9 ms·
Regulating Crypto: How we move forward as an industry from here
- danuker 4y agoI am somewhat surprised they tout self-ownership, which would work against any fractional reserve scheme that exchanges might try with customer funds. > First, self-custodial wallets allow customers to store their own crypto in a way where they don't have to trust anyone else. But the "multi-party computation and social recovery" is exactly "having to trust someone else". > First, self-custodial wallets allow customers to store their own crypto in a way where they don't have to trust anyone else. Technology improvements, like multi-party computation and social recovery, will make it easy for anyone to safely store their own crypto without needing to trust third parties. I wonder if their tune would change once centralized exchanges would become influential again.
- blitzar 4y ago20 Oct 2022 — FTX CEO, SBF Releases Draft That Proposes Crypto Regulation
- Mistletoe 4y agoSBF was the complete opposite of this proposal if my memory serves. He wanted to neuter defi with regulation and push more people to his centralized exchange. Once we’ve seen how the sausage was made at FTX, you can see why haha.
- blitzar 4y ago> Coinbase - "Regulating stablecoin issuers is a good place to start" 12 Oct 2022 - Sam Bankman-Fried: Stablecoins Are ‘Lowest-hanging Fruit’ for Crypto Regulation ... One regulator should have the duty to ensure all stablecoins are backed by dollars, FTX founder says
- nailer 4y agoAs someone who hates SBF I think he was right on requiring proof of capitalization for stablecoins that say they're capitalized. USDT used to say this on their website, then removed it and now they just print money (Hacker News doesn't support emoji but I'd use the person throwing trash into the bin emoji here).
- blitzar 4y agoIf stablecoins are regulated then they are just USD's. They are just an excuse to earn transaction fees and print fake money in exchange for bypassing regulations, always has been - insert Always has been meme.
- nailer 4y agoI can send you a million USDC right now on the most popular blockchain, it’ll arrive in less than a card tap and the transaction fee is USD .00025.
- blitzar 4y agoI can write you a cheque for a billion actual USD for 0 cost.
- nailer 4y agoCool but: - my bank has an upper limit of 1500 GBP so I can't receive the cheque - if I could receive the cheque, the latency on me getting the funds is a few orders of magnitude more than 400ms
- blitzar 4y agoAnd getting 1 mil of USDC to your bank account would take longer and be more problematic!
- epolanski 4y agoYou got to love how industry regulations really defeat most of the benefits and points of the decentralization by going in the opposite direction. The problem in reality would be non existent if people used crypto currencies for what they were meant to be used for: an alternative economy with no need for exchanges and third parties: you sell me a banana, I give you some satoshis. Not saying this is convenient IRL, requiring to sync to a network and chain is expensive and difficult from a phone, but that was the supposed use case. I'm more and more convinced that blockchain industry solves no real world problems at all, except in the crypto sphere itself (like smart contracts do have a use...for crypto exchanges, crypto games and crypto gambling) and that 99% of the people who get involved couldn't care less about crypto use cases, only if they will sell for more $ than they bought for.
- JonathanBeuys 4y agoindustry regulations really defeat most of the benefits and points of the decentralization How so? Bitcoin's use cases seem unaffected: 1: Hold something that is expected to stay scarce and not printed or mined to infinity 2: Make international, fast and cheap payments that are instantly finalized.
- Double_a_92 4y ago1: How do you easily get bigger amounts of crypto, without a centralized exchange? 2: How does the receiving person use the received bitcoins, unless there is a real economy or again a centralized exchange?
- CurrentB 4y agoWho said anything about not having a centralized exchange? Centralized on ramps are not necessarily antithetical to a decentralized system.
- messy 4y agoI’m sorry, but yes they are… the security of the system was supposed to be built in, and it was supposed to have its value built in. Neither are true. It’s not decentralized and at this rate it never will be, and seeing how it turned out so far, it would be a good thing to fail.
- Mistletoe 4y agoThis all seems to make sense to me. I hope it is implemented.
- cactusplant7374 4y agoHow many tokens on Coinbase are securities? The SEC won’t audit them and Coinbase pretends that they have done due diligence. This is the elephant in the room.
- LatteLazy 4y agoWhether a given token is a security or not is independent of whether a given exchange can pass an audit (and audit also does not mean what you think it means though everyone seems to use it that way so I am probably over reacting)...
- cactusplant7374 4y agoAgree. That's my entire point. Coinbase is not in the clear. Not even close.
