8 ms·
Many of these students ultimately end up going into finance or consulting, not because they were particularly excited about that as a career path but because it
by paulpauper 4y ago
Many of these students ultimately end up going into finance or consulting, not because they were particularly excited about that as a career path but because it’s the easiest high-status next step from their in-retrospect-poorly-chosen major. Unfortunately, those are also career paths that require long hours and where the work is often meaningless. While I’m sure that finance and consulting are the right career choice for some elite college graduates, I’d be surprised if it was the best choice for nearly 50% of them.
But the pay is so much more too. This means you can retire sooner and then use the free time to find meaning. It also means you have more money to fund your hobbies and interests, and also just having a nice standard of living is good too, and not having to worry so much about unpaid bills, medical costs, etc. . People who have crappy jobs also work long hours too and find the work meaningless.
- hammock 4y agoAre finance and consulting really high status beyond the pay? Why? In theory it seems like they might be, but most of my peers in these fields are pretty uninspiring
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoCan't speak for the US but here, "suit" jobs are generally held to higher regard even if the job no longer requires a suit. Fancy names and a history of good pay definitely help. If anything, IT is the outlier in "well-paid office jobs which garner lots of respect".
- switchbak 4y agoSuit jobs are only highly regarded amongst a subset of the population. I think the more you understand the realities of those jobs, the less appeal they have. There's also certain personality types drawn to those roles which isn't attractive for everyone. I used to look at engineers and think I missed out by not going down that road. Fast forward a few years and it turns out most engineers I talk to see the tech industry as being a much better draw (higher salaries, more jobs, etc).
- robocat 4y ago> IT is the outlier in "well-paid office jobs which garner lots of respect" That is a relatively modern thing - I thought IT was relatively unrespected even 20 years ago, although I am not in the US, so maybe different there. I suspect the change was occurring about when Zuckerberg became wealthy, maybe late 00’s? It is fucking bizarre to me seeing “geek” go mainstream (although commercialised geek is definitely different from traditional geek - maybe even incompatibly so?).
- Falkon1313 4y agoI think it was at least 30 years ago. With the dot-com boom and impending Y2K disaster, tech had tons of high-paid jobs, and relatively few people had used computers much if at all. Tech 'wizards' were viewed as mysterious brilliant people who could do magic with a little bit of typing or tinkering.
- patja 4y agoThey are extremely high status among friends and family who do not work in tech or IT, or among recent graduate peers who are struggling to get a white collar career going and stuck in service jobs or other jobs that will never break 100k/yr. For a lot of those folks, just hearing about the types of lunch and travel expenses enjoyed by consultants can imbue the job with high status.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hammock 4y agoWhich gets at the uninspiring bit. Having experienced fancy lunches and travel, it ain’t all it’s made out to be and I doubt that anyone higher status than me whom I would actually aspire to, would give two hoots about it the way the people you describe do
- quartesixte 4y agoWe live in a world where high pay = status. Not ideal if you aspire the world to be more Meaningful or Spiritual or what have you, but this is reality. And when in the United States alone the average salary hovers around $75K/yr, a 24 year old being able to command a near $150K base-salary (excluding bonuses) is in the eyes of many absolutely flying high. Add to that Finance/Consulting/Professional Services eats/live/travels/dresses in a manner that is high status in our society and the jobs quickly becomes a status symbol and attracts those who are willing to sacrifice some amount of passion for status or material wealth. It also is a field where it confers that wealth and status without Having to Know Someone or Be A Genetic Outlier In Physical Performance/Appearance. Lastly, survive long enough and climb the ladder high enough and you start gaining Power. That wealth no longer buys you things but rather connections, access, and influence. Finance sits in close proximity to many powerful people in the world, and thus by proxy also gains status. SWE/IT offers similar levels of wealth but unfortunately lacks that proximity to power (yet) and as a class of professionals seems to espouse cultural values that go against the ostentatious displays of wealth that the average person associates with high status. At the very least, no one is showing up to morning standups in a custom tailored suit. Source: my social circle growing up mostly consisted of working class immigrant families. Getting into a T20 University and breaking into Wall Street was the very definition of Making It.
