5 ms·
The top 1% pay 40% of the federal tax revenue. The top 5% pay 60%. California has the highest income tax at 13.3%, the highest federal tax rate is 37%. That m
by WalterBright 4y ago
The top 1% pay 40% of the federal tax revenue. The top 5% pay 60%.
California has the highest income tax at 13.3%, the highest federal tax rate is 37%.
That makes the top income tax rate 50%.
- underdeserver 4y agoTop 1% of salary earners. The CEOs, highly paid doctors, engineers. The real capitalists - those who hold the assets and pay for their yachts with stock-backed loans - they don't pay 40% of the federal tax revenue. Their salary is $1/year.
- WalterBright 4y agoLoans are not income.
- janalsncm 4y agoThere is no law of nature that says only income can be taxed. Loans could be taxed.
- bmitc 4y agoYou totally get it, and I really like the law of nature phrasing.
- WalterBright 4y agoHow about taxing your mortgage, then?
- janalsncm 4y agoThat could be a law. It would be a bad law for most people since they don’t own any houses. Taxing loans to billionaires is a good law because it closes the “just take out a loan” loophole.
- dragonwriter 4y agoAlternatively, loans are income today coupled with an expense over some future period. Including loan proceeds in taxed income (and deducting repayment) is certainly a potential policy choice. OTOH, treating pledging an asset as security for a loan as a realization event at FMV, making it both taxable if a gain and a basis value update, while taxing capital gains as normal income would also be a way to shutdown the “use secured loans to fund your lifestyle to avoid realizing gains and being taxed” hack.
- vladvasiliu 4y agoHow are stock-backed-loans paid back? If in cash, they have to get the cash from somewhere, right? Supposedly selling the stocks. That can be taxed then and there. If they transfer the stocks to the lender, that means the stocks in question are valued at $x, since that's the value of the loan. So tax that value.
- brianwawok 4y agoAfter you die your estate sells stocks
- matthewdgreen 4y agoDoes the estate pay capital gains on those stocks, or can it take advantage of stepped-up cost basis rules to avoid those as well?
- ti00 4y agoI'm not an expert, but my reading of the IRS's FAQ [1] is that the cost basis of inherited assets gets reset to the fair market value of the assets on the date of death. 1. https://www.irs.gov/faqs/interest-dividends-other-types-of-income/gifts-inheritances/gifts-inheritances https://www.irs.gov/faqs/interest-dividends-other-types-of-i...
- WalterBright 4y agoYou're right, and then you pay the inheritance tax which is more than the capital gains taxes would have been.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> > And then you pay the 40% federal inheritance tax and the 20% state inheritance tax on the total value at the date of death. After the $12 million (nearly $13 million next year) exemption, the unused portion of which passes to the surviving spouse and increases their tax-free estate exemption. But, yes, in the limit case estates aren't the tax-optimal way to transfer capital to survivors, which is why other vehicles are used for people for whom the estate exemption is small potatoes.
- bmitc 4y agoI have already covered this elsewhere, but that's an excuse and actually only points to how concentrated the wealth is. Too bad they pay more money than others. Tax them more.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe wealth that wealthy people have isn't "concentrated", it's created. I.e. they didn't take it from you.
- int_19h 4y agoIt's not created by those people. It's created by some worker somewhere, and those people collect most of that created wealth as economic rent, solely because they own the capital used in the process.
- nickpp 4y agoWithout their capital the whole organization where workers are creating would not exist in the first place. So the market is rightly rewarding capital owners for risking it in the first place. Do you think that is easy and just "collecting rent"? What is your experience investing?
- int_19h 4y agoWithout the labor, the output wouldn't exist either, so why do the capital owners pocket most of the generated wealth? For that matter, how did it come to be that capital is so concentrated that most productive people have to rent it to generate wealth?
- nickpp 4y agoBoth capital owners and workers are paid according to the prices set by the free market for their input. Most of the generated wealth however is captured by the society (ie we each derive more value from the stuff we buy than the cost we pay for it) and by the government - taxes on work, consumption and profit are usually much larger than other costs in a company operation. Capital tends to concentrate, indeed - but that is also a good thing as it allows bigger enterprises. However the cost to build a new business has been steadily decreasing over the year together with the cost of capital while its availability has been increasing. Today's most productive people can easily open their own practices and set their price on their own contracts. The "rent" they pay is hugely outweighs by their future profits. If you want to rail agains something, rail against the fact that financial education and investing is not more widespread so people do not understand that they can participate and invest in capital markets from very low amounts of money. Capitalism is powerful and empowering but requires work and education.
- danny_codes 4y agoBefore Kennedy it was 91%. Imo we are well bellow the Laffer curve.
- dsfyu404ed 4y ago>Before Kennedy it was 91%. To which the common retort is "but nobody actually paid that because prior to the tax code simplifications of the 70s you could trivially reduce your burden in all sorts of ways"
- WalterBright 4y agoNot only that, the tax avoidance schemes required investing in tax shelters, which were usually very poorly performing investments. When Reagan exchanged the lowered tax rates for elimination of those tax shelters, it allowed capital to flow instead to productive investments, which helped the economic growth.
- mrguyorama 4y agoThen surely, they would have no problem returning to that exact system right? No they want to avoid that by all means necessary? Sounds like they know how much it truly effects things.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoAs a purely theoretical concept I don't think it's a big deal. It wouldn't have a large effect on me personally. That said, society might hurt a bit from the tax shelter vs productive allocation of capital problem another commenter above mentioned. As a practical matter I have zero faith that the usual scumbags would not corrupt the process leaving everybody with higher taxes than either system and then gaslight everybody into thinking they're paying less. Look at how healthcare turned out.
- naasking 4y ago> That makes the top income tax rate 50%. While interesting data points, I'm not seeing an argument that they are paying enough, which seems to be your implication. Maybe it should be 90%. Maybe it should be even more.
- WalterBright 4y agoMake taxes too high, and who is going to invest in America? It will be a Pyrrhic victory for you. We already see wealthier people fleeing California for Texas and Florida, the same for New York. It's not the government that produces the wealth in the economy, it's business. Confiscatory taxes will wind up with everyone poorer, including you.
- naasking 4y agoMost business revenue in America is still from small to medium sized businesses, so this investment you speak of doesn't sound too important. So yes, I agree that business produces wealth, but the business that matters isn't going anywhere because they're largely local. The larger corporations are still going to do business here as well because of the market power. As for wealth flight, it's overblown. First fleeing to another state is very different than fleeing the country. Second people aren't staying in America only because the taxes are lower, there's plenty more to offer. Edit: I forgot to add that the actual evidence for wealth flight is pretty thin. And for those corporations or wealthy people that do leave, fuck 'em. They're not special, irreplaceable snowflakes. They beat out their competitors by luck, and local competitors will immediately spring up to fill the void they leave.
- nickpp 4y agoPretty much every country that tried to tax wealth had to back up exactly because of wealthy and capital flight. > local competitors will immediately spring up What is your experience starting new businesses? It is a highly difficult and risky endeavor and few people find it more attractive than simply getting a job. It's exactly this kind of people that you will alienate and drive away with these of wealth-hostile policies.
- Valakas_ 4y agoBillionaires should not exist. When one gets to a certain amount of wealth, TBD, there they should get a golden plate saying "Congratulations, you won capitalism" and from them on, tax rate is 100%.