3 ms·
You're right: it's the policy that's bad. However, facial recognition is what makes enforcing that policy possible, and society and the law haven't changed quic
by kstrauser 4y ago
You're right: it's the policy that's bad. However, facial recognition is what makes enforcing that policy possible, and society and the law haven't changed quickly enough to deal with the repercussions.
For instance, say 18 year old "Joe" gets caught stealing soda from a fast food place. The manager kicks him out and bans him from the store. Fast forward a decade, when Joe walks back into the store with his wife and kid to buy a quick meal.
Without facial recognition: Joe's grown up and matured. The manager was either replaced years ago, or doesn't remember the incident, or vaguely remembers but doesn't care about it anymore. Joe and his family pay, eat, and leave.
With facial recognition: the system notices that someone on its "do not allow" list has entered the store and summons police to deal with the trespasser.
When human judgment is involved, we rarely deal with absolutes. A lifetime ban isn't really for life. It's until both parties grow up and the situation cools down. A ban on a competitor's employees isn't absolute. Maybe you won't serve the owner, but if his dishwasher comes to your place on a date, you're not gonna hassle the kid. We're really, really bad at designing automated systems that handle nuance. It's way easier to write code like `if photo_hash in banned_people: ...`.
- bmitc 4y agoWhy is the policy bad? They are preventing employees from a law firm in active litigation with them from attending their venues while the litigation takes place. It's not some draconian thing.
- monsieurbanana 4y agoI'm certain you didn't read the article. The link between the woman and the litige case is very tenuous. She doesn't work on the case, and the venue has nothing to do with the case either, besides that a huge corporation owns both the venue and the restaurant under litigation.
- bmitc 4y agoI did read it. MSG notified the law firm of their policy while the litigation is ongoing, twice. > "MSG instituted a straightforward policy that precludes attorneys pursuing active litigation against the Company from attending events at our venues until that litigation has been resolved. While we understand this policy is disappointing to some, we cannot ignore the fact that litigation creates an inherently adverse environment. All impacted attorneys were notified of the policy, including Davis, Saperstein and Salomon, which was notified twice," a spokesperson for MSG Entertainment said in a statement.
- monsieurbanana 4y agoThat does sound pretty draconian to me, you haven't adressed my point.
- bmitc 4y agoWhat is your point?
- techwizrd 4y agoAlso from the article: (a) Conlon does not practice law in New York where Radio City Music Hall is located. (b) Conlon is not an attorney pursuing active litigation against the MSG Entertainment. She works for a NJ-based law firm who representing another party in litigation against an unrelated restaurant which now happens to now be owned by MSG Entertainment. She's not part of that ongoing litigation. (c) > A recent judge's order in one of those cases made it clear that ticketholders like her "may not be denied entry to any shows." (d) > "The liquor license that MSG got requires them to admit members of the public, unless there are people who would be disruptive who constitute a security threat," said Davis. "Taking a mother, separating a mother from her daughter and Girl Scouts she was watching over — and to do it under the pretext of protecting any disclosure of litigation information — is absolutely absurd. Refusing her entry doesn't even make sense according to their stated policy, and it is absolutely _draconian_. She doesn't work on the case—she just happens to work for the same company. If this firm was representing a client suing Meta or Google or Apple, would it be okay for Meta/Google/Apple to ban all attorneys from using all of their services? This type of behavior just discourages firms from taking on clients suing large companies.
- bmitc 4y agoThe law firm was notified ahead of time, twice. Lawyers expect others to abide by such notifications, do they not? They act like this was a crime against humanity, when they were told ahead of time that they were not allowed in their venues during the ongoing litigation. Does the law firm have 100,000 employees? According to their website, they have about 29 attorneys in the firm. Bringing up companies the size of cities compared to that is completely ridiculous and irrelevant. And companies like Meta, Google, Apple, etc. will absolutely enact draconian policies when IP and other litigations are going on. The secrecy and policies those companies put in place likely go well beyond simply not letting a lawyer part of a law firm that is suing one of your businesses into your building. Why does it matter where she's licensed? It's irrelevant. Lawyers play these little games all the time. I'm not necessarily for the policy or the use of facial recognition to enact it, but they were told ahead of time. They should know better. If they wanted to argue the points ahead of time and get approval, they could and should have.
- romwell 4y agoThe policy is bad because it results in unfair outcomes.
- bmitc 4y agoWhen are lawyers considered with fairness? I'm not sure I see what's unfair here. They were notified. If they wanted to negotiate around it, they could have done ahead of time. They're lawyers. They should know to read material they're sent.
- bavila 4y ago> When are lawyers considered with fairness? As any good lawyer would say, "It depends."
- brookst 4y agoAll policies are bad, then? Can you think of any policy anywhere that never results in unfair outcomes?
- azernik 4y agoRetaliating against a law firm's employees for doing their jobs by representing their clients is absolutely draconian. Especially for a large company doing this with unrelated properties.
- bmitc 4y agoIs it retaliation, or is it protection?
- defrost 4y agoRetaliation and intimidation. If it were protection .. to prevent a lawyer from witnessing something at a public venue that might be used as evidence agains them ... then there is no protection possible. A sensible law firm would not use one of their employees with a public image available, they'd use a contracted private investigator to gather evidence. This smacks of punitive behaviour to not only punish the law firm (for doing their job) in a petty manner, but to also intimidate any other law firm thinking of taking them on. Eg: Hypothetically if Disney were to ban all members of any company that challenged Disney on ride safety .. how would that appear?