- hammock 4y agoYou are onto something with the proximity to power thing. A lot of understanding of the world unlocked for me once I started peeling apart wealth & power, how wealth /= power, and how power is the more important end (vs wealth). For example, if anything, someone with a lot of wealth has likely been selling away a lot of power in order to acquire the wealth. >It also is a field where it confers that wealth and status without Having to Know Someone I wouldn't have thought this. What in your view are those fields?
- quartesixte 4y agoHollywood is a prime example of this. Music industry is another. Book publishing is also rife with nepotism but in a non-familial way. Anything media related in general. Even journalism -- Anderson Cooper is a Vanderbilt. Chris Cuomo's father and brother both high ranking politicians.
- giantg2 4y agoI work for a financial company. The closer you get to the money, the more status you're expected to display. They expect you to have a BMW, Tesla, or similar. They expect you to hire a guy to perform any manual labor. They expect that you have a nice house in a nice area. If you don't have these things, you're looked down on and people assume you aren't successful/skilled. Just projecting the image is enough to push some people into a promotion.
- JauntTrooper 4y agoI think the 'need to impress people' is often used as an excuse to splurge. Maybe it's more expected for salesmen like financial advisors, or small business attorneys that are dealing with retail clients. I'm a fairly senior investment banker (Managing Director, group head), and I drive a 14 year old Honda. None of my co-workers or clients have ever seen my car or been to my house. I don't wear a watch. Some of my co-workers will wear bespoke clothes and flashy jewelry, but it's not required, and mid-tier conservative suits and shoes are fine.
- throwaway2037 4y agoI agree. I see two types of finance MDs: Flashy and low key. It sounds like you are more low key. My sense about the flashy ones: Their net worth is surprisingly low because their burn rate is so high. The low key ones are loaded.
- robocat 4y agoWhat are the options to avoid the status treadmill? Faking displays seems hard (status markers are chosen for their difficulty to fake, presumably the easy faking is done by everyone, and I guess high cost if busted and competition to catch others out?) Can you be so competent that you can ignore the status rules? Presumably difficult, because competence is hard to measure, and competitively it is hard to achieve a significantly higher level of competence than others? A status player can have mistakes forgiven, but betting on competence requires you never make a misstep? Or do you just optimise for a level of acceptable status, and maximise savings? What happens to those that bug out?
- greggman3 4y agoThe typical response is being in these jobs changes you so that when you have the money you no longer have any meaning. You have a passion, you put it on hold for 10-20yrs for $$$, you come out the other end having lost your passion Further, that assumes you make it out the other end. Almost no one saves the money and retires early. Instead they get some money, they get a nicer apartment, nicer car, start eating out at fancier restaurants, shopping at higher end places, buying fashion brands etc...
- Xeoncross 4y ago+1 The project outline vs the actual shipped product
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hinkley 4y ago> And if you gaze long enough into an abyss, the abyss will gaze back into you.
- giantg2 4y ago"you put it on hold for 10-20yrs for $$$, you come out the other end having lost your passion" People change for a lot of reasons. I gave up some hobbies when I had a kid and I'm pretty sure I won't pick them back up when I retire. People's passions change, or they realize certain things are unobtainable. That's just life.
- ip26 4y agoIt’s become clear some hobbies are essentially status-seeking among young adults and/or showing off to potential partners. They simply don’t make much sense anymore for someone married with kids.
- giantg2 4y agoMaybe for some. Mine weren't about that, but I could certainly see some people involved in those same activities could be.
- cung 4y agoI keep hearing that consulting and finance are terrible uninspiring careers, but as a consultant I honestly have no idea what else I could do that would be more inspiring. I would love to know though.
- perfecthjrjth 4y agoThere are no other better choices available, unless one is born into wealth. That's why whoever talks about passion, inspiration, etc, is just talking throgh his/her hat. For 95 percent of the world population, some job is better than not having a job.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- anon7725 4y agoIf you are happy with your own life, you can CTRL+W on this and all other navel-gazing internet fare.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoThere are plenty of things which are more interesting than consulting which is why most consultants actually use the career as a stepping stone to go do what their clients were doing.
