7 ms·
No amount of document release is gonna convince anyone. "It's in the one they didn't release" or "there are some they're pretending don't exist".
by ceejayoz 4y ago
No amount of document release is gonna convince anyone. "It's in the one they didn't release" or "there are some they're pretending don't exist".
- sonotathrowaway 4y agoThe more interesting event to me is that the balance of evidence on MLK’s assassination shows that he was murdered in an operation coordinated between the FBI and the Memphis police and mafia.
- 082349872349872 4y agoHe had been proposing levying the mutual-assistance form of economic sanctions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34013751 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34013751 , after all.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dwater 4y agoTo those downvoting because they think this comment is baseless: "The Loyd Jowers Trial (officially the King family vs. Loyd Jowers and other unknown co-conspirators) was an American civil suit brought by the family of Martin Luther King Jr. against Loyd Jowers, following his claims of a conspiracy in the assassination of the civil rights leader in 1968. The jury would eventually decide in 1999 that there was a conspiracy perpetrated by Jowers and other conspirators." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loyd_Jowers_trial https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loyd_Jowers_trial
- Aunche 4y agoRegardless of the merits of the MLK assassination conspiracy theory, this trial definitely discredits the theory more than it helps. It's clear that it was designed to be a public spectacle. Jowers had continuously changed his story prior to this trial. The FBI certainly didn't pay the equivalent of nearly a million present-day dollars to a random restaurateur, to help them kill a completely unguarded civilian.
- sonotathrowaway 4y agoClaiming he was unguarded conveniently ignores some very relevant details. Like the fact MLK was guarded by a contingent of black Memphis policemen every time he visited Memphis. On the visit he was murdered, those policemen were pulled from that guard duty for reasons never explained. There’s a very good podcast, The MLK Files, investigating the conspiracy surrounding his killing - one of those black policemen was interviewed on the podcast, along with many other people. Some other inconvenient facts about his assassination are the facts that the rifle claimed to be used in the killing is physically incapable of firing the bullet that killed MLK, a fact recorded in the FBI ballistics report along with a note that the gun should never be re-tested. The other interesting fact is the man convicted of the killing adamantly denies pulling the trigger, but acknowledges being part of the conspiracy- which is why he pled guilty. Prior to the killing he escaped from jail, and was provided a fake US passport by other conspirators to help him smuggle items from Canada to the US. And this is only scratching the surface, there is so much more documented information on the killing, like the relationship between Hoover’s #2 and his known relationship with the Dixie Mafia that dominated Memphis at the time. Since you seem to have a familiarity with Jowers, I’d encourage you to listen to the podcast. Jowers testimony is discussed, but it is far from the only piece of evidence examined. It’s not even the main evidence cited, there are a lot of other witnesses whose testimony was never examined or who were threatened into silence.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Some other inconvenient facts about his assassination are the facts that the rifle claimed to be used in the killing is physically incapable of firing the bullet that killed MLK, a fact recorded in the FBI ballistics report along with a note that the gun should never be re-tested. These are the sorts of facts that would heavily benefit from a reputable citation. The closest thing to your assertion on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_F._Kennedy_assassination_rifle#FBI_tests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_F._Kennedy_assassination_... is that it'd be hard to sight because of some missing metal shims, which may've been lost while in FBI posession rather than in Oswald's.
- 4y ago
- pseudo0 4y agoSo they sued the guy claiming the conspiracy existed, not the government, because the government would have mounted a real defense? That trial sounds like a farce, as the two parties were in agreement and just wanted that conclusion on the record.
- steve76 4y ago[dead]
- mjd 4y ago
- aliqot 4y ago
- mjd 4y agoThis is an unhelpful response because it doesn't say what you want me to stop. I say to you: this is not Reddit, and I have been here twenty times as long as you have, so please assume a little more good faith on my part.
- highwaylights 4y agoI don't think parent's post was trying to propagate that conspiracy theory (they're saying even producing the document didn't stop the tinfoil hat people).
- mjd 4y agoThat was what I meant. If the Obama birth certificate release didn't satisfy the birthers—and it didn't—nothing will satisfy the JFK conspiracists. Because the original situation is much more complex, and because the conspiracists have had much more time to entrnch themselves in their theories.
