wings" with some "V" icon or leaf icon next to it? I will never understand why parts of the vegan movement need to disguise foods as something else. Vegetables are good!
- edent 4y agoWhy do meat eaters disguise things as burgers, sausages, and nuggets?
- dmitriid 4y agoThey don't "disguise" things as burgers, sausages etc. That's how meat has been prepared since time immemorial across all cultures. Why do vegans and vegetarians insist on disguising vegetables as meat - now that's the question. Even though the same cultures have a mind-boggling variety of foods that don't involve meat, and don't pretend to be meat.
- edent 4y agoWhat part of the mighty buffalo is the wing? As to why vegans do it - hotdog buns are really well designed for holding a tube of protein.
- OJFord 4y agoThe suggestion was for 'cauliflower' (or whatever) to replace 'vegan buffalo', no change to 'wing'. I might buy 'halloumi and apple sausages', just like I might 'pork and apple'. I wouldn't buy 'vegetarian pork and apple sausages', even though it describes the former (and could be the same) - it's vague and unappealing.
- lmm 4y agoFor people who want to reduce meat consumption for environmentalist reasons, being strictly vegan would sometimes do more harm than good (e.g. almond "milk" involves more CO2 emissions than milk). So the concept of a meal that doesn't include large amounts of meat, without necessarily being vegan, is a valuable one.
- namdnay 4y agoThose are really edge cases. What is certain is that if everyone were vegan, our CO2 emissions would be way way lower
- scaredginger 4y agoyou got a source for that claim, chief?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- remirk 4y agoYou're saying that vegan people have to use milk alternatives like almond milk. Which is certainly not the case. What a non-argument. Also, the problem with milk is not necessarily CO2 but CH4.
- dmitriid 4y ago> You're saying that vegan people have to use milk alternatives like almond milk. Which is certainly not the case. For vegans it certainly is the case. Vegans don't eat food that comes from animals. Milk is one such product. So vegans will definitely use milk alternatives.
- andrewshadura 4y agoYou're forgetting that not everyone drinks milk or milk substitutes.
- scaredginger 4y agoI think it's a shame that 'vegetarian' has come to mean 'lacto-ovo vegetarian' in the vernacular. Now, 'plant-based' generally takes the position in language that 'vegetarian' should occupy. To be clear, there is also a distinction between 'plant-based' and 'vegan' in that the latter has ethical implications. If making a product caused animal suffering, but that product wasn't made from any animal products, then I'd argue it would be plant-based and not vegan. As someone who has these ethical concerns, these distinctions are important to me, even if they're not to most people.
- namdnay 4y agoSo a tomato picked by a trained monkey would be plant-based but not vegan? What about canned tomatoes picked by quasi-slaves on some mafia farm in calabria? Would they not be vegan then?
- onion2k 4y agoIf you're OK with eating food picked by slaves, quasi- or otherwise, then you have more to think about than veganism.
- namdnay 4y agomy question was more on how this is tracked/labelled. if something is sold in the UK with the vegan logo, does that mean it is also free from human exploitation?
- philwelch 4y agoAre you aware of how lithium ion batteries are made?
- vel0city 4y agoAre you aware of how oil production proceeds fund global terrorism and warlords? Guess you can't buy any gasoline, since some % of oil is sold on the market from warlords committing atrocities in their countries. Did you know when you buy gasoline at the pump you're supporting a market which buys missiles for Saudi Arabia to bomb Yemen?
- captainmuon 4y agoOne reason I dislike "plant-based" that's not in the article: it singles out plant-based food. But for most of history, for most people, food based on plants was the default and still should be. Food should have labels when it includes stuff other than plants (or other than what we humans evolved to eat typically). The other thing I don't like is that "plant-based" always sounds like marketing. Especially here in Germany where companies have started to use the English term, even though we have plenty of normal German terms. It sounds like a brand or a fad.
- User23 4y agoHomo sapiens is something like 100 to 300 thousand years old from the latest estimates I’ve seen. Agriculture is maybe six to twelve thousand years old. I don’t think there’s a strong evolutionary argument that humans are meant to primarily eat plants, but rather quite the opposite. And then there’s the amusing observation that cows are entirely plant-based.
