11 ms·
SBF Written Testimony Notes 12/12/2022
- europeanguy 4y agoBlaming the chapter 11 team. Funny.
- secretsatan 4y agoIf I hadn't been forced to file for bankruptcy, none of these crimes would have been discovered
- hef19898 4y agoWhy didn't they let me delay bankruptcy? Funding was just around the corner to keep the pnzi scheme running!
- NhanH 4y agoFirst page basically said he is so sad he didn’t have time to clean up more evidences. And “pinky swear, I promise US citizen/ residents won’t be as fucked”. How cute, and I want to see the version of this he would write when an EU or non US country try to charge and extradite him.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> to see the version of this he would write when an EU or non US country try to charge and extradite him Why haven’t they?
- jxi 4y agolarge political donations
- rippercushions 4y agoI think they're more than happy to let the US foot the bill for the criminal trial. I'm sure there will be plenty of civil lawsuits flying in from all corners of the globe though.
- Sebb767 4y agoAlso: > “pinky swear, I promise US citizen/ residents won’t be as fucked” As of now, there is no indication that this is actually true as far as I am aware. So other countries don't really have a better case and there is hardly any money to be reclaimed from him.
- ViViDboarder 4y agoBahamas have.
- jasonhansel 4y agoSBF: "I seriously fucked up." Also SBF: "Why won't the bankruptcy team listen to me and take my advice?"
- cxr 4y agoPlease don't post these sorts of low-effort comments or use manufactured quotes. <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13602947 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13602947> <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15892014 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15892014>
- moralestapia 4y agoThe "f*cked up" quote comes straight from the document, though. I was about to comment on how delusional SBF must be to be this deep in trouble and not snap out back out to reality, leaving aside that "edgy teenager" or whatever mien he's been exhibiting. Is he actually aware of his situation? Perhaps the move to Fox Hill will help him come to terms with what he's done.
- _zoltan_ 4y agowhy the star? Can't you write fucked like an adult?
- ChainOfFools 4y agonot OP, but some auto complete systems (esp smartphone STT) insert these and you may not catch it before pressing submit
- jcranmer 4y agoThe testimony literally begins: > I would like to start by formally stating, under oath: > I fucked up. The second quote is a pretty apt summary of what feels like roughly half the document (I didn't specifically count pages)--there's a lot of criticism of the Chapter 11 bankruptcy team, especially that he felt they were ignoring the offers he had received to keep FTX alive. Indeed, to the extent that it's a misrepresentation of the testimony, it's because it doesn't refer to another key focus of the testimony "it was actually CZ's fault!"
- bogomipz 4y ago>"I have sent five emails to Mr. Ray. Mr. Ray has never responded, nor has he reached out to me to communicate in any other ways. He has not responded, for instance, to an email of mine that stated: >“I have potentially pertinent information concerning future opportunities and financing for FTX and its creditors. I also believe that I have relevant financial information about FTX US, and further that I have potentially relevant regulatory information concerning FTX" It's difficult to read that and not think he's become entirely divorced from reality. Weren't his ideas about "future opportunities and financing" and "relevant regulatory information" exactly the cause of this entire mess?
- jrumbut 4y agoThere's a certain logic to it. What statement could he make where, if it was believed, it would put him back where he was three months ago? Clamming up and speaking only through counsel might have changed things in November, but it's too late now. May as well throw your Hail Mary. It's the same sort of logic that pervades the entire project. What would you do in a world where crypto prices only go up? Try it in the real world and see what happens.
- mcculley 4y ago> "John Ray and S&C were both lawyers and/or administrators for the estate, which paid out roughly $700m in legal fees" There is a lesson here to future entrepreneurs. There is often a lot more money in the long term for those doing the boring work of cleaning up messes than for those building paper wealth and spending it on football sponsorships and other branding.
- z2 4y agoIndeed! There's an entire industry of litigation consulting that exists often for this very purpose. Lawyers and consultants made about $6 billion in revenues over the course of Lehman Brothers' decade-long fallout and unwinding all of the liabilities. The same industry probably made a similar amount on the opposing side as well, representing the debtholders. Very complicated and tedious work, and thus it gets rewarded.
- anonymoushn 4y agoSBF stole 90c on the dollar from customers. John Ray and S&C will spend much more time and effort to pay themselves the remaining 10c.
- mcculley 4y agoHow much will SBF have in the end? It seems John Ray will end up richer than SBF.
- 55555 4y agoIt's slimy work, though. Basically a second set of scammers that swoop in after the first.
