9 ms·
Taxpayers paying billions for the renovations and construction of NFL stadiums
- bumby 4y agoThis is why I respect how the Green Bay Packers raise money. They sell “ownership” of the team. Sure, it’s largely a novelty without much real ownership benefits, but it seems like a better approach than using taxpayer dollars to subsidize a highly profitable business.
- kerbs 4y agoVery against the rules. The Packers aren’t savvy here, they just existed long before business interests shut that practice down.
- rtkwe 4y agoThe original stadium was funded like most others with a bond measure passed by the city not from the Packers organization. The more recent remodel was done through the 'stock' sale though.
- maxerickson 4y agoWikipedia has a summary: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Bay_Packers#Community_ownership https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Bay_Packers#Community_ow... The NFL (and other professional leagues) probably wouldn't allow a similar structure to be put in place for another team. Sort of ironically, Green Bay paid to build Lambeau Field in the 1950s.
- jasonladuke0311 4y agoI’m certain the NFL and other owners would sacrifice children to change GB ownership structure if they could.
- vitaflo 4y agoTo be fair, the renovation back in 2001 (IE, Lambeau as you know it today) was partly funded through tax payer dollars (as well as a stock sale). There was a referendum on the ballot to increase sales tax by 0.5% in Brown County for something like 15 years. So the public got to vote on it (it passed). I purchased my Packers stock at that time and voted Yes to the sales tax increase (lived in GB at the time). But yes the Packers will do stock sales to help fund stadium improvement, or just pay it themselves.
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://youtu.be/xcwJt4bcnXs https://youtu.be/xcwJt4bcnXs (Stadiums: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver)
- spamizbad 4y agoTo play devil's advocate: American football is a huge part of American culture. So this is merely tax payers investing in the proliferation and preservation of their culture. (which is probably why all football teams should be publicly owned also)
- zaphod420 4y agoI hate football, and I paid over 300k in taxes last year... Edit: not sure why I'm being down voted. I was an Ethereum ICO buyer and I cashed some out last year. I hate that my tax dollars are going to football.
- bumby 4y agoI think the downvoting is in part that whether or not you like something may not be material to the discussion. If you don’t like police/schools/highways it doesn’t mean you shouldn’t fund it with tax dollars. I think the central argument is whether or not a stadium is a public good and worthy of tax funds.
- bladelessninja2 4y agoHow did you get from stadium to police? The whole idea why people organize themselves in countries is to ensure internal and external safety and thus that everyone pay taxes for police, army and courts. Everything else is an addition and in my opinion even undesired to fund by whole community - you can always organize fundraiser or start a private enterprise for such things.
- bumby 4y agoI was interesting that to some people (not me, though) a stadium is a public good and this worthy of public tax dollars to support. Just like the police or schools.
- bladelessninja2 4y ago
- thrdbndndn 4y agoMost of stadiums (or similar infrastructures) are built with taxpayers'/government's money, so I genuinely don't know where to draw the line between "a stadium" and "a football stadium". On one end, cities obviously need stadiums; on the other hand, I'm not trying to pretend these specific stadiums in case are not going to benefit the football team and its associated private group the most, despite it can be used by others. Again, I just feel it's a very nuanced topic.
- bittercynic 4y agoSincere question: Do cities really need stadiums? A stadium was built in my city several years ago, and for me it has occasionally caused a moderate inconvenience, and had no upside. Some of my neighbors really like it, though.
- TrueSlacker0 4y agoI was thinking this same thing. We might want one, but we don't need one. If we needed one someone would build one, same as we build restaurants, bars, refineries, breweries, manufacturing, etc without any subsidies from the gov. I would love one for my small business, on a related note, I can't even count the times I have watched my city give millions in tax breaks to bring in already successful, wealthy, large businesses and give the local ones jack shi.
