5 ms·
You got to love how industry regulations really defeat most of the benefits and points of the decentralization by going in the opposite direction. The problem
by epolanski 4y ago
You got to love how industry regulations really defeat most of the benefits and points of the decentralization by going in the opposite direction.
The problem in reality would be non existent if people used crypto currencies for what they were meant to be used for: an alternative economy with no need for exchanges and third parties: you sell me a banana, I give you some satoshis.
Not saying this is convenient IRL, requiring to sync to a network and chain is expensive and difficult from a phone, but that was the supposed use case.
I'm more and more convinced that blockchain industry solves no real world problems at all, except in the crypto sphere itself (like smart contracts do have a use...for crypto exchanges, crypto games and crypto gambling) and that 99% of the people who get involved couldn't care less about crypto use cases, only if they will sell for more $ than they bought for.
- JonathanBeuys 4y agoindustry regulations really defeat most of the benefits and points of the decentralization How so? Bitcoin's use cases seem unaffected: 1: Hold something that is expected to stay scarce and not printed or mined to infinity 2: Make international, fast and cheap payments that are instantly finalized.
- Double_a_92 4y ago1: How do you easily get bigger amounts of crypto, without a centralized exchange? 2: How does the receiving person use the received bitcoins, unless there is a real economy or again a centralized exchange?
- CurrentB 4y agoWho said anything about not having a centralized exchange? Centralized on ramps are not necessarily antithetical to a decentralized system.
- messy 4y agoI’m sorry, but yes they are… the security of the system was supposed to be built in, and it was supposed to have its value built in. Neither are true. It’s not decentralized and at this rate it never will be, and seeing how it turned out so far, it would be a good thing to fail.
- Double_a_92 4y agoIn this specific argument, it was about regulations, which such centralized exchanges would need to comply with. Generally, it's literally the whole basic premise of everything 'crypto'!
- jrm4 4y agoThis argument kills me all the time. Like, yes, when I take my kids to Chuck E. Cheese I do want to convert my money into the tokens. I do not want to store them as that.
- mattbrewsbytes 4y agoMost regulations around securities involve disclosures as in over some percent threshold the entity owning that security must disclose their ownership and report on it every quarter to the SEC. Disclosure of ownership in crypto really should be around a dollar threshold, not percentage and that mostly defeats the purpose of anonymity. I think financial institutions (banks, exchanges, wall st.) should have to disclose holdings in crypto for both crypto trader awareness but also for their customers in other business sectors awareness. There should also be strict rules preventing operating an exchange/market maker and any sort of investment firm (hedge fund, etc.) by any degrees of separation. That means they can have no relationships at all organizationally (parent/grandparent company owns both type of thing). Any transactions between exchanges and funds of that sort should 100% be reported and tracked. I think it can be anonymously tracked for some period of time but must be disclosed to an independent regulating organization.
- britneybitch 4y agoBitcoin is not a security though. Both the CFTC and SEC have said so publicly: https://bitcoinist.com/cftc-chair-only-bitcoin-is-a-commodity-not-ethereum/ https://bitcoinist.com/cftc-chair-only-bitcoin-is-a-commodit... https://decrypt.co/103926/sec-chair-gensler-bitcoin-not-security-what-about-ethereum https://decrypt.co/103926/sec-chair-gensler-bitcoin-not-secu...
- gremlinsinc 4y agomaybe it should be? on SoFi for example the UI/UX for trading stocks and ETFs is the same flow for trading crypto and people trade it like it is one. Else, why hodl at all if it's not in hopes it'll go up in value?
- epolanski 4y agoYou seem to have jumped my second sentence: > The problem in reality would be non existent if people used crypto currencies for what they were meant to be used for Which is more or less what you're pointing at.
- pyinstallwoes 4y ago> A purely peer-to-peer version of electronic cash would allow online payments to be sent directly from one party to another without going through a financial institution > We have proposed a system for electronic transactions without relying on trust. Any regulation introduces a 3rd party which Bitcoin was designed to remove.
- yashg 4y agoWhen it comes to money, a purely peer to peer system of payment is just not possible unless you are doing barter. Even when you use cash, you are using the cash issued by a third party that both the payer and the receiver trust to have value. Whoever wrote the Bitcoin whitepaper was definitely a brilliant programmer but had no idea about human psychology and economics. Trust is the most important factor in economic transactions. In a complex world like ours third parties like government, banks, exchanges provide the trust. You cannot outsource the trust to code. Code is not law. You cannot solve all problems with code.
- pyinstallwoes 4y agoI tend to agree with you.