- Mistletoe 4y agoAre you implying humans evolved to only eat plants? Every documentary and paper on early humans I see points to otherwise, and that our large brain was directly a result of access to extra protein from hunting meat. https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2008/04/eating-meat-led-to-smaller-stomachs-bigger-brains/ https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2008/04/eating-meat-l...
- beebeepka 4y agoDo we know this for sure, though? I don't think we do. Sounds like self-congratulatory hogwash to me. Creatures eat what they can. Some purely carnivorous species have been around way longer than us, and yet, the stars did not align just the right way for them.
- Aaargh20318 4y ago> Do we know this for sure, though? I don't think we do. We know for sure we have evolved to be omnivores. This can easily be determined based on e.g. our teeth and the length of our digestive system.
- kazinator 4y ago> Same with “plant-based cookie”—does that mean no animal butter, but yes to eggs? An egg isn't the fruit of a plant; of course it's not plant-based if it contains eggs. Everyone should be irked, regardless of their political alignment in the area of food, if they are told that something with eggs is plant-based. It is a mistake or misrepresentation. Plant-based can only possibly mean that it's made from leaves, stalks, fruits, nuts, seeds, bark, roots or any other part of a plant. If it contains mushrooms, yeasts or fungi, it's not plant-based; those are not plants. However, I would be generous in that if some plant comes with certain naturally occurring bacteria or fungi, then something made with that plant can still be plant-based. If the plant material is fermented, confirming bacteria or moulds, let's say it can be plant-based anyway. Insects have to be removed, though.
- mytailorisrich 4y ago"Plant-based" does not imply uniquely made of plants as per the dictionnary definition of 'based'. That's an issue with the term, which is fuzzy and aimed at marketing.
- Aaargh20318 4y agoThis. I interpret "plant-based" as "plants are the majority of the mass of the product."
- blacksmith_tb 4y agoSure, though it still feels a little sneaky, clearly the majority of a cookie that contains eggs and butter is still wheat... It reminds me a little more of packaging that proclaims that a box of table salt is "fat-free!" or a box of sugar is "gluten-free!" - well, yes, I'd hope so, since you'd have to go out of your way to add those in...
- scatters 4y ago> you'd have to go out of your way to add those in And yet food companies are adding minimal amounts of peanut oil or sesame flour to products, specifically so they don't have to guarantee that they are free of those allergens.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI have a can of bug spray that is "plant-based" (eucalyptus oil). Ricin is "plant-based," as is cyanide.
- Bedon292 4y agoFor bug spray I think it does make sense, at least to some level. Natural means of bug repellant like eucalyptus, lemongrass, or citronella seem to have less side effects than something like DEET. And may be the preference if there isn't a high level of insect borne illnesses in the area.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI doesn't "repel" them. It kills them dead. Apparently, Eucalyptus is quite toxic, but smells a bit like cinnamon. Koalas are tough little dropbears.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- petesergeant 4y agoAre people really selling food with eggs and milk in as plant-based, like the author claims?[0] 0: I mean, I'm sure some people are, but is anyone doing it non-fraudulently?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tengbretson 4y agoI typically interpret the term "plant-based" in a similar way to when I see that something is "based on a true story."
- sheusndudn 4y ago[dead]
- xenonite 4y ago`Plant' can also mean `factory', which makes the term luckily more factual given the highly manufactured origin of `plant-based' material.
- roflyear 4y agoWhat do you mean by this? I genuinely don't understand, and don't mean to flame bait, and no offense, but to me it sincerely seems like your comment is a mix between some kind of dog-whistle and... flame baiting...
- bcatanzaro 4y agoI’ve never seen “omnivore” used negatively before. Personally, I love fake-bleeding plant based impossible burger. Tastes great. Better for the planet. I am sad that vegans have decided it’s gross and wrong.