- beefield 4y agoI would be quite keen to know how a state trust based "stable"coin would work in an environment where treasuries give negative yield. (Only a question of time, even if yields are currently going up)
- roenxi 4y agoThe incentive structure for any large exchange is to make an attempt to capture the regulator. In a free market, exchanges can't make a big profit because they are too easy to replace. In a regulated market, where new entrants are blocked by KYC and AML regulations and a host of red tape, the exchanges can maintain a much higher profit margin. I don't think Coinbases' interests align with the interests of the people using crypto in this article.
- jqpabc123 4y agoSo we have now come full circle. Crypto started out as a naive attempt at money without government. But this was quickly shown to be an open invitation to rampant fraud that is still ongoing and technology alone can not prevent. So now in a last ditch effort at survival, crypto is begging for a government lifeline with oversight and regulation. I said all along that the only thing government needed to do to kill crypto was absolutely nothing --- just give it some space to self implode. This has largely come to pass. Only one final realization remains ---- if regulation is needed, crypto is not. It no longer will have any compelling *legal* reason to exist
- logicchains 4y agoThis is not crypto, it's parasitic centralised exchanges that want a bunch of institutional money in the ecosystem so that they can collect their cut of the fees.
- acdha 4y agoThat is cryptocurrency, even if you find it inconvenient for marketing purposes. You can “no true coin” everything negative but at that point there’s almost nothing left — all of the billions in funding have had surprisingly little real-world impact because once you subtract the scams and the effort spent trying to work around problems created by the design there isn’t much left.
- jrm4 4y agoBut "not much" is completely different from "nothing," and it would be a massive mistake to presume "little real world impact" because you haven't seen it now, or yet, e.g. Black Swans et al.
- acdha 4y agoI said little real world impact because after many years and billions of dollars, the number of people outside of the industry who’d be inconvenienced if it disappeared is very small - perhaps a few people who can save a percentage over Western Union and some people in Venezuela who prefer laundering money that way. Contrast that with things like the web which despite much higher barriers to adoption had been incorporated into normal people’s lives within a couple of years. In less than the time bitcoin has been around, we went from the pre-iPod era to one where most people were connected everywhere and the way people worked, played, traveled, dated, etc. had changed notably.
- ramoz 4y ago“Trust the laws of math” Can someone explain to me how code that processes my private information, in some “Bob’s 40K Basement Mining” node is protected and secured? Whether it be a smart contract or these new “use GPU VMs at fraction of cloud costs- through this token market” “Because Bob risks a large stake if reputation is tampered” doesn’t cut it. What’s the tech here, genuinely.
- CurrentB 4y agoThe only info miners/validators have is public info anyway. Their job is just to constantly decide which public ledger is the "real" one.
- csomar 4y agoThe miners don't decide the chain. The users do. You can fork off to a lower hash rate chain if you want to.
- CurrentB 4y agoWe haven't specified which exact blockchain we're talking about but in basically all cases you're wrong. Users just send their transactions to a p2p network. It's miners that pick those up and put transactions into a block and decide which block is the parent to the one they built.
- miracle2k 4y agoSocial consensus > blockchain consensus. Its the job of miners/validators to pick the head of the chain. But users have the ability to send transactions to whatever p2p network they want to send it to, even if it's a fork proposed by CurrentB on Hackernews.
- csomar 4y agoI'm sorry that you don't know how either the Bitcoin or Ethereum blockchains work but still have strong opinions about it. To re-iterate, it's the users (with Full-Node) that decide which chain to follow. That is essentially what a hard-fork is (a portion of these users moving to a different chain) and it requires no special mining capabilities. Miners follow the users, not the other way around. However, in reality, users are also led by network effects. Users can always cancel any chain the miners have decided to support if they collectively decide to do so.
- LatteLazy 4y agoI think these proposals are mostly good and practical. I see two issues though: * first, we've seen resistance from BOTH sides to sensible proposals in the past. Some because they thing Crypto should be totally unregulated (purists) and others because they want crypto shut down completely and any reasonable (even enabling) regulation makes that less likely * second, there are still some core issues here. For instance, a major up side of crypto is the ability to evade regulation like sanctions. On a case by case basis this is sometimes good (helping Venezuelans access desperately needed international help) or bad (helping corruption or ransomware). This line: >Establish a blacklist capability to meet sanctions requirements hides within it a very large technical and social problem depending on exactly how it is implemented. And should that be different between stable coins (where the requirement is listed) and other coins?