- patja 4y agoConsulting is also great on the job training in how the real world of commerce and business operate, with the bonus that after a year or two you probably have personal knowledge of how a handful of major corporations operate, including which corporate cultures are healthy/positive and which are not. The types of lessons you never learn in a classroom.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoThe gap between what consulting companies like students to think they will learn and what they actually learn is very significant.
- runlaszlorun 4y agoHa, that’s true. But at least you get to see how dysfunctional nearly any corporation is pretty quickly.
- UnpossibleJim 4y agoThose are good reasons, I'm not going to deny that but there's something to be said for enjoying life while you're young enough to take full advantage of it. Being poor(ish) when you're young isn't the worst thing in the world, when you have no real responsibilities. Grinding to make money in your thirties and beyond, when those real responsibilities hit always made more sense to me... but I may have done all of it wrong. I don't know.
- aiwv 4y ago> Grinding to make money in your thirties and beyond I sort of think grinding is generally wrong at any age. If you feel like you're grinding, perhaps it's time to take stock and consider what you could be doing differently so that you don't have to keep grinding to both meet your responsibilities and enjoy life. Of course some might find themselves with enough exigencies they have almost no choice but to grind, but I doubt too many people on HN are really in that boat.
- hgomersall 4y agoRight, if you're not doing it for the journey, maybe you need to find another destination or a better route or something.
- ZephyrBlu 4y agoInvesting time early on can permanently change your trajectory. My experience has been that "grinding" has very big returns. When you're starting out, putting in 2x more time gets you way more than 2x returns over the same period of time. Personally I'm happy to "grind" for a few years at the start of my career to set myself up for the rest of my life.
- swagasaurus-rex 4y agoMaybe there's no right answer and everybody meanders through life goals at their own pace, or not at all. The requirement to make enough money to survive is unignorable. Anything beyond that is just making up goalposts. There's always another goalpost you could strive to reach.
- theGnuMe 4y agoIt's the journey, not the destination.
- kneebonian 4y agoLife before Death Strength before Weakness Journey before Destination
- giantg2 4y ago"This means you can retire sooner and then use the free time to find meaning." Why does anyone have to find meaning?
- b0afc375b5 4y agoBecause the alternative is an existential crisis.
- giantg2 4y agoWhy is that? Is it that we are conditioned to want a purpose, just as we are conditioned by society to want a bigger house, or a fancy wedding, etc?
- annyeonghada 4y agoI wish I lived in the same society as you where people condition themselves and other to find purpose. On the contrary it seems to me that most people live a completely unexamined life, and don't concern themselves with meaning, purpose, truth, morality or whatever. On the contrary, some people, a small minority, are bugged by these existential questions: nobody conditioned me, the ridiculed me for "thinking too much". Not everything is "social conditioning": some people through a mixture of genetics and experiences are just born this way. I wish I weren't.
- quartesixte 4y agoBy the way, I find it confusing that the article states that finance and consulting is the result of poorly chosen majors. That's the kind of thinking you apply to kids who picked Jazz Theory and then realized that La La Land is nearly pure Hollywood fantasy (the ending anyways). Those business/biz-econ/business admin/econ classrooms are filled with kids who have no delusion about what they're getting themselves into it. They're in it for the money and a shot at being hired by the big shot names on Wall Street. They're either passionate about the money, or they just want a stable life with money. And the entire undergrad experience of those two fields of study do a pretty swell job of weeding kids out. Business Frats, Clubs, Societies -- the emphasis on networking and internships. Like, the classroom experience might be less rigorous compared to your average pre-med student but make no mistake getting a job on Wall Street requires a lot of work. Just a very different kind of work. It is also the only high status step outside of medicine and law. Or claiming fame via Hollywood (in which nepotism runs rampant) or Athletics (in which your ability to gain status is almost entirely decided by whether or not you were born a genetic outlier). The first two require a lot more schooling and particular academic talent. The last two are basically moonshots and the road to fame littered with failed attempts. So finance it is.
- barry-cotter 4y ago> Those business/biz-econ/business admin/econ classrooms are filled with kids who have no delusion about what they're getting themselves into it. I know Harvard doesn’t have anything so vulgar as business, accounting or finance at undergrad since well bred young men and women leave that to grad school. Similarly for Stanford, Yale and Princeton.