- mdip 4y agoI share some of the concerns of the author, but I think she's failing to "never ascribe to malice ..." -- in this case "when there are a myriad of other, less malicious reasons that are probably the cause." I suspect the biggest reason companies are choosing "plant-based" (and including "vegan" somewhere less prominent, or maybe not at all) is because they want their products to appeal to both vegans and non-vegans. In fact, they may be making products that don't appeal at all to vegans despite being vegan, but would appeal to non-vegans. First -- non-vegans -- if I see "Vegan" on something, I won't buy it unless it would only ever come that way (or would typically come that way, like a salad). If it's a "Vegan Burger", I'm assuming it's a piece of minced paper mixed with soy/plant oils and packed with enough herbs "used for grilling" to make it taste like "burnt grilled something" attempting to hide the fact that it tastes nothing like beef. If it's cheese, I assume it won't melt. It'll kind-of melt, then it'll start to harden, brown, and catch fire. If it's chicken, it's probably not vegan, but vegetarian (which are actually very good), but if it's vegan, it'll be ... wrong ... I don't know how to describe it. I was Lacto Ovo Vegetarian for a year (for health, not puppies). I tried every single vegetarian pretend-to-be-meat product that Whole Foods and Kroger sold (in 2005). Amazingly, I found a brand of sausage that almost passed if you squinted at it just so. The vegetarian (non-vegan, I think) Morningstar Farms "plant-based" chicken was better than the frozen "real" chicken equivalents a few doors over. Everything else was inedible if it was trying to be meat. I like Black Bean burgers and Portabello Mushroom burgers, but you have to season/prepare them as that kind of product. When they tried to turn it into "something beef like", it was a disaster. Fast forward to today where we have burgers that are "plant-based" that have the right texture, taste and even bleed. I don't know if my set is skewed or if this is normal but every Vegan I know (out of about 6) is vegan for their own moral, not health, reasons. Not one of them liked the meat-substitute products that I liked. They think eating animals is disgusting and it makes the flavor/texture gross to them. I'd imagine a plant-based burger that bleeds would have a similar impact. So marketing to vegans with "Vegan" prominently on the label (and any required certification/testing/other necessities to ensure you don't get a class-action by accident) and there's a good chance your actual market avoids the product right along with the vegans who don't want it (unless it stops you from eating meat, you can have that crutch. :P). > I used to hate the phrase “plant-based” because I thought it was a cute way of avoiding saying vegetarian or vegan, as well as all the cultural baggage that comes with those identifiers (and I do believe some cultural baggage here can be a mark of honor). And there's the last little nugget. To those that "Vegan" doesn't mean "Soy Pretending to be Meat and So Not Pulling it Off", it elicits images of judgemental people being vocal (in passive-aggressive ways) about the smell of the rare, juicy, Ribeye on the plate in front of me. "Plant-based" might be "Vegan except LARD" or might be "Vegan except some ingredient with an unpronounceable name that is an animal byproduct" (gelatin/glue). It probably means the latter in most cases and that's fine for the people they're marketing to.
- Waterluvian 4y agoIs it not all just an attempt at re-branding to avoid the stigma attached to the labels? A subgroup turned “vegan” into a culture and now the word is broken for use as an objective descriptor.
- cies 4y agoVeganism is an attitude towards the suffering and commodity status of animals. Being vegan you agree to boycott of products/services that entail animal suffering, "as much as possible". Vegetarianism, by contrast, is exclusively a diet that excludes dead animals. Plant-based is a diet that does not include the products that a derived from animals. Basically the diet component veganism. Though products that are produced with the help of animals (like monkeys in coconut production) is certainly not vegan, but still plant based.
- tedmiston 4y agoPlant-based does not imply meatless, vegan, or vegetarian. Many people who eat a mostly plant diet call themselves "plant-based" even if they e.g., eat meat 10–20% of the time, or eat only chicken for instance. It is its own category: where vegetarian to binary omnivore has become a spectrum. The author's confusion derives from trying to fit a round peg in the existing square holes. One can eat largely salads and vegetables with occasional meat and still be plant-based.