5 ms·
It's rather a surreal artifact of Tolkien's writing process. He began his book as a direct sequel to The Hobbit, and chose Gollum's ring as the macguffin to dri
by jfengel 4y ago
It's rather a surreal artifact of Tolkien's writing process. He began his book as a direct sequel to The Hobbit, and chose Gollum's ring as the macguffin to drive the plot. As the story evolved, the ring became The Ring, at which point some of the original story didn't actually work any more.
He could simply have chosen a different macguffin, but Tolkien had a weird way of fixating on things that he'd already written. It's almost scientific: you explore the space of stories, and whatever hangs together consistently must be "true".
He solved that not by deprecating the original book, but by rewriting it, and then including a preface in The Lord of the Rings about how the original book was Bilbo's self-promoting propaganda.
This is emblematic of his work. He kept re-writing and re-writing to find something that felt "true". Which is partly why he never really settled on anything. He kept assigning characters different names, and then assigning some names to other characters until they fit. In the early Hobbit, Thorin was called "Gandalf", which makes it a hell of a thing to read. (And the wizard was named "Bladorthin". Which is almost as bad as "Bingo Bolger-Baggins", the original name of Frodo. Or "Trotter", the original Strider, a Hobbit with wooden feet...)
Given that The Hobbit was not actually intended to be connected directly to his Middle-earth works except retroactively, and that The Silmarillion was not published until after his death (with significant editing, because he kept re-writing it until it was no longer compatible with The Lord of the Rings), in a sense there is only one truly "canonical" Middle-earth book: The Lord of the Rings.
Tolkien was not only an extraordinary genius, but we have an incredible collection of his draft works to see how his genius worked. I can't think of any other author whose process is simultaneously so remarkable and so well-documented.
- bee_rider 4y agoIt is sort of funny. Historical myths and legends of were not controlled in the same sense that modern fiction is, so you had various sets of stories — King Arthur, Greek pantheon, etc, where the canon is really more of a suggestion. Events can be jumbled around to ignored, new characters can be introduced, the Lancelots of the whole thing stick around but some of their aspects are pulled forward or pushed back. And then of course modern stories are generally single-source and totally controlled (other than comic books and that sort of thing). And one of the major authors who sort of bridges the gap… his method seems to have been “well I’ll just run that whole historical process in my head, with the various characters and groups recording their legends and myths!”
- jfengel 4y agoThat is the truly epic thing about his, uh, epics. He basically used his own evolution of thoughts as a parallel for the history of a culture -- all by a single person. The languages themselves evolved in his head, and he documented all of the versions as if they belonged to thousands of years of linguistic divergence. Star Wars and Marvel still evoke debates about canonicity, but at least that's a bunch of authors taking things in their own directions. Tolkien achieved that kind of argument about canon all by himself. It's actually ripe for fanfic, and why people really shouldn't get so up in arms about whether modern expansions of Middle-earth are in conflict with "canon". He explicitly called for "other hands and minds" to expand on his work. But what he achieved all by himself is so masterful that it's understandable that some want to think of it as a pristine canon unto itself.
- wardedVibe 4y agoI hadn't thought of it before, but cannon seems mostly to be a consequence of copyright. Places like SCP, which only vaguely use copyright, have a cannon that more closely resemble traditional mythmaking.
- harimau777 4y agoI have a pet theory that copyright is one of the reasons for toxic fandom. If you prefer earlier versions of Robin Hood where he's less overtly Catholic, then you are free to write your own version. On the other hand, if you are invested in Star Wars and don't like the way that Disney is taking it, then your only option is to do something like review bombing.
- whakim 4y ago> Historical myths and legends of were not controlled in the same sense that modern fiction is. I think this point misses a bit of context - notably the contrast between oral and written literature. Many historical legends and folklore originated in some kind of oral context, which gives rise to a huge set of interconnected stories (and it's only later that we get some kind of "canonical" version of these stories, when someone writes down one of those oral performances). The oral performances of such stories necessitated some of the attributes you allude to. The characters and plotting are formulaic and interchangeable because that makes them easier to memorize; the details are sparse and interchangeable because that allows the bard to fill in details to fit the meter and appeal to the preferences of their audience. > And then of course modern stories are generally single-source and totally controlled. Tolkien was incredibly aware of this written/oral distinction, and this whole post is great evidence! Tolkien uses the way that oral storytelling functions as an in-world device to explain away a discrepancy between conflicting written versions of the same story. This ends up feeling incredibly satisfying because people intuitively understand the nature of oral folklore, as opposed to, say, George Lucas's endless revisions to Star Wars (which conflicts with the audience's desire for a single "canonical" version.)
- xg15 4y ago> Given that The Hobbit was not actually intended to be connected directly to his Middle-earth works except retroactively In the first version of the book I read, there was an offhand mention that a Took ancestor had married a "Fairy" (or Fae). It was never discussed in the book again and I found that later versions had it charged to "Elf". I always supposed that this was another bit left over from the time where the Hobbit was its own universe - at least I never heard any mention of Fairies living in Middle-Earth. Edit: Of course maybe a wiser choice might have been to leave it in - and present it as a sign that there are still a lot of unexplored corners in Middle-Earth and even after reading all the books, we don't know all about it. I think the modern pressure to have a "canon" which explains absolutely everything that goes on in the world can lead to sterile and unbelievable worlds as well if a worldbuilder gives in too much.
