5 ms·
None of this shows Lyft's business model is broken. In fact it shows it's working splendidly for Lyft. The fact that Lyft takes a different percentage of each
by crazygringo 4y ago
None of this shows Lyft's business model is broken. In fact it shows it's working splendidly for Lyft.
The fact that Lyft takes a different percentage of each ride -- from less than 20% to more than 70%, in the author's experience -- is a reflection that at different times of day, on different days, in different locations, there are different mismatches between driver supply and passenger demand.
Lyft obviously pays the minimum needed to ensure available drivers, and charges the most that passengers are willing to pay. None of this is surprising -- it's how a market intermediary works. As more drivers sign up and are active in relation to passengers, driver pay decreases. As more passengers need rides in relation to drivers, passenger fares increase. And vice-versa.
The idea that taxi dispatchers could be more efficient, or as efficient, is ludicrous. Does nobody remember regularly waiting 30-60 minutes for a taxi from a dispatcher?
To answer the author's question, of course Lyft could make deeper cuts while keeping the core business running. But most of running a business is about reinvesting profits/capital into growth when growth seems available.
After all, the very first sentence on Wikipedia makes it clear all the things it's trying to do at once, of which ride-hailing is one of many [1]:
> Lyft, Inc. offers mobility as a service, ride-hailing, vehicles for hire, motorized scooters, a bicycle-sharing system, rental cars, and food delivery in the United States and select cities in Canada.
It takes a lot of employees to be doing all those things.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lyft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lyft
- lallysingh 4y agoThe argument I read was that they're charging a higher percentage than the previously-profitable taxi, yet still losing money overall.
- UncleEntity 4y agoPlus, I might add, the drivers are responsible for 100% of the expenses of operating the vehicle. Back when I drove cabs the company owned the car and was responsible for all maintenance and insurance requirements. I just had to put in gas and if it broke down they’d send out a tow truck and give me another car. It was more expensive this way but once I got the lease + gas paid I kept everything I made. Some days I’d have the car paid off in the first couple trips and some days I ended up working for free but I always ended up making enough to pay my rent and eat. I have to take Lyft whenever I’m in Phoenix because they destroyed the taxi industry there and I have a pretty good general idea how much it costs to get places in a cab and Lyft is currently charging as much if not more than the cabs charged while giving the drivers a smaller slice of the pie. Last time I went to visit my parents Lyft charged me ~$50 while giving the driver (IIRC) $18 plus a whole $0.50 gas surcharge for a 23 mile trip. In a cab it probably would have cost $56 (I’m really good at estimating it turned out) which would have all gone to the driver to do with what the will. Beginning of the shift that’s half their lease, end of shift it’d be all profit. The last company I drove for the owner was really good to the drivers and would do things like adjust the lease price depending on the market conditions and he had no problems turning a profit up until Covid hit.
- julianeon 4y agoThis reminds me of a good principle I try to come back to: If the way things are before was better, why did we end in the place we are now? If the answer is 'no explanation' then it's this explanation, or alternative, which is bad. In other words, if we rewound things back to where things were before Lyft... then we would expect them to end up in the same place they are now, [now-then] years later. It would just be a replay. Now it's different if things changed: if computing power got 100x more expensive, okay, taxi companies might come back in style and win in a replay. But failing that? Evidently people prefer Lyft & Uber to taxi companies: because the world was once [large percentage] taxi companies vs. [tiny percentage] ridesharing, and now it's the other way around, post-competition. Note: to get to the author's preferred outcome, just assume a non-Lyft non-Uber low-cost ridesharing company. That seems like the best way to get to that point, without swimming against the tide of history.
- rightbyte 4y ago> Evidently people prefer Lyft & Uber to taxi companies Americans prefer taking an Lyft to not getting a taxi at all due to taxi number medallion cap. Most place did not have the problem Lyft and Uber solved. I.e. circumvent medallion shortages.
- finnh 4y agoMedallions caps were not the only problem with cabs. Not by a long shot.
- TylerE 4y agoMedallions are an NYC thing. Not applicable to most Americans. Not that it makes taxi service any less dreadful.
- rightbyte 4y agoI tried to get cabs to my home in Mountain View, CA multiple times but every cab company but one said that was not their area and the designated cab company had hours of wait. Only Uber worked. I could easily get a cab to the home from the city though. There had to be something up there to.