- throw_me_5555 4y agoSo outside drug trade and crypto lockers what constitutes the crypto industry? The only constant I know are pump&dumps, be it in form of alt-coins, ICO or NFT.
- intotheabyss 4y agoHow about the recent news from Visa where they would like to develop a smart contract wallet infrastructure (no seed phrases and account abstraction) on a layer 2 which uses zero knowledge proofs to batch transactions offchain for scalability? https://usa.visa.com/solutions/crypto/auto-payments-for-self-custodial-wallets.html https://usa.visa.com/solutions/crypto/auto-payments-for-self... Oh right, this doesn't follow the narrative that crypto is useless for everything.
- striking 4y ago> As part of Visa’s internal Crypto Hackathon challenge earlier this year, we took on the opportunity to explore the above scenario using a novel technique. They say in their conclusion that they're interested in this. I don't see any talk of commitment.
- yao420 4y agoWhere are you getting that they would like to develop or even explore this further? From the link, this was taken from an internal hackathon earlier in the year before the further crypto meltdown. they didn’t even write a proof of concept. Call me when they actually trapease or do something.
- robby_w_g 4y ago> Oh right, this doesn't follow the narrative that crypto is useless for everything. As someone with casual knowledge of crypto, that jargon in the first paragraph sounds useless to me
- __derek__ 4y agoThat describes an approach to solve a problem with using crypto for payments. The problem (bill pay) is already solved in the real world.
- schizo89 4y agowhy would anarchists even use centralized exchanges and provide their identities. i'd say these central crypto bros go serve coffee to your boss on walk street
- xnx 4y agoI often find myself wishing that half of all financial regulations were replaced by an aggressive consumer education/consumer reports type agency.
- throwaway0x7E6 4y agoyou die, hopefully. crypto will live on. but the "industry" of money people parasitising on it will inevitably die. and that's a good thing
- snake_doc 4y ago“2. Enforce a level playing field Getting regulatory clarity would be a good first step, but if we don't enforce these rules evenly, both domestically and abroad, we will not have a path forward.” How ironic, so a crypto exchange wishes the U.S. government, an immensely powerful centralized entity crypto was designed to omit, makes everyone else play nice on the global stage. How would the US do that? Hmm… guessing regulating flow of dollars. Ha!
- DebtDeflation 4y agoClassifying crypto as a "commodity" rather than a currency or a security was the fundamental mistake. Correct that mistake and really no further regulation is required. If you want to take deposits and make loans, you must be licensed as a bank. If you want to execute trades and make markets for securities, you must be licensed as a broker-dealer. If you want to manage funds for customers, you must be licensed as an investment company. Existing banking and securities regulations cover all of this.
- RobotToaster 4y agoYou know what this currency that was designed to be unregulated and decentralised needs? Regulations and centralisation!
- vageli 4y agoAn established player looking to cement its position through regulation? Color me surprised. Less cynically, though, crypto could stand to benefit from more regulatory clarity. Though it's interesting that coinbase considers stablecoins "other" when I believe coinbase itself offers interest on its stablecoin. It remains to be seen if interest-bearing stable tokens are securities.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- stjohnswarts 4y agoI say don't regulate it and let it eat itself.
- thelastgallon 4y agoChina's crypto regulation history: https://www.coindesk.com/learn/china-crypto-bans-a-complete-history/ https://www.coindesk.com/learn/china-crypto-bans-a-complete-...
- mekster 4y agoDo I see the observation that quality of HN comments on crypto has increased as the price stays low and all those people with "fear of missed out" are no longer aggressively posting?
- jakupovic 4y agoYou are correct. This place needs to fill the coffers of even the ones who missed out a few times. Then we will think it's more than a scam.
