13 ms·
1k True Fans (2008)
- jmathai 4y agoThe 1k true fans approach is the most suitable one for most people looking to build a business or income stream. It lets you hyper focus on a niche that may not be well served by more general purpose solutions. But don’t let the 1k number fool you. Getting even 1 true fan is incredibly difficult. But the idea is that if you can get 1, you can find your 2nd, then 4th, 8th, 16th, 32nd, 64th, 128th, 256th, 512th and finally your 1k. It’s a tractable number of steps. Hard, but something you can wrap your brain around and small enough to start focusing. A personal example is that I’ve a few hundred passionate users of my photo management software [1]. It’s open source so they aren’t paying for it. I’ve tried a few ideas without much success to provide a fiscally beneficial aspect of it - without much luck yet. But it remains one of the best opportunities for me to create a small community of people willing to pay for something I create - which is my goal. [1] https://getelodie.com https://getelodie.com [1 also] https://github.com/jmathai/elodie https://github.com/jmathai/elodie
- m3kw9 4y agoAlso the first fan could be yourself, if you kid yourself thinking you love it then you will suffer endless questions on why it isn’t taking off.
- blueboo 4y agoIn some sense, it has to be yourself. If you’re not fully bought-in to the value to the extent that you genuinely enjoy and benefit from using it, you’re forced to hypothesise about that first true fan, even if she sits across from you. More likely you’ll get lost in discussion of personas and market segments and user journeys and end up condescending to your audience. In short, you’ve got feel the need for the thing to exist—for yourself.
- jmathai 4y agoI think the 1k true fans approach means going deep instead of wide. And in order to do so you need to really understand what would make people fans of your work. A mistake many people make is that they mistake low intent interest as a proxy for opportunity. You can’t always ask people what they want. You have to build a thing that intersects with their (often subconscious) needs. This is where scratching an itch you have a deep understanding of is helpful.
- boredemployee 4y agoYep. To get one real fan, other than your mom and your girlfriend is super hard. I worked as a professional music producer and dj for 10 years in a good niche, paid my bills and raised my kid for that long, and while many other djs and producers played my music productions/compositions and threated me as one of the best in my country, my career never took off. Today I do it as a hobby in my free time and no one really seemed to care that I stop doing it lol so maybe I never had a single REAL fan.
- ttjjtt 4y agocan you see yourself making and releasing music again at some point?
- boredemployee 4y agoMore like a hobby yes. If you ask me if I would try to make a living out of it again, then I'm not sure (probably not). The feeling of not making a single cent for a few months in the beginning of the pandemic was a bit traumatic.
- paulpauper 4y agoWelcome to survivorship bias. For every person who succeeds there are many who fail but you never hear about them.
- boredemployee 4y agoAnd yet I was miles ahead many other struggling artists and musicians that couldn't make a cent out of their craft. I was shrinking but what really forced me to stop and start to learn a programming language was the pandemics (that's how I learned about HN btw).
- justhw 4y agoWhat genre if you don't mind? I'm curious if we can hear your mix.
- rafram 4y agoNitpick: On Elodie’s homepage, “No Propietary Database” should be “No Proprietary Database”.
- jmathai 4y agoFixed. Thanks.
- paulpauper 4y agoBut the idea is that if you can get 1, you can find your 2nd, then 4th, 8th, 16th, 32nd, 64th, 128th, 256th, 512th and finally your 1k. Things don't always scale like that. It's called the logistic curve. At some it becomes harder to keep growing at the same rate as before.
- jmathai 4y agoBut don’t let the 1k number fool you. Getting even 1 true fan is incredibly difficult. That’s what is great about 1k. The degree to which you need to scale is reasonable if you find a large enough niche - and they number of niches where scaling your 1k true fans is large. Doesn’t make it easy, but doubling the number of people who love what you create is tractable.