- voisin 4y ago> It also means you have more money to fund your hobbies and interests Except investment banking and consulting both have notoriously long (100+ hr/wk) work weeks leaving very little time for other interests and hobbies. These careers effectively force you to adopt the career as the core of your personality.
- bedhead 4y agoTrue but it still might be better than the alternative of working just enough (~40 hours/week) to still make it hard to spend a lot of time on outside interests while not living very comfortably, financially speaking.
- HEmanZ 4y agoMy 2-cents seeing friends and a sibling go through the IB track. You have 100+ hr/wk for a few years in your 20s, when you're young and can sort of handle it. But by the time you're having a family you work more normal hours and make absolute FU money (e.g my younger brother makes over 10x/yr what I do at only 31 years old). It's not about the salary and hours when you start at 22, its about the salary and hours when you're 32 and 42. I compare this to my friends who became physicians or accountants, and I think the IB folks have a waaaay better work-to-pay ratio long-term. I'm on the fence about consulting because the pay ceiling seems lower and I don't personally know enough of them.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoYou have much more flexibility of where to live as a physician. Remote software developer is probably the best pay to quality of life at work ratio, and probably even higher pay outright if you were at a high flying tech company for some portion of the last 15 years.
- galdosdi 4y ago> You have much more flexibility of where to live as a physician. Ludicrously false. In the long run, sure. But your youth will be spent in whatever random town the residency match takes you to, and that's after having to go wherever there's a med school that'll take you. The flexibility comes much later and by then you may have settled down accidentally somewhere you randomly got placed.
- zitterbewegung 4y agoI’ve tried doing my passion by doing two startups and also going into finance and since hindsight is 20/20 a good reason why I think I should have actually went into finance first and or even going into consulting as a technical person in a large Fortune 500 is that budgeting of projects and planning of software to meet budgets is much clearer to me now and management of time to find a solution would have informed me much better than doing the startups first. Also I could have started saving money for another startup instead of incurring credit card debt.
- saiya-jin 4y agoThat's all nice theory on paper, but you sure have no clue about reality of most folks you write about... Life is too short, and damn too short to make huge mistakes like this, for something so meaningless as just money. I am not saying cash is completely meaningless, we don't live in utopia, but the more you have them less meaning/significance they have. Any white collar folk who ain't completely useless can earn enough to have a decent life and realize (as quickly as possible) that true meaning in life, and long term happiness are in completely different direction than piles of cash. At one point you start paying heavily with former to get latter.
- twelve40 4y agothis is stated rather categorically for a subjective opinion
- adamsmith143 4y ago>But the pay is so much more too. This means you can retire sooner and then use the free time to find meaning. The type of person that goes into Finance/Consulting is certainly not the type of person that will want to retire early.
- steine65 4y agoFinance person here. I rarely meet people in finance who want to be working the rest of their lives. Not sure if your comment was sarcastic.
- KMag 4y agoThat's my experience in finance, as well. Jim Cramer mentioned that when he interviewed at Goldman, they asked him what he planned to do when he left Goldman. Lots of people hit comfortable retirement money at Goldman in their late 30s to late 40s and pivot to working in the public sector. I went on a tour in Cambodia through a company that donates a portion of its profits to local schools. The last day of our tour, I had dinner with the guy who started the company, and it turns out that running a business that benefits one of the poorest countries is his soft retirement after leaving his position as an MD in Goldman's London office in his mid 40s. I left Goldman for a hedge fund, but if I didn't have a kid, I'd be soft retired by now.
- overgard 4y agoHow many people live well below their means and retire early though? I imagine most people taking those jobs just ended up living expensive lifestyles and retiring around the same time the rest of us do. Plus even retiring early generally means waiting until you're in your 40s or 50s.
