5 ms·
Another Fermi Paradox thread. Take a shot any time von Neumann probes are mentioned. Regarding the paper (or at least its abstract) it's worth mentioning that
by krapp 4y ago
Another Fermi Paradox thread.
Take a shot any time von Neumann probes are mentioned.
Regarding the paper (or at least its abstract) it's worth mentioning that our own radio transmissions have become significantly less likely to be detected after our transition to digital, and that electromagnetic signals dissipate, so they might no longer be recognizable as intelligent signals beyond a certain distance. That would seem to restrict the "Contact Era" window from "a few hundred to a few thousand" years to a century or less. One would expect that advanced civilizations became essentially radio silent to us long before we were even capable of detecting their transmissions in theory.
- MontyCarloHall 4y agoI post this on every Fermi paradox thread. Non-directional radio transmissions (e.g. TV, broadcast radio) would not be distinguishable from cosmic background radiation at more than a light year or two away [0]. Highly directional radio emissions (e.g. Arecibo message) an order of magnitude more powerful than the strongest transmitters on Earth would only be visible at approximately 100 light years away [1], and would only be perceptible if the detector were perfectly aligned with the transmission at the exact time it arrived. Space is really big, and radio emissions are comparatively really weak. [0] https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/245562 https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/245562 [1] https://arxiv.org/pdf/astro-ph/0610377.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/astro-ph/0610377.pdf
- Mistletoe 4y agoI feel the same way. How do the SETI people explain this away and justify their search? One light year is tiny, I think it would take an incredibly generous Drake equation estimate to make that contain intelligent life. Same for 100 light years too. But I lean towards pessimistic Drake equation values. Life is even more rare and precious the more I dig into the equation. > The true stellar density near the Sun is estimated as 0.004 stars per cubic light year, or 0.14 stars pc−3. > There are around 60,000 stars within 100 light-years, and the same again with 100-200 light-years, and then the numbers fall quickly. By the time we're 1,000 light-years out, there are fewer than 8,000 stars and, at 1,300 light-years, fewer than 5,000 stars.
- throw1234651234 4y agoThere are other techno-signatures to look for: Dyson swarms (marked by irregular dimming). Infinitely more powerful transmitters - i.e. irregular pulsars. Oumuamua type fly-bys. "Unnatural" gasses in atmospheres. All purely theoretical, of course. As far as we know, we might not even notice life on Alpha Centauri planets 4ly away.
- m4rtink 4y agoI think a big Orion drive powered spaceship flight profile would be widely noticeable. Like, nature rarely produces hundreds of sequential nuclear detonations in deep space in quick succession, possibly perfectly matching high energy transfer orbits. Just not sure what would the other party thing about builders of such craft. On the other hand, its clear what would they think about anyone running a Nuclear Salt Water Rocket - eq. riding continuous fission detonation for minutes or hours! They would definitely think they are batshit insane! :D
- pharke 4y agoI would have to assume that they know this and are in fact only looking for messages that are purposefully sent at very high power. It's also why they favor listening at the hydrogen line since transmissions at that frequency stand the best chance of penetrating through cosmic dust, i.e. you would only use that frequency if you were intentionally trying to transmit across interstellar distances. I think they don't popularize the downsides of a radio search since it could threaten their already tenuous funding. Basically, they have to be optimistic in order to maintain the pittance of a budget given to them which allows us an extremely small chance at detecting a purposefully sent signal if we happen to be in the right place at the right time and listening on the right frequency pointed in the right direction, etc. In order to do SETI right we really need radio telescopes in solar orbit far away from the Earth and enough of them so that they can cover all of the nearby stars or other likely directions for signals to originate from. The only way we're going to get there is if space launches continue to become a lot cheaper. Fingers crossed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_line https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_line
- maerF0x0 4y ago> Non-directional radio transmissions (e.g. TV, radio) would not be distinguishable from cosmic background radiation at more than a light year or two away this is going to come across as sarcastic in text, I genuinely mean this. Why don't the authors know this? Why doesn't someone tell them?
- cannonpr 4y agoBecause I suspect that under focused analysis the signal won’t quite look like cosmic radiation background. Now I also haven’t done the analysis, but information, and entropy are funny things. Will they get to watch a human TV show ? Hell no. Would it look “random” versus showing that it once contained some structured information ? I think that’s a very open question. There are probably more serious papers that deal with the matter and how long and far “techno-signatures” survive in the noise.
- PaulHoule 4y agoAn old NTSC video signal has a clear periodic structure. Simply counting lines is going to reveal a lot about the structure and if anyone gets the idea of plotting lines they will figure out how to decode it. An efficient digital signal is going to maximize the use of bandwidth if it looks like white noise. That said, a signal like that needs a carefully calibrated receiver, so part of the signal in time-frequency space is going to be allocated for something that is easy to acquire and will tell to how to decode the main signal. You might see a periodic structure: if you want to run a "signal frequency network" with multiple transmitters with the same signal, have to deal with a lot of reflected signals, or listen from a mobile terminal that suffers from the Doppler Effect you will probably turn off the signal for part of the cycle so that reflections can die down and you can reset your echo cancellation algorithms. Thus digital signals aren't going to be invisible but they are going to spend maybe 5% of the energy in a way that is easy to interpret as opposed to all of it.
- maerF0x0 4y agoMakes me wonder if alien life will actually not find our messages simply because we're using such "ancient" techniques. Perhaps they invented a TV like object and used a NTSC like signal, but like 100k years ago and no one in their race knows to look for our old signals. Maybe our comms look like hieroglyphics to them ?
- bnralt 4y agoI've been wondering what the advantage of von Neumann probes are. Once you have the ability to autonomously construct probes, it seems like it would be easier and faster to mass produce them in one solar system and send them directly to their destinations. For instance, with a von Neumann probe you have to have probes with additional mass for self-replication, have it accelerate halfway to point A, decelerate halfway their, spend time replicating a new probe that will accelerate halfway to point B and then decelerate, then spend time manufacturing a new probe, then have that accelerate halfway from point B to point A, then decelerate the second half of the way, etc. But if you can automate manufacturing, you can just make specialized devices that mass produce probes in one system, and send them directly to their destination, without waiting for the parent probes to stop at all the in between points to do some manufacturing. And the probes are going to be much lighter because they don't need replication devices in them.
- tsimionescu 4y agoThe point is that solar systems have tiny amounts of resources when compared against the idea of colonizing an entire galaxy, whereas the concept of a von Neumann probe swarm would have resources proportional to the task. Now, whether that is actually possible in any serious sense is very much in doubt.
- bnralt 4y agoThere are ~2 x 10^9 stars in the solar system. The mass of earth is 6 x 10^24 kilos, with about 1/3 of that being iron. So even if we're just using the mass of a single celestial object the size of the earth, and only looking at iron alone, that'd be 1,000,000,000,000,000 kilos of iron you could use per star (for reference, this would be the equivalent of ~300 million fully fueled Saturn V's per star). It seems like a single solar system would have enough resources.
- tsimionescu 4y agoI am quite certain that using all of the iron in a single planet's core is well beyond the difficulty of building a self-replicating probe (which itself is well beyond our technical capabilities). Not to mention, such probes are unlikely to be build able from a single metal, and some metals used for advanced electronics are significantly rarer than iron.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoFurther because a sufficiently powerful compression+encryption scheme would be indistinguishable from noise, how would we even know any pattern is or isn’t a natural noise or an artificial noise?