- mustafabisic1 4y agoEvery time I've read this article it hit differently. Reading 1 (2016): Oh man it'd be great to have 1k true fans. This guy makes it easy. Reading 2 (2019): Now I have some things in life and I should build, how hard could it be. You try and fail. Reading 3 (2022): You've gained even more experience and go for it hard. You realize that the guy had disclaimers across the article (like this: The truth is that cultivating a thousand true fans is time consuming, sometimes nerve racking, and not for everyone. ) Not sure what the 4th reading will bring, but if you're a remote working parent check out my work - https://thursdaydigest.com/ https://thursdaydigest.com/ Not sure what the It especially hits differently now that I'm a builder.
- metadat 4y agoPrevious discussions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26270182 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26270182 (Feb 2021; 120 points, 66 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21369257 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21369257 (Oct 2019; 71 points, 24 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17007347 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17007347 (May 2018; 69 points, 8 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10625906 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10625906 (Nov 2015; 47 points, 9 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1338957 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1338957 (May 2010; 35 points, 10 comments)
- yunruse 4y agoIn general I think this is why embracing tiered levels of payment/subscription seems to be working for a lot of people -- it captures the fan-intensity curve, providing a structure which is both fit to hyper-fans and casual fans alike, whatever the business model is. This seems to explain to me the rise of tiered models (Patreon, Kickstarter, ads-or-premium, freemium apps, etc), and why DLCs and sequels tend to be more popular in media. Heuristics like these seem to work by exploiting general properties of this Pareto-y curve. Obviously people in real life don't necessarily follow curves... but as a total economics laywoman, it is intriguing to see how, similarly to a supply-demand curve for physical goods, a Zipfian curve of "fan intensity vs frequency" (as shown in the article) has sort of begun to show itself in various places.
- neilv 4y agoThis is part of why I abandoned my one-stop book on practical software engineering in a powerful fringe language. Rather than 1,000 true fans who'd buy anything I create, for $100 per fan per year... I could invest half a year of intense work on the book, and be pretty sure at least 10 people would buy it for $25, out of a sense of obligation. $50 would be pushing my luck.
- coldtea 4y agoThis idea reminds me of something I've read on some old blog post about enterpreneurship. So, the guys starting the company were excited, because they said "We know the odds are small, but we don't need much, if just 1 in 1000 buys our product we're rich, as that's like 350K people in the US. And how difficult would be to get 1 in 1000 to buy our stuff with a little marketing? It's a great product anyway! Heck, if just 1 in 10,000 buys our product, that's still 35K sales, enough to bootstrap the company and make some decent profit! And 1 in 10,000 should be trivial!" Ultimately, though the message the author of the post got from that business plan failing miserably, is that there's always the posibility of 0 in 1000 buying their product... "Just get 1000 true fans" downplays the difficulty.
- Mtinie 4y agoDoes it downplay the difficulty? As an artist, I appreciate the statement because it reminds me to appropriately scope what tiers of “success” can mean. I have zero illusions about the ease of convincing 1000 people to trade their money for works I’ve produced. But 1000 people is a small enough number that I can conceive of in my minds eye and then plan concrete steps to try to make it happen.
- ugjka 4y agoIf you read their definition of a true fan they sound like borderline insane >A true fan is defined as a fan that will buy anything you produce. These diehard fans will drive 200 miles to see you sing; they will buy the hardback and paperback and audible versions of your book; they will purchase your next figurine sight unseen; they will pay for the “best-of” DVD version of your free youtube channel; they will come to your chef’s table once a month.
- actionablefiber 4y agoYeah, seems like maybe they will also show up at your house unannounced and uninvited!
- bookofjoe 4y ago
- MrLeap 4y agoDoes anyone have any suggestions where I could go looking for fans? I'm making a text editor/game where you write text documents with tentacle arms. Learn ritual magic based on what you write / activate machines by writing. I've got about 1400 followers on twitter, had a few semi-successful posts on reddit. Tiktok did less well. My weathervane is currently pointed towards doing more on YouTube. Enough people have downloaded the demo on steam that a few novels worth of text has probably been written with it, so that's fun. I'm not at a point where I can discern my count of who is a _true fan_, but there's probably a few in there.
- bhaak 4y agoIf it's a game I wonder why you tried TikTok but not Twitch? That would probably need more time involvement than TikTok but most game livestreams are still on Twitch. Although from your description I'm not sure how much of a spectators game it is.