- mcculley 4y agoHow so? I have worked with accountants who serve in the role of receiver for bankrupt companies. They do not seem slimy to me.
- mcculley 4y ago> "I deeply regret what happened" He does not regret what he did. He regrets what "happened".
- ndsipa_pomu 4y ago"I am deeply sorry for getting caught"
- Gasp0de 4y agoBla bla bla "I fucked up" Blah blah "But ultimately it's everyone elses fault and my only mistake is being the CEO while other people screwed me" Bla bla bla
- dougmwne 4y agoBla bla bla all the way to prison.
- ndsipa_pomu 4y agoExcuse my ignorance, but isn't the chapter 11 team supposed to be impartial and not connected with the previous "managers"? He seems to be whining about how they're not asking him for advice and help - wouldn't that be opposite to their purpose?
- compsciphd 4y agono, chapter 11 is just a reorg of the debt (chapter 7 is liquidation of the company). the same management can remain in chapter 11.
- ndsipa_pomu 4y agoThanks. That raises the question of why they didn't keep the same management for the chapter 11 reorganisation.
- hef19898 4y agoThe answer to that should be pretty clear.
- nicpottier 4y agoThe lengths he does to blame CZ and Ray is pretty telling. He really seems to still be in massive denial. The idea that he could still raise billions to make customers whole and that this pesky chapter 11 technicality is getting in the way also seems insane. This reads as if he wrote this himself with no legal supervision. Is he under oath with these statements?
- temp2022acc 4y ago"raise billions to make customers whole" also still means fraud; he's taking investor money and giving it away. The purpose of invested funds is to improve the business, with a long-term goal of returning more than you were given to investors. Not doing that is the definition of securities fraud.
- Sebb767 4y ago> "raise billions to make customers whole" also still means fraud; he's taking investor money and giving it away. I think the means "take investor money, make customers whole, thereby restore FTX, raise the company value and then pay back investors", which is not fraud. That being said, I wouldn't put it beyond him anymore to publicly suggest defrauding investors.
- anonymoushn 4y agoGiven the apparent identities of the investors, it's unlikely that he was misrepresenting his plans to them.
- trillic 4y agoAnything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. He opened with, "I would like to start by formally stating, under oath: I fucked up." This dude's lawyers are either fucked in the head or nonexistent.
- jcranmer 4y agoAt one point in the saga, he fired his lawyers because they were telling him to shut the fuck up and he didn't want to. Whatever lawyers he has now are probably still telling him to shut the fuck up, and he's completely ignoring their advice right now. Great idea, by the way, when you're facing criminal charges.
- Consultant32452 4y agohttps://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2022-211 https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2022-211 Looks like Caroline got her bag and is out.
- propter_hoc 4y agoWhat are you talking about? The SEC just announced their charges against SBF yesterday. They are nowhere near either a conviction and sentencing nor a settlement. It is impossible for the $20 million award you linked to be in any way related to these charges.
- mthoms 4y agoWhistleblowers, by definition, blow the whistle on something that otherwise would not have been discovered. But, Caroline was complicit in the scam even as the whole thing was blowing up. Remember - she offered to buy Binance's FTT stake during the so-called "bank run". At best, she'll get a lighter sentence for co-operating. There's no chance in hell anyone will outright pay her for whistlerblowing.
- bushbaba 4y agoWould be truly dirty if they gifted her 20M then followed up with a more than 20M fine for her own involvement
- draw_down 4y ago
- jjulius 4y agoYeah that's absolutely not for her.
- CPLX 4y agoThe payment comes at the end of the action so by definition this is unrelated.
- Octokiddie 4y ago> A run on the bank forced immediate liquid delivery from FTX. Which bank? FTX? FTX was in his own words an "exchange." An exchange holds customer funds in custody for immediate redemption. A bank lends customer funds out and can't meed a redemption surge. Also, the conspiracy theorists claiming that this guy was swept out of the hearings to protect powerful people are in for a big disappointment. It's just more of the same line as before "I messed up, but I won't tell you specifically how and if I hint at it it will be self-serving."
- BlandDuck 4y agoI think the "bank run" terminology should be read as a term of art from economics and finance that describes the situation when an entity holds long-term assets against short-term liabilities, and these liabilities are called by customers on short notice creating a solvency issue. The classical reference is Diamond-Dybvig (1983). It is not so critical whether the organization is formally a "bank" under a legal and regulatory definition, the economics are the same regardless.
- kgwgk 4y agoThe economics of an exchange are not - should not be? - holding long-term """"assets"""" against short-term liabilities.
