8 ms·
An old friend has a niece with a life-long, major mental illness. When off her medications (I've lost count of how many times, over the years), she goes "on th
by bell-cot 4y ago
An old friend has a niece with a life-long, major mental illness. When off her medications (I've lost count of how many times, over the years), she goes "on the run", and phones home to various family members (often many times per day) with angry rants - which very often include threats of great bodily harm and/or death. Her grip on reality in that state is rather poor - asserting that Bugs Bunny and the CIA are conspiring to create a brain controlled army of polar bears with space lasers would not be unusual.
When on her medications, she is a relatively pleasant & rational person, usually able to hold an entry-level job.
Her family do not want to throw her in jail for all the threats (I'm not asserting that they could, if they wanted to), she really does not like the side effects of her medications, and (under the current system) neither confining her to a long-term mental health facility, nor reliably forcing her to take her medications seem to be available options. (Her family has talked to lawyers about their options more than once.)
What would be the "humane" thing to do? In composing your answer, please recall that her family are also humans, and - barring a premature death - she is likely to outlive most of them.
Edit: Thank you for all the replies, but my 4th-paragraph question was intended to be rhetorical. My point is that the case-by-case reality, even from the PoV of a well-to-do family that really seems to care about the mentally ill person, is often agonizingly difficult.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- brodouevencode 4y agoIt's certainly tough for sure. I think the ultimate question is what is considered "humane". Locked up in a straight jacket in a padded room for having slightly depressive thoughts is certainly not, but also allowing someone like in your story to spiral out of control and act out their trauma is arguably equally as inhumane. I wish I had a good answer for you.
- jimbob45 4y agoAssuming her threats and behavior would eventually result in her being tossed in jail, the choice seems to be between her imprisonment and her being forcibly medicated. I don't have an answer for you. I think you've come up with a potential plot for a very interesting Star Trek episode though.
- bell-cot 4y agoHer family's guess is that she'll be killed in some violent altercation while "on the run". Probably one for which she bears most of the "responsibility". And they pray that she won't get any innocents maimed or killed before that happens. (Star Trek: My guess is that such an episode, if it had any serious depth, would be vetoed in the script stage - due to being an extremely painful subject for too many viewers.)
- mjevans 4y agoStar Trek and the like also have utopia levels of medical tech. Physical level problems are all solvable with their level of technology. In Scifi: Real bad people exist. Real people who need help exist. Real people who just need some time to talk out their problems with the ship's / a local counselor exist. Real people who can't be helped don't exist, they reductively condense into one of the three classes above because society and tech are advanced enough. (Except in cases of extreme breakdowns; E.G. Voyager wasn't the only ship mostly sucked to the delta quadrant.)
- anotherman554 4y ago"Star Trek and the like also have utopia levels of medical tech. Physical level problems are all solvable with their level of technology." The poorly written second season of Star Trek Picard had a character who was suicidal and refused treatment, then killed herself. I think people refuse treatment in real life because the drugs don't work too well, not because they don't want to feel better, and at any rate you can't have a utopias if people choose to due horrible things to themselves or each other, you just have real life, so I think it went against the tradition of Star Trek being utopian fiction.
- stonogo 4y agoEthical dilemmas persist: Voyager's "Lon Suder" character had violent tendencies which he struggled to control. The Next Generation episode "The Outcast" replaced dangerous, violent tendencies with romantic love; the character in question was forced to undergo treatment and then afterward was grateful for them, which raises questions whether informed consent is even possible under those circumstances. Star Trek alone had countless plot lines surrounding incurable medical conditions. Worf broke his spine, Picard has some kind of syndrome which will cause cognitive decline, La Forge had to settle for a visor for most of the franchise, and so forth. Even under utopean circumstances, ethical considerations abound, as in "The Schizoid Man," an exploration of both rights for artificial life and transhumanism. Sisko's father ignored medical advice because he chose to, and in VOY's "Scientific Method" we find aliens desperate to develop lifesaving technology, even at the cost of agency for Federation staff.
- pcurve 4y agoWhat a dilemma. Is she aware of how she acts when she's off medication? Has she seen herself act this way on video?
- runnerup 4y agoThat won’t help. There’s hundreds of thousands (nearing or exceeding a million) people like this in the USA alone. If that worked, it would be widely practiced. These mental illnesses break the ability of an individual to choose to do what’s best in terms of medication, treatment, and lifestyle. The illness makes one not want to be properly medicated. Someone can be consistent with their treatment and lifestyle for many months, but it just takes one trigger and a couple days off medications to lose all progress.
- kdmccormick 4y ago> That won’t help. While I agree with the rest of your comment, I want to gently challenge this specific statement, as someone who has to take a powerful med (lithium) to avoid relapsing into mania with psychosis. I was so extremely reluctant to regularly take meds, and lapsed in and out of mania for a few years. The main thing that got me to stick with lithium, and a major driver in me staying on them today, is grokking how deeply destructive mania is to all the relationships and other good things in my life. I'm not saying we should shame mentally ill people, but part of treatment should be helping them understand & agree that permanent treatment is in their own best interest. Easier said than done, of course... it took years for me.
- abracadaniel 4y agoThank you for sharing these insights. The whole problem space feels so intractable, and all options seemingly inhumane in their own ways, so it’s very helpful to hear from someone whose had success working though it.
- guerrilla 4y ago> The illness makes one not want to be properly medicated. The medications do that too. The side-effects are horrific.
