6 ms·
Although a lot of this list seems silly, it also has slurs like "retard" and "jewed" on it, which i think are very reasonably considered offensive. I think the
by bawolff 4y ago
Although a lot of this list seems silly, it also has slurs like "retard" and "jewed" on it, which i think are very reasonably considered offensive.
I think the tarball thing is rediculous, but the opposite extreme of no words can be hurtful is also rediculous.
- imgabe 4y agoIt oddly doesn't have a lot of other slurs, like the n-word, etc. Does that mean they are acceptable? I don't think most people need to be told that "jewed" or "retard" are not appropriate professional words. Certainly not anyone who works at Stanford, just like nobody needed to be told not to say any of the other slurs that aren't on the list.
- bawolff 4y agoI dont disagree, but you literally wrote "I reject the notion that anyone hearing or reading a word from this list could possibly experience anything properly categorized as "harm"." Those were words on this list, so i disagree with that statement. I also don't think anyone is arguing that the authors of this list intended it to be exhaustive.
- imgabe 4y agoYeah I still don’t think that’s harm. Feeling offended is not harm. It’s just information about the world. Learning that someone has prejudices or is rude or just careless about their speech does not harm you.
- makeitdouble 4y agoThat rhetoric is incredibly similar to bullies in school arguing that they were just playing and nobody is harmed by their little jokes. You can’t be the one deciding if people are hurt or not, it’s their call. Wether them being hurt justify such and such action is another issue.
- 4bpp 4y ago> You can’t be the one deciding if people are hurt or not, it’s their call. Are you trying to suggest that this is a dichotomy? It seems to me that the common-sense position is (used to be?) that neither the person performing an action nor the person at the receiving end can be considered impartial and trusted to make that call. Either way, the idea that "being hurt" is a state that the individual has full discretion to declare themselves as being in seems incompatible with our existing widespread moral intuition that A hurting B results in a moral and potentially legal claim to redress from B towards A; otherwise, anyone could trivially claim constantly being hurt by everyone and therefore entitle themselves to an arbitrary amount of restitution. One of the two therefore has to go for society to function: either you don't get to make the call if you are hurt, or it's a priori morally neutral to hurt you.
- makeitdouble 4y ago> our existing widespread moral intuition that A hurting B results in a moral and potentially legal claim to redress from B towards A This would be the part where differ. I understand the argument, but as you point out it would lead us to a dead end. IMHO someone being hurt doesn’t mean they need reparation. As an example, people mourning are deeply hurt, and they will also be extra sensible to specific words that are mundane but resonate differently to them. We can both recognize they’re hurt, some words hit them differently, and have no redressment to them outside of sympathy perhaps. That’s an extreme example, but I would see a lot of steps on the spectrum, including for instance my boss hurting my feelings by coldly and factually pointing out how bad of a job I did. I get to decide if I’m hurt or not, but that doesn’t automatically make me a victim entitled to reparations.
- TeMPOraL 4y ago> IMHO someone being hurt doesn’t mean they need reparation. There needs to be some kind of end, some kind of closure to hurt - otherwise we have a positive feedback loop that amplifies suffering and eventually turns violent. > As an example, people mourning are deeply hurt, and they will also be extra sensible to specific words that are mundane but resonate differently to them. In this and similar cases (bad breakup, loss of health or future prospects or sentimental property, etc.), other people are making a time-limited concession to let the grieving person process their experience. Beyond that time limit, one should not expect others to keep carefully controlling their language for one's sake. One should especially not count on making those concessions permanent. > That’s an extreme example, but I would see a lot of steps on the spectrum, including for instance my boss hurting my feelings by coldly and factually pointing out how bad of a job I did. Happened to me the other day, and while I did suffer internally, not for a second I thought they should've been prohibited from saying what they said, or from saying it the way they did. It's not the words that hurt me, but awareness that I'm seen as less reliable in the eyes of the other (coupled with anxiety/fear related to the prospects of my future employment).
