11 ms·
Why Solana was decimated by Bankman-Fried’s downfall
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- polygamous_bat 4y agoWhy Solana was decimated by FTX's downfall? Because in a silly, Scooby-Doo villain fashion, they were literally the same people more often than not. Personal anecdote: I was supposed to get in a call with a few people on the Solana team -- received a calendar invite with a name@ftx.com address, which was then amended to a name@solana.com address. Make of that what you may.
- optimalsolver 4y agoSame way that Tether and Bitfinex are exactly the same people.
- nileshtrivedi 4y agoI looked at the Solana ecosystem when people started claiming its strong performance and scalability aspects. It was remarkable how difficult it was to find the identities of actual people behind Solana, Phantom, Serum etc, even though Solana is a VC-funded chain. Personally, I would never put money in any project where the team does not even put their identity & reputation at risk. But in those times, lots of people did exactly that. https://twitter.com/nileshtrivedi/status/1459438723305725952 https://twitter.com/nileshtrivedi/status/1459438723305725952
- pavlov 4y ago> “I would never put money in any project where the team does not even put their identity & reputation at risk.” In the heady days of web3 of <checks watch> six months ago, we were being told that it’s actually better if you don’t know who is behind a project because that’s the true spirit of decentralization. Just another crypto gaslighting exercise. Remember when people were very upset that the creators of the Boring Ape NFTs were revealed from public records?
- dragonwriter 4y ago”zero trust” is when there are plenty of key people in critical, load-bearing roles, but you have no basis to trust any of them, right?
- biztos 4y agoI met a youngish European guy who was working as a project manager for a DAO, I forget what they did but they made money and the staff got paid (crypto). It turned out many of the people working for the DAO were anonymous and nobody in the DAO knew or cared who they were in real life. They did good work, got paid crypto, everyone was happy. When I asked “what about sanctions” he gave me the blankest look I’ve ever seen.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoBecause sanctions and crypto are inherently incompatible. The former is a flex of institutional, state power. The latter is an exercise in screw-the-state libertarianism.
- Galanwe 4y agoI don't necessarily agree... I want widespread crypto, because I want to have the autonomy to initiate transfers myself, transparency of my accounts, easier back office, less payment middlemen, etc. Yet I would like a state managed crypto (e-euro?) so that a fraudulous transfer, stolen wallet, etc can be canceled. - We're in 2022 and I still can't have an API with my bank to analyze my purchases, I have to parse PDF monthly reports. - I still can't automate my savings without a third party robo advisor than requires me giving my account credentials. - I can't easily make FX swaps without a third party broker with 2 days wire transfers in/out. - I can't swap without a brokerage margin account. etc. Centralized crypto? yes please, it's still better than the current state of affairs. Not everyone lives in Europe or the US with fancy worldwide smart banking. Here in HK, banks are from the 90s. Crypto centralized would level the banking experience to the current century.
- 4y ago
- kragen 4y agosatoshi
- defrost 4y agobourbaki
- kart23 4y agocome on, it's on wikipedia and they put it on their linkedin. It's really not that difficult, it's not like they tried to keep their identities secret.
- polygamous_bat 4y agoWhere are you finding it? Wikipedia only lists the "founders", which links to the "History" page in Solana's homepage [0], which only has story until 2018. Notably, this is before FTX was a thing, so my claim becomes "Solana was taken over by FTX at some point." [0] https://docs.solana.com/history https://docs.solana.com/history
- kart23 4y agook, i assume you just wanted to know about who was behind solana, which is pretty simple. i don’t know about any of those other crypto projects or who is running them now.
- nailer 4y ago> It was remarkable how difficult it was to find the identities of actual people behind Solana, Phantom, Serum etc. https://www.linkedin.com/company/solanalabs/ https://www.linkedin.com/company/solanalabs/ https://www.linkedin.com/company/phantomwallet/ https://www.linkedin.com/company/phantomwallet/
- darth_avocado 4y agoYou mean BitFinesse
- spaceman_2020 4y agoI have zero confidence that the 30B or so Tethers floating around on Tron are actually real.