- aliqot 4y ago
- jdhdjdbdjdbd 4y ago
- _justinfunk 4y ago"convince anyone" of what?
- ceejayoz 4y agoThat it wasn't the CIA, or the Russians, or the lizard people, or that JFK isn't secretly still alive in hiding. Take your pick, there are a lot, some more absurd than others. One or more might even be true, but they aren't going to release the proof of that.
- snapcaster 4y agoI don't know why the mockery is required. There are some very weird "coincidences" with his assassination and the idea of a political ruler being assassinated in a conspiracy is something that has happened countless times. I think it's in bad faith to lump CIA based theories (they have killed countless people and overthrown so many governments) with shit like lizard people
- ceejayoz 4y agoNo mockery; whichever theory someone subscribes to, no matter how plausible, nothing's going to prove a negative here. If you believe there's a secret about who did it being kept here in the docs, you believe they'll never release that specific document or documents.
- noslenwerdna 4y agoCan you specify the coincidences? This conspiracy has been written about to death, and the mainstream theory that Oswald assassinated him is the only one that makes any sense.
- HideousKojima 4y agoOne of the more mainstream/less out there ones is that the mafia supposedly had nothing to do with the assassination but a known member of the mafia just happened to kill Oswald before he could stand trial. The idea being that Oswald was hired by the mafia, and they had Jack Ruby kill Oswald to prevent him from revealing their involvement.
- beepbooptheory 4y agoI do like, unbeknownst to OP, that this statement could be speaking for either side at this point.
- ceejayoz 4y agoNo, there's a significant difference between "prove something happened" and "prove something didn't happen". If there's a document in there detailing a conspiracy by the CIA to kill JFK, and it gets released someday, a lot of people are going to be convinced. It's less true in the other direction.
- highwaylights 4y agoI think it’s more “I’ll believe you if you say what I already believe, otherwise you must be a liar”.
- seanw444 4y agoHave you seen the documents they released in the past? There are so many redactions. They are undoubtedly hiding something deemed too sensitive for the public.
- beepbooptheory 4y agoI guess I don't understand your distinction here on purely logical terms, why the uneven burden of proof? The Warren Report is just that, a report written by humans. Even if you firmly want to believe it, if you read it you'd understand its not really doing anything differently than the tin-foil heads and their books (of the better ones at least). It did not create the reality of its hypothesis along with it, it can't really know what Oswald was thinking.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> I guess I don't understand your distinction here on purely logical terms, why the uneven burden of proof? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell%27s_teapot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell%27s_teapot It's possible that "yep, it was a conspiracy" will be confirmed if new data is found/released. That's something it's possible to prove. It's not possible to prove there wasn't a conspiracy.
- jasmer 4y agoThe fact that they continue to release more stuff over and over gives very legitimate credence to the notion they are hiding something. It seems clear they don't want us to know something. Now, it could be more or less political, or personal, or something ultimately mundane, but the conspiracy theorists can make it anything they want of it. I suggest there might have been something really complicated wherein nobody could point the finger fully at any group, but that the CIA was doing something sketchy, funding the wrong people, Johnson new about it but only in superficial terms, someone somewhere took it too far, it got out of hand and that the truth is just too damaging to the state (and various agencies) itself so they want to keep it hidden.
