7 ms·
“The more reliant we are on others, the less resilient we are as a nation”
- Razengan 4y agoFuck this tribal mentality belongs in caves.
- Jupe 4y agoMy take on globalization is that it appears to make sense from a global stability and business perspective. Most of this is uneducated opinion but based on experiences with the local auto industry and some personal thought on the impact: 1. Having inter- and co-dependence between nations decreases the likelihood of global (potentially nuclear) war. It is difficult to decimate another country when all of your aluminum, cars, wheat or salt were coming from that country. 2. From a "big-picture" perspective, global markets enable massive potential growth for many corporations. I lived through the globalization of the auto industry here in Michigan; it was a slow-motion horror show affecting virtually every person, everywhere. Similar things happened in the mining and steel industries to the south and east of us. 3. There is no free-market value to extract from 500,000,000 poverty-stricken people; better to have them working and buying your products. Low growth/low margin industries (laundry soap, packaged food, etc.) were virtually drooling over the thought of opening up the Indian, Chinese and African markets. 4. The assumption that if, through globalization, you reduce entire industries that helped build a nation (steel, automobiles, are good examples in the USA) those people will simple re-train and get jobs in other industries, particularly white-collar or service industries. 5. People are adaptable. But, these seemingly sensible ideals are difficult to attain. We have seen that: 1. Inter- and co-dependence can be adversely affected by things other than war: e.g. a global pandemic. 2. Not all countries open their markets the same, with trade imbalances being more frequent than desired. More modern, higher-precision industrial equipment simply made Japanese cars better and longer-lasting than the decades-old "Big Three" equipment. 3. There is no guarantee that 500M newly-appointed-middle-class people will even buy your countries products. A global free market is designed so that better designs win; but marketing and market manipulations don't always work out that way. A vast majority will spend less on a product if they can; even if it is of lower quality. (looking at you Amazon). 4. Some people just don't want to be white-collar workers or provide services to others. A "days work" is best measured by the things they built, rather than the processes they optimized, or the signatures they acquired. 5. While people are adaptable, watching them adapt to seemingly non-sensical drivers (at least in their world view) breeds great amounts of discontent. Hence movements like MAGA are born.
- dingaling 4y ago> It is difficult to decimate another country when all of your aluminum, cars, wheat or salt were coming from that country. Conversely if the supplier of salt and aluminium has a government that is acting in an immoral or oppressive way, then the dependence of other nations upon that supplier would seem to reduce the likelihood and magnitude of coercive action that might be taken by those nations.
- okasaki 4y agoNotably absent: any thoughts on being reliant on the United States :-)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gottebp 4y agoAt the international level, it is debate-able. It depends on the goodwill nations have towards one another. At the individual and family level though, atomization is incredibly destructive to culture and community. Reliance on others is needed more than ever. To be absolutely independent, is to be without love (given or received). Family, community, and nation cannot exist without love — it is the vital glue that holds it all together and makes it worth holding together. Arguably if this was healthy at the local and national level, it makes sense then to extend it internationally as well.
- jvanderbot 4y agoI'd argue that inter-reliance is what brings a framework for peace and mutual respect, at all levels from family up to global politics. Less personally, in Accidental Superpower, the case is made that the west's insistence on free and safe trade over international waters has helped to broker a long stretch of mostly peaceful time - precisely because it creates these interrelations that become important.
- olivermuty 4y agoEurope has been war torn for thousands of years, then post ww2 we got a long lasting peace. Turns out a side effect of the union is that you are less likely to want to shoot someone who is buying your goods!
- fleischhauf 4y agothat was the German strategy towards Russia "Wandel durch Handel". Assuming that trade is mutual beneficial it makes an armed conflict less likely because both sides have so much to lose. With Russia it did not work unfortunately. It's debatable if it works with china.
- c22 4y agoBeing self-reliant is a pre-requisite of being able to effectively help others. The self-reliant can still experience love and community, they just can't be trapped by dysfunctional relationships. Edit: I guess if everyone was born radically self-reliant we might not learn to care. But no one starts out that way.
