16 ms·
Scientists' proposed calendar synchronizes dates with days
- dawilster 15y agoGood luck convincing the rest of the world to convert to a scientifically optimized calender.
- shirro 15y agoAll those unscientific countries still haven't adopted rods and hogsheads. I guess it will just be the US, Burma and Liberia again.
- shirro 15y agoBrought to you from a country that has not adopted SI units.
- maratd 15y agoThat depends on what you mean by adopted. The federal government/education establishment/etc. all use SI units. It's the general populace which couldn't care less. Which means this proposal has the same probability of adoption as me winning the lottery. And I don't buy lottery tickets.
- rahulnair23 15y agoThe US Department of Transportation, for example, does not use SI units. They did try to pass a mandate to change to SI by 2000 by tying federal funds to states that make the change, but that was rejected.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- waterlesscloud 15y agoHappy Thermidor!
- eternalban 15y agoMy thoughts, exactly. Those magical ("happy") days of The Terror were indeed too short. And UTC -- practically a symbol of British Naval prowess and Empire -- is really a nice touch, specially for the "brown/yellow" ones who get to toil happily at "midnight".
- Swizec 15y agoHere's a revolutionary thought - the calendar is already fixed. Sporting events (etc.) don't have to happen on the same weekday, they can just always happen on the same date. Voila, predictable time planning that doesn't have to be redone every year. And I love the idea of eliminating timezones, especially the example that pilots already use UTC. Ever considered this might be because the concept of "day" doesn't really apply when you change 10 timezones in 10 hours? Personally I think eliminating timezones would make relating to people internationally very difficult. It's already weird enough that Australians think of December as a summer month. Consider half the world thinking of 20:00 (8PM) as the morning. How does "everywhere is the same hour" even remotely fix the fact people sleep at night and work at day anyway? And what do you do with an extra week "every five or six years"?
- k-mcgrady 15y agoIn the UK there have been discussions about stopping DST. The main problem is that in places Scotland it would be darker for longer in the morning which could lead to more traffic accidents. The affects on crime and traffic accidents would be huge. And it would never be possible to get half of the planet to agree that they will forever work while it's dark and sleep while it is light.
- vineel 15y agoI don't think the suggestion is that the working day everywhere should start at X:00. The idea is that 4:00 in California is 4:00 in Britain and 4:00 in China. When the day starts would vary from place to place; perhaps 1:00 somewhere and 12:00 somewhere else. The point is to eliminate the confusion caused by timezones, especially those like Nepal's which are 15 minutes off other time zones for no good reason.
- Figs 15y agoThat's just substituting one sort of confusion for another, I think.
- 15y ago
- k-mcgrady 15y agoInteresting but it won't happen. It would have to be adopted throughout the world (especially where religious days are affected) and there would never be agreement on which holidays fall on which day (NYE on Friday or Saturday?). I don't fully understand the other point in the article about ridding the world of time zones to improve business and trade. How would that work? Do they expect certain countries to agree to work while the sun is down?
- Xixi 15y agoI think you understood the point about timezones backwards. The point is for everybody to use, for instance, UTC time. So instead of working the proverbial 9am to 5pm, if you are in Japan you would work from 0am to 8am (UTC). It makes sense to me, but I can see how lots of people would have a very hard time understanding and accepting this.
- jaequery 15y agosounds like a typical startup idea
- jaequery 15y agoa typical crazY startup idea
- wtvanhest 15y agoAs long as my birthday is on a Saturday it works for me. (seriously though, imagine how mad people will get when a particular event happens on the "wrong day" every year) I like it though. I'd even take a Tuesday birthday to make it happen.