- tensor 4y agoI have a high school friend who is the same way. It's beyond traumatizing for his friends and family. Many of them live in fear. Same story, neither confining him nor forcibly medicating him are options, so he roams around, unable to hold jobs, randomly threatening various people. I worry that one day he'll end up being shot by police or something. It's awful.
- kayodelycaon 4y agoI don't have any answers here, but I want to provide some context for the drugs in question. I'm on antipsychotics. They are nasty drugs. Absolutely brutal. The worst of the side-effects for me are the sexual side-effects and motor-control issues. If I get dehydrated or my blood sugar gets low, I can lose the ability to walk. Within the first hour of taking my meds, I can't stand without losing my balance. I lose both my inner ear and kinesthetic senses. I don't know where my feet or hands are. I can only walk by having my eyes open to see if I'm level and feeling where the pressure is on my feet. During the day, I have medication that helps this but I still trip on uneven surfaces or drop things. The sexual side effects, I can't orgasm. Combined with the hypersexuality a manic episode creates, it is unbearable. Fortunately, I'm on yet another drug that makes this less of an issue. The only reason I can tolerate this is the alternative of going crazy is so terrifying, I'll do anything to prevent that from happening. If anyone wonders why people don't stay on their meds... this is a big reason.
- sieabahlpark 4y ago
- asveikau 4y agoMy brother was on antipsychotics for about 20 years. His compliance was poor. He is homeless now and without treatment. Growing up he would tell me how terrible the medications were. I believed him, and still do to an extent. However he also identified with his illness and thought the drugs were taking away his special powers. That was a symptom. For those reading who have less experience, they sometimes call that anosognosia or lack of awareness. In the end it's a very existential thing. It's easy to wonder about identity. I had a few people in my life with this sort of illness. I developed a model where medicated, treated, and stable, that is the "normal" them, their identity. However, these people got offended by this, and engaged in behavior I would describe as identifying with symptoms. Acknowledging symptoms, no matter how evident, was tantamount to personal attacks. I think we all have issues with this in our lives. Self awareness and identity is a difficult problem. It's only when it falls far outside of norms, into extremes, that we call it a disorder. It can be very tricky to draw those lines.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 23B1 4y agoI think what's really important about your comment is that there might not be an answer to some problems. This is something that most people struggle with – and certainly publications (even the respectable Economist) love these sorts of conundrums because they pluck at the tragedy-strings of most humans. Sometimes there simply is no solution to a problem, a very hard concept to grapple with as participants in a community, society, or civilization.
- pyuser583 4y agoThe side effects of medications can be horrific. I’d rather be dead than deal with extreme nausea. However … eventually she’s going to make contact with the criminal justice system. This can very productive. Authorities can make plea deals/pre-prosecution agreements that require medical compliance. I’d advise the family to move to a jurisdiction with lots of resources. A wealthy suburb should work. Then wait for her to commit a crime and make report it. I too have a relative who has psychotic episodes. I’ve had wonderful experiences with the criminal justice system (in rich suburbs).
- sheusndudn 4y ago
- toast0 4y ago> However … eventually she’s going to make contact with the criminal justice system. This can very productive. Authorities can make plea deals/pre-prosecution agreements that require medical compliance. Depends on the law enforcement. My aunt would ocassionally get arrested, but they'd never charge her with anything, just bring her to the hospital for an involuntary psych hold, and she'd find her way back home after that. I don't think they ever found meds that worked for her and that she'd take consistently for more than a couple weeks. (This was in San Pedro, CA, which doesn't fit your suggestion of a wealthy suburb)
- squirrel 4y agoRead books on schizophrenia by Dr Xavier Amador for an interesting perspective on gaining compliance without necessarily agreeing on what the problem is. Excellent videos on YouTube also.
- Dma54rhs 4y agoI've been forced to be on antipsychotics. They are nasty and I compare it to sexual conversion therapy. I totally understand the society is not ready for that discussion but it does irk me the supposedly compassionate people are quick to mentally sterilize you.
- sshine 4y agoIt’s a controversial topic that the side effects are so bad that some choose to go psychotic instead. But it doesn’t change the picture that all the stories on this page tells you how much each side sucks and how much the other side sucks more.
- Melatonic 4y agoI am hoping these kinds of things are the perfect candidate for future biotech implants. Having to take ap ill everyday can be difficult to regularly remember even for the totally sane. What if we had some type of implant that could somehow recognize when someone was going through a major mental episode and then dispense some medication to help them? Or even one that simply regularly released the medication throughout the day and then periodically had to be refilled? Seems like the side effects of a lot of these harsh meds might be tempered by a slow release vs all at once with a pill. I am not a medical professional though so I could be completely wrong here.
- TylerE 4y agoI dunno why docs don’t hand out pill organizers like candy. Make life so much easier. Only have to open the pill bottles once a week, and I easily tell if I’ve taken a dose or not. One I bought on Amazon was maybe $6 or something?
- zaknil 4y ago> When off her medications Sure. The problem is that most (probably all) of these drugs give severe withdrawal symptoms when abruptly discontinued by a patient. You'd have to spend a lot of time to slowly wean her off all(!) drugs to know if they're helping or harming. Nobody does that.
- mjthrowaway1 4y agoThis is my reality as well with a family member. The only real option is to move to a state that has more effective mental health laws. The self-destruction that takes place during episodes isn’t fun for the niece either. Similar to my situation the government doesn’t make conservatorship easy to obtain. The practical solutions (10 day forced stays with up to 180 days involuntary) are nowhere to be found. Instead the govt thinks the best option is for the person to go bankrupt, burn all social relationships, and put themselves on the streets for a few months every other year.