- lakeshastina 4y agoWould the business case not be - commerce generated during sporting events, multiple businesses nearby the stadium benefiting from increased foot traffic, and so on? Projected over a 10-20 year horizon, the city would likely make back its money and then some, while increasing income for businesses in the vicinity.
- rubiquity 4y agoYou presume that money couldn’t be spent elsewhere or even gasp saved away for a rainy day or paying down a debt early.
- bluedino 4y agoThere are what, 8 home games every year for an NFL team? That's a lot of money coming in for parking, hotels, restaurants, and bars in the area. A Super Bowl that the new stadiums usually get can bring half a billion in. That stadium also gets used for other events like concerts. The bad thing is you can't spent less than $2 billion on a new stadium. Kind of like a new apartment building, it has to be high end.
- ISL 4y agoSeattle has restricted public financing for teams. We just picked up an NHL expansion team anyway :). https://www.seattlepi.com/news/article/Initiative-91-Seattle-rejects-sports-subsidies-1219229.php https://www.seattlepi.com/news/article/Initiative-91-Seattle...
- helsinkiandrew 4y agoIt’s always been odd that the sport of the land of capitalism is the least free market of all the worlds sport - particularly compared with European soccer for example https://syndication.bleacherreport.com/amp/177539-american-sport-communisim.amp.html https://syndication.bleacherreport.com/amp/177539-american-s...
- SantalBlush 4y agoThe notion that capitalists prefer free markets is nothing more than a children's story, right up there with Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny. They're not lobbying Washington to ensure there is healthy competition in their industry.
- bmitc 4y agoExactly. Capitalists pursue bought markets, either buying up competitors or politicians to achieve their goals.
- jdminhbg 4y agoSports are zero-sum and the greater economy is not. What’s odd is Europeans treating each exactly the opposite of what that would imply.
- winternett 4y agoWhat is even more troubling to me is how an athlete can make 60 million dollars a year, and why tickets to games can cost $800 and up while our tax dollars subsidize it all... Back in the day there was a brutal revolution on taxing tea... Now people are totally cool with student loans and mortgages indenturing our children for life while defense spending is astronomically higher than the moon. Even mortgage interest deductions were gutted in the last 4 years. I'm no revolutionary, and I painfully pay my fair share every year, but there is not much fair about taxes, and as usual it's always a costly lie to everyone that obeys the law/
- SomeBoolshit 4y agoIf popular athletes making lots of money is "even more troubling" to you, your priorities are messed up.
- pcbro141 4y agoTheir issue is not with the athletes making lots of money alone. It's that the league is spending so much, and bringing in so much revenue, while also taking taxpayer handouts.
- bmitc 4y agoThey are saying all that is more troubling because it isn't like the NFL and teams can't afford it. They are raking in money but still force the people to build their stadiums.
- texaslonghorn5 4y agorather than being troubled by the athlete salaries, be even more troubled by the vastly larger owner salaries
- barbazoo 4y ago> rather than being troubled by the athlete salaries, be even more troubled by the vastly larger owner salaries We can be troubled by multiple things at the same time.
- osigurdson 4y agoI suppose a politician could run on not providing any funding for sports arenas / stadiums. It has worked before and teams naturally end up leaving. Another angle might be to get a number of similarly minded people together and stage a protest. I feel like few of the "no arena / no stadium" crowd would have that strong of convictions however - though I could certainly be wrong.
- gtmitchell 4y agoJust more proof that bread and circus remains an effective strategy for politicians to win favor with the masses.
- lapcat 4y agoThe reason these things happen is that the politicians get bought by the team owners. I've seen it happen in more than one city I've lived in. Massive political corruption. Totally legal too, because it's "campaign contributions". We've legalized bribery.
- bladelessninja2 4y agoWell, encourage socialistic views, there will be more tax money to "help" those organizations.