- MrLeap 4y agoIn order to extend the runway of a self funded solo development text editor rpg game, I moved into a barn. The upload from my martian rover rusty can antenna is not sufficient for live streaming, however, I can wait several revolutions of the daystar for asynchronous uploads. Starlink was supposed to be my enabler and savior, but Elon betrayed us because my barn isn't a boat or a plane I guess. My easily accessible options are youtube/twitter/reddit/ + light a candle for twitch someday.
- slater- 4y agodude, what?! i am immediately a fan.
- MrLeap 4y agoGlad to have you.
- DVassallo 4y agoYou will want to go where people already hang around. There are many sites where people interested in some topic are constantly refreshing the page looking for something interesting/helpful/useful/entertaining/etc. Find those places, help as many people as you can, and build a name for yourself there.
- grepLeigh 4y ago1,000 true fans is an essay about a thousand die-hard fans paying a content creator $100/year, which comes out to 100k before taxes and expenses. I'd argue that if you're smart enough to be reading this website, you're smart enough to create and sell a piece of software to 10 businesses. If you can add 2% of revenue/quarter or save 5-10% of an expense, you can name your price (as long as it's below the amount of revenue you generated or money you saved). Paradoxically, it's easier to charge lots of money vs. convince lots of people to give you a little bit of money. If you don't believe me, I encourage you to run a time-boxed experiment where you attempt to do both for 1 month. Post your findings to HackerNews! This might seem more boring compared to 1,000 fans (1,000 people who follow you is a great dopamine hit), but it's also much easier!
- rafale 4y ago> I'd argue that if you're smart enough to be reading this website... I would agree that the average IQ (or potential in general) of the HN readers is more than that of the general population, but I disagree there is any minimum threshold here in any capacity that warrant your statement. Many readers here can't code at all, or couldn't learn to well enough to build and market software.
- grepLeigh 4y agoIf you're reading this and can't code (yet), the pressure of delivering something real is an effective way to learn! You can also accomplish a remarkable breadth of tasks with no/low-code tools, to the point where you don't need to be a software engineer to build an MVP and start charging money to validate. Take a swing (and keep swinging even after you've struck out - you'll hit something eventually, and it'll feel great) (edited)
- intelVISA 4y agoI wouldn't say being able to code is a requirement to build and market software these days. You could get decently far just glueing together libs in Js/Py until VC funding.
- 4y ago
- paulpauper 4y agoThis again? 1k true fans, like the 10k hours rule popularized by Gladwell or the Purple Cow by Godin, etc. sounds better on paper than in practice, but there are always caveats and major survivorship bias. Getting those 1k fans is quite hard, as it turns out, maybe impossible even though it's not that many on an absolute basis. According to Kevin Kelly, a true fan is more than just a Twitter follower or a Facebook like. It's someone who is a paying customer or will refer others. https://greyenlightenment.com/2022/06/26/1000-true-fans-long-tail-grit-and-other-popular-bullshit/ https://greyenlightenment.com/2022/06/26/1000-true-fans-long... How do you get those 1k fans? Hard enough just getting 1000 hits to a website, 1000 people to even click a link, etc. It's like MLM. "All you need is 2 people ..and then they tell 2 people, etc."
- tester457 4y agoBut unlike an MLM all the money goes to you and not the top of the pyramid.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- willhinsa 4y agoYou only need 1 true fan if it's the right fan! There was a (uploaded to TikTok) video I saw where this guy had 18 followers on YouTube, and just was not getting any kind of traction at all. I mean some traction but not much -- only 18 followers! Was about to quit. Then all of a sudden he got contacted by Oprah Winfrey's people about hosting a TV show about the ideas that he talked about in his videos. It turns out that one of the 18 followers he had on YouTube was Oprah Winfrey's hair stylist, and Oprah was talking to her about this project she was trying to get started, and the stylist mentioned this one YouTube account she loved who was all about that topic, and the rest is history. Every single person who watches your video is a unique human individual, and magic can happen from just one spark, from just one person!