- ufo 4y agoFTX customers can perform leveraged trades, where they borrow money from FTX and post other assets as a collateral. In theory there could be some kind of liquidity crisis if FTX had to liquidate many margin trades at the same time. But that's irrelevant; the real issue with FTX was plain old embezzlement of customer funds.
- kgwgk 4y agoWould you qualify that collateral as "long-term assets"?
- rippercushions 4y agoThis testimony is truly remarkable in its level of petulant whinging. Perhaps the single most astonishing thing in it, though, are screenshots of what appears to be a private group chat with Binance CEO CZ, called "Exchange coordination": https://imageio.forbes.com/specials-images/imageserve/63981bda4d894e06ad41c303/Screenshot-2022-12-13-at-1-29-32-AM/0x0.png https://imageio.forbes.com/specials-images/imageserve/63981b... https://imageio.forbes.com/specials-images/imageserve/63981bfbb439524ded7ab5dd/Screenshot-2022-12-13-at-1-30-02-AM/0x0.png https://imageio.forbes.com/specials-images/imageserve/63981b... So not only is he admitting to conspiracy, he's just entered it in the Congressional record!
- zeven7 4y agoInteresting. It's odd that b) and c) are the same screenshot. I wonder if he intended to post a different one. It was extremely weird for CZ to accuse SBF of trying to depeg Tether with a $250k short. I don't know what to make of that. Also strange is how CZ asked for group admin permission from another person at FTX and then went right away to asking if anyone objected to removing SBF from the group. I guess the group was managed by FTX and CZ was attempting to take control of it as FTX was collapsing.
- anonymoushn 4y agoZane worked at Bitfinex and Okex prior to FTX so he could credibly have been admin of this group prior to FTX existing.
- ChainOfFools 4y agoI think it's pretty obvious what's happening. CZ, not yet fully aware that he is dealing with an unsophisticated bumbler (and thus the risk that this chat would someday be part of congressional testimony), is talking candidly but at cross purposes with Sammy. CZ knows (and presumes SBF also knows) how incredibly thin this market's liquidity really is, and thus the potential destabilization that a mere 250k signal could ignite. while Sammy apparently believes something closer to version of the numbers meant for public FOMO consumption. This little screenshot, (if not eventually proven fabricated, which is almost certainly going to be the counter signal message by CZ, parroted across the crypto community) likely is the biggest bombshell tell in this testimony so far.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kobalsky 4y agofirst: > i) We signed an LOI that prevented us from talking to other potential investors as long as the negotiations with Binance were ongoing. > ii) During that time, I received serious expressions of interest from multiple potential investors who represented billions in capital that could have gone to customers. I was inhibited in responding by the LOI. and then: > 5) At roughly 4:30 am on November 10th, 2022, against my better judgment, I clicked on a Docusign link that would nominate John Ray as the CEO of various entities. > 6) Less than 10 minutes later I received a potential funding offer for billions of dollars to help make customers whole I never read what this guy said before this meltdown so I can't actually judge for myself, but, were there signs that this clown was there? these are toddler-level lies.
- SilasX 4y agoPer my other comment, he was telling the same story (regarding item 6) weeks before, in a letter to colleagues: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33984977 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33984977
- wnkrshm 4y ago> ...I received a potential funding offer for billions of dollars to help make customers whole Even if they were made whole, there would still have been fraud. A crime doesn't disappear because you tried to rectify it on your own, though you might get let off the hook a little.
- robryan 4y agoIt seems like all of these offers were about as likely to go through as the binance one. It isn't really surprising that there would be a lot of parties interested in taking a look at doing an offer. None of them were going to invest after even a cursory look at the finances.
- moralestapia 4y ago>I have sent five emails to Mr. Ray. Mr. Ray has never responded, nor has he reached out to me to communicate in any other ways. Wait ... so who is "Mr. Ray" working for now? IIRC it was called there by SBF in the first place.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Wait ... so who is "Mr. Ray" working for now? FTX's creditors.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- slyrus 4y ago"chalk full"? The horror...
- bluelightning2k 4y agoTo my surprise I found some of this quite compelling. I will withhold judgment until the inevitable fact-checking. I think this case will end up in case-law textbooks. It's going to generate so much precedent.