- jimrandomh 15y agoI like this idea. Unfortunately, it can't coexist with the Gregorian calendar in its current form; if a small fraction of the world switched to it, they'd always have to wonder which calendar someone writing "Jan 1" was referring to. When a date is written down, it needs to be immediately obvious which calendar it's referring to. It needs a special notation that doesn't overlap with any of the currently-used notations for dates, so that it will be unambiguous (and so that the old calendar will remain unambiguous). I propose doing this by giving each month a letter, A-L, and writing dates like this: 2012-A01 = New calendar, first day of first month of 2012 2012-L30 = New calendar, thirtieth day of twelfth month of 2012 2012-01-01 = Gregorian calendar, first day of first month of 2012 C30 = New calendar, thirtieth day of third month of whatever year this is With the notations neatly separated, you could then print calendars with the two schemes side by side, and let people convert back and forth for awhile while the new system is adopted. We could give the months fanciful names, too, as long as they start with the right letters. But the important thing is, the two schemes must be unambiguous and distinct.
- jaylevitt 15y agoObviously, the calendar ambiguity can be resolved by some sort of calendar NAT.
- SquareWheel 15y agoYou know, let's just use Unix timestamps when marking future dates. Removes all ambiguity from calendar types, time zones, etc.
- martythemaniak 15y agoI like your idea, let's get together and discuss it over drinks. Hows your 1325357149?
- SquareWheel 15y agoI retract my previous suggestion.
- yaix 15y agoThe scientific part is simple, its just a little maths. The difficult part is to get 8 billion people to agree to pull in the same direction. And my guess is, that it will never happen, unfortunately.
- biturd 15y agoI would tend to agree, but then we have things like DST shifting around all the time. The government just states they are making a change, and everyone does. Every software that isn't based on a network time server breaks, and is fixed, and we move on. The same could happen with this new calendar, the government simply mandates that by a certain year it has to be in place. The largest burden will be on legacy software and getting that patched. That very well could be reason enough for the reversal of this calendar, as every government software breaks, and they find out how slow they are to keeping up with their own mandates.
- forensic 15y agoThe gov adapted to Y2K, so they know exactly what they need to fix. The difference between adapting to Y2K and adapting to the HH calendar is minor. If the gov survived Y2K they would survive the HH-adoption.
- yaix 15y agoI remember when I lived in Mexico some 12 years ago and the government introduced DST there. Some schools would actually start an hour later to sync their starting time with before-DST-time, people where complaing about being totally confused, etc. Don't know if there is still DST now or if they abandoned it because of the many (often totally irrational) protests. Its not easy to change people's habits.
- meric 15y agoHey look, it worked when the Chinese government in the early 20th century switched to the Gregorian Calendar... Or did it? Paper calendars in China generally represent both Gregorian and Chinese calendar dates. I'm going to assume when this new calendar is adopted, the chinese will then be able to buy three calendars in one.
- tokenadult 15y agoFrom another point of view, a given date gradually occurring on every day of the week is a feature, not a bug. I see that the proposed calendar puts my birthday on a weekend, every year year after year, but I kind of like my birthday (and my wedding anniversary, and other important dates) occurring on a new day of the week each year, for variety. I note too that the calendar would not "make it easy to plan annual activities" for any of the dates in the "extra week" proposed for the calendar, if by annual activities we mean activities that occur in every calendar year. The extra week occurs "at the end of December every five or six years," and the new memory load everyone would have to bear is remembering which years--2015, 2020, 2026, 2032, 2037, 2043, 2048, 2054, 2060, 2065, 2071, 2076, 2082, 2088, 2093, 2099, 2105, "et cetera" are the extra week years.
- forensic 15y agothat "new memory load" is functionally zero, since no one would have to remember that. By the time the Extra week actually arrived, people would have been looking forward to it for an entire year, and it would not catch anyone by surprise. No memory required. Even subterranean cave trolls would be aware it is coming. I think it's a nice idea especially if we could have a big weeklong worldwide party once every 5 or 6 years
- felideon 15y agoThe corporate drone pessimist in me thinks that the extra week would just be another work week, with the best case being "Ah yes, you get an extra half-day worth of PTO this year."
- MichaelApproved 15y agoHumans are slaves to traditions. If it's introduced as a world wide party week from the start then people will feel like "it's always been done that way" and be less likely to fight it.
- ericdschmidt 15y agoI also immediately thought of a big celebration occurring during that week
- dustingetz 15y agoAnd yet, the US still isnt on metric.