- diffxx 4y ago> None of this shows Lyft's business model is broken. In fact it shows it's working splendidly for Lyft. Even if this is true, should this be celebrated even it comes at the expense of the > 99% of the population that doesn't work for Lyft as well as the thousands of drivers who are being exploited by their business practices? It is a relatively small minority of citizens who actually rely on these businesses for their day to day lives but their externalities are borne by all. > The idea that taxi dispatchers could be more efficient, or as efficient, is ludicrous. Does nobody remember regularly waiting 30-60 minutes for a taxi from a dispatcher? Even if you're right, this presupposes that it is a net benefit to have easily available taxis. It also seems to suggest that efficiency is best measured by latency between ordering a taxi and being picked up. Taxis are easily the least efficient form of transit. They are even worse than private vehicles because of the deadheading. Then there is the whole induced demand problem where they actually make traffic worse as people with the means opt out of more efficient mass transit so overall transit efficiency suffers even if it is (seemingly) more convenient for many users. > In any case, yes surely Lyft could cut costs drastically in order to become more profitable, but it's also continuing to invest in growth as much as possible. So they can try to hold the public hostage and mobilize their minority user base against any legislation that will rein in their excesses.
- burnished 4y agoYour points aren’t really in opposition to anything they said - analysis isn’t endorsement, you might infer their feelings on these practices from their first bit saying that these were good practices - for Lyft. It reads to me like OP had an analysis that did not agree with the TFA, and that you read that take as an explicit endorsement as opposed to a description of what is going on.
- 908B64B197 4y ago> The idea that taxi dispatchers could be more efficient, or as efficient, is ludicrous. Does nobody remember regularly waiting 30-60 minutes for a taxi from a dispatcher? And getting completely ignored should your pick-up location be on the wrong side of the tracks here in Palo Alto? Sure do. It's interesting how it's now fashionable to bash on Uber and Lyft. Seems everyone conveniently forgot about the medallion system Uber and Lyft disrupted. Pre-Uber/Lyft, either the driver rented the car to a middleman who rented the medallion from a rich owner, or said owner was selling and financing (most banks won't touch these medallions!) a medallion at a ridiculous interest rate to a driver that planned to use it as his retirement savings (an extremely volatile asset and not very liquid). Sure back then the dispatch only took a 15-20% cut, but medallion payments took at least a 50% cut on every ride. That money didn't get re-invested or re-distributed as incentives to drivers, no. It went straight to the pockets of the local rent-seeker. The more I spoke to cab drivers the more it seemed their industry was a pyramid scheme aimed at helping established rent-seeker take advantage of often poor new immigrants. Uber/Lyft brought a breeze of fresh air: Someone could simply buy a car, calculate the depreciation and it's value on the market (since unlike medallions cars are relatively liquid assets!) do rideshare and calculate their profits or loss. They can get out of the game at anytime, and they know exactly how much they are going to get for the car they have should they sell it. And I'm not even touching the usual pain points and often discriminatory practices of medallion drivers (refusing card payments, refusing rides to non-white passengers and to non-white neighborhoods...).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- arcticbull 4y ago> The idea that taxi dispatchers could be more efficient, or as efficient, is ludicrous. This really doesn't follow from your position. Taxi operators are significantly more efficient because they are able to pool their leases together and are able to insure themselves as a group. Relying on individuals to do both leaves economies of scale on the table. There's no reason that taxi dispatchers can't use better scheduling systems - however, the fundamental premise of Lyft and Uber is that they cannot ever recognize the efficiencies of scale in the underlying business. The cost basis of a Lyft or Uber ride is fundamentally higher than that of a taxi. What has changed recently though is the markets and investors have stopped pouring money into rider subsidies and the price of Lyft and Uber rides is starting to approach the actual cost. That cost is often significantly higher than incumbents. The prices you saw over the last few years weren't operational efficiencies, just subsidies that taxis couldn't match because they have to actually recover their costs at the farebox instead of on Sand Hill Road. > After all, the very first sentence on Wikipedia makes it clear all the things it's trying to do at once, of which ride-hailing is one of many [1]: They're all terrible businesses. Food delivery couldn't even make money during COVID lockdowns when nobody went outside to eat and spent like a year and a half just ordering off Doordash. Now they're trying to get into the grocery business and offering 50% off that. I paid $30 for groceries, delivered in hand, and the receipt showed the Uber Eats driver paid $50 for them. I'd really recommend Naked Capitalism's 'can Uber ever deliver' series that's as true now as it was when they started writing it in 2016. [1] [1] https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2016/11/can-uber-ever-deliver-part-one-understanding-ubers-bleak-operating-economics.html https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2016/11/can-uber-ever-delive...
- troad 4y agoWhy does it take the author of the linked piece thirty-six paragraphs to make what was already a widely known point, that Uber isn’t profitable? It’s not like the piece is particularly rich in elaboration or explanation, it just seems… verbose. Like a high school senior desperately trying to stretch a preconceived conclusion to the required word count.