- alfiedotwtf 4y agoI think that's called luck... so apart from putting in the time and effort, work towards increasing your Luck Surface Area.
- swyx 4y ago> Luck Surface Area https://www.swyx.io/create-luck/#luck-surface-area https://www.swyx.io/create-luck/#luck-surface-area
- paulpauper 4y agoOr better yet, just be the CEO's son..one fan lol
- jb1991 4y ago> You only need 1 true fan if it's the right fan! Also known as an employer.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wingerlang 4y agoWho was that, and what was the idea?
- cgag 4y agoMy friend showed me a cool series of photography books he'd backed on Kickstarter called Vanishing Asia. Only after we'd finished flipping through them did I realize they were by Kevin Kelly. I just looked up the campaign (https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/kk-org/vanishing-asia https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/kk-org/vanishing-asia): 2,348 backers pledged $603,420 to help bring this project to life.
- fxtentacle 4y agoReminds me of this story: Influencer with 2 million "fans" fails to sell 252 t-shirts out of her new collection. https://de.style.yahoo.com/influencerin-mit-2-millionen-fans-schafft-es-nicht-36-shirts-zu-verkaufen-101727389.html https://de.style.yahoo.com/influencerin-mit-2-millionen-fans...
- amelius 4y agoThis can't work, otherwise people would make actual money from publishing e.g. technical books, which we know is not really profitable.
- tester457 4y agoI think a true fan only applies to creative works that people consume for the sake of enjoyment. Because most people only read technical books to attain skills, not for fun. Theres not much that separates the one Tedious Tome of Typescript from another, even if the author's style is different. Meanwhile people genuinely want to consume art for fun by paying for patreon tiers, buy books and sign up for mailing lists, or support indie games on kickstarter.
- tkgally 4y ago> I think a true fan only applies to creative works that people consume for the sake of enjoyment. That was my thought, too. And not all creative works, either—rather, creative works where the personality and individuality of the creator are clearly expressed. The author lists “craftsperson, photographer, musician, designer, author, animator, app maker, entrepreneur, or inventor” as examples of people who “need only thousands of true fans,” but the first six seem to me much more likely to attract long-term true fans than the last three.
- amelius 4y ago> I think a true fan only applies to creative works that people consume for the sake of enjoyment. I don't have the numbers but I'm sure only a few topseller authors make a lot of money, while there is a long tail of writers that live near poverty.
- csa 4y agoI’m not sure if this falls under your definition of “technical books”, but Michael Hartl’s Rails Tutorial is an incredible example of a 1000 fans-esque type of (light) technical book. That was started in 2010, and for a long time the online version was free (he made money from videos, pdfs, etc. He has since expanded his library. He has many fans, and makes quite a bit of money from his projects.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoMaybe some of you know of Dave Bull: the Caucasian Canadian that took a shine to Japanese woodblock carving (Ukiyo-e printmaking). I have pondered his "business model". Apparently the master Japanese carvers were loathe to take this gangly gaijin seriously when he began his obsession decades ago. And yet, Dave set for himself some insane goal of carving 100 wood blocks for prints over the space of a decade. Now as a dabbling artist myself, I simply can't imagine laying out my artistic landscape for the next couple of years, let alone the next decade. That shows a serious dedication and vision. And so he proceeded. Well, after the first year and 10 prints or so, he got a handful of customers that began to buy up his prints. And to be sure, by replicating some of the designs of the great masters of history, he was learning a lot about Japanese woodblock carving. I don't recall if he said how much he money he made the first year, but I believe calling him a starving artist would not have been a stretch. But nonetheless he continued. The second year and another 10 prints and more patrons. It turns out that people that buy these sort of things, fine art prints, often collect them and will become repeat customers. No doubt there comes to be a stable of customers that are effectively subscribers and will henceforth buy everything he creates. Going into the third and fourth years he can start to predict a lower threshold for what he will make as an artist in the coming years since he can more or less assume his regular customers will buy everything he prints in those years (and his work is no doubt getting better with each block he carves and learns from). And of course the collector-type customers keep arriving as he and his work become better known — and so his business snowballs with more subscribers. By the time Dave finished his decade-long goal he could comfortably call himself a professional wood block carver, no longer a novice but had now taken the vows so to speak. Dave seems to have figured out the way to make a career out of art. I applaud him for that — brilliant. 10 fans became 100 became 1000 and then more. Dave Bull says that, begrudgingly perhaps, some of the Japanese carvers began to at least then acknowledge him after his ten year carving odyssey. He started a YouTube channel since then and it has really caught on — perhaps surprisingly as the field of artisans practicing traditional Japanese wood block carving has apparently been in decline. Dave has said that privately a few carvers have reached out to him to tell him that Dave is doing what they should have been doing all along.