- zhyder 15y agoAgreed with the general proposal: the only time periods that are important to preserve are the day (coz of morning/night), the week (coz of work-week and religious days), and the year (coz of seasons). The month is pretty arbitrary. They propose a 364-day year with 8x 30-day months and 4x 31-day months. If they're okay with a 364-day year, wouldn't it be better to have 8x 28-day months and 4x 35-day months. Or you could have 13x 28-day months. That way the day-of-week would be even more predictable.
- tabbyjabby 15y agoYeah, except you lose the morning/night distinction, because they also suggest that the entire world use one timezone. This, in my humble opinion, seems to a very cumbersome and onerous system. Yes, there are obvious business advantages to having just one timezone, but it also completely robs us of heuristics that have been developed over centuries.
- ams6110 15y agoFor any purposes which require clear unambiguous time values, we already have UTC. This is just not a problem.
- tuananh 15y agoNo don't do this. My birthday is on 31st 0_o
- deerpig 15y agoWow, after reading the comments it's amazing how difficult it is for most people to understand that eliminating time zones doesn't mean that anyone will change when they work. You will just have a different number for the time you do things than in than other parts of the world. In England you might start at 09:00, but on the other side of the world they would start at 20:00 which would be morning for them.
- Swizec 15y agoThe problem is that these are still timezones. It's actually a very trivial change. Instead of saying you're in a different timezone, I say you wake up at 20:00 instead of 8:00 like I do. That's not a very significant change ...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- usaar333 15y agoWhy is this better though? When scheduling a meeting, I still have to figure out what "zone" another place is in so as to schedule an event during a normal workday.
- meric 15y agoI can imagine the faces of the staff (who are too scared to speak up) when the CEO from overseas calls to organise a meeting at 3.30am in the morning the next day.
- kschua 15y agoThis proposal doesn't have my vote. The present system is good enough in that every one has an equal chance for special events in their lives to fall on a weekend.
- tapsboy 15y agoWhose in re-writing lot of software? I am not :)
- lancefisher 15y agoImagine the cost of changing all the software in the world to use a new calendar system. This will never happen.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- 6ren 15y agoSeems unlikely, yet, Europe switched to the euro. If we get better at software integration, different calendars might not be such a problem. We already convert between currencies, times and date formats. Is this really that much different to a new date-format, just with deeper syntactic changes? (rhetorical)
- billswift 15y ago>yet, Europe switched to the euro And isn't that working out really well.
- salvadors 15y agoExcept Europe didn't simply switch to the Euro. Some members of the EU (plus a few others who aren't in the EU) switched to it, over a twelve year period, with some others pegged to it (and maybe switching some day), some other countries adopting it 'unofficially' (i.e. it's their official currency, but they're not officially members of the Eurozone), and some countries who theoretically must join, voting against it in a local referendum, and thus deliberately failing to meet the entry conditions on an ongoing basis so as they can't join. (And this is, of course, ignoring all the logistical hassles involved in switching, never mind the much bigger questions, now very pertinent, as to whether trying to do all this may have been a cause of the downfall of Western Society, etc.) So I suspect this example gives more weight to the 'unlikely' side, than the 'yet...' side.
- LeafStorm 15y agoComputers have had to deal with multiple currencies from their inception, so the technical aspects of euro conversion were fairly minor. But they have never had to deal with an actual change in the rules of the calendar.
- artursapek 15y agoI wonder if calendar companies would lobby against this. I imagine people would still buy a new calendar every year or so, since they get worn/written on.
- ams6110 15y agoClassic academic waste-of-time project to solve a problem that doesn't exist. I hope they didn't have any federal grant funding for this (have skimmed half a dozen web postings about this and none really address this question).
- ScottBurson 15y agoYuck. The solstices and equinoxes would be on different dates from year to year. And as far as making time calculations simpler for financiers -- that extra week "every five or six years" will be just as hard to deal with as leap years are now.