- KMag 4y agoI think plenty of people work hard to hit retirement money, and then make mid-life career switches to jobs with better work-life balance. My wife and I were having lots of trouble starting a family and were preparing to basically retire early. The problem is, it's difficult to fit in socially if you're retired early. I was about to start working in earnest on a career pivot to consulting/gig work that I could do for a few months out of the year and travel with my wife the rest of the year. The main aim of the flexible work was to remain employable and able to ramp back up if something went terribly wrong with our retirement investments and/or our living costs. Luckily, our 4th pregnancy worked out (unlike the previous 3). Now, we're working to maximize opportunities for our son, but we were preparing to make serious career changes to trade the majority of our income for much more flexibility. Now, the plan is to keep working until our son is through college, but he's less than 2 years old, so there's plenty of time for plans to change. Had we lost our son, the plan was to live out a 3-4 star lifestyle, traveling the world and working just enough to keep the option open for ramping work back up in an emergency. So, it's a sample size of one, but I think the type of people who live well enough below their means to retire early also tend to be the the type of people who dial their careers back to idle for a "soft retirement" instead of quitting work cold-turkey.
- eldritch_4ier 4y agoExpensive lifestyles are expensive because there’s more demand for them. Living a more desirable lifestyle and then retiring at the same time is still better is it not?
- SamvitJ 4y agoThe pay in consulting is not typically the main draw. Finance and tech are almost always more lucrative. Even within finance, most jobs do not pay particularly high salaries for entry-level positions, if seen through the lens of hourly rates (e.g., investment banking).
- zdragnar 4y ago> People who have crappy jobs also work long hours too and find the work meaningless. This part of your comment isn't getting nearly the attention it deserves. Hard work and long hours aren't the reward, they are what let you reward yourself- however you find value or meaning. Some jobs don't require long hours. Some jobs pay more than others. Sometimes, doing a job can be intrinsically fulfilling. Not every job is all or any of those things, and any one of them may mean tradeoffs to the others.
- SoftTalker 4y ago> But the pay is so much more too. This means you can retire sooner and then use the free time to find meaning. What I seem to see more often is just more or more expensive consumption. Bigger house, expensive furnishings, expensive cars, designer clothes, lavish vacations.
- lmm 4y agoMost people eventually figure out that meaning is overrated and comfort is where it's at.
- ramblerman 4y ago> This means you can retire sooner and then use the free time to find meaning Ugh. What an illusion. Please don’t put your life on hold to find meaning in your 40/50s
- coffeebeqn 4y agoAt least in the US in a high paying job you can very easily save 50% and still have more spending money than most people around you. It doesn’t necessarily mean you have to sacrifice anything other than lifestyle creep
- acapybara 4y agoYes, did exactly this. People who say things like "you're putting your life on hold" have no discipline. I set out on this path at 17. I'm 36 now. I have a wife, kids, have traveled a lot, lived in better houses than most of my peers, ate out plenty, etc. Much living was had. I left salary work at age 34 (FIRE). What do I do now? Work harder than ever and play the long game, and of course continue to live a rich life. To anyone considering saving and building wealth starting at an early age: yes, it's worth it. No, you don't have to "pause your life." You will need discipline.
- annyeonghada 4y ago>People who say things like "you're putting your life on hold" have no discipline. Imagine trying to extrapolate moral superiority from having had the luck of finding a high paid job. >I set out on this path at 17. I'm 36 now. Yes, I too had dreams at 17. I even had an entire notebook with journaling about those dreams. None of them came to life. NONE. I guess I wasn't worthy or disciplined enough like the morally superior: the rich.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- spritefs 4y ago> But the pay is so much more too. This means you can retire sooner and then use the free time to find meaning. This spiel about waiting for retirement to "find meaning" is a load of BS. Telling people to sit around and wait for decades on end until their life is 4/5 of the way complete is inhumane. Why wait for decades when someone can just do what they're interested in now? The fact that some people unironically think this crazy stuff (and don't see how crazy it really is) is just sickening to me
- IIAOPSW 4y agoHere's a profound realization. Utility is a function of both variables, time and money. Wholly unemployed people have plenty time but can't afford to spend the money using it how they want. So the situation is valueless. On the opposite extreme, people who spend every waking working have plenty of money but can't afford to spend a second using it how they want. So that situation is also valueless. Based on nothing more than crudely assuming utility = time*money and then optimizing with simple calculus, you can get very close to deriving a 40 hour work week as the utility maximizing choice.