- imtringued 4y agoYeah ok but the first use case kind of doesn't work. The "nanny" state raises interest rates a tiny bit and suddenly nobody cares about the scarcity of Bitcoin. What gives?
- danaris 4y ago> The problem in reality would be non existent if people used crypto currencies for what they were meant to be used for In other words, "if people would stop exercising their free will and acting in ways that may benefit them, but are detrimental to my idea/this system/society/etc, everything would be fine!" As the admin and main developer of a small browser-based game, this is a hard lesson I've had to learn over the past several years: We don't get to define how people act and think. When we build systems, we must take into account how people will actually try to use them...and if we find that they're using them in ways that are detrimental to the structure as a whole, we need to rethink our systems.
- psychphysic 4y agoExactly! What's the blooming point? What governments want is digital currencies, all the privacy concerns and none of the benefits of cryptos. But, let's see if crypto can survive this pressure. Really it must be robust to this if it has any purpose.
- epolanski 4y agoCurrencies are already mostly digital since decades.
- psychphysic 4y agoNot disagreeing but to many's surprise cash is more popular than ever. Most of us no longer us bank notes, yet the amount in circulation climbs...[0] what's going on? It actually probably acts like a buffer, with BOE spending the net on government assets while the notes vanish off to places we prefer not to think of [0] https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/statistics/banknote https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/statistics/banknote
- polygamous_bat 4y ago> Most of us no longer us bank notes, yet the amount in circulation climbs. The plots you shared are meaningless if they are not normalized against the total money supply. I think if normalized by total amount of money in circulation the percentage would be shrinking and not growing.
- pjc50 4y ago> The problem in reality would be non existent if people used crypto currencies for what they were meant to be used for: an alternative economy with no need for exchanges and third parties You know, I think we can help you with that: crypto exchanges should be banned on sight. Including localbitcoins. Let the libertarians have their playground, but there must be no linkages between it and the regular world of money.
- TobTobXX 4y agoEven in the case described by OP, exchanges would still be a thing, just like they are between EUR & USD.
- epolanski 4y agoDepends on legislation.
- Zpalmtree 4y agowhy?
- kodyo 4y ago"Regular world of money" is bizarre phrase. I'm assuming you mean the government monopoly on currency, but the idea that a country outsourcing its currency management to a central banking cartel is "regular" is lunacy.
- pjc50 4y agoIt looks pretty regular to me? Currency issuance has been a function of the government since the Bronze age? And paper money since, what, the Song Dynasty?
- kodyo 4y agoYou missed the part where I pointed out that the US government outsourced the administration of its currency to a private banking cartel and some people just think it's normal.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoDo you mean that crypto actually might not solve a real problem within the realm of finance and that the tools and structures that exist today actually serve a purpose? Who could have seen that coming? /s
- nyolfen 4y agoyou ought to tell that to the millions of people across the developing world who suddenly have a means of resistance to their governments debasing their savings: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/5d/Venezuela_inflation_on_the_black_market_%28DolarToday%29_on_a_logarithmic_scale.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/5d/Venezuel... crypto is many things, but the single most important is demonstrating cryptography as a foundation for robust digital rights. we can guarantee digital rights in a way that require complex and frequently corrupt institutional enforcement in the real world. this is a mind-bending achievement and we're only at the very outset
- epolanski 4y agoThe idea that money (which is made as a mean of transmission between goods) should be hoarded is stupid. No wealthy person in this planet got wealthier by hoarding pieces of paper with pictures of national heroes, but by investing it in gold, art, land, real estate, stock markets and many others. If you and some other people agree that specific hashes on a specific blockchain have some value for you and avoid "debasing your savings" you're free to hoard them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- imtringued 4y agoThe problem isn't necessarily hoarding but rather governments decided to only have one legal tender and sabotaging that legal tender is effectively the same as sabotaging the entire economy. Hoarding is a kind of sabotage but if people hoard something that isn't legal tender they are not threatening the economy. The wealthy might be hoarding Lamborghini's but we can always build more cars. Can't do that with money unless the government or a commercial bank does it.
- nailer 4y ago> You got to love how industry regulations really defeat most of the benefits and points of the decentralization by going in the opposite direction. Are industry regulations preventing self custody? I hope and believe we're talking about regulation being rightly applied to centralised exchanges. So they don't front run customers on token listings (Coinbase), use customer funds when customer's haven't allowed them to (FTX), replace their customer's coins with a different currency (Binance), or whatever else.
- yieldcrv 4y agodidn't read the article its regulation on centralized popup companies and letting onchain activity and constructs operate as they are