9 ms·
Tesla Market Cap falls below $500B
- michaelmcdonald 4y agoPast 12 months has seen a hefty decrease in the value of $TSLA (~50%, it's 60% if you look at just 2022). I've read numerous reports about Tesla quality (fit / finish), the FSD is receiving horrid reviews, and that's not even bringing into the equation Musk and his antics. Can't say I'm surprised to see the stock taking a hit and hope it doesn't dissuade companies from continuing down the EV path.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoTesla is massively profitable. The vagaries of the stock market are just a distraction, what matters is profits, and Tesla has lots of that. Other companies will want some of those sweet profits too.
- throwawaymanbot 4y ago
- loeg 4y agoIt makes a lot of profit but it has an irrational P/E ratio well in excess of other automakers (49 for TSLA vs 11 for TM).
- snovv_crash 4y agoHow about if you factor in the last 10 years of marketshare trajectory and then extrapolate a little?
- philjohn 4y agoPast performance is not an indictor of future performance. VW is on pace to outsell Tesla in a little over a year, they're just one competitor. I now see just as many Polestars and VW id's as Tesla's in the UK ... it's quite remarkable how much things have changed from Tesla being the only real game in town just a few short years ago.
- JumpinJack_Cash 4y agoMusk doesn't exactly strike me as a guy who would not cook the books. Guy believes in manifestation and self-fulfilling prophecies, fake it till you make it type strategy. General Electric employed the same strategy too with all its financial engineering but at the end of the day you are still making turbines in the real world and with anything manufacturing you have razor thin margins. Of course we came to know about it only after
- _hypx 4y agoAgreed.
- twawaaay 4y agoShare price reflects expectation of future profits and growth. When you buy a share you do not care about the profits in the past, you care that the company will generate profits and thus increase its value in the future. The only reason people care about past profitability is in how it can help you predict future profitability. This is also the reason why companies can be generating losses quarter after quarter and still be gaining value -- as long as there exists expectation of future growth and profit. And in case of Tesla a lot of this expectation of future profits and growth was based on charisma of its owner and on belief that he is the force behind Tesla's spectacular success. Starting one successful company is impressive but can be partly attributed to luck. Starting multiple hugely successful global multi-hundred billion dollar companies is not luck at all, especially when you spend a moment learning about Elon's work ethic and his tight grip over everything. Now, if you are an investor, it seems the owner lost its focus and made a bunch of questionable decisions. This puts a huge question mark on whether he will be as involved and as effective with Tesla in the future.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kjksf 4y ago> in case of Tesla a lot of this expectation of future profits and growth was based on charisma of its owner Not even a little bit. Musk has a charisma of a bag of potatoes. What matters is that Tesla had 10 years of 50%+ revenue and unit growth, on average. They performed better than any of the FAANG companies. With Giga Berlin and Giga Texas ramping up, Cybertruck, refreshing Model 3 for lower cost of production, ramping 4680 battery production, lithium refinery in Texas, Inflation Reduction Act in US => the 50% growth the company is guiding for in the next several years seems to be in the bank.
- twawaaay 4y agoWhat charisma is depends on the person. It is defined as ability to induce devotion in others and different people will get moved by different things. Charisma is not an absolute and objective measure. Some people will find Trump charismatic to them, some people will see him completely opposite. I personally find Warren Buffett very charismatic, some people will probably see him as an old and wrinkled guy who is boring them with stories they don't care about. As investors are generally mostly interested in money, ability to get shit done and generate profits reliably IS charisma.
- danuker 4y agoA Tesla share is $159.32, and its EPS for the last 12 months is $3.61 [1]. That means 2.3% per year. A Toyota share is $145.55, and its EPS for the same period is $16.82 [2]. That means 11.6% per year. [1] - https://companiesmarketcap.com/tesla/eps/ https://companiesmarketcap.com/tesla/eps/ [2] - https://companiesmarketcap.com/toyota/eps/ https://companiesmarketcap.com/toyota/eps/ If Tesla is massively profitable, Toyota is 5 times so.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoTesla's gross margin is 25%, Toyota's gross margin is 15%.
- makestuff 4y agoDo they still make a large portion of profit from selling carbon credits though?
- chroma 4y agoNo. In their latest filing[1], automotive regulatory credits are around 1% of revenue. 1. https://www.sec.gov/ix?doc=/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000095017022019867/tsla-20220930.htm https://www.sec.gov/ix?doc=/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/0000...
- hef19898 4y agoRevenue =|= profits. Now, if you are interested, devide what ever that revenue was by Tesla's profits. Because those credits have a zero cost behind them. And those credits will go away with every EV those other brands build and sell.
