2 ms·
> > Since this is behaviour Google is already doing > How so? Using a different browser on google.com or youtube.com has many times shown me ads claiming that
by acdha 4y ago
> > Since this is behaviour Google is already doing
> How so?
Using a different browser on google.com or youtube.com has many times shown me ads claiming that the web is better using Chrome.
Google Cloud's console frequently breaks for non-Chrome users.
YouTube for many years used a non-standard API which only Chrome optimized instead of the standard one which all three implemented, which meant that video playback used far more CPU on other browsers.
YouTube for many years favored WebM format at the expense of video quality and performance.
Google Meet for years would drop sessions for Firefox or Safari. No other WebRTC service had problems with those browsers.
> Chrome's market share destroys every Webkit-based browser combined.
Yes, that's the point. Chrome would not have gotten so far ahead of Firefox and WebKit without both a huge financial push and heavy promotion on Google's most popular web properties.
- smoldesu 4y agoSo, Google builds around Chrome. That's fine. Apple has every right to implement those non-standard APIs that Google uses (Microsoft fought Oracle for that right), and they could feasibly hack in workarounds for all of these problems if they cared or had to compete with Chrome in the first place. We'll have to see where things go after Apple starts playing nice. I support legislation that restricts Chrome only if Apple doesn't stand to directly profit from it.
- acdha 4y agoIt's not that Google builds around Chrome as much as they use their control of things which are unrelated to Chrome to promote Chrome. Right now, Apple favors their browser on iOS and Google favors theirs everywhere. I fully support consumer choice so I think the right answer would be iOS supporting other browsers and Google not being allowed to promote their browser in unrelated apps. If Chrome is actually so much better, they don't need to interrupt a YouTube or Gmail user's session to tell them.
- smoldesu 4y agoThen we're at something of an impasse. Apple also promotes their own browser on MacOS, so it's not like they're innocent of this too. Having more options is simply a greater priority than stopping $COMPANY from cross-promoting a browser.
- acdha 4y agoYou have to think about what happens next. Google pushing Chrome on users of their web apps has successfully put Firefox into what appears to be a fatal downward spiral, and has lead to more developers only supporting Chrome. Microsoft stopped trying to fight that and created Edge-on-Chromium. Safari on iOS has been the primary thing keeping web development from being Chrome development and if you care about the web or open standards you want to think about what happens if that changes.
- smoldesu 4y agoOpen Standards had their shot, Apple turned their back on them. It doesn't matter at this point what happens, because both companies have proven that they need government intervention to do the right thing. If Apple doesn't want to build a Chrome competitor, then that's not Google's fault. Both companies are refusing to give up their strangleholds, and should be prosecuted accordingly. First and foremost though, Apple needs to be litigated. The rights of the user should supercede the petty combat between browser developers.
- vehemenz 4y agoIt seems a bit strong to suggest the "rights of the user" are in question here, when no one is being forced to use an Apple phone. It's happening everywhere in this thread, and I'm a bit surprised why more people don't recognize that consumers already have rights and a choice. It's called Android.
- halostatue 4y agoIt is untrue that Apple turned their back on open standards. What is true is that Google has hijacked the standards body and has pushed things as "standards" that nobody except Google wants (WebUSB anyone?) and have significant downsides for user security and privacy. WebKit has flat-out refused to implement standards that impose risks greater than their benefit. So has Firefox. It would help if you argued on the facts, not on your emotion.
- pessimizer 4y ago> I support legislation that restricts Chrome only if Apple doesn't stand to directly profit from it. Why would you connect how these two different companies should be treated? Sculpting regulation to attempt to engineer an outcome institutionalizing the current market balance between two oligarchs is just about the opposite of what I want any regulator doing.
- smoldesu 4y agoYou don't litigate Carnegie Steel before preventing Rockefeller from directly profiting off it. Monopoly-busting 101.