- tillcarlos 4y agoThis is beautifully written - thanks so much! This story reminds me of (how I imagine) the career of Connor Price looks like. Check him out on youtube. He makes so many tracks with so many people - and eventually things pick up. He could very well be the next Sheridan.
- satvikpendem 4y agoRelated, from Andreessen Horowitz, 1,000 True Fans? Try 100 [0]. It's about going B2B for high value customers over B2C lower value customers. [0] https://a16z.com/2020/02/06/1000-true-fans-try-100/ https://a16z.com/2020/02/06/1000-true-fans-try-100/
- calltrak 4y ago[dead]
- SergeAx 4y agoWhat if I don't want brainless fanatics to be my fans?
- amelius 4y agoThen don't become an influencer.
- SergeAx 4y agoI think that if one does something for a long time and with constant passion, and then reflects about that in the form of text, podcast or video - they are doomed to become an influencer of sorts. So your recommendation is equal to "do not reflect on your passion in public", which is quite sad.
- pattern_shift 4y agoThis essay has it all around backwards. 1k true fans is a recipe for destroying your own creative life and devoting most of your time to sales funnel building, fomo emails and clickbait offers and bribes for mailing list signups, running ads, etc. The true fan who spends $100/year wants you to be their therapist and to belong to your tribe, will stalk you, will send you unsolicited emails offering advice, etc. Don't hunt the whales. It's better to aim for constantly increasing quality, and with the ease of reaching many people with modern technology, find some combination of your 10,000 mediocre fans willing to give you $10/year, 100,000 sh*t fans getting you $1/year. You put out music or writing or art for these fans, they spend a very reasonable amount on it per year without upsetting the household budget, they think of you occasionally but you o random creator are not constantly 'top of mind' for them and they can think about their friends and/or family and/or day-to-day work instead. And you aren't babysitting their feelings or constantly begging them for money. B2B can be even worse, you're support, therapist, babysitter all the time. They pay you big bucks and think they own you. If you don't have enough customers, maybe they do. 1000k true fans, you're responding to emails all the time, trying to look cool on socials, sticking calls to action in every video or email. ~$10, these people are buying a print or an album or a t-shirt or a book once a year, ~$1 they're streaming your songs a couple hundred times a year. They've got a normal 'someone who makes something I like' relationship with you, you're not some big fan. You're not supporting your product, hopefully you're spending your time making the next thing you want to make. Someone will probably jump in and yell about how you won't get to those numbers of meh fans without someone recommending you. Yeah, that's right -- but with quality people and algorithms will recommend you because of the _thing you made_, not because you took them on a customer journey from browser to fan to friend with your relentless hustle. As someone making music, there's nothing better than the spotify algorithms recommending my music to people while I sleep and spending the creative time that I have making music and not marketing campaigns. Or production music I made showing up in netflix shows I love despite me never having been yelled at by a director. YMMV.
- astrange 4y agoJudging from how much people spend on streamers/entertainers/gambling I think you can get a lot more than $100/yr out of people before they think they own you. That’s the price of getting one YouTube superchat read in a popular channel, though the way it’s publicly visible changes things. It does mean you tend to produce content that gets you the superchats rather than what you want to do. And that’s probably not writing a tech book.