- wmf 4y agoWould you have felt better if all the developers worked for Solana Labs? Honestly I would consider it not bad if development was split between Solana Labs, Jump, and FTX.
- nailer 4y agoIt was decimated because FTX held between 5-11% of all Sol and sold it immediately when they were going down, dropping the price from 36 to 10 dollars. Eth is down 70%. Sol being down 90% given the above isn’t surprising.
- largepeepee 4y agoIt's far from just tokens. They funded several sol projects that are now underwater without their money even DeFi ones with how FTX was controlling serum. Serum itself was the backbone of numerous sol projects and when it got exposed for being heavily manipulated by FTX, it was obvious sol was gonna get fucked.
- nailer 4y agoTo be fair the Solana community replaced serum with opendex in one week.
- wc- 4y agoThis point is getting missed by a lot of people I think. FTX / Alameda had a part in funding almost all solana-based projects, and almost all of these fundings involved some kind of "use FTX as your bank" fundraising stipulation. So not only were they propping up the ecosystem with projects getting funding that might not have really deserved it, but now those projects have no treasuries. The entire solana ecosystem is just nuked now and it isn't hard to see this in on-chain activity and project/dao comm's. edit: as a dev solana had some nice implementation details and was a step forward over some other chains in some ways. IMO it's totally DOA now, but I hope the dev community (whoever is real and not an alameda-funded "anon" dev etc) continues on in some capacity on a fork or other chain.
- abacadaba 4y agofor better or worse, at least it is/was something other than another evm fork. will buy some at $3.50 for lulz.
- lend000 4y ago
- ignoramous 4y ago> ...they were literally the same people more often than not. Curiously, a16z is the lead investor in Solana and Coinbase, while Sequoia...
- polygamous_bat 4y agoTo be completely fair, they were investing in FTX and FTX but with a comically large mustache on; two different entities entirely.
- m00dy 4y agoIt is a good project though...A very elegant account model, Rust in action, engineering practices that make sense for becoming the fastest chain in the market...And then, SBF showed up and shit hit the fan.
- agd 4y agoI don’t understand the value of Solana. Crypto’s value (at least in part) depends on it being decentralised. I.e trustless. Solana looks like it was relatively centralised, so what’s the point? And why would it be worth much even before FTX collapse?
- oneoff786 4y agoThe value of crypto to many people was the fact that other people were willing to give them dollars for it.
- andirk 4y agoSeeing as stonks trade for often >40x the company's actual output, sounds pretty similar, doesn't it? Most coins should be worth a fraction of their traded value, and the same with Wall Street. The keyword is speculation that it will eventually catch up to its bullshit traded value. We learned that in 2008, and a lot of people lost their savings and the roofs over their children, then a few years later we completely forgot and now act like crypto invented the idea of trading bullshit.
- ffssffss 4y agoSure, it's kind of like really crappy penny stocks that are in danger of being delisted and probably doing fraud. But real companies have cashflows and assets, get audited by real auditors, hire real employees instead of teenage "anons", etc. It's actually pretty different!
- andirk 4y ago
- hanniabu 4y agoWhat's sad is projects like this and the broader crypto scene (rightfully) turn people off of blockchain and then overlook Ethereum
- te_chris 4y agoNo one’s overlooking ethereum, it’s just not that useful to use the worlds slowest, most expensive computer when there is literally any other option for most cases.
- hanniabu 4y agoIf you're willing to throw out security and use one of the many EVM clones, then you're just better off using a database. You're giving away the main value add and are just left with inefficiencies.
