5 ms·
Cato and other libertarian organizations really miss the point. Free trade and free movement of labor (which are two sides of the same coin) will give you econo
by rayiner 4y ago
Cato and other libertarian organizations really miss the point. Free trade and free movement of labor (which are two sides of the same coin) will give you economic efficiency. But economic efficiency doesn’t make people happy. Living in stable, cohesive communities where there are jobs and people can raise their kids near their extended family without moving around to chase opportunities is what makes many (I’d argue most) people happy. Many people would rather have that and pay more money for widgets and strawberries.
My family immigrated to northern Virginia in 1989 when it was still a bit southern and quite homogenous. It was a warm, friendly community. Fast forward 30 years. It’s much richer. There’s a Google office in Reston which used to be a bit downscale. Immigrants chasing high paying American jobs are a big chunk of the population. So are transplants from other parts of the country. And all the soul of the place is gone. The warm community has been replaced by a bunch of people living next to each other. That’s the kind of society free trade and fee movement of labor creates and many people don’t like it.
- tptacek 4y agoJust bring them a tray of brownies when they move in, and say hi to them when they pull in in the afternoon. A neighborhood isn't a birthright; it's a thing you (and all of your neighbors) consciously build. Maybe you need to have the one neighbor who really goes nuts working at it, hosting game nights and organizing the block parties, to really grok this. Economic systems don't really come into it. The neoliberal economic system moved that neighbor of mine to Dallas, and we still all talk to him on Facebook. Presumably he's mobilized his Dallas block similarly. Be that person, or be receptive to that person, and acquire and calibrate your principles of justice separately, because your community doesn't depend on what you believe about health care funding or the max/median wage ratio. I don't disagree with the argument that our current economic order demands that people move away from their extended families, and that that's bad. But that's no excuse to stop being a good neighbor, or to pretend you need to move to a neighboring county just to continue keeping up your end of the bargain.
- rayiner 4y agoEconomic systems drive patterns of migration, which pulls apart and reshuffles communities. For example in our current economic system, people are pushed to move to large metro areas to pursue economic opportunities, which leaves them without kinship support networks, and fragments the communities which they leave. Building communities is a lot of work and takes time. In many countries around the world, people’s names include the name of your father (“bin” in Arabic, “son” or “dottir” in Swedish). In those places, communities are the product of multigenerational efforts. Communities like that can’t be sustained within an economic construct that requires each generation to move around because of free flow of capital and labor. And diversity in language and culture—a byproduct of economic structures that encourage migration—makes building close communities more difficult. There’s an enormous amount of shared assumptions and context within a particular culture, and cultural differences create friction. Most people would just rather be around what’s familiar, and when thrust into a diverse community won’t make the effort to overcome those barriers. You’ll see that in diverse cities like Toronto or New York, the most cohesive communities are homogenous enclaves, where everyone goes to the same church or mosque, recognize kinship ties, etc.
- tptacek 4y agoWhen you move, you do indeed have to put in the work to establish bonds with your new neighbors. And, hopefully, you recognize that's true of people who move in near you: again, with the brownies. Put the effort in. Building a block doesn't take lots of time. It took us weeks†. Did I mention the trays of brownies? New neighbors are one of the few situations in adult life where standard US social protocols give you explicit permission to be open and inviting to total strangers. If you're missing those opportunities, it's not the economics blog posts you've been reading that have screwed you up. Writing paragraph after paragraph of excuses not to be neighborly is the least-conservative and most antisocial thing I think you can with these circumstances. Normal Rockwell wouldn't be having any of this. You don't have to, either. † I mean, the block was here, and we certainly didn't do most of the work. But, still.
- rayiner 4y agoSure you can take measures to mitigate the economic and social forces fragmenting and atomizing communities. But on average, a culturally and religiously homogenous community, where people have multi-generational kinship ties, is going to be more cohesive than a diverse community without multigenerational kinship ties. Your standard of “bringing over brownies” is a low one. We have a pretty close community given that nobody is from here and nobody attends the same civic or religions institutions. But it’s nothing like a Bangladeshi enclave in Queens or town in Iowa. Even when we lived in Dhaka, a city of millions of people, our community was more tightly integrated thanks to family ties and shared culture. It’s a profoundly different experience to live in a community where people’s parents know each other. I don’t know much about Norman Rockwell. Wikipedia says he was a “staunch liberal.” I get that liberals enjoy novelty for its own sake, travel, and find it stifling that tight-knit communities can more easily enforce social and moral norms. But most people don’t see the world that way. They don’t want their kids to move thousands of miles away in pursuit of economic opportunities. They want to live near childhood friends. And the community enforcing shared moral and social norms (especially on their kids) is a feature, not a bug.
- kasey_junk 4y agoI live in maybe the most globally free movement neighborhood in the US and the one that perhaps invented the globalist mindset you are criticizing (Hyde Park, Chicago). Yet I know everyone of my neighbors and our community is cohesive and stable (though it’s rare to live near extended family, thankfully in my case). Virtually everyone of those neighbors (including me) is an economic migrant. We have soul, we have warmth and we have near daily events that cause us to interact closely with each other. Maybe it’s not the globalism that caused the issues you are seeing. Maybe it’s zoning or the civic planning of your community? Do you spend a lot of time in cars? Does your community not have civic organizations that allow you to work with a variety of people in your neighborhood? Or perhaps there isn’t any diversity so everyone feels isolated? Or maybe you just aren’t participating in your community?
- rayiner 4y agoI’m talking about real community, not just atomized households going to yoga in the park. The fact that you list not living near extended family as a plus confirms that you don’t understand what I’m talking about. For most people in the world, and even in America, kinship ties are very important.