- bombcar 4y agoTolkien originally used the term Fairy (as in Fae) to mean elf - but he changed the name without changing the concept; he felt the term elf was closer and fairy had too much “baggage” from Shakespeare and friends. I wonder how he’d feel known Ing that his concepts of orc and elf and dwarves now dominate fantasy
- xg15 4y agoOh, I wasn't aware of that. That's interesting to know!
- jfengel 4y agoTolkien also kept using the word "Gnome" to refer to a particularly high-class subset of the Elves. That, too, reads very strangely, because it puts me in mind of garden gnomes. I have no frame to think of the most beautiful Elves -- including Elrond and Galadriel -- as "gnomes". He eventually gave up on that and used "Noldor", a term he'd been kicking around for a while in various contexts. That's much more comfortable, but he kept using "gnome" way longer than seemed reasonable.
- rimunroe 4y ago
- niemandhier 4y agoSo LOTR was written in iterations, and the Hobbit was patched after first released? Sounds like a good framework for productivity.
- jfengel 4y agoIt was released only because he was forced to by management. Given Tolkien's druthers, he'd have kept it all in a private repository, working on branch after branch, cherry-picking changes strung like a Christmas tree. What he really wanted to release was The Silmarillion, but they passed. It included a long but incomplete verse version of Beren and Luthien, which utterly baffled the readers. The publisher demanded a Hobbit sequel -- which already included a bunch of random stuff from The Silmarillion, but mostly just a few inconsistent fragments. So he wrote The Lord of the Rings, and despite himself, managed to actually get it released. All the while he kept tinkering with his masterpiece, never releasing it at all. Some other developer (his son) finally cobbled something together after he died -- mostly by reverting to branches that were decades behind the HEAD. He was very, very, very unproductive. But he sure made a lot of commits -- and then reverted them.
- thevagrant 4y agoI think it's unfair to say he was unproductive. Tolkien was an academic and didn't approach this in the same way a professional writer would today.
- pvaldes 4y agoAgree, is almost as he was using TeX to write it. But his product still sells, and has feed his family for a couple of generations. There is a lesson to learn about productivity here.
- jonnycomputer 4y agoIt's almost as if ... Tolkien were a painter painting a tree, but he kept painting and repainting his first leaf.
- sprkwd 4y agoIt’s wonderful, right? Being able to directly observe creativity and iteration in the story.
- sdenton4 4y agoThe Hobbit edits here make a lot of sense in the bigger picture, though. Given what we later learn about the Ring, there's NO WAY Gollum would wager it as a 'present' in a riddle game... And if he somehow did, he would cheat like hell to keep it, despite all the 'ancient tradition' around the Riddle Game. The edit is great; it solves the continuity problem in a really creative way. Making the old version into Bilbo's self-serving rationalization is an excellent bit of meta-fiction, further reinforcing the seductive power of the Ring.
- wolverine876 4y ago> He could simply have chosen a different macguffin, but Tolkien had a weird way of fixating on things that he'd already written. Tolkien pulled much from older myths, of which Tolkien was a leading scholar. The Ring as a driving force (and its power and the consequences of that power) was not an invention of Tolkien's; Tolkien didn't get the idea from the Hobbit. Wagner famously used it in the 19th century, and likely myths, on which Wagner also relied, preceded Wagner. I think your description is a common process of many (most? almost all?) artists and creative workers. Creation is not making things in a first draft out of whole cloth. You don't know where you are going or what will work. It's not unlike a startup in that respect (please let's not get carried away with our frame of reference): you have some great ideas and talent; you develop it, often in unanticipate directions; and eventually you find an application for them - sometimes completely unanticipated, even from a side project. > He began his book as a direct sequel to The Hobbit Where does Tolkien describe that?
- jfengel 4y agoHis biographer says that Allen & Unwin (his publishers) asked for "a new Hobbit book". The earliest drafts are about a second adventure for Bilbo -- he had run out of money and needed a new treasure fetch-quest. You can read the early drafts in book 6 of the History of Middle-earth, and watch as "the tale grew in the telling". They start with Bilbo, then the protagonist changes name and identity as the concept fills out. He made it as far as Bree in a very Hobbit-esque style before scrapping it all and rewriting it in the more adult LotR style. (He later tried to re-write The Hobbit in that LotR style, but it was dreadfully boring and he gave up after a few chapters.)
- wolverine876 4y ago> His biographer says that Allen & Unwin (his publishers) asked for "a new Hobbit book". I wonder what the publisher's thoughts were about Tolkien's response: 'How about a six book, three volume epic, not suitable for much of the same audience (children), in essentially a new genre, with almost all new characters?'
- 4y ago
- colechristensen 4y agoIsn’t most fiction writing like this though? You just don’t get to see it because it’s not so interesting and you don’t generally have a person (tolkiens son) making editing leftovers their life’s work. People edit, make major changes, names change, a minor detail in an early draft becomes a central plot point. Neil Gaiman definitely talks about development of his work like this. Tolkien seems to be particularly interested in having a body of his life’s work writing being consistent, but it’s not so out of line with how any fiction is written.