- wiradikusuma 15y agoIn Malaysia, if holiday falls on Sunday, it'll be "carried forward" to Monday (you still celebrate on Sunday, but Monday will be extra holiday). And in some companies, if holiday falls on Saturday, you get extra 1 day leave entitlement. Now, you can see conflicting interest here, especially between employees and employers :)
- paxswill 15y agoSame for the federal government in the US.
- devolve 15y agoThis is not far from how most of Sweden operates. Most offices comply to the idea of "half-day before holiday" notion and as where fixing the dates wouldn't interfere with that too much, I doo believe that fixing Christmas to a Saturday would make a lot of Swedes angry. For one, we celebrate the 24th, and having the 25th on a Saturday sure gives Friday and half of Thursday off. But the 26th is also a holiday, which would then be on a regular Sunday. New Years Eve is not a holiday, and having that on a constant Friday would open the days between Christmas and NYE as a work week. Where as now some years you can have a nice long (10-14 days) vacation with only a couple days of actual leave, because the rest are considered national holidays. (Example: 2012 I can get 14 days off with only 5 days of leave.)
- masklinn 15y ago> Now, you can see conflicting interest here, especially between employees and employers :) Why would there be a conflict of interest? The point is that employees always get the same number of "days off" per year is it not? The conflict of interest would arise in countries where holidays are not carried forward (or stashed in leave entitlements), employers interest would be to have all of them fall on week-ends, whereas employee interest would be to have all of them fall on week-days. Or did I miss something?
- Navarr 15y agoI love this idea, but there are a few things that aren't covered in the comments that I want to know about. 1) How does this calendar align to the phases of the moon? How many moons are there per-year? Is this variable? This is important due to archaic calendar systems and dates that are based on solar-lunar calendars (e.g. China & Japan) 2) Is there a quick and easy algorithm for re-mapping dates? My birthday was on Mar 30, 1991 - for example. Would I simply keep the old date, or adopt a new one? I assume keep the old since its still on the calendar, but what about people born January 31st? 3) How do seasons align and fluctuate along these new datelines? And how does this floating week influence it?
- clvv 15y agoPeople can accomplish the same thing after learning a mental algorithm to calculate the day of the week. Doomsday rule, invented by Mathematician John Conway, is one of the easier ones to remember.
- vorg 15y ago> "You have a whole area in the mathematics of finance that could be cleared up, and lots of confusion, lots of error, done away with by going to this calendar," he said. People don't realize the time they're wasting simply because of the variable calendar, Hanke said. Most economic and political activity in Western countries is to give people something to do so they'll conform, be it accounting and tax rules, legal requirements, or ICT interfaces. The actual labor required to mine resources, manufacture things, and grow and distribute food is some small percentage of overall economic activity. Taking away this complexity would put people out of work, more likely to question governments or occupy Wall Street.
- shimon_e 15y agoSo in a matter of a few thousand years we have gone from Emperors (Caesar) dictating calendars to scientists proposing new ones. :) These type of reforms were quiet popular in the beginning of the 20th century. E.g. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_World_Calendar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_World_Calendar Had this proposal been suggested a century ago. I would have a good feeling it would have been made a reality since it doesn't interfere with a 7 day work weak. Today with computers, it isn't really necessary. Anyone is able to check when July 1st will be in 2500 without calculating. So it is not likely to gain to much interest except in by theorists. This proposal introduces an artificial calendar that is neither solar or lunar but realigns every few years. It is quiet a novel idea. The Jews did similar engineering in their calendar system. The rabbis did not want some holidays to fall out on certain days of the week because of varied reasons. So they engineered rules for the leap years and new months to happen in a pattern to prevent this. The Jewish calendar is lunar but realigns itself with the solar calendar. It need to be certain Jewish holidays always accure in the same season.
- gus_massa 15y agoThe former calendars were proposed by scientists, but named after the ruler that forced them: Julian: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julian_calendar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julian_calendar "The Julian calendar began in 45 BC (709 AUC) as a reform of the Roman calendar by Julius Caesar. It was chosen after consultation with the astronomer Sosigenes of Alexandria and was probably designed to approximate the tropical year (known at least since Hipparchus)." Gregorian: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gregorian_calendar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gregorian_calendar "The Gregorian calendar reform contained two parts, a reform of the Julian calendar as used up to Pope Gregory's time, [...]. The reform was a modification of a proposal made by the Calabrian doctor Aloysius Lilius (or Lilio)."