- azernik 4y agoProtection from what? The lawsuit has nothing to do with the MSG venue, but rather with a restaurant somewhere else that MSG owns; and this lawyer isn't working on that case anyway.
- bmitc 4y agoWhat is an easier policy to enact? A subset of people that they can’t exactly determine for a subset of their venues, or a blanket policy covering all employees of the small firm at all their venues?
- azernik 4y agoMaking the ban be for fewer venues would be way easier. Or just, like, not doing this at all. This is James Dolan, the owner of Madison Square Garden, being petty as usual and banning people from the venue who annoy him. e.g. Spike Lee for saying bad things about him, Woody Allen for the wrong reasons (he refused film ads for Dolan), &c I am under no obligation to contort myself to assume good faith on his part in the face of a pattern of behavior that indicates otherwise.
- kergonath 4y agoBecause employees are not their employers, and have a life outside of work in which they still do stuff? Seriously. Yes, it is draconian. Besides, if the law firm really wanted someone in there for hand-wavy reasons, why would they not just hire someone for it? Blacklisting is petty, counter-productive, trivial to abuse, and solves nothing.
- bmitc 4y agoSo what? There are a lot of laws and policies based upon where you work that restrict you in your personal life. The lawyers can get over it. This is a non-issue, and I suspect the law firm did all this on purpose to drum up another lawsuit against MSG.
- rg111 4y agoIt's always the policy that should be modified, and not the tech that should be stopped. Because bad policies can do only damage. And tech can do both good and bad.
- kstrauser 4y agoI’d amend that: it’s always the policy that should be modified in the longer run. Sometimes it’s wholly appropriate to pump the brakes on the tech that would allow mass application of the bad policy.
- int_19h 4y agoIt rarely if ever actually works out for the simple reason that, if one jurisdiction pumps the brakes, there's a dozen others willing to floor the other pedal on the same thing.
- underwater 4y agoScale is also an issue. So many things are either owned by a megacorp or run via a centralised platform. Getting banned by a store pales in comparison to being banned by Uber, Google, Visa, etc.
- LarryMullins 4y agoJust as most websites today use captchas run by one or two companies, we may see a scenario unfold where most brick and mortar businesses use a facial recognition blacklisting system run by one or two companies. Get labelled as trouble by the system and you'll be banned by every store in town.
- kstrauser 4y agoThat’s a great point. For that matter, imagine that being maintained by Verisign or the like. Get a ding on your social credit report, and voila, you can’t walk into a grocery store anymore.
- kstrauser 4y ago:facepalm: I mean Experian. It’s too late to edit it now, but if a future person reads this, I was thinking of credit bureaus managing these lists.
- thwarted 4y agoThis was already a problem with the email spam blacklists, DNSBL.
- mrguyorama 4y agoThis is not allowed in my state thank god
- phpisthebest 4y agoSee Las Vegas Casio's who have been doing that for awhile
- monksy 4y agoThis is happening already with PatronScan which is being pushed agressively into schools, and bars: https://scribe.nixnet.services/id-at-the-door-meet-the-security-company-building-an-international-database-of-banned-bar-patrons-7c6d4b236fc3 https://scribe.nixnet.services/id-at-the-door-meet-the-secur... There have been references to the ban lists going from one venue to another.
- Nifty3929 4y agoCan you imagine getting into an argument with a bartender and being asked to leave - and then you can't go into any other bars either? Yikes! Reminds me of the hidden low-level-banking-employee blacklist that some would end up on for not forcing enough customers into expensive products they didn't need. Or the opiate painkiller registry that doctors use to centrally track folks who come to them for painkillers, and which by the way counts any painkillers you might have gotten from the vet for your dog. Fewer central registries please!
- lmm 4y agoBlacklisting is something we already recognise as wrong; banning who you want from your own establishment is fine, but passing around a list of people and banning them on someone else's say-so isn't. Perhaps the laws against it should be enforced, or strengthened.
- Nifty3929 4y agoI don't know of any laws against this at all, at least in the United States.
- bigwavedave 4y agoThe parent may be referring to employment laws; google claims 29 states have made blacklisting illegal in an employment context.
- 4y ago
- Gigachad 4y agoI see it as things returning to how they were. In a small town, the person running the fast food joint often did work there for decades and everyone recognized everyone. Theft was hard to get away with because you don't just blend in to the masses like a modern city. Now tech is allowing us to hold people accountable again.
- kstrauser 4y agoI think that’s a romanticized memory. While holding people accountable is good, so is eventual forgiveness. If you steal a candy bar from Old Man Smith at the town’s only gas station, and he’s the kind to hold grudges, you’re boned. Never mind teens trying to buy condoms when every cashier in town knows them. There’s a happy medium in there somewhere. You don’t want to let repeat offenders off scot free, but there needs to be a cooling off period, too.
- acomjean 4y agoWhat’s weird to me is MSG had to get pictures of all this law firms attorney’s and enter them into their facial recognition database. It seems wasteful and really petty. They probably pulled from they law firms website. Another reason to keep wearing masks…
- dredmorbius 4y agoRealID and drivers license databases are increasingly available to very-tenuously-based "security" measures.
- KronisLV 4y ago> A lifetime ban isn't really for life. It's until both parties grow up and the situation cools down. This is especially worrying when no humans are involved. If your Google account gets banned by some automated bot for whatever reason, you might find any attempts to create new accounts be considered "ban evasion". Regardless of the fact that you have very few options for things like ad networks or publishing Android applications, even before you consider losing access to your e-mails or any servers you might have.