- JohnBooty 4y agoFeeling offended is not harm It really depends on the context, right? If a stranger on the internet uses some controversial word, you can decide it's no big deal. But now imagine your boss is using terms like "jewed down" or some other thing thing that applies to you, specifically. Are you harmed? It's very possible that you are harmed in a very literal sense; your career path is intertwined with a person that seems to think cheapness and haggling is synonymous with your people. (It is also worth noting that this list of harmful language is targeted specifically at the "Stanford IT Community" which is a workplace. This is not their attempt to regulate the speech of the world at large.) Now, having said that, I also understand the flip side of things. Some of the entries such as "tarball" struck me as absurd. And on a personal note, I'm partially blind and I don't give a rat's ass about terms like "blind studies" and so forth. In fact, the phrase "keep an eye on things" always makes me chuckle since I'm blind in one eye: if you tell me to keep an eye on things, I'm likely to ask you "which one" because you're going to get a very different level of attention depending on which eye we choose. I also don't mind that we as a society have decided that "see" is a synonym for "understand."
- naasking 4y ago> But now imagine your boss is using terms like "jewed down" or some other thing thing that applies to you, specifically. Are you harmed? It's very possible that you are harmed in a very literal sense; your career path is intertwined with a person that seems to think cheapness and haggling is synonymous with your people. You would harmed by the prejudicial actions taken against you, like skipping you for advancement, but not by the use of the word specifically. If anything, letting people use the word makes it easier to gather evidence of any prejudice against you, so making the word taboo makes such prejudice easier to hide.
- JohnBooty 4y agoYou would harmed by the prejudicial actions taken against you, like skipping you for advancement, but not by the use of the word specifically Yes, but there's a cyclical relationship between words and actions. Words can reinforce attitudes and actions. When your boss uses the term "jewed down" they are also sending the message that it's okay to stereotype people. I do not support some kind of zero-tolerance approach to language. (After all, "tolerance" is the goal!) However, I do find quite a few of these changes worthwhile. For example, a recently disabled friend pointed out how it kind of sucks for her to hear words like "lame" used as a synonym for "bad." So I've tried to weed that one out. Is it going to solve all of her problems? Is that even in her top 100 problems in life? No and no. But I mean, like why not try and make a little change like that?
- oblio 4y agoIsn't Stanford in the US, where people are very trigger-happy? I've found that various American courses and certifications are very explicit, a lot more than non-American ones, for example European ones. Then someone told me: they're afraid that if they don't include the absolute basics, someone will complain/sue/whatever about having been presented the basic concept, so that's why their education is incomplete or why they failed their certification exam. This basically aligns with the same logic, saying this as an outside observer. The US is <<full>> of defensive behavior, if you look at it as an outsider.
- mschuster91 4y ago> The US is <<full>> of defensive behavior, if you look at it as an outsider. Yeah. Like people getting sued for swimming pools because parents can't be bothered to teach their kids how to swim or to not go on private property unauthorized, or people being forced to file lawsuits against close relatives because they have no other way of recouping healthcare expenses... so many of the horror stories we Europeans read from across the pond leave us with a plain "WTF, are these guys nuts?" feeling.
- SturgeonsLaw 4y agoAmericans aren't nuts, the legal system is just filling the role that the government fills in other countries (enforcing regulations, welfare, etc)
- franga2000 4y agoOk but many Americans are proud of their country, despite the fact it's failing to fulfill some of the most basic roles almost all other countries do. Nearly half of their voter base votes for people who explicitly support (the other half isn't much better, but at least some people there can blame it on the bipartisan system). That's nuts.