- shimon_e 15y agoInteresting. :) Any rulers out there want a calendar named after them?
- uiri 15y agoAll I can think of is xkcd 927 ( http://xkcd.com/927/ http://xkcd.com/927/ ) There are already lots of calendars if one cares to look. Why bother with a 7 day week other than the biblical mandate? Why not use a lunar calendar? It would certainly simplify 'calculating' Easter. Having a leap day is a lot less intrusive than a leap week and does anyone actually bother to memorize the Metonic cycle? Is it because lunisolar calendars are uncommon or because they're a pain or both? I think having timezones benefits us in the sense that we can say "It is lunch in city A when it is dinner in city B". Knowing when people are likely to be sleeping/working/playing in different places helps more than having One Timezone. Pilots use UTC because they're between timezones too much for them to follow a 'standard' schedule according to our approximations of the Sun's movements.
- Sorpigal 15y agoCompliance with biblical mandates is a popularity hack. You need popularity if you want a new calendar to be adopted (or you need massive power on the level of an emperor^Wdictator.
- tylerneylon 15y agoI've been using an independent calendar for my own records for over a decade now - it's the day-of-year, written base 7. It fits in with weeks; if we reset weeks every year (why not? we do worse things already with leap days and seconds) then dates become equivalent with weekdays. One number expresses the day-of-year, day-of-week, week-of-year, and month-of-year, using a 49-day month. http://tylerneylon.com/b/archives/122 http://tylerneylon.com/b/archives/122 I don't really expect many other people to use this, despite being a better designed system. I think hardcore math/cs people would like it, though. I've written some small pieces of code that work with this system, if anyone's interested.
- graywh 15y agoIf everything is a 0-based index (e.g. first day being 0), why aren't the years?
- tylerneylon 15y agoThe 7date doesn't say much about how we count years. It's all about how you count days and other sub-year units. You could combine it with any method of counting years that you like. I defaulted to using the year system I'm used to because it's convenient.
- js2 15y agoLovely, the Esperanto of calendars. It's bad enough my birthday falls on Christmas Eve, now it's forever to be on the Sabbath too? No thanks.
- vorg 15y agoSome people, groups, or governments could change over on a case-by-case basis to a week-based system, without a sudden change to the worldwide date system. Just label the weeks with numbers, e.g. 1-Wednesday, 27-Monday, or 52-Sunday for Christmas this year. It seems Chinese people generally don't remember the time of week so much as the Month and date. Whenever someone in China tells me "this is happening on the 28 November", in my mind I have to work out what day of week it is before I can internalize it in my memory. Chinese seem to just remember the month and date. Schools often say "Monday's and Tuesday's timetable will be shifted to the previous Saturday and Sunday, respectively". And of course their idea is Western-centric. Chinese and Muslims both have their own calendars for festivals.
- shimon_e 15y agoThat is because most the Chinese are hard working and do not work on a 7 day work week. Most Chinese get X days off per month or X days per 10 days if more than 3 days off per month. Not X days per week. I believe most Ayis get 1 day off per month. Factory workers 1 day off per 10 days. Office workers 1 day off per week. Actually, with the bigger factories their workers are getting 1 day off per week (e.g. established textile factories, foxconn, etc.).
- knowknowledge 15y agoI don't know how popular this is at other companies, but Intel (or at least my group) does use a week-based system for all dates. Today (December 28) would be "WW53.3". WW53 is the work week and .3 means Wednesday. Weeks start on Monday as ".1", whereas Sunday is ".0" and Saturday is ".6". While this system should in theory make it easy to calculate the days need to complete a task, I still find myself converting to Month-Day every time. On the other hand, I don't have a clue what day of the week March 2nd is going to be, but if it's called WW9.5, then I immediately know that it's on a Friday 9 weeks from now.