- celeritascelery 4y agoWhile there is certainly some truth and wisdom to this view, it also worries me. I see the increasing globalization and interdependence of the modern world as one of the major reasons for the decrease in armed conflicts. You are a lot less likely to attack someone who is a trade partner. There is a saying that “there has never been an armed conflict between two nations that both had a McDonald’s”. Russia has broken that, but that is case where the exception proves the rule. Russia has been devastated by the repercussions of their choice to invade Ukraine. And Europe is suffering due to the lack of oil and natural gas. I fear a world where nations are not reliant on each other is going to be less peaceful. That being said, the memo specifically calls out relations with China, which is a country that is dangerous to have too much reliance on, due to also being run by an absolute dictatorship.
- likecarter 4y agoBesides preventing conflict, globalization was supposed to increase democracy in the world. Increasing trade relations with China was in part to make them more democratic, as the theory was the more prosperous a nation is, the more democratic they become. I think we got it backwards. Now we know it doesn’t work, and this historic reason for globalization is moot.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoIf you ever visited China 20 years ago and now, you may have noticed the change in openness, though. The first time I went, I was confined to limited areas, and had to be followed by a state appointed guide for my entire trip. I couldn't kiss my girlfriend in the street, it was considered bad behavior. Now, I can just go alone, and where I please, and demonstrations of affection are not as frown upon. Women also seem have more freedom than before. China was always a dictatorship, but I would say it looks more free that it used to be, at least from my very limited external point of view. Now, China is still corrupted, with massive informational control. And it also became terribly polluted, and under systematic automatic surveillance, so I'm not sure it balances out, but it's not like there is an objective scale to those things.
- cs702 4y agoReads like a slogan for anti-globalization and nationalism. As with all slogans, it ignores important details that contradict it. Over the past four decades, our current global economic system, promoting economic integration and interdependence between countries, has lifted billions out of poverty.[a][b] Billions. No sensible discussion of globalization can ignore that. The current backlash is not against globalization per se, but against: * greater concentration of economic power (e.g., more markets dominated by global mega corporations), * greater concentration of political and military power in authoritarian regimes who play by different rules (e.g., China), and * greater concentration of income and wealth (e.g., the hollowing out of the middle class in the US). We shouldn't throw the baby out with the bathwater! -- [a] https://ourworldindata.org/poverty https://ourworldindata.org/poverty [b] https://ourworldindata.org/extreme-poverty-in-brief https://ourworldindata.org/extreme-poverty-in-brief
- HL33tibCe7 4y agoBut let’s also not throw out the baby with the bathwater in the _opposite_ direction. We should not be reliant on Russia for energy to such an extent that our economy gets destroyed when a Russian tyrant goes on an ego trip. We should not be allowing Chinese entities to own our energy infrastructure. We should not be allowing foreign nationals to buy up massive amounts of property in London with shady money, distorting the property market for normal citizens. There is a happy medium somewhere in between complete globalisation and complete isolation.
- peoplefromibiza 4y ago> We should not be allowing foreign nationals to buy up massive amounts of property in London Same way England should not be allowed to reign over 56 states with their King? I mean, if it goes both ways, I agree.
- cs702 4y agoWe should not be reliant on fossil fuels for energy, period. There's a mountain of scientific evidence showing that extracting, transporting, storing, and burning all that poisonous crap is very bad for humankind. The sooner we move to other sources (fusion (!), solar, wind, etc.), the better for humankind. However, companies that make money from fossil fuels don't want that, and for the past four decades they've had the political and economic cloud to slow down or even stop progress. We have such "single points of failure" in the global economy because we have allowed market power to become highly concentrated, nationally and globally, without any checks and balances.
- dionsaur84 4y agoI’m going to have to disagree with the core premise here. At face value, this article implies that if we all just live alone in the woods and hunt and grow our own food, that somehow we will be stronger as a people. The irony here is that this is coming from a post made on the internet. The internet is comprised of a large network of servers and infrastructure that isn’t possible without relying heavily on the labour and creativity of lots of other people. Yes, that includes the work of people from other nations. We’re talking international, here. Imagine you couldn’t see a website hosted in Australia because some right wing politician arbitrarily decided that invisible borders should define our evolution as a species. This post is literally self defeating by virtue of the mechanism in which it was messaged.