- KMag 4y ago> If you're willing to throw out security and use one of the many EVM clones... The devil is in the implementation details, but if we're talking about eBPF vs. EVM... one of them was designed for deadlock-free execution of untrusted code in-kernel, and the other is EVM. Though, for smart contracts, I think we're best off with a graph reduction execution model, where the contract is presented its initial state and an array of the output contract states, and the contract graph evaluates to True i.f.f. the outputs are an acceptable end-state given the initial state. The client code would propose the new state, along with a compact representation of the path taken through the graph. (The path represented as the index of each branch taken at every OR node in a pre-order traversal of the graph.) The client-side execution to find a True path through the graph might not be efficient, but the on-graph verification is fast, and the format lends itself to a declarative contract description.
- cfcosta 4y agoIsn't this a modified version of eUTXO [1]? Known initial state/datum, transactions can be simulated/commited without needing global input like the account model needs. The tradeoff is, of course, that scripts become much harder to implement, as you can't depend on global state. [1]: https://iohk.io/en/research/library/papers/the-extended-utxo-model/ https://iohk.io/en/research/library/papers/the-extended-utxo...
- yashg 4y agoAll these articles are written in all seriousness as if all these gambling projects have some kind of real world utility and these coins/chains/layers have some value. A bunch of swindlers get a pack of nerds who sincerely believe they are changing the world to build these projects and the hoard of starry eyed simpletons lose their life savings in the hope of hitting the jackpot. It's the same old story.
- arez 4y agoevery generation has to learn their lessons and greed, ponzis and scammers is always taught
- tshaddox 4y agoIf only there was a way to learn about bad things that happened in the past over and over again without simply repeating the bad thing. Like some way to record descriptions of past events.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 4y agoIt's an Eternal September of people needing to develop antibodies to scams, one generation at a time. Unfortunately immunity doesn't get passed down intergenerationally, or at least not enough that a few members of the herd won't be receptive to the infection the next time around. Every time "this time is different" with a sizeable group.
- bombcar 4y agoIt’s a bit easier now as you can search and find out what the scam behind “stuff envelopes for money” for example. Being able to see everything beforehand and “for free” helps immunize against lots of them.
- meepmorp 4y agoI was 14 or so, my dad and I stopped to watch a 3 card monte game being played on the street. I thought I knew where the card was, impulsively bet $20, and lost my money (obviously). My dad watched this happen, told me why betting on it was stupid and made me buy lunch afterwards. I got off easy.
- nailer 4y ago> a layer 1 smart-contract blockchain that in some respects competes with Ethereum He could have said “the most active blockchain” but chose not to. Interesting.
- treis 4y agoThere's a lot of companies that are going down with SBF. All the money that Alameda + SBF used for bailouts and acquisitions is subject to clawbacks. That's billions of dollars that will have to be paid back. Likely that none of them will be able to since they needed the bailout in the first place and crypto has crashed.
- tootie 4y agoThere's so little legitimate business happening in the crypto world. All these crypto whales are just other exchanges. Or criminals. And braindead VCs.
- monero-xmr 4y ago[flagged]
- robin_reala 4y agoBoth can be true?
- zinekeller 4y agoYeah, the pretentious ignorance of cryptobros to reality irks me out. It seems that in discussions they really try to change the goalpost while saying "X is tolerated, why not crypto?"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tootie 4y agoThat's completely untrue though. There's enormous amounts of legitimate business happening in ad tech. You're just saying you don't like the methods. Ads drive sales of real goods and services. And mostly for reputable real-world businesses.
- 4y ago
- strangescript 4y agoEveryone wants to blame it on something, but the reality is we are in a bear market. All but a few coins will go down 90+%, the few others will go down 70% and bitcoin dominance (bitcoin market cap compared to entire crypto market cap) will go up. Some of these coins will recover in the next bull market, but the question is always which ones. This cycle has happened multiple times at this point. Crypto is dead, the sky is falling. Its all happened before. The only thing that might be different this time is we could be starting a very long global bear market started by high interest rates in the U.S. to curb runaway inflation.
- abakker 4y agoAnd crypto has also categorically failed to be a hedge against inflation! It has proved to be high correlated and it is just as fiat as anything else. Backed by irrational exuberance.