- Navarr 15y agoI just pointed this out to a friend and she gladly brought up the Shire calendar from Tolkien's works, which according to her has 12 months, 30 days a month, 7 days a week, 365 days a year with the date of each month staying the same weekday due to the separation of the five other days as holidays that are separate from the months (including leap-day, which doesn't belong to any day of the week). Which actually solves the exact same problem in a much cleaner fashion than this proposal.
- ndefinite 15y agowow, I like it more: http://shire-reckoning.com/calendar http://shire-reckoning.com/calendar. We're already used to stat holidays; "Days of Yule" are much less intrusive than leap weeks
- ars 15y agoNo it doesn't. Making a day not be part of any week breaks the strict 7 day cycle, and will be rejected be the vast majority of the world.
- Sorpigal 15y agoThe real innovation in this calendar, which I don't rememebr seeing in previous perpetual calendar proposals, is the system for 7-day-week seasonal drift adjustment. Adding an "extra" 5 days to every year is much more common, but not popular. What I can't figure out is what algorithm they use to calculate when to add an extra week. It seems slightly irregular, but I asssume there must be a simple formula I could use in a date library to account for it.
- Navarr 15y agoWell, with 364 days that means there's 1.25 days pushed into the buffer every year. That means that the buffer would be full (mathematically) every 5.6 years hence the "every five or six years." In order to keep general season alignment, I figure they vary between the two. This decimal doesn't go away until after 28 years - so I assume some combination of fives and sixes that add up to 28. Lets say three sixes and two fives. (18+10). So in order to make any pattern they might do something like 6 5 6 5 6 6 5 6 5 6. And now, looking at the leap years, I think my theory is confirmed: 2015-2020 (5) 2020-2026 (6) 2026-2032 (6) 2032-2037 (5) 2037-2043 (6) 2043-2048 (5) 2048-2054 (6) 2054-2060 (6)
- scythe 15y agoWhy preserve the seven-day week? The appropriate factorization of 365 is 73*5. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discordian_calendar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discordian_calendar Plus, the Discordian calendar has the advantage of already being implemented in Linux!
- notatoad 15y agoif you read the linked article, you see the explanation: the fourth commandment specifies resting on the seventh day. any proposed calendar that doesn't have a seven day week will never be adopted as long as religion still exists. and even if it weren't for religion, everything is structured around a seven day week. changing that would mean a drastic lifestyle change for most people.
- LaGrange 15y agoThen make the week 73 days long. You can rest on 7th day, and corporations would really like it.
- fl3tch 15y agoThis would be great if we had already achieved the 1950s dream of the three-day work week.
- mbreese 15y agoI'd like to know how much extra complexity these leap weeks add to the calculations that would supposedly be easier... I would imagine that it is non-trivial. Am I the only one that likes the fact that dates occur on different days? This way everyone's birthday will occur over a weekend every few years.
- fullsailor 15y agoWhat would happen with birthdays that occur on days that were cut out of the new calendar? Jan 31, May 31, Jul 31, Aug 31, and Oct 31. Also, that extra week business seems more confusing than leap years. "Every 5 or 6 years" seems indefinite.
- wavephorm 15y agoA more simple solution is to have 13 months of exactly 28 days, plus one day for new years day. That's even better because every month is exactly the same number of days which means semi-monthly and bi-weekly billing systems are the same thing. And because there's the same number of days anything billed per month can be easily prorated per day, and any billing cycle will match up with every other billing cycle... so basically everything imaginable becomes considerably easier. The only real problem is coming up with a name for a new 13th month and where to insert it.
- divtxt 15y agoPretty nice! Too bad a non-trivial segment of the population won't be happy with 13. You might as well call the new month Deviluary. :D
- bhrgunatha 15y agoSatanber?
- Quequau 15y agoWell, then they can all hide indoors for the month ala the ancient Incans and the rest of us can create some sort of new sort of month long Saturnalia/Yule/Winter Solstice remix. We could even send a Krampus to go rattle their doors and windows on the appropriate day.
