6 ms·
I’ve never been a big fan of Taibbi. But all the things you’re mentioning are characteristic of his journalistic style, which made him famous in his coverage of
by rayiner 4y ago
I’ve never been a big fan of Taibbi. But all the things you’re mentioning are characteristic of his journalistic style, which made him famous in his coverage of Wall Street back in 2008. It’s uncharitable and filtered through a fundamental distrust of moneyed corporations, but I’ve never heard it described as “unhinged.”
And I’m not sure “unhinged” is an appropriate description. For example, while “internal lingo” may be common, isn’t it also fair to observe that much corporate internal lingo is pretty Orwellian? Similarly, as to your second point, is it unreasonable to draw an inference that Twitter is doing what some agency wants it to do, when the agency asks Twitter to do something and then Twitter does it?
- emodendroket 4y agoThe argument seems to be that what the FBI is doing is more or less analogous to you clicking the report button, which hardly makes you a shadowy figure controlling Twitter if they act on your report.
- pasquinelli 4y agoyeah except i'm just me and the fbi is the fbi.
- emodendroket 4y agoObviously these reports are given more priority but who's going to just ignore FBI reports?
- devmunchies 4y agoFor real. exactly why the govt is supposed to stay out of censorship.
- pasquinelli 4y agoi'd probably just do whatever the fbi wanted so as to save myself a possible hassle. which is the point: the fbi can fuck with me. to say, "well, the fbi is just reporting stuff" ignores that the fbi has power. power is something people seem to have an odd tendency to ignore.
- ModernMech 4y ago> power is something people seem to have an odd tendency to ignore. Indeed, just as you seem to ignore Twitter’s power. They are protected from the FBI by the Constitution and the courts, and they have the money (read: power) to actually enforce those protections had they felt threatened or coerced by the government. The FBI may have power but they are not all powerful, not even close.
- emodendroket 4y agoSo what is the revelation here, or what does it suggest we should do?
- benmmurphy 4y agoIt is very clearly an improper purpose. The FBI is trying to suppress 1A protected speech by reporting the tweets. The FBI is not allowed to suppress 1A protected speech. Imagine there was a button that would delete a Tweet and anyone could press it. Just because anyone could press the button would not make it legal for the FBI to press it.
- eganist 4y ago> It is very clearly an improper purpose. The FBI is trying to suppress 1A protected speech by reporting the tweets. The FBI is not allowed to suppress 1A protected speech. Imagine there was a button that would delete a Tweet and anyone could press it. Just because anyone could press the button would not make it legal for the FBI to press it. I keep seeing this, and I'm confused every time I see it, because speech on a private platform isn't protected by the first amendment. Twitter can always say no to the feds (and other governments) in re: far more onerous and demanding requests than just an agent clicking a Report button, and in fact with far more official processes you can see the stats where they actually do just that. https://transparency.twitter.com/en/reports/removal-requests.html#2021-jul-dec https://transparency.twitter.com/en/reports/removal-requests...
- refurb 4y agoI keep seeing this, and I'm confused every time I see it, because speech on a private platform isn't protected by the first amendment. Ummm… yes it is when the speech is being suppressed by the government? That’s kinda the entire point of the 1st amendment. The courts have ruled that the government asking a private party to censor is no different than the government censoring itself.
- emodendroket 4y agoWhat case did they rule that? It seems pretty routine that they get in contact with newspapers for this purpose so I'd be at least a little surprised to learn that it's been ruled unconstitutional but they're just flagrantly doing it anyway.
- faddypaddy34 4y agoExcept it's not clicking the report button. See the FBI could have a special agent assigned to clicking the report button instead of directly emailing Twitter asking for the removal of things that are in some cases obvious jokes.
- naasking 4y ago> The argument seems to be that what the FBI is doing is more or less analogous to you clicking the report button Weekly meetings between the FBI and top Twitter executives is "akin to clicking the report button"? Name one other Twitter user that had this privilege. I think that's a pretty strong sign that you're trying to stretch this analogy too far.
- TOMDM 4y agoWhere are you getting weekly meetings from? This set of tweets details 150 emails total over a period of over two and a half years (jan 2020 to nov 2022). It even specifically quotes their mention of their quarterly meeting. My biggest problem with people who think the Twitter files are A Big Deal, is their seeming inability to accurately describe the contents.
- naasking 4y ago> My biggest problem with people who think the Twitter files are A Big Deal, is their seeming inability to accurately describe the contents. Or maybe you're just ignorant of the contents: https://news.yahoo.com/twitter-executive-met-fbi-weekly-015002812.html https://news.yahoo.com/twitter-executive-met-fbi-weekly-0150...
- TOMDM 4y agoAh, I was reading this dump for the proof of a weekly mention, my mistake.
- UncleMeat 4y agoOrwellian does not just mean changing terms or using euphemisms. It is about terms that make the expression of undesirable thoughts actually impossible. Do any of the scare-quoted terms do this? I can't see any.
- the_gipsy 4y agoAre you talking about Newspeak? What you describe does not sound like what I think "orwellian" usually means.
- UncleMeat 4y agoThe term "Orwellian" in describing language comes directly from the properties of Newspeak. "Orwellian" can mean other things when describing state power or surveillance technology, but in this context it is being used to describe language so the connection to Newspeak is the relevant one.
- nopenopenopeno 4y agoIt's straightforwardly a broad term and you have no basis for your nonsense gatekeeping.
- UncleMeat 4y agoIt isn’t gatekeeping. “Orwellian” has a negative connotation. It is unreasonable to describe ordinary internal jargon as such.
- nopenopenopeno 4y agoIf you disagree, then make an actual argument for the content of your position. This subjective word policing is pathetic and unconvincing.
- wyclif 4y agoThe problem for me was never that Twitter had their own in-house term for shadowbanning. It was that they obfuscated and hid behind the term in order to avoid accusations of shadowbanning. It's like saying "this is not a sub sandwich, it's a hoagie!"
- SilverBirch 4y agoI think the biggest thing that chafes at people is that Taibbi is meant to be uncharitable and distrustful of big corporations. But he's not. He's charitable and trustful of the current management of Twitter. It's the exact opposite of speaking truth to power. The old twitter was a set of weak, fragmented, individuals doing their best and getting absolutely excoriated for it constantly. Now the company is run by the richest man on earth beholden to no one, and he faces literally no skepticism from Taibbi (although it looks like Weiss is about to break).
- rayiner 4y agoMusk has been at the helm of Twitter for five minutes and has done nothing of consequence. The previous management played a major role in US politics for years. It had a major impact on a U.S. presidency and suppressed true information that could have significantly impacted a Presidential information. Taibbi is entirely correct to focus on what happened before and not on Musk’s mean tweets.