5 ms·
> Communism wasn't even suggested as a solution by me Communism came up when someone asked who was working on solving wealth inequality. That is what this part
by WalterBright 4y ago
> Communism wasn't even suggested as a solution by me
Communism came up when someone asked who was working on solving wealth inequality. That is what this particular thread is about.
> You clearly don't like communism
Neither do the people who've lived under it. It produces a bountiful crop of misery. That's why communists had to build walls around their countries to keep the citizens from fleeing. If you know of one that produced joy, I'd like a reference, please.
> Do you know of any government-policy-free societies that have scaled and prospered?
Government is necessary. But there should be as little of it as practical, because governments wield power and power is dangerous. It's like gasoline. I need gas to run my car and the lawnmower. But I keep as little of it around as possible. And I don't use gasoline as a household cleaner, and I try not to inhale any of it.
> No one said it didn't.
Leftists do.
> Any thoughts on how to harness self-interest in a way that doesn't bifurcate society socio-economically quite so much?
I don't see the mere existence of wealthy people being a problem. The fact of someone creating wealth (which is how people get wealthy in a free market) is not taking something from someone else.
I understand that point of view is unpopular.
- hardwaresofton 4y ago> Communism came up when someone asked who was working on solving wealth inequality. That is what this particular thread is about. Yeah if it only went that far then maybe it would have been a useful answer to a problem and nothing else, but so much anti-communist propaganda has been said at this point it seems more like you have an axe to grind rather than actually contributing to dialogue. > Government is necessary. But there should be as little of it as practical, because governments wield power and power is dangerous. It's like gasoline. I need gas to run my car and the lawnmower. But I keep as little of it around as possible. And I don't use gasoline as a household cleaner, and I try not to inhale any of it. This is too broad a statement to be accurate. You can insert many things in the place of "government' in that lawn mower analogy and sound correct. This statement is also not very interesting because "as little of it as practical" is the whole debate, for anyone who has thought about it for more than 5 mins. So essentially, your stance seems to be "small government good". Excellent -- but that doesn't really relate to my point, unless your stance is "small government good, so current and future wealth disparity is fine". > I don't see the mere existence of wealthy people being a problem. The fact of someone creating wealth (which is how people get wealthy in a free market) is not taking something from someone else. > I understand that point of view is unpopular. I suggested we need more wealthy people with higher variance amongst them, so we can see more interesting/varied outcomes. How is this relevant to that discussion?
- WalterBright 4y ago> anti-communist propaganda I'm open to any references to communist experiments that worked. > because "as little of it as practical" is the whole debate People look upon the government as the solution to every problem far too often. The proof is the constant accretion of ever more laws and regulations.
- hardwaresofton 4y agoWell I would ask the same/agree on both of these points. I don't think there are many communist experiments that worked. I also agree that government is not always the solution, as it's just another actor and can be corrupted. But I'd argue that the original thing I was looking for -- more varied people in positions of wealth/influence/power would help solve this... But it may not be solved in a way that the small government crowd would like necessarily. Is the only reasonable state gridlock amongst equally powered proponents on either side? It's not always the case that the right answer is in the middle, of course, but on this issue it seems the passable solutions seem to be.
- WalterBright 4y ago> I don't think there are many communist experiments that worked. I regularly ask for any examples of working communism. To date, none have been offered. To be fair, sometimes someone will post one. But investigating it shows that it didn't actually work. For example, one long-running commune appeared to be successful, but what it was successful at was recruiting a constant stream of enthusiasts to join up, but who inevitably left after 2 years. It's almost as if communism and human nature are just incompatible. For some reason or other, humans are not bees and living in beehives doesn't work for humans.
- hardwaresofton 4y ago> It's almost as if communism and human nature are just incompatible. For some reason or other, humans are not bees and living in beehives doesn't work for humans. This, I completely agree with. Self interest is natural for humans, and is a force to be harnessed.
- amelius 4y ago> Government is necessary. But there should be as little of it as practical, because governments wield power and power is dangerous. Yeah, but we clearly have too little of it now. Speaking from a tech standpoint, we have a duopoly in OSes. Apple has amassed an enormous amount of power. It controls an entire market of developers. It is actually being a regulator itself on that market. So, if you let the free market play things out, you will end up with something that resembles more of a dictatorship, or perhaps a bunch of them. Also, we almost completely lost net neutrality.
- WalterBright 4y ago> we clearly have too little of it now It consumes what, 40% of the GDP?
- amelius 4y agoThis only demonstrates that the size of government is not the real issue, but its parameters need tuning.
- evgen 4y ago"Consumes"? How the fuck does that work? Do those people working at the IRS or for the Forest Service simply eat all of the money being spent on those departments? Does the department of education make a big pile of cash each quarter and engage in pagan rituals while they burn their allotted percentage of GDP?
- WalterBright 4y agoConsuming it by spending it on unproductive things that nobody would spend their own money on. Governments are infamous for misallocation of funds to unproductive things. Businesses can't do that, or they go out of business.
- lukas099 4y agoWhere is the number of 40% from? Personally, I think that living in an environment where free markets can actually exist and we can live in relative safety and security is worth far more than I pay in taxes.