- gnosis 15y agoJust skip 13 and make it the 14th month.
- silon4 15y agoOr the zeroth month.
- mooism2 15y agoThis breaks quarterly cycles.
- ww520 15y agoThis is interesting but the leap weeks are kind of fussy, 5 or 6 years.
- ndefinite 15y agoYeah the week long adjustment every so often seems excessive
- lambda 15y agoHave they come up with any estimate of the global cost of the switch, and compared that to the benefit of the new calendar? It seems to change a bunch of stuff, and add a complicated new "leap week", for no particularly good reason. Yeah, it might reduce the cost of printing calendars slightly, though a lot of people use new calendars yearly so they can write on them, and a lot more just use their computer. The cost of the transition would not be insignificant. In the Western world, we've had two major calendar changes in the past 2200 years or so. The most recent one, the transition from the Julian calendar to the Gregorian calendar, lasted for about 400 years, as different countries transitioned at different times, with, I'm sure, plenty of friction caused by the lack of synchronization. Is it really necessary to go through all of that again? Also, while this proposal would make holidays based on the solar calendar fall on the same day every year, it would do nothing for the holidays based on the lunar calendar. They would still drift around. Reading their proposal on cato.org linked to from the article, it seems that a large part of their motivation is the synchronization of calendars for various financial instruments. But that doesn't require changing everyone's calendar; you can fix just the financial instruments, which already don't follow the ordinary calendar, without wreaking havoc on every other use of the calendar. And I'm not sure how this extra week in December ever few years is supposed to help solve the problems with financial instruments. Under the current system, you need to deal with the fact that months may differ in length by up to 3 days, and that needs to be dealt with every month; in the new system, months would regularly vary by 1 day, but suddenly vary by another 7 days once every 5 years or so. I think one of the reasons we've gotten ourselves into this mess is that we keep on trying to fit together different cycles of arbitrary length such that they match up exactly, which is impossible, so we add hacks on top of hacks to try to fix the problem. We try to make the cycle of days match the cycles of years, we try to make the cycle of months match the cycle of days (and years), and this proposal tries to shoehorn the cycle of weeks into that too, with a hack that adds an extra week every 5 or 6 years seemingly at random (while there is a regular rule for it, it's not as easily remembered as the Gregorian "leap year every 4 years, except for years divisible by 100, but an exception to that exception for years divisible by 400"). Instead of trying to do hacks to get all of these cycles to line up, why not move in the other direction and take the approach of having regular cycles at different frequencies that do not line up? You can have a financial calendar of 30 solar days (or whatever period is most convenient for you), a lunar calendar of one lunar month, the 7 solar day week, the tropical year that aligns with the seasons, the sidereal year that aligns with the orbit of the earth around the sun (which differs from the tropical year due to precession of the earth's axis). We have computers that can keep track of how all of these things line up when we care these days; instead of trying to simplify everything to fit together discretely with hacks added to fix it up, just let the computers deal with the precise details and allow each cycle to be simple and independent. Now, moving to a single worldwide time standard (just use UTC for everyone for everyday use) seems to make a little more sense. While I understand the desire to make the hours line up with the solar day in a reasonably uniform way around the world, timezones (and daylight savings time) are an ugly hack that add a lot of cost and give you only a very rough approximation of what you are trying to achieve.
- codex 15y agoI am still typing on a QWERTY keyboard, and that standard only a hundred years old. The modern calendar is two thousand years old. We will see the singularity before we see a new calendar.
- mooism2 15y agoThe modern calendar is nearly 430 years old, but I agree with your broader point. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gregorian_calendar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gregorian_calendar
- kellenfujimoto 15y agoThe whole "everybody should adopt UTC" business makes no sense to me. If a business needs to use UTC because of time zones or whatnot, they already are. It'd be weird having the day of the week change in the middle of the day in Japan, too.
- vacri 15y agoThat's an excellent point: "We'll need to be ready by Tuesday morning"... does morning mean 'sunrise' or does it mean 'time near where Tuesday 'starts'?
