4 ms·
What you're talking about is what we in the ML world call a stochastic parrot. You may have also heard the term "gullibility gap." A lot of language and convers
by godelski 4y ago
What you're talking about is what we in the ML world call a stochastic parrot. You may have also heard the term "gullibility gap." A lot of language and conversations can be held that don't require any actual understanding of the subject matter, but rather because it follows certain patterns. People and LLMs can trick you into thinking they are highly intelligent because they can speak eloquently but that doesn't mean they are intelligent themselves. These LLMs can't understand inference or extrapolation, things that humans do easily (though we all know plenty of people that are idiots and can't do this).
The same can be said about programming, which includes a lot more patterns. People joke that modern programming is slapping together APIs and it would be unsurprising that a (albeit really sophisticated) stochastic parrot can do this. But I've also seen it hand me code that looks correct but has major issues upon investigation.
Don't let something fool you just because it appears intelligent. Human or machine we must handle information with care.
- lumost 4y agoAs a fellow participant in the ML world, I think there is compelling evidence to disagree with this take. ChatGPT’s responses on operator valued functions were accurate and valid, however ages of time on google failed to turn up this topic previously. On coding tasks, chatGPT can ask clarifying questions on requirements and determine if it has enough information to write the code correctly. Unfortunately you need to direct it to ask questions as needed and include appropriate tests to get the right answer. ChatGPT also fails in cases where it needs feedback from an external environment/documentation search. It will produce close enough code, but may need correction based on observed errors etc.
- adriand 4y agoI’ve been using it regularly for programming assistance over the past two weeks and it’s extremely helpful. Others have pointed out that it sometimes produces inaccurate results, but if you already have domain expertise, as I do for programming, that is easy to identify. But it’s still a massive timesaver! I’ve been doing things like saying, “what follows is the database schema for entities X and Y, write a function that…” and then pasting in the schema, and it generates code good enough to copy and paste. It can also be instructed to modify results in various ways, for instance, I can ask it to provide the same code but in a different language, or to avoid using a certain framework feature, or to use a certain framework feature. It’s remarkable. Between ChatGPT and Copilot my workflow today is different in a way I couldn’t have begun to contemplate just a few weeks ago. Once they figure out additional ways to ensure correctness, I think it’s a totally new world we live in.
- godelski 4y agoA big reason I have no reservations in calling it a stochastic parrot is because I've seen very strong evidence of this. But if you can think of very common phrases (like the above "which weighs more") and tweak them slightly you'll find that it almost always answers as if they were untweaked. For example, ask "Which weighs more, a kilogram of bricks or two kilograms of feathers?". I'll save you the hassle and paste the answer below. Multiple variations of this consistently give me bad answers (does even worse if you don't include the second "kilogram"). You can even see that it didn't ignore the fact that the feathers are two kilograms. The problem is that it neither understands what a kilogram is (despite being able to tell you what one is) nor what numbers are (again, despite being able to describe it to you). These types of questions strongly demonstrate that the model doesn't understand the language that it is processing but rather is relying on stochastic patterns. It very clearly gives us the answer with expectation if we were relying on the patterns of the input sentence rather than the actual words (humans often do this too fwiw and it tends to lead to fights. See most political discourse). You can find many examples of this and the NLP literature shows this pattern holds across many different models. I don't want to undermine the work though. I think many people that complain about stochastic parrots also fail to recognize that they still are quite useful, as many other comments are noting, but useful is a far cry from intelligent or has the ability to understand. We need to be clear about that difference if we're working towards AGI vs working towards useful products. > Which weighs more, a kilogram of bricks or two kilograms of feathers? > A kilogram of bricks and two kilograms of feathers both weigh the same amount. The weight of an object is determined by its mass, not the size or shape of the object. One kilogram is equal to 1,000 grams and two kilograms is equal to 2,000 grams. Therefore, both a kilogram of bricks and two kilograms of feathers weigh the same amount.
- lumost 4y agoI agree that this model suffers at arithmetic, however if you change how you ask the question to “two kilograms of bricks weighs less than one kilogram of feathers, correct?” you'll likely see the model tell you the right answer. Note that you must spell out numbers for chatgpt to work correctly. In general, the ability for llm models to be able to complete any reasoning tasks is a surprise. This google writeup shares good detail on these emergent behaviors. https://ai.googleblog.com/2022/11/characterizing-emergent-phenomena-in.html https://ai.googleblog.com/2022/11/characterizing-emergent-ph...