3 ms·
It is man against machine. If we fully understand how genes work, would you trust some private company to create a trustworthy social credit score based on any
by imtringued 4y ago
It is man against machine. If we fully understand how genes work, would you trust some private company to create a trustworthy social credit score based on any potential situation, even situations that are obviously not in the data set?
The story was about people blindly trusting a machine to say "valid". The police force didn't want to figure out the crime, they just wanted to find the one without the "valid". The setting that was presented was some sort of communist utopia where the economic calculation problem has been solved through a gene scanner and central computer control.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoAFAIk the ‘invalid’ was just unregistered, Vincent wasn’t just intentionally shedding someone else’s DNA he kept his own from being registered- it would have been a much shorter movie if it was.
- chrchang523 4y agoNo, there’s at least one scene in the movie where the DNA scanner does identify Vincent, so he is registered in the system.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoIf you mean the photo I figured that was a recreation based on the ability to predict attributes from DNA like facial structure, hair, and myopia. Myopia was listed as a known characteristic in the ‘invalid’ image. It didn’t give his name and his own brother had to work to find his identity. They go looking for the him amongst the vagrant unregistered population where it’s pointed out that they’re looking for someone smart so he’s probably not going to be there. It could be assumed that all genetically engineered people are registered so ‘invalid’ would imply not-genetically engineered. Modern identification based on DNA is far easier in real life as he would still share many genetic variants with his brother.