- d_e_solomon 4y agoMost of the gains in Bitcoin are highly correlated with gains in the SP500. The times that it tends to decouple is when Bitcoin is crashing due to Bitcoin problems. So definitely not a great inflation hedge and definitely a rather risky asset class.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kzrdude 4y agoSeems to be correlated with everything else that was buoyed by surplus money
- dinkumthinkum 4y agoPeople talk about fiat as currency as if it is ludicrous but the crypto market has verifiably been a series pump and dump schemes.
- 4y ago
- yieldcrv 4y agoI’m not a speculator or a developer on Solana, but there isn't anything fundamentally different about this chain to really… worry about it? Blocks will still be produced, and when someone DDOS’ the ability to produce blocks all the validators will route around it and keep producing blocks Who cares if the price of Sol is $.20 cents (~$73 million market cap on 367 million Sol) by the time institutional funds, Sam and bankruptcy trustees finish selling, thats not really a factor in technology like this If you wanna dump all your files and application onto this data store, cheap Sol will let you do it very cheaply and validators will happily store it.
- m3kw9 4y agoEver notice that during a bear market, blockchain seem to have become useless, and come bull market everybody would say this is like the internet in the 70s. Lmao
- guessbest 4y agoIn the 1970's there were very few Internet providers so probably a bad place to create a startup.
- biscottigelato 4y agoBitcoin is used increasingly as a tool against French colonial CFA Franc in Africa. A lifeline to access the outside financial world for citizens of countries under sanction. https://iharare.com/african-countries-are-no-strangers-to-the-use-of-bitcoin/ https://iharare.com/african-countries-are-no-strangers-to-th... Everything else is garbage I agree
- friend_and_foe 4y agoWhat makes Monero garbage?
- brian_cunnie 4y ago> Bitcoin is used increasingly as a tool against French colonial CFA Franc in Africa To quote hn_zorba [0], who replied to a similar comment you made: > There's no mention of CFA Francs in that article? Also the bitcoin experiment that this article briefly talks about has since become a failure - though that's probably more on the incompetence of the rollout than bitcoin. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34165882#34168577 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34165882#34168577
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- someonewhocar3s 4y ago[dead]
- paulpauper 4y agoWhat hasn't been decimated? Except BNB almost every major coin is down a lot. Don't blame SBF, blame a major bubble bursting and people trying to get out at any price to preserve little capital that remains.
- Marazan 4y ago> Except BNB almost every major coin is down a lot. If this isn't the most red flag of red flags about BNB then nothing will be.
- kerkeslager 4y agoSolana was centralized in a bunch of really obvious ways, and if you were taken in by Solana, I strongly suggest that you gain an understanding of what was centralized about Solana before investing in any crypto again. This has happened before and will likely happen again. If you're investing in crypto without understanding what decentralization is, you're investing in things you fundamentally don't understand, which is always a poor choice. What worries me more about this is that companies like Coinbase listed Solana at all. I think that Coinbase does understand decentralization and knew Solana was centralized, so listing a centralized coin shows that they're not committed to decentralization.
- sanjayio 4y agoI couldn't agree more. There were so many signals that Solana was bad technology. There were times when transactions were down and times were out of sync. This should never happen with decentralized technology. There are no devs on PagerDuty to fix these issues when they occur, neither should we want devs to have the ability to put up or down a decentralized technology. I stayed and plan on staying very far from Solana.
- nailer 4y agoBugs exist in all tech decentralised or otherwise. Banking systems go down, Visa goes down, Twitter goes down, HN goes down. Sol has never gone down for some serious unfixable design flaw: rather a bug gets discovered and fixed. That’s how scalable systems using new architectures are built. If one of the less active chains handled Solana’s volume they’d occasionally have had issues too. Also Solana has been pretty damn reliable of late despite doing more volume than ever before: https://status.solana.com/uptime https://status.solana.com/uptime
- virtualritz 4y agoIf a bug in a purportedly decentralized system can bring the entire system down/to a halt, this very fact refutes the claim and shows that the system has a – drumrolls – central point of failure.