- analog31 4y agoAt a granular level, the earth can't produce enough food for all of us to live by subsistence, without technologies that require a relatively sophisticated society just to function. For example, more than half of the world's animal population is sustained by the Haber process.
- funstuff007 4y agoIt's worked out real well for North Korea. > The goal of Juche is to establish a self-reliant state which independently determines its political, economic, and military affairs. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Juche https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Juche
- jhbadger 4y agoAlthough Juche never really was meant to be taken as actual NK policy but just as internal propaganda (why want to leave if we have everything we need and the rest of the world must be worse?). NK has always been dependent on foreign aid from the USSR (when it existed) and China. Originally because these countries supported NK ideology, but now mostly because China fears what would happen if NK collapsed.
- 082349872349872 4y agoan alternative viewpoint from 1961: ...if a beachhead of cooperation may push back the jungle of suspicion, let both sides join in creating a new endeavor, not a new balance of power, but a new world of law, where the strong are just and the weak secure and the peace preserved. — JFK
- Gravityloss 4y agoThe content was a lot better than the headline.
- HL33tibCe7 4y agoPlease take the time to read the actual content before commenting…
- AntoniusBlock 4y agoThe comments in this thread are kneejerk responses to the quote in the OP, which is silly because if you people had just clicked the link you'd realise that the report is mainly focused on China. We are _all_ too reliant on China and addressing the issue is not "nationalistic" or "North Korean juche" or the other rubbish I've read ITT so far.
- brookst 4y agoIMO that’s also a kneejerk response. There are dangers to our already-declining reliance on China, but also benefits. The big one is that countries with deeply entangled economies rarely go to war with each other. A world where we don’t rely on China for anything is a world where we are more likely at war with them. “Security means not depending on anyone else” is just off-the-grid survivalism writ large. It’s true in some very narrow sense, but it is also naive to think it’s even possible, especially while continuing to pursue any other goals.
- AntoniusBlock 4y agoI might've agreed with you had Russia not invaded Ukraine. Your assumption is the same assumption we all made, but they invaded Ukraine anyway.
- brookst 4y agoWhat did Russia depend on Ukraine for? Russia did not think it was attacking Europe. It is not a remotely analogous situation to US/China. China is much more mutually dependent on the US, and much more sane.
- AntoniusBlock 4y ago>Russia did not think it was attacking Europe. Do you really think Putin and his generals thought that everyone would stand by and watch as they invaded Ukraine and do nothing? That's absurd. >It is not a remotely analogous situation to US/China. China-Taiwan and Russia-Ukraine are eerily similar, actually. >China is much more mutually dependent on the US, and much more sane. Their massive military build up and itchy trigger finger aiming at anyone who even tries to insinuate that Taiwan isn't part of the PRC says otherwise. Not to mention their posturing in the South China Sea, which has perturbed not only Taiwan but Vietnam and the Phillipines too. >much more sane Are you sure? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020%E2%80%932021_China%E2%80%93India_skirmishes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020%E2%80%932021_China%E2%80%... Around 40 people died in these skirmishes. And 40 is a conservative figure btw. India claims that more than 30 Chinese soldiers died, whereas China claims 4 died. US intelligence has the number at 20-35.
- jpm_sd 4y agoAverage citizens, OTOH, regret Brexit and wish they were more integrated into the EU: https://uk.movies.yahoo.com/brexit-buyers-remorse-over-50-103902867.html https://uk.movies.yahoo.com/brexit-buyers-remorse-over-50-10... I guess we'll see how that shakes out https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/12/britain-brexit-regret-polling-populism/672467/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/12/britain-br...
- uudbddtyzq 4y ago
- dang 4y agoUsers flagged it, software marked it as a flamewar, and moderators downweighted the thread. I don't know in what order these things happened, but as the article seems like garden-variety political material (not to mention flamefodder), it's not particularly on topic for HN. p.s. Number of comments doesn't make a story rank higher, nor should it.