3 ms·
So unprofessional for a security company to be hosting their code on GitHub and connecting with lots of silly integrations, access tokens, etc. Okta has not le
by rvz 4y ago
So unprofessional for a security company to be hosting their code on GitHub and connecting with lots of silly integrations, access tokens, etc.
Okta has not learned their lesson with security with this hack, especially when they got themselves breached before in January.
- terom 4y agoHow so? It refutes that right there in the advisory: > Okta does not rely on the confidentiality of its source code as a means to secure its services. Would it be more professional for them to host their code in a public repo?
- robertlagrant 4y agoIt might be, yes. With the right protections on pull requests.
- bennyelv 4y agoDid they decide that that was their strategy before or after this breach occurred? They were trying to keep their source code secure, and they failed. Not a great look for a company that ask you to trust them with all of your user accounts.
- grishka 4y agoYes? What do they have to gain from the code not being public?
- madcadmium 4y agoCompetitive advantage?
- papito 4y agoThat's not a bad point. GitHub is convenient, yes, but if you manage security for companies that are collectively worth billions, you want to minimize your attack surface. In my experience, security is usually an afterthought in most tech companies. Just look at how many MongoDB instances in production were running on open ports with the default password, which was... no password.
- throwawaysleep 4y agoAt my jobs, employees routinely share passwords in Slack or use simple passwords. Frankly, as an employee, security is not my problem.
- lukev 4y agoSolving security issues and maintaining secure systems isn't your problem, but adhering to company policy most certainly is, and the policy almost certainly forbids you from sharing passwords (especially via Slack.) Unless you're in a tiny or ass-backward company that doesn't even have a policy that covers such things.
- throwawaysleep 4y agoThey have a policy, but there is nobody who cares to enforce it.
- yakubin 4y agoIt always amazes me how many companies host their source code in “the cloud” visible to external companies, accessible from the public internet, only a single bug/security vulnerability/human error away from being leaked. The companies I’ve worked for so far host their source code on their own servers, which are physically under their control, and aren’t accessible from the public internet. Add on top of it that functionally GitHub/GitLab don’t hold a candle to code review functionality of Gerrit, project management of Redmine/Jira; and the only explanation is that those companies really, really don’t want to hire 1/2 sysadmins to manage their infrastructure.
- ralph84 4y agoCompanies host data a lot more valuable than source code in the cloud. Developers like to think we’re the center of the business, but access to a company’s Salesforce or NetSuite instance is a lot more economically valuable than access to a company’s GitHub org.