- mschuster91 4y ago> Ok but many Americans are proud of their country, despite the fact it's failing to fulfill some of the most basic roles almost all other countries do. That's mostly due to decades worth of brainwashing and propaganda ("American Exceptionalism"), as well as a factor of just how big the US actually is. Here in Europe? In like two or three hours worth of driving time from Munich, one can reach half a dozen other countries and see a complete contrast: other languages, other ways of organizing society, other activities, other sports, other varieties of alcohol, other political parties. We actually have competition here.
- bluedino 4y ago> "jewed" or "retard" are not appropriate professional words Real, professional example from the automotive world: 'the knock sensor can retard the ignition timing' Is that still okay to say?
- allturtles 4y agoI'm assuming both you and the GP know that the 'retard' that's clearly offensive is the noun 'retard' referring to a person.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoWhich is the whole point. The offense is the context, not the word itself.
- slothtrop 4y agoThe explicit purpose of a list like this is to suggest that no, it isn't, for any context. That is the banality of it.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoHere's a short list of professional people in the last few years that needed to be informed that "jewed me down" is not a compliment to Jewish people. https://forward.com/culture/522179/jew-you-down-antisemitic-slur-offensive/ https://forward.com/culture/522179/jew-you-down-antisemitic-...
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoI mean it's a university, they kinda expect you to use half a brain when using words instead of mindlessly following their list of Words To Avoid like a robot.
- dsfyu404ed 4y ago>It oddly doesn't have a lot of other slurs, like the n-word, etc. Does that mean they are acceptable? Depending on who's mouth they come out of they kind of are acceptable. Which is kind of a glaring example of why this whole policing words bullshit is in fact bullshit. It's not the words that do harm. It's the context in which they are used.
- MrBuddyCasino 4y ago"It is high time someone wrote this list to finally put an end to the commonly accepted and pervasive use of the words 'retard' and 'jewed' in academia." Does this make sense to you?
- Eisenstein 4y agoAt the risk of sounding pedantic or critical (it is but only in the helpful well, I assure you) -- the word 'ridiculous' comes from the Latin 'rideo' which means to laugh, which is in contemporary French 'rire', Italian 'ridere' and English 'ridicule'. It has nothing to do with the color 'red', if that helps you remember that it does not have the word 'red' in it. As well, you can associate 'rideo' with 'video'.
- jojobas 4y agoBy banning words like "retard" you just create a void that will be filled with another word very quickly (the word itself used to be a medical term). Imbecile, special needs, oligophrenic, whatever, something associated with intellectual disability will be used instead. They are not trying to ban "harmful language" from being said or written, they are trying to have you suppress "harmful thoughts", or ideally render you incapable of harbouring them. Do you want Stanford (or anyone else) to dictate what you can think?
- iinnPP 4y agoIt's also worth noting that insults don't need to be real language or any language. Just laughing can be incredibly offensive. So an aggressor has infinite words to use and is effectively impossible to censor. I hesitate to mention SouthPark, but they do an episode where Cartman is especially cruel using laughter as his weapon. It's quite effective and obviously offensive. Unlike the list in the article.
- warkdarrior 4y agoI expect laughter will be a banned behavior on next year's version of the list.
- TeMPOraL 4y ago> By banning words like "retard" you just create a void that will be filled with another word very quickly (the word itself used to be a medical term). You can see this happening in the Stanford list itself - some of the terms listed, particularly in the "Ableist" section, are clearly second or third iteration through the euphemism treadmill. In fact, some could be about to complete another one - for example, my self-preservation instinct on the Internet tells me I shouldn't use "disabled" as an adjective, despite it being listed as a proper alternative to "crippled". I fully expect "disabled" to land in the left column of this or similar list in a couple of years.
- jojobas 4y agoI just checked and "differently abled" is apparently no-no already. It's as if a choice of words can change the unfortunate fact that losing a leg sucks. https://www.betterup.com/blog/differently-abled https://www.betterup.com/blog/differently-abled
- walkhour 4y agoThis list was bound to mix reasonable proposals with wild ones. So that when you point out the wild ones, you can be told "hey, but what about this very reasonable thing?".