- arcticbull 4y ago
- KennyBlanken 4y agoThe reason Lyft and Uber are working "splendidly" is because they ignored, and then lobbied their way out of, a lot of regulations that taxi companies (in my urban area) were required to follow. At first by claiming they were somehow different because there was a smartphone involved instead of raising your hand or calling a number...and then by lobbying their way into much cushier regulations. In my city taxi related regulations included: * a police unit dedicated to "hackney" matters and a hotline to call for everything from reporting dangerous driving, dirty/poor-repair vehicles to lost item reports, and police actually followed up on most of these, and had the authority to pull a vehicle from service * mandated minimum number of paratransit vehicles, ie wheelchair vans * prohibitions on declining rides based on the destination or pickup area * submitting drivers to a criminal background check by police. Go lurk in the uber/lyft forums and do some searches and you'll see drivers bragging about sailing past the corporate-run background checks even with violent felonies. * random inspections by police * standards for being in-service * actual wheels-rolled-this-far metering by a device certified with visible-to-customer seal, not GPS which isn't nearly as accurate especially in dense areas with tall buildings where you get multipath errors and very limited constellation visibility...and almost entirely an uninspectable software black-box even ignoring issues with high density areas. Lyft and Uber could be inflating their mileage by a couple percent whenever they feel like it and nobody would be able to tell. * receipts on the spot listing vehicle, driver, distance, fare. Live in a known bad neighborhood? Good luck getting an Uber/Lyft to pick you up. Need a wheelchair van? Good luck, Uber/Lyft didn't have any for years and it took lawsuits by states and cities. Drivers describe seeing someone come out their door on crutches and driving off because they don't want the "liability" (really, they don't want to wait for someone slow.) See an Uber driver driving dangerously? Nobody gives a damn, and good luck getting the plate versus a large, high contrast 3-4 digit number posted on every corner of the car. You cannot reach anyone at Uber or Lyft unless you had a ride booked; the apps trigger an outbound call from their call center, but only if you had a booked right and answer the questions the app asks you correctly.
- Jochim 4y agoFrankly these companies operated as criminal enterprises, intentionally creating programs and taking action to evade law enforcement officials in multiple countries. The companies and the executives responsible are criminal should be treated as such. The companies should be destroyed and the executives imprisoned. Any early investors/VC funds that provably knew the illegality of the company's actions should suffer the same fate.
- Jochim 4y ago> Does nobody remember regularly waiting 30-60 minutes for a taxi from a dispatcher? Only at extremely peak times. On the other hand I could actually book a car and have it show up at a pre-arranged time. Availability during the day was much better and after bars close it's almost impossible to find a car now. Prices were much lower. The drivers were much more skilled. Uber/Lyft are the perfect examples of how much damage VC backed US startups can cause to a functioning market. To the point that if China style restrictions on the operation of US companies in my country were proposed I'd most likely vote in support of them.
- amscanne 4y agoYour experience with taxis was the polar opposite of mine, and I used to ride them pretty frequently. With respect to prearranged rides, I’d say that reliability was in the 50-80% range. My mother still refuses to use any apps, and calls the taxi company to arrange pickups at specific times. You’d think they’d try hard for the last business they have, but they failed to show the last two times (leading to panic and a small fortune in airport parking). This is saying nothing regarding their flagrant violations of the law (refusing fares, refusing to accept card payment because “the machine is broken”, unbelievably reckless driving, unsafe vehicles, etc.). Maybe it was just where I was, but the industry was a government-enforced oligopoly begging for disruption.
- Jochim 4y agoThe taxi industry where I am was fairly well regulated. Card payment was sometimes contentious. It was generally polite to ask to stop at an ATM on the way to the destination but if it was the only option they'd rather get paid. Now most companies allow you to pay for the fare via their own app which I assume is a licensed white-label or managed service. The quality of the drivers was better. Uber/Lyft drivers often don't know where they're going and have left me feeling more uncomfortable/unsafe both personally and in terms of driving. Service is still generally good although overall poorer than it used to be due to the effect Uber has had on the market. Previously there was fairly healthy competition between a decent number of companies, most of which have now merged. I don't believe that would have happened without the external pressure. > Maybe it was just where I was, but the industry was a government-enforced oligopoly begging for disruption. The disruption was a $30bn charade though. Would these companies have succeeded if they actually had to make any money? I'm actually quite not sure how to deal with the concept of a company that's lost that much money and still doesn't seem to be close to being profitable. I do believe companies and their executives should be punished harshly for acting criminally though.
- yellowapple 4y ago> Does nobody remember regularly waiting 30-60 minutes for a taxi from a dispatcher? I've waited similar times for an Uber or Lyft.