- survirtual 4y agoWhen it comes to crypto, no one is thinking big enough, with the exception of maybe Satoshi Nakamoto. Bitcoin is much bigger than people realize. I have a better idea on “how we move forward as an industry.” Money is just a piece of the social contract generalizing specific work into tokens of value. It allows a specialized worker to transact with another specialized worker such that we all have our needs met. It is a mechanism of decentralized organization enabling deep specialization absent needed to trust of even know someone else. You can see the production of someone, and transfer value to them without them needing to trust them personally. You could say finance is the backbone of modern technological society. It is implicitly pseudo-democratic, in that where it flows, resource allocation power is afforded, which results in production of resources based upon the usage of whoever wields resource allocation. If you analyze systems from this lens, look at the production of money itself. What work is being distilled into generalized value with money systems? What is the minting processes relationship with governance and democratic institutions? There is a theme here. Money is directly coupled with governance. That coupling comes in the form of resource allocation, and it comes with an assumption of government control — where government is entrusted with the interests of public good. Hence, taxation comes into play, and a treasury, and tax collectors, and penalties, and policing, and military — the full faith and confidence of the people. With something so tightly coupled to democracy, would a free and democratic people not want their money system to also be free, open, and democratic? Yet before the invention of Bitcoin, it has been anything but that — and if you can’t see that, you have some reading to do. Long story short: bitcoin is part of a bigger picture. It is the backbone of government. Of a new form of government. Of a government bound in the laws of physics, codified as subservient to the governed. Of a government true to the cause of freedom. Of a government mathematically and verifiably auditable, in which no man can corrupt the fundamental rules of governing, in which every human has a voice, in which the evils of the world have no recourse nor cracks to hide in. Imagine that for a moment. What that means for all of us. Imagine taxation as an automated component of crypto, for instance. No more taxation by force, no more complex paperwork, no more statistical enforcement, all of that process and ruling by fear — ALL of it — gone. There are countless additional ripples here, but I will leave you with some food for thought on the possibility and dire necessity of this: - houses are no longer affordable to most people who do not own one. This means that family and community is no longer possible for most people. Many of you here enjoy this. What would you so if you lost your house and had to care for your family in a cramped, crime-laden apartment? - food is increasingly not affordable. What happens when people can no longer eat? How stable is that? - medical care is not affordable for anyone, without perpetual servitude, and often times the insurance is a joke coming with it - transport is out of reach for most people. This means you have no mobility to change your physical circumstances - police are out of control. Their union is too powerful and their primary interest is securing property rights. - tax payer funds are stuck in a transfer of wealth from the poor and middle class to the mega rich. Look at the military industrial complex, the medical complex, and all the other complexes across industries. - the politicians are bought and paid for. You think any of those people have power? How effective have any of their policies been on solving these basic and ancient problems? - the climate is killing life as we know it on this planet, and while society is increasingly aware of this and want it to be fixed, policy makers and corporations are barely changing. Who really controls everything if not the people? I could go on all day, but the summation is: the current system is tyrannous and oppressive to most. It is faceless and has no central target to blame. The people are left in darkness, condemned to having no present, no future, reduced to a fragment of themselves, consumed in servitude of a faceless shadow. We have a resource allocation problem. A big one. Bitcoin was stage one of the cure to this problem. It has done something most people thought was impossible before it: it made the minting process accessible to anyone, and liberated the opaque financial system into the hands of the people, turning a shadow system into a beacon of light. It gave humanity its collective spine. What comes next? It is inevitable what comes next. And it is unstoppable. Our current society is having trouble feeding its people, housing its people, healing its people — these are the most basic upon basic needs, in a world of automation and light speed communications, we can barely manage even the basics. It isn’t just sad, it isn’t just pathetic — it is negligent, it is malicious, and it is not necessary. When government in the information age, an age of mastery of atoms, of space, of light, of matter, how is it possible society CANNOT HOUSE AND FEED THEIR PEOPLE. It makes my blood boil. But I keep it in. I keep it calm. I imagine the suffering of billions and feel their pain. It is paralyzing. But cool heads prevail. We all must carry on and not let the flames of rage consume us. If you don’t see or understand the connection to bitcoin, I just don’t know what to tell you. Maybe, in your relative luxury, you don’t see the reality of the suffering your fellow man is enduring. And so maybe, you haven’t had cause to investigate the root causes. If you did, you would inevitably be lead to the mode of thinking I carry. I don’t want to spoil the next steps, you all know it already, you feel it in your hearts, but here’s a raging clue for you to chew on: > WHEN in the Course of human Events, it becomes necessary for one People to dissolve the Political Bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the Powers of the Earth, the separate and equal Station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God entitle them, a decent Respect to the Opinions of Mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the Separation. > We hold these Truths to be self-evident, that all Men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness—-That to secure these Rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just Powers from the Consent of the Governed, that whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these Ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its Foundation on such Principles, and organizing its Powers in such Form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness. Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient Causes; and accordingly all Experience hath shewn, that Mankind are more disposed to suffer, while Evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the Forms to which they are accustomed. But when a long Train of Abuses and Usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object, evinces a Design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their Right, it is their Duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future Security.