4 ms·
I fear the day that we get a run on your own machine version of ChatGPT. Within a week I think virtually every public signup forum will be crushed by bots which
by Gigachad 4y ago
I fear the day that we get a run on your own machine version of ChatGPT. Within a week I think virtually every public signup forum will be crushed by bots which act and talk more natural than some humans.
You’ll just expect that most of the users on discord are bots unless you know them irl.
- _osorin_ 4y agoThis is an early plot for a blade runner scenario.
- wrinkl3 4y agoNot clear how to deal with this either - you can improve authentication but it won’t prevent the properly auth’ed users from running LLMs. You can watermark the output of officially vended LLMs (Scott Aaronson seems to be working on that) but nothing is gonna prevent people from running non-watermarked versions
- Gigachad 4y agoIts basically too late, as soon as one rich person decides to train a model and dump it, it's game over. I feel we might actually be experiencing the last months of an internet where you can expect to be talking to a real human on the internet. Every year the cost of training these models drops so they won't be out of reach for long.
- elevenoh 4y ago[dead]
- thunderrabbit 4y agoEternal September in late 90s(?) Now we're coming to an Eternal (AI) Winter.. Spooky to think about, but you could be right. :-/
- awb 4y agoRequiring a phone # might be a good starting point.
- ipdashc 4y agoYou're not necessarily wrong, but you have to admit there's something funny about solving the problem of cutting-edge artificial intelligence so advanced it can pretend to be human... by requiring a telephone number. Mashup of the newest tech with some of the oldest, I guess.
- glass3 4y agoTime to invest into Facebook where users are clearly identified. How can HN and its open registration survive?
- chmod775 4y ago> You’ll just expect that most of the users on discord are bots unless you know them irl. Maybe if all you ever exchanged with someone was a few sentences about inconsequential stuff. ChatGPT isn't even close to being able to consistently act like a single human being with interests, plenty of long term memory, and a life outside a chat room. Right now the performance of ChatGPT in your average discord chat room would be absolutely awful. Nobody is bothering to write their messages as proper prompts a state-of-the-art AI could understand. People don't even just talk about one thing at a time - having multiple threads of conversation interspersed with each other is quite common and would absolutely confuse any current AI. There's also in-jokes and subtle references to things said days ago. People try to only use minimal information to convey what they mean, and often make figuring that out a small puzzle/joke to keep the conversation interesting.
- swores 4y ago> ChatGPT isn't even close to being able to consistently act like a single human being with interests, plenty of long term memory, and a life outside a chat room. Is it really not close, or just not done yet? They're already using human feedback loops to get it as good as it is generally, is it a huge step to then allow personalised feedback loops so that the local instance remembers its own "personality"? (I'm not an expert so maybe that is a huge, unrelated leap in a way that I can't see?)
- visarga 4y agoIt's not complicated to explain. The model can handle 4000 tokens at once. So all you can do is work with the limitations of this window. You can use part of it to quote the previous interactions, and part of it for the response. If your content is too large, you need to summarise it. There are AIs for that too. If the output is too large, you need to split it in multiple rounds. It is pretty hard to work around this limitation, for example to write a whole novel. I think we need LLMs capable of reading a whole book at once, about 100K tokens. I hope they can innovate the memory system of transformers a bit, there are ideas and papers, but they don't seem to get attention.
- tnzk 4y agoYou can just ask "Are you a LLM? What is <large number> + <large number>?" to reveal.
- throwaway0x7E6 4y agotheir bullshit pointless essays are out of place even here
- tjoff 4y agoThis is coming, I've been thinking that you should perhaps start to be skeptical of any content created by accounts later than 2022. Thinking of online reviews etc. where you don't have a proper log and can't follow a user properly. They are really bad as is, but they could be made completely useless in a millisecond. Even proper reviews with images etc could be absolutely trivial to make and for $10 you could automatically generate rave reviews for your product and trash any number of your competitors. We will probably need to identify users somehow, which will only serve the centralized FAANG version of internet that at least I despise.
- amelius 4y agoEternal January ...
- amelius 4y agoOn the bright side, we can use this tech to keep spammy sales representatives busy for years.
- yreg 4y agoThis is my worry as well, and I think the governments (out of all entities) could assist here. I (EU member) already have an ID card and a government issued electronic signature, perhaps a service like reddit could just ask me to sign something to verify that I'm a real and unique human being. Of course there are all kinds of risks of people being hacked, no throwaways, leaked signatures being traded, government refusing to issue IDs to whistleblowers on the run, and so on.
- dejj 4y agoI, for one, welcome our new robot overlords. Too long already has been the struggle to distinguish the phraseologists from those who think. Finally here is the societal pressure to develop means to distinguish what brings progress from all the semantic sugar that merely brings feel-good.
- ramblerman 4y agoI think it is not that far away, my prediction is - the value of real face 2 face interaction for both business and personal life will go up again. - We will see more of twitter's pay to participate models as an attempt to verify real human beings. - Online advertising will waste trillions of dollars and be late to realize they are selling to bots.
- naillo 4y agoThe api for gpt-3 is pretty cheap (and even cheaper on alternatives https://textsynth.com/ https://textsynth.com/) Either it's already happening or people don't want to use resoruces to destroy the internet, or idk what.
- generalizations 4y ago> I fear the day that we get a run on your own machine version of ChatGPT. I can't wait. I think we may see what Vernor Vinge envisioned - that we'll use AI-ish tech on our own computers to mediate between the massive flow of information on the internet and ourselves.