- atleta 4y agoAnd in 2022 you know that it doesn't work because you don't see any examples. Despite quite a few people trying to make a living from their fan base on various social media platforms. (Youtube, Instagram, TikTok, etc.) While if it did work, we should see a lot of these. But instead of the 1000 fans they need tens or hundreds of thousands usually. And even those don't pay. Maybe it works on OnlyFans as someone mentioned. But that's a special market for a very a specific type of product/producers... Oh, and we also have patreon to support fans paying the creators. But it doesn't look like the $100/patron/year model is a thing there. Or that too many people make $100k/year at all. https://graphtreon.com/patreon-creators https://graphtreon.com/patreon-creators
- JakeAl 4y agoIf you've never read his "Out of Control" book (for free on the web site) it's a must read. Really great stuff.
- Sprite_tm 4y agoAm I the only one who thinks the 'true fan' definition is a bit... icky? If I have a person who buys everything I offer, regardless of if it's a duplicate of something I already offered earlier, regardless of quality, that person sounds like they put me on way too much of a pedestal. I'd rather have fans that go 'nah, this ain't worth it, I ain't buying' when I send out something that's dog shit. The 'true fan' definition on offer sounds a bit too stalker-y to me.
- sboomer 4y agoIt can bring with it the anxiety of living up to their expectations. This is present for big celebs too, but in this case the pressure is amplified because you are kind of close to these 1000 or so guys, and they pay you.
- 3np 4y agoThe mindset here strikes me as the social-media/content parallel of "solution in search of a problem". If you're looking for money: You should focus on making content you know there is demand for, ideally with customers lined up to pay and/or distribution channel deals. The fundamentals here are the same as for any business. If you're making content creatively you should be ready doing that without financial compensation. This influencer-hustle mindset is not helpful and a distraction for both approaches. Get your priorities straight.
- quickthrower2 4y agoAh yes… factor the number 100000 in some way, and then say “if only just”
- jannw 4y agoI wrote a phd, in part, on this (actually on crowdfunding for creatives, but this essay bookended the thesis). Writing in 2008 KK essentially predicted D2F crowdfunding built on e-mailing lists and facebook. He gets a lot right, and it stands up well - but, make no mistake, he describes a full-time job, and the "admin" involved is more than 50% of the effort. It's not for everyone, but it can work, and does for many. Anyone following this path should consider reading my paper on how your communication channels impact "sales" https://www-sciencedirect-com.vu-nl.idm.oclc.org/science/article/pii/S0747563221003289?casa_token=TOaVyCR_dQ4AAAAA:8pzp1-7GeeLC5Fs_kPzDa9CVFJ0M4gwFyF8GoZVAnD8bwsJAS7lcxf0n2SeJym6ajJrtxP0SCw https://www-sciencedirect-com.vu-nl.idm.oclc.org/science/art...
- glass3 4y agoFrom a different perspective: How many skilled people are needed for 100 creative people? How much of the $100,000 are circulated among creative people? If those transactions are ignored and we only look at the usage of skilled work, how much is needed? There needs to be food, shelter, clothing, medical care, transportation, energy, etc. My guess would be that it takes 100 skilled people to supply 100 creative people.
- bookofjoe 4y agoJust finished reading every comment on this. Full disclosure: After 18+ years publishing a daily blog I currently have one (1) paying fan. Every month via Ko-fi/Stripe he sends me $2, of which $1.64 is deposited into my bank account. And I'm fine with that.
- codazoda 4y agoI’ve never been a consisted blogger (i.e. weekly) and I haven’t setup a way to collect donations, but I get a lot of nice emails. Some of them even say I saved the user hundreds or thousands of dollars with my technical instructions. Yeah, it’s hard to find your fans. But, it’s also on us to do so in some organized way. They aren’t going to donate if I don’t have a donate button.
- bookofjoe 4y agoBoy, you lasered right in on the crux of it: Long ago, back in August of 2004 when I started my blog, the guy who set it up for me asked if I wanted him to include a DONATE button. I said no way because it seemed — and still does — to me to be akin to begging, like people do who really need help. Now, if I could've had a sort of line graph that said "Help me make my first million" where the endpoint was $1m and each little amount — even a penny — added would show up a là Million Dollar Homepage [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Million_Dollar_Homepage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Million_Dollar_Homepage], I'd have mos def done that.