- chroma 4y agoIf you look at the SEC filing it's 8% of profits. Though Tesla isn't trying to be particularly profitable right now. They've been spending tons of money on new factories so they can scale up production.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sakopov 4y agoTesla's build quality never seemed to impact stock performance. I think Elon's takeover of Twitter has definitely been a big hit on Tesla stock. The main concern being his focus on all things Tesla, which appears to be shifting to Twitter.
- MildlySerious 4y ago> Tesla's build quality never seemed to impact stock performance. Tesla for a long time had a lack of serious competition, and a popular hype man at the helm that kept investor's eyes pointed at the future, by making promises such as "Fully self driving in 12-18 months" for a decade plus. With the age of pop culture hype taking a turn for Musk and Tesla, competition starting to look quite attractive, and the whole sector becoming more mature, attention is beginning to flow back to boring things like build quality.
- snovv_crash 4y agoWhich electric car can I buy that has similar range, similar charger infrastructure and is priced at a similar point to eg. Model 3? Genuinely curious, last time I checked everything non-Tesla was severely compromised somewhere.
- ok_dad 4y agoWhy do I care about those things if all I do is drive to town and back and I charge at home? Not everyone is a jet setting Bay Area resident who also drives to wine country every weekend. I would prefer a reliable Toyota over the quality issues plaguing Tesla, plus the poor working conditions at the factory put me off of ever buying a Tesla, for ethical reasons. I don’t care if the model 3 is gold plated and cheap, the company and product quality sucks.
- martyvis 4y agoMaybe Tesla has quality issues, but what car market doesn't (at least their wheels don't fall off - and I love Subaru). Have you actually looked whether the other manufacturers don't have issues with working conditions?
- porphyra 4y agoThe Model Y build quality is really good nowadays. And Tesla cars have great performance and ace all the safety tests. So they are still good cars that are undeserving of all the hate.
- zarkov99 4y agoPeople who hate Elon musk, which includes almost all of media, have no qualms about lying about Tesla in order to hurt it/him. In fact they might think is the right thing to do, for the sake of, well whatever. If you are interested in the ground truth, check the videos by owners, talk to people who use FSD and best of all see if you can rent and drive a Tesla yourself. Its sad to say, but even in tech we swim in an ocean of ideologically driven BS and not all of us have realized it yet.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- stephc_int13 4y agoElectric cars have a brilliant future. It seems that Elon Musk have over-promised and under-delivered repeatedly, including about Tesla; the market acted like it believed that everything he announced was going to happen. I would not be surprised if the majority of what he said was magical thinking. Given the actual business performance of Tesla compared to other automakers, what do you believe the stock value should be? I never tried a Tesla, but I've seen contradicting reports about the build quality and customer satisfaction, I think this is a relatively important heuristic to evaluate the potential of any consumer product.
- ghostpepper 4y agoThe biggest question in my mind is whether the electric cars from the traditional auto companies are profitable on their own, or are they being heavily subsidized by their fossil-fuel offerings
- themitigating 4y agoInitially wouldn't it be unprofitable as they are dealing with new technology?
- bmitc 4y agoHasn't Tesla been propped up over the years by government subsidies? What makes you think existing automakers can't have profitable EVs? Wouldn't it be easier for them to be profitable? They have existing supply chains, manufacturing, distribution, etc.
- xeromal 4y agoEvery subsidy Tesla has used has been offered to other manufacturers.
- snovv_crash 4y agoIt's funny, 5 years ago everyone was wondering if they would ever actually deliver the Model 3. 10 years ago they were digging themselves out of the e-Lotus hole. I'm not one to bet on volatile stocks, but if FSD ever becomes a thing, they're the only automaker actually capable of taking advantage of it. From a automotive market capitalisation perspective they're overpriced, but from a high growth tech focused company with their own manufacturing capabilities they really aren't. Toyota still doesn't have a 100% electric vehicle. VW still makes electric cars using chassis designed for ICEs. Meanwhile Tesla is on their Nth electric chassis/drive iteration. Yes, it's just engineering, but so was Apple vs BlackBerry. I think the correction in Tesla's prices are coming from increased interest rates and the risk inherent in growth stocks, not due to public sentiment about Musk, Twitter or anything else.
- mdorazio 4y agoAs it should given the realistic expected future sales potential, joke that is FSD, and increasingly competitive nature of the BEV market. When it falls another 50% it will be fairly priced (roughly on-par with Toyota's market cap).
- epolanski 4y agoI just don't see on which premise Tesla should be fairly priced if it is priced as Toyota, the biggest car manufacturer in the world.
- daveguy 4y agoAgreed. Now that Toyota and every other major auto manufacturer has a good electric vehicle, Tesla is one among many. Their current revenue vs growth potential should be priced accordingly. That likely means a much lower market share than Toyota.
