3 ms·
Given how many shadow banned accounts keep going on with their tirades well after they've been banned, it means it is good to keep them. I suppose some just nee
by sph 4y ago
Given how many shadow banned accounts keep going on with their tirades well after they've been banned, it means it is good to keep them. I suppose some just need the outlet to write whatever inane idiotic crap passes through their mind even if nobody can engage with them.
Every comment from a shadow banned account is one dang doesn't have to waste time moderating.
- roflyear 4y agoYou may not want their speech (HN management does not either) but that doesn't make shadowbans good for discourse. It's good to limit speech you do not want sure. But not good for getting alternative views on things.
- sph 4y agoIt's not alternative views that are shadow banned. It's people on a Rust post ranting about the current US president, for example. It's Terry A. Davis (may he rest in peace) throwing insults at Jews and black people during one of his fits on this forum. Not all ideas are not all equally worthy. The hard problem always is "who decides what is worth and what isn't?", but "everything is worth something" is too simplistic an answer, in my opinion.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- roflyear 4y ago> Not all ideas are not all equally worthy. The hard problem always is "who decides what is worth and what isn't?", but "everything is worth something" is too simplistic an answer, in my opinion. We agree - I'd just like easier to understand rules.
- rhaksw 4y ago> Given how many shadow banned accounts keep going on their unacceptable tirades well after they've been banned, means it is good to keep them. This position completely ignores the harms that come from non-disclosure of moderation decisions. Note that while the title of this post mentions shadowbans, its discussion is about undisclosed or shadow content moderation.
- fellowniusmonk 4y agoI comment and post rarely but this account has been active for nearly 12 years, I was shadowbanned very early on for unknown reasons and someone vouched for me only in this last couple of years since I was very nearly a lurker, on review I was told there didn't seem to be anything warranting a shadowban in my comment history. Despite this experience, one that you might expect to turn me off from using HN, I am extremely pro shadow ban as a tool to protect this forums utility. Both here and in my professional online life. There are many places online where you can spend nearly infinite time writing and researching thorough rebuttals only to have them washed away in the sea of low content memes. It's nice to have a place where the gold is still in the comments and articles (as interesting as they are) serve primarily as a prompt and conversation starter for deeply knowledgeable people to share. The utility of having a thoughtful and knowledge filled space has been far higher to me then the marginal value of "having my voice heard on this account" during that period.
- manuelmoreale 4y agoI had a similar experience to yours. Lurker for 90% of the time, only comment here and there and never spammed linked unless they were pertinent to the discussion I was commenting on. At some point I got shadowbanned and I only noticed because no one ever replied or interacted with any of my comments. It was easily solved with an email to dang asking if there was a reason why that happened. If I broke a rule, I obviously want to know because I do care about following guidelines here. It got quickly resolved and that was a very pleasing experience. But that's because I was able to ask questions to a human and a human took time to answer them. I still think shadowbanning is a good tool and a necessary one when it comes to moderation, especially because contrary to the real world, here and on most online comunities, anyone can join. IRL no random person can just join your friends circle and become part of the conversation. This is an almost exlusively online issue and all the various forms of banning are the only tools at our disposal to deal with the issue. And letting people think they're part of the comunity while preventing them to do harm is a good compromise. I'll wait for the day when a clever dev decides to use GPT to make a bot whose sole purpose is to engage with shadowbanned account.
- tjpnz 4y agoWhat proportion of shadow banned accounts continue to do this on any given day though? Conservatively I would put it at half. I'm not suggesting shadow bans are without merit but often you have to look really far back through some comment histories before you have an "aha!" moment. I'm also not fully versed in the way this place works, but people go through shitty periods in life and there should be systems to account for that.
- rhaksw 4y ago> What proportion of shadow banned accounts continue to do this on any given day though? There's an example linked in the post where someone continued posting on Reddit for years before they noticed. It's also quite common for subreddit shadowbans to go unnoticed. And most people never notice the shadow removal of individual comments. > people go through shitty periods in life and there should be systems to account for that. I completely agree. Undisclosed moderation short circuits any ability to forgive. The sanctioned user will never know to appeal. Hiding the punishment is like taking away the judiciary or removing habeas corpus. There is no trial, it's straight to jail and you aren't even told.
- sph 4y ago> Undisclosed moderation short circuits any ability to forgive On here, the vouch feature is a kind of forgiveness, if you will. If you are shadow banned but you say something interesting one lucid day, people will vouch you and engage with you. This is why I browse HN with showdead on.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]