- kolinko 4y ago> The fact that they continue to release more stuff over and over gives very legitimate credence to the notion they are hiding something. "If they are innocent they would not to fight the charges so much"
- jasmer 4y agoThis is a false equivalence. If an innocent person held some information in their literal pocket, that they could very simply reveal to the world, at no cost to themselves, which proved their innocence of some crime unambiguously - but refused to do so and instead chose to stand trial for some offence - it would be entirely rational to be suspect. This is why in some cases 'pleading the 5th' can be considered as evidence towards guilt. The government is more than aware of the vast conspiracies surrounding the incident, not only do they have a responsibility towards transparency in any event, it's even more important in this case. There's a 100% chance they are hiding something - otherwise they wouldn't hide it. So the question boils down to only what they are hiding: mundane administrative information? or 'The CIA did it!'? I suggest it's more towards the former than the later, but not all the way. I'm put it at 90% chance there were at least some shenanigans, but I don't think it was as bad as 'the CIA ordered his death' kind of thing. But there were shenanigans.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- TheRealDunkirk 4y agoThey confirmed the existence of a conspiracy with the Warren Report, and the endorsement of the idea that there was a single-shooter, explained by the so-called magic bullet. I still can't wrap my head around the fact that The Most Serious People in the government signed their names to something that any 12 year old who's shot a .22 caliber rifle would know is utter, complete, and irredeemable nonsense. All the rest is window dressing. That's all you need. And, after sealing the deal, there's only one organization which could have been responsible, by sheer power (to get SCOTUS and POTUS to go along with it), and motivation (standard MIC motivation of endless war in SE Asia).
- SuperFine 4y ago
- treebeard901 4y ago> And, after sealing the deal, there's only one organization which could have been responsible, by sheer power, and motivation. There is a ton of circumstantial evidence backing this theory? up too. The goal seemed to be to gain control over a Government organization that since the 30s had grown to act with basically no oversight. They were an international group with enormous power and wanted to keep that power and expand it. The Kennedy administration was trying to provide that oversight and roll it back. The Bay of Pigs and the continued oversight along with the belief that Kennedy was somehow a Catholic communist sympathizer with connections to Russia. It's really fascinating to read those accusations in hind sight. Then consider that after Kennedy, Nixon was very friendly towards the supranational intelligence service and after Carter, the CIA Director was even Reagan's VP, then became President himself for four years. He lost the next election to someone with clear CIA ties from the drug running happening in Arkansas as he was governor. The story behind the movie American Made is incredible. So, Bill Clinton then became President for 8 years with many of this same group from the Defense Dept and CIA who had been in executive power for decades. Rumsfeld, Bush, Clintons, etc. Bipartisan even... So what do you get after the Clintons? Another Bush who had control for 8 years. Then consider how history might have been different if Kennedy was able to reign in the CIA, work with the Soviet Union to avoid escalation in Vietnam and then maybe the executive branch would not have been captured by CIA linked people for over the next few decades. Anyway, we will all likely never know the full story but all of this seems more than plausible to me. End rant!
- starkd 4y agoWell, releasing ALL the documents would be a good start. Seeing as how it is over 50 years after the fact, when all of the principles are now dead, that should not be too much to ask.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Seeing as how it is over 50 years after the fact, when all of the principles are now dead, that should not be too much to ask. Henry Kissinger is 99. Plenty of people from that era are still alive. More importantly, if there's information on specific CIA informants in there, their networks and the people they recruited may well have survived them.
- toomanyrichies 4y agoNot to mention locations of safe houses, organizational / reporting structures of CIA stations, techniques for cultivating assets, etc. There are plenty of above-board reasons for not doing a full and complete release of all docs. To paraphrase Pulp Fiction, "When you conspiracy theorists get together, you're worse than a sewing circle."
- tgflynn 4y agoKeeping the same safe houses or reporting structures in place for 60 years seems like it would be terrible OPSEC. The IC is very good at coming up with plausible sounding explanations for why they have to keep secrets that the masses will believe without question but that don't stand up to deeper reflection. I suspect the remaining redactions are because they're waiting for certain people to pass away. Probably not major players but there could be people who were in their 20's or 30's in 1963 who had some knowledge of what happened. Once they've all died off it will be forever impossible to prove anything because anything really damning would never have been written down or the records would have been destroyed years ago.
- orangepurple 4y agoI don't think they'll release the truth until after Felix Rodriguez passes. He's still killing people in 2013. Batista wasn't enough to satisfy his thirst for murder.
- 2devnull 4y agoI disagree. There are enough facts already to conclude that powerful forces have tried to obfuscate facts surrounding the assassination. What that means is unclear because that’s how muddying the waters works. But only a fool would buy the official narrative. It may be very close to the truth but there are too many unexplainable aspects to not think there is more to what happened that the average person believes. That may be different now since people trust journalists and government less. It’s clear the let Oswald get shot. And the bullet? It’s a joke.