- martyvis 4y agoI'd love to know which Toyota EV you are referring to? Ask a 100 people to name an EV, 80 would say Tesla, and 70 could point them out, and 40 name some model. Not so with Toyota
- thwayunion 4y agoThese days I see more plug-in Prius/RAV4 hybrids than Teslas. You can be an EV purist but they're competing for the same customers and plug-in hybrids also qualify for tax credits.
- daveguy 4y agoFair point. What I was thinking of is their line of pluggable hybrids. Where if you keep it plugged in at night it acts as all electric for a 16 mile each way commute. Prius Prime is their main PHEV but they are also making trucks and SUVs pluggable.
- oluwie 4y agoStill overvalued IMHO.
- citilife 4y agoThis year they appear poised to make $20B in gross profit, in contrast Toyota is poised to make $40B in gross profit... Toyota's market cap is <$200B Both likely will not continue to grow at the same pace with the dropping availability of capital to consumers. IMO a fair prices for Tesla is still going to be at Toyota's market cap or lower
- snovv_crash 4y agoYes, but Tesla's margins are much higher. This will probably drop if they ever manage to make a 90s Corolla equivalent and go downmarket, but it seems they still sell as much as they can make for the moment.
- denimnerd42 4y agoToyota weighs the cost of running individual wires (as a part of the harness) when building the Yaris. The margins are that hard at the low end. Adding any small tiny feature is hard due to the cost they are trying to hit.
- guenthert 4y agoCan't speak of the Yaris. My 2008 Prius with more than 100kmi runs flawless though. Surely (even accounting for survivor's bias) there would have been ways to cut costs. Methinks there are other motivations in play then just maximizing short term profit. I believe Toyota is in there for the long run. I'm not so sure that Tesla is.
- kalari 4y agoI have had Prii since 2001 (back when it was a sedan). Had good experience with them until recently: 2011 prius with 110K miles had to have it's engine replaced. Decided to do that instead of getting another car because anecdata tells me this was an aberration.
- 4y ago
- Ztynovovk 4y agoHave you considered Tesla is not the ‘gold standard’ anymore?
- memish 4y agoIt's down 50%. Amazon is down 46%. Are they back into good deal territory?
- pcurve 4y agoAmzn would be safer bet than Tsla. Amzn is looking for bottom, but Tsla is on solid downtrend.
- epolanski 4y agoNo single person in this planet has an answer to that.
- MuffinFlavored 4y agowhich is fascinating if you think about just how much information we have at our disposal/fingertips on the topic + how many professionals exist to digest said information and form conclusions
- senko 4y agoWhich is exactly why. You have to have better info than all of them to have a shot at answering that.
- grey-area 4y agoHas the cost of money changed?
- KerrAvon 4y agoHow do you accurately value a memestock?
- izzydata 4y agoThey aren't the same company so those have little to do with eachother. Amazon could start to go up while Tesla could drop another 50%. Time will tell.
- _ea1k 4y ago
- fareesh 4y agoIf the overall economy is poor, is it a reasonable expectation that a growing number of people will be buying expensive electric cars?
- lalalandland 4y agoTesla is the Nokia of car business. Once a huge player. Destined for obscurity
- humanlion87 4y agoWhen have they ever been a huge player in the car business? They are a tiny percentage of the total number of cars sold. Or did you mean to specify electric cars only?
- mmanfrin 4y ago> When have they ever been a huge player in the car business? Their market cap is currently more than double the next largest car company on earth.
- dmreedy 4y agoBy the same logic one might say that Gamestop was one of the biggest players in brick-and-mortar retail for a few minutes there.
- atlasunshrugged 4y agoI think that's kind of their point -- they had a huge market cap but shipped dramatically fewer vehicles than the majors
- mikeg8 4y agoI believe they meant EVs
- lalalandland 4y agoThey are a huge player in the EV business.
- josefresco 4y agoThey might take the Apple route. Incredible initial product, years of languish and then rebirth courtesy of a new product.
- boringg 4y agoMarket caps fluctuate, markets rise and fall. Its a dumb metric to use it as some kind of meaningful intel into a company.
- tartrate 4y agoWell, it's the market value in the current market, which is fluctuating, sure, but Tesla clearly decoupled from the DJ index 2.5mo ago (which has climbed since) and is on a steady decline. Means nothing? Means that the market believes increasingly less in Tesla.
- xeromal 4y agoOr in the economy in general or in cars as an investment or just in elon musk
- lapcat 4y agoIn March 2020, TSLA was below $30 per share. In November 2021, it was above $400. Whatever you think a reasonable value is for the stock now, how could that much increase in that little time have made sense?
- headhasthoughts 4y agoStock prices are speculative. It makes sense because the market wants to buy and sell it at that price.
- arcticbull 4y agoThe question is do the prices have staying power. It's fine to say "prices go up when people buy" - we know that - I think the question we're trying to figure out is whether it's priced in line with comparables in a way that it would at least hold its value moving forward.
- lapcat 4y ago> It makes sense because the market wants to buy and sell it at that price. This sounds like a tautology. Is it literally impossible for the stock market to ever be irrational? Even if the stock price has gone down $250 per share in the past year?
- headhasthoughts 4y agoIt is impossible for the stock market to be irrational, but individual actors within are often irrational. Within the game, "the stock market," it is rational. The game is "What do I think other people will pay for this?" The price of a given stock is always rational under that game. Your problem is assuming the price is justified based on any particular aspect of any company in question. The answer is almost never "Yes." The price doesn't represent competence, it reflects confidence. The market is a confidence game, and so the prices are always rational. The game itself is even rational! However, the actors are not always or often rational, and prices are only ever coincidentally (and rarely) aligned with the actual value. The price going up that much in that short of a time period is very rational, because the price is a function of what others think others are willing to pay for it, rather than trying to reflect anything wider.
- outside1234 4y agoStill at least 4x overvalued - https://companiesmarketcap.com/automakers/largest-automakers-by-market-cap/ https://companiesmarketcap.com/automakers/largest-automakers...
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoI really am curious how much Elon's rantings are affecting potential buyers of Tesla cars. I used to be a huge fan of Elon, was greatly turned off years ago, but now I actively loath him. Not only would I now never consider buying a Tesla, I wouldn't want my friends to buy one either and would tell them "Buy any EV except for a Tesla". It's quite likely my sentiment is inconsequential, but it's pretty obvious that some of Tesla's biggest fans (and EV fans in general) were the left-leaning people he now vilifies.
- UseStrict 4y agoI tend to buy a new car every 5 years, my next one would be coming up in 2023. If you asked me in 2020 I would say a Tesla Model Y, not a chance of that happening now. Lots of great alternatives with less of the social stain.
- newsclues 4y agoWhat are the alternatives to Tesla you are considering?
- aliqot 4y agoRivian truck is nice
- arcticbull 4y agoHas the benefit of existing, too, which is nice.
- luma 4y agoMight want to check recent news. It's questionable if Rivian is going to exist in 12 months.
- throwawayacc3 4y ago>Might want to check recent news I just did: Rivian is going to meet it's target for 25,000 vehicles produced this year, Amazon is continuing to take delivery of its Rivian electric vans, and preholder count continues to grow... The only "negative" is the Mercedes-Benz deal fell apart due to some Biden administration law that passed (dodged that bullet anyway, Mercedes-Benz makes garbage vehicles). >It's questionable if Rivian is going to exist in 12 months. Heard this exact quote about Tesla quarter after quarter 8 or so years ago.
- alexose 4y agoMy personal theory is that just it's not as hard to build an electric car now as it was in 2012. Remember that back when the Model S was newly released, Tesla seemed like they'd done something impossible. Not only had they released a practical electric car, but it was good. They'd solved a ton of hard technical problems that other companies hadn't been able to: Fast charging, liquid battery cooling, ultrasonically welded fuses on every cell, OTA software updates, permanent magnet synchronous reluctance motors, you name it. It looked like pure magic to investors. As soon as it became clear that the company would survive, the stock price went vertical. Over time, though, this niche problem space has become well understood. Legacy automakers have shown that not only can they solve the same set of problems, but they can also apply a hundred years of manufacturing experience, support, and brand loyalty. Electric cars also tend to be even simpler to build, with a smaller BOM and fewer precision-made components. In the meantime, it seems like Tesla hasn't been able to shore up their quality control issues. Tesla's remaining moat is in their software, as well as a series of longshot bets that (to me, anyway) seem less likely to pay off: Full self-driving, in-house cell manufacturing, rooftop solar, humanoid robots. At one point, I would have figured Tesla's secret sauce applied to just about any problem. Now, I'm not so sure. In retrospect, it looks like it just applied to a series of discrete engineering and industrial design problems. What once looked like Apple levels of product leadership maybe now looks more like Blackberry: An early entrant to a huge market, but ultimately not able to fend off the legacy players.
- r00fus 4y agoThe reason Tesla did so well (other than some amazing engineering) was due to the innovator's dilemma. Legacy manufacturers were dependent on ICE supply chain and profits. Not to mention the dealership and auto parts/repair feedback loops. All of these would be disrupted by Tesla, who had to play difficult mode (replacing gas stations with superchargers and home chargers, fighting the dealership incumbency, and the stigma of "range anxiety").
- shaman1 4y agoAlways invest in an industry index and not in individual companies as you can't pick the winners. This is investment 101. EVs will become mainstream eventually but the likelihood of Tesla to dominate the market is low. Their only possible redeeming strategy is building a robot but it can also backfire (see Meta).