- bane 4y agoI don't care about organized sports much, and big collegiate sports are basically under my radar. But I'll tell you something -- some of the best "leaders" I've hired over the years were athletes -- especially collegiate athletes -- especially female athletes in underappreciated sports. There's an incredible drive there to tactics, organization, consensus building, and so on that I never appreciated while growing up as a nerd in tech. Later, when I ended up with an employee who had both a strong tech and sports background I really started to appreciate the benefits of a collegiate sports education. That all being said, professional sport appear to be out of control in a similar way that k-pop, appears to be. The real problem is that, outside of monetary compensation for themselves and their agents, these job categories offer very little in the way of societal benefit. They aren't building homes for the homeless nor are they curing cancer or colonizing Mars. A nearly endless supply of new recruits, combined with limited professional positions plus the modern celebrity-industrial-complex, creates and endlessly toxic environment that sends young people into career funnels that produce failed <insert job> instead of successful <insert social benefit>. Conversely, when I was going to my higher education, the universities were overrun with incoming students who had been convinced that Computer Science was the way to a stable and prosperous career regardless of their personal passions for the field and the industrial uses for CS graduates. Tax subsidies to pro-sports systems appear to be nothing more than a social cancer in the same way. Tens of thousands of sports hopefuls literally erasing years from their lives so that they might have a chance at a lower-tier professional feeder league -- which again contributes very little to overall society -- if Football disappeared tomorrow, it would have very little long-term disruption to anybody. Bread and Circuses are only valuable to bakeries and race course hot dog vendors.
- tshaddox 4y ago> But I'll tell you something -- some of the best "leaders" I've hired over the years were athletes -- especially collegiate athletes -- especially female athletes in underappreciated sports. Hypothesis: having strong ability and interest in leadership roles causes people to pursue athletics.
- Tempest1981 4y agoThe 49ers, with their stadium in Santa Clara, provide double the entertainment: 1. entertainment watching the 49ers football games. 2. entertainment watching the 49ers owners fight with the city of Santa Clara -- over the deal the team agreed to, in order to build the stadium. Wasn't the team even funding various city-council candidates this last election?
- ablatt89 4y agoThe 49ers bring entertainment but the stadium built at the new location hasn't really brought much to the local community aside from lots of traffic on Sundays. I lived right next to the stadium for several years and there's been next to no commercial development nor housing development. Anyone who goes to the 49ers game has to drive to DTSJ to continue the party. I don't know if it's the result of NIMBYs or the local government, but the stadium has brought nothing to the local community (maybe to the pockets of the mayor and the admins who approved it however).
- MrSqueezles 4y agoThat one IHOP next to it shut down and nearby businesses have become huge targets for car break-ins on game days, so we can't say it hasn't brought anything to the community.
- exogeny 4y agoWell, it's a pretty simple calculus for the owners. You're going to get people to pay for my stadium, Mr. Politician, or else losing this thing that millions of people in this city love is going to be, fairly or unfairly, blamed on you. It's of course gross and hilariously stupid given that every professional sports team owner is a billionaire, but most of those marrow suckers didn't become billionaires by not leveraging incentives when the benefit for doing so is obvious.
- hestefisk 4y agoThat’s a lot of teachers and doctors and roads and hospitals.
- mcoliver 4y agoSan Diego Chargers owners tried to pull this and the city of San Diego voted to reject the measure. So they left to LA and play second fiddle to the Rams.
- bdcravens 4y agoIn the end they were playing in a new, state of the art stadium. And this year, they're a much better team than the Rams.
- cjwilliams 4y agoSeattle lost the supersonics because it didnt cave to this backwards farce. Unfortunately the city is worse for it
- rdevsrex 4y agoGee, it's almost like we live in a country where the rich use the political system to get richer.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- amazon_illegal 4y ago[dead]
- GreatGiza 4y ago[flagged]
- MrSqueezles 4y ago> Las Vegas and Chicago rely on tourism taxes to help pay off these municipal bond commitments I didn't have any idea that's what those taxes were for. What percent of hotel guests chose to visit those cities to see sports games?
- za3faran 4y agoIt should be an option to opt out of tax dollars going toward such useless things.