- tersiag 15y agoMy bday would always fall on a Monday on this calendar system and that is not fun
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- xoxa 15y agoI saw something along these lines recently: a calendar-clock. http://clackcolander.tumblr.com/ http://clackcolander.tumblr.com/
- teja1990 15y agoI dont like this. All the people who have b'days on 29,30 and 31 are screwed. And its really hard to get whole of the world onto it. No country can force another country to follow something.
- vacri 15y agoThey would drop the quadrennial 366-day leap years entirely in favor of an extra week at the end of December every five or six years. and The two men also propose eliminating time zones and adopting a universal time around the world to streamline international business. indicate that there are some fundamental things they don't understand about business.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- hmottestad 15y agoHow about just sticking to using the week number and the day of the week.
- hogu 15y agowhat if your birthday is on that leap week that occurs every 5-6 yrs?
- eigenvector 15y agoYou would probably do exactly what people who are born on February 29 do.
- throw_away 15y agoI wonder what these leap year babies (I am one of them) would do were we to adopt this new calendar, as presumably that date would no longer exist.
- Sorpigal 15y agoFor people who are apparently enlightened enough to realize that no calendar, however rational and perfect, will be accepted if it violates a certain religious rule (the sabbath), they are apparently quite ignorant in their advocacy of UTC for all purposes. It's all well and good to eliminate time zones as such and have each region operate on a fixed clock, but to suggest that people will simply stop paying attention to the sun is insane. If you want wide adoption you can't expect people to make radical change in their lives. Most people prefer to wake with the sun and sleep when it's dark; some studies suggest that we are biologically predisposed to want or need this. Whether it's 05:00 when I wake or 16:00 when I wake is immaterial to me (that's just a number, just what you call it) but whether it's daylight when I'm out and about just plain matters. In effect you'll probably always need a way to divide the world by when the sun is up, even if the clock doesn't change.
- colanderman 15y agoI'm pretty sure they're not advocating screwing with the Circadian cycle. You still wake up and go to sleep with the sun; just now you wake up at 13h00 instead of 8:00 AM.
- Sorpigal 15y agoRead it again, they are. Quote from the proposal: "For example, the adoption of Universal Time would give new flexibility to economic management in the vast East-West expanse of Russia: everyone would know exactly what time it is everywhere, at every moment. Opening and closing times of businesses could be specified for every class of business and activity. If thought desirable, banks and financial institutions throughout the country could be required to open and to close each day at the same hour by the world time. This would mean that bank employees in the far East of Russia would start work with the sun well up in the sky, while bank employees in the far west of Russia would be at their desks before the sun has risen. " The article omits this in its summary.
- fr0sty 15y agoA world in which the state mandates that your work day begins before the sun rises... Where do I sign up?? sarcasm off
- jstclair 15y agoCould someeone who is advocating for no time zones please explain how a normal work "day" that crossed actual days work in practice? So you want to wake up at 8 Utc and some else wakes up at 20 Utc. Ok, then they start work on Friday at 21 Utc and work until Sat 4:30. I'd imagine that you'd have to redefine weekend to mean Sun-Mon?
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoImagine living on a space ark. Any calendar would work, since there would be no incentive to line up with the motion of any particular planetary body. Now, imagine we stopped caring about that anyway. Ok, leave days, but the rest? Superfluous. How about decimal time? 100,000 seconds in a day, count days and be done with it. When is Xmas? In 300 days.
- mrpollo 15y agoWill this be somehow comparable to the Y2K bug if we switch? a bunch of software broken?
- bumbledraven 15y agoSo the dates of the first "extra week" would be Dec 32-38, 2015?
- texjer 15y agoI never remember if we have 30 days or 31 in most months... nope, actually I got everything right except for May and March. http://www.calendarzone.org/calendar/2012-calendar-10.jpg http://www.calendarzone.org/calendar/2012-calendar-10.jpg
- nostrademons 15y agoHere's a trick for that (courtesy of Shari Lewis): hold your knuckles up in front of you, index fingers together, no thumbs. Each peak represents a month with 31 days. Each valley represents a month with 30 (or 28, for February) days.