9 ms·
Microsoft fined $64M by France over cookies used in Bing searches
- jefftk 4y agoEarlier discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34095258 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34095258
- jvdvegt 4y agoIronic that scmagazine.com has the exact same issue with their cookie banner as what Microsoft is now being fined for.
- wongarsu 4y agoGDPR enforcement so far is one of these rare examples where the bigger fish are fined and prosecuted first. (Yes, fines against smaller players happen, but are less likely on a per-company basis).
- wmeredith 4y agoIt would be nice if everything worked that way. When it works the opposite way, it's a vicious cycle of letting the biggest fish grow and making them even harder to go after.
- r00fus 4y agoThat’s the expected outcome if you let the big players capture [1] the regulatory regime. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture
- johndhi 4y agoAgreed. Jfyi if curious, cookie law technically isn't part of GDPR. It's from an older law that was ignored for many years called the e-privacy directive.
- Semaphor 4y agoThe (very small) company I work at got a warning from our DPA (Germany, SH, so the relevant one is the ULD). I had a nice discussion with our caseworker there, where he also said that for small companies, they are extremely lenient and very happy to work with them to improve things.
- _0w8t 4y agoI was at presentation about GDPR in Norway and the implied message was similar. It can be tricky to implement GDPR correctly, but if a small company will mistake on that, authorities will simply point to it with a reasonable timeline to fix it before any talk about fines. Bigger companies is supposed to have resources to implement GDPR properly the first time.
- slowwriter 4y agoGDPR is not the EU regulation on cookies. GDPR only has a single direct mention of cookies. The ePrivacy Directive is what's known as the "cookie law" (https://gdpr.eu/cookies/ https://gdpr.eu/cookies/)
- loeg 4y agoThe ePD dates to 2002 but stupid cookie banners only came into being around the same time as the GDPR in 2018. I think you can say the cookie banners are in some technical legal sense ePD's fault, but to laypeople it certainly seems that the GDPR is why every website is less usable and more annoying than it was just a few years ago.
- meowface 4y agoHaven't those annoying banners been prevalent long before 2018? Maybe GPDR made them more popular, but I'm not sure.
- loeg 4y agoThe short answer is no. They are a very recent phenomenon.
- corney91 4y agoI don't think that's right, I remember joking about cookie banners in the late 00s. Since GDPR they now have buttons and categories though, whereas previously we never had a choice, just a notice that cookies were in use.
- loeg 4y agoThere were banner shaped popovers in the 00s, but to my memory they weren't for cookies. Any chance you're a European? We may have been visiting different slices of the internet in that period.
- deltree7 4y ago[flagged]
- hansworst 4y agoOr, you know, maybe companies could just respect the laws in the countries in which they do business. And if they disagree with those laws, they can either ignore them and pay the fine, or simply choose to not do business in those countries.
- mopsi 4y agoWhat's draconian about requiring opt-out button to be displayed the same way as opt-in button?
- rahen 4y agoI'm pretty sure European companies are expected to follow US laws when operating on US soil. Why shouldn't the opposite be true?
- johndhi 4y agoThis regulator approach is pretty common in western Europe so it's hard to choose which country to exit between France, Germany, or Italy. And worst yet, each has its own pet peeve that it enforces - France with cookies, Italy with contract language, Germany with employee monitoring.
- deltree7 4y agoCan you tell me how GDPR has improved European lives over say a New Yorker? Go ahead, I'm waiting. The number of HNers who are willing to accept stupid laws and beholden to bureaucracy is mind-boggling
- mopsi 4y ago> Can you tell me how GDPR has improved European lives over say a New Yorker? My spam disappeared overnight. There was a flood of "click here to give consent" emails a little before GDPR came into force, and then radio silence. I now only get the low-effort botnet viagra emails that are trivial to identify and catch, and even their amount has dwindled to only 5 this month. I guess most of them fail SPF/DKIM/etc tests and don't get delivered at all. Same with snail mail. I used to get a pretty large pile of all kinds of ads every week, now I get only invoices, official notices and postcards from friends. In online services like Youtube, I don't have to click through menus to opt-out of tracking anymore. There's now an equally visible opt-out button on the consent dialog. When I visit sites like USA Today, I get a much nicer version without tracking, ads and auto-playing videos: https://i.imgur.com/YQXaavw.jpg https://i.imgur.com/YQXaavw.jpg
- johndhi 4y agoI interpret cookie law for a tech co. Imo the law should be structured such that people who care can opt out of cookies programmatically, but every day people who don't care don't need to see a pop up on every site. That causes psychic load and makes us hate the internet. Also, people should get together and vote on what constitutes "strictly necessary" cookies that don't require consent and "non-essential" cookies that do. It's currently up to some nerds in EU. Why can't we have people make these calls?
- shadowgovt 4y agoBecause behavioral psychology tests reveal that the public is both super-paranoid about being spied on and will sell their PII to anyone who asks in exchange for a $5 discount at a store. It's hard to craft good law when the mismatch between public stated desire and public behavior is so wide.
- johndhi 4y agoWell put. We were given Facebook for free on the basis that they can advertise to us. We voted for behavioral advertising with our feet. Yet, we consume documentaries about how evil zuck is and love to hate him. But shouldn't we take both into account or just think about it hard once and then be done with it? We're wasting a lot of time and energy.
- shadowgovt 4y agoHistory suggests that trying to fit a "once and for all" solution atop a populace in disagreement results in disaster.
- dybber 4y agoIt shouldn't be by law, it should just be part of web standards that you can set your cookies preferences once and for all and all websites should respect that setting. I guess browser vendors and whoever else sits in these W3 consortiums like their cookies too much.
- martinald 4y agoI think despite the goals of GDPR/cookie law being laudable, it really has turned into a complete trainwreck for the European tech sector IMO. I work with tech product companies in both the EU and US. EU companies are completely stymed by GDPR/privacy implications. Features are often delayed for weeks/months as it goes through endless cycles of GDPR etc compliance discussion, which often doesn't have a concrete answer in the end! Smaller tech companies in the US are in the whole not doing this. They are moving far, far, faster because of it. It really is night and day. Sidenote: EU tech companies tend to be much more risk averse than US ones in general. This means GDPR really scares leadership there and the often lose the bigger picture. The worst thing about these laws are that the regional/national courts are all interpreting them differently, often with major implications. I think we will actually get to the point where many tech products just block the EU from using them. It is impossible to comply with the law IMO with so many conflicting interperations from regional courts and if the fines keep ratcheting up it will become uneconomic to serve the EU market.
- RajT88 4y ago> I think despite the goals of GDPR/cookie law being laudable, it really has turned into a complete trainwreck for the European tech sector IMO. It's a giant pain for my work for sure. Anything which could potentially have some intersection at some point with European customers has to fully comply with all of these EU privacy regulations. Usually that means taking an already clunky internal system and adding a bunch of restrictions to it to make it even more clunky. Also banning some useful practices and tooling that me and people like me use for our day-to-day. Yes, some of this is due to internal dysfunction.
- jgalt212 4y agoThis story has been up for while, but no one has made a joke about the crumb-sized fine for Microsoft's bad cookies.