- skeeter2020 4y agois the response then, "the universal reasonableness implies we don't need to guide and caution people from using it"?
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoThey do expect you to apply your own professional and university level discretion when using words. I really don't understand this thread or threads like this. Suddenly people are all about using exact lists of acceptable discourse and following Rules and the like.
- slothtrop 4y agoSo now we're pretending there couldn't be consequences and a strong incentive not to use any and all terms listed?
- himinlomax 4y ago> it also has slurs like "retard" Nobody has ever been genuinely harmed by hearing the word "retard." It's made up outrage. Note: being butthurt is not being harmed.
- slothtrop 4y agoI would agree insofar as they would not be harmed in excess of any other word used as an insult in its place. What "hurts" is being insulted (potentially) or bullied.
- coldtea 4y agoRetard was not a slur. It was a medical term, "mental retardation" (it's still actually used in some of the literature). It was used as a slur, the way any term can be used as a slur: by saying it to insult someone. The intend made it a slur, not the term. In fact, in the case of insulting, it was primarily used against people who don't have that condition (mind developmental problems). "See what you've done? Are you a r...?", etc. For the people actually having such condition, it was just the medical term the literature, and their own doctors used to describe their condition. Replacing the term doesn't change the mindset. Any new term adopted can equally be used with malice, it's just a BS arms race, focusing on words, when it should have focused on the bullying and attitude. But that would actually make sense - and have an actual effect, so why not take the easier path?
- oldgradstudent 4y agoAny euphemism will become a slur, and so will the euphemism that replaces it.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoAt first it's not the euphemism, but the intent behind it. Over a long enough time period, if people are called the euphemism enough with said intent, the word itself has lost its original meaning and associations. This is sometimes used maliciously though - like how a contraction about being against facism somehow got a bad connotation (antifa), or how being aware of social injustices is bandied about by right-wing outlets (woke).
- slothtrop 4y agoInsults are only effective because of their meaning. Terms like "idiot" and "stupid" mean exactly what they have from the outset in the medical field. You cannot divorce derogatory use from meaning, much as you would like to. But to follow your rationale, we'd be right on track by now for "retarded" being kosher, as other terms have replaced it. That has not happened.
- skeeter2020 4y agoBut that's how this type of ridiculous become standard practice: you include a few unambigous examples, then the rest lean on them for support. Did Stanford really need an official document telling their community that the word "jewed" probably should be avoided? If so, there are lots of worse words and phrases not included here, why not? How did they decide the word "tarball" should be included because it starts with the same three letters as a derogatory term, but "tarsands" (along with being technically inaccurate) is OK? No one said words can't be hurtful. If you work or attend Stanford you know these words. This document is apparently about harm reduction though, and that harm would be mitigated far more effectively if Stanford admitted more people like the ones these words supposedly trivialize.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mannykannot 4y agoThe commingling of words and phrases which are often used outside of their domain of applicability in order to be offensive, with those that are not, just spreads the contagion to no useful end. It is particularly bad when the given replacement is nowhere near synonymous. The first one that really got my eyes rolling was 'detail-oriented' for OCD: being detail-oriented is an aspect of safety in a number of areas, and this is nothing like OCD, which has a clinical definition. If one cares about something, don't make it easy to ridicule and dismiss.
- PebblesRox 4y agoI think the intention with non-synonymous examples is to use those as replacements for non-literal uses of the term. E.g. reserving the use of the term "addicted" for someone who actually has an addiction; only saying someone has OCD if they actually do and otherwise calling them detail-oriented. (I agree that the document is silly but I don't think it's quite as bad as your interpretation.)
- mannykannot 4y agoI agree that's not so bad in general. In this particular case, however, when one wants to say that someone is obsessively preoccupied with irrelevant issues (which could be a valid issue), OCD is not a good choice, but 'detail-oriented' misses the point entirely.