- skippyboxedhero 4y agoI was a huge critic of SBF and his lies. But a lot of the points he makes about the role of CZ and the bankruptcy lawyers are quite correct. People will do the usual thing: talk about SBF in hushed tones, FTX goes bankrupt, well the guy is just a total idiot...and I agree, the guy seems like a total idiot, the interviews, the way he is behaving now...it is childish. But he is also saying stuff that is quite correct (for example, pointing out the Sullivan Cromwell immediately took their $4m but ghosted him when he was trying to talk about an offer...whether it was true or not, Sullivan Cromwell had a responsibility to check, they didn't, and they didn't because they will see way more fee income that way...I have seen this happen over and over). The world has to be black and white in these cases, but isn't. I have no doubt that SBF committed crimes but I would gently point out: the bankruptcy lawyers have a vested interest in certain questions not being answered immediately, Ray is working at $1.5k/hour, and will be billing 10+ hours a day...for 5+ years if they are able to...$15k/day...again, FOR YEARS. That is, potentially, $20m+ of basically guaranteed income. The business is exceptionally profitable and these people are skilled in milking these cases dry (to the cost of creditors, these cases are...contrary to what people think...not terribly complicated, even with Lehman a lot of the claims were sold on...it was an international business though, so you had global law firms sink their teeth in hard).
- BLKNSLVR 4y agoAs another commenter alluded to above: blaming the bankruptcy team? The horse has bolted. The fact it got to that point is the point, not what happens afterwards. The fraud and whatever else has already been committed. Anyone pointing fingers at the bankruptcy team are attempting to distract from the core issue (which is precisely why SBF is doing it - don't look at the monumental mess I made, look how badly they're trying to clean it up).
- slyrus 4y agoAdderall is a hell of a drug.
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoSo is money.
- SilverBirch 4y agoIt's really remarkable to me just how often this guy gets offered several billion dollars just when he can't take it. It's like people can sense he's signed a document preventing him from taking money and then inexplicably jump in and start making it rain.
- TurkishPoptart 4y agoI'm curious about what kind of connection FTX had with the World Economic Forum. Apparently WEF had a webpage dedicated to singing FTX's praises, and then promptly deleted it after November 8th. [1] [1] https://nypost.com/2022/11/14/how-world-economic-forum-others-are-hiding-past-ties-with-ftx/ https://nypost.com/2022/11/14/how-world-economic-forum-other...
- BLKNSLVR 4y ago
- snapcaster 4y agoI'm not buying it. Nobody needs to "orchestrate" anything like this in unregulated markets. It's not like this style of scam was unheard of before FTX this one is just bigger scale
- razakel 4y agoIt's interesting how the conspiracy theorists suddenly come out of the woodwork when there's a fraud perpetrated by a Jewish person. I wonder why that might be. You never saw the same vitriol towards Elizabeth Holmes, except the typical misogyny.
- BLKNSLVR 4y agoI didn't even know he was Jewish. I did think twice about even posting the comment as it's against the "don't attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity". I'll delete the comment. Can't, too late, sorry.
- jayess 4y agoWow. He is delusional. He can't understand why the Chapter 11 team won't talk to him. He's toxic waste. He's headed for a very long prison sentence. They want absolutely nothing to do with him.
- H8crilA 4y agoNowhere in these pages and pages of teenage mumbo-jumbo does he talk about this little fact of using customers' money for his own purposes (that's the fraud part! important! you didn't tell clients that you'll take their deposits as donations!). The dude is still in so much denial.
- boomerango 4y agoAll I could think as I read his statement: “ Mr. Madison, what you’ve just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.”
- gemmy 4y agoI'm so tired of having to listen to and read SBF's lies. If Alameda made bad bets and blew themselves up, then Alameda should have been liquidated and that should have been the end of it. Sam acts like it's normal that one customer blowing up (Alameda) would take down FTX. Of course, that's not the case, since individuals and funds blow up every day trading with leverage without collapsing exchanges.
- tananaev 4y agoThere's no way all he has left is $100k in his bank account. I bet he has a lot of money left and he's hiding it. Maybe he didn't expect the empire to collapse this quickly, but it's clear that he knew about many problems.
- knorker 4y agoHere's a gem: While a multi billion dollar implosion is being investigated, potentially hundreds of years of jail time being handed out, millions of victims. Self-disappearing messages and basically no documentation, he just got caught admitting to co-mingling funds on tape, and getting dragged in front of congress, SBF is bothering the Chapter11 team to give him the password to his linkedin account. You linkedin account? It's like the end of the (excellent) Scrubs episode "My Screwup": "Where do you think we are?". One of us is not understanding the situation, and I don't think it's the grownups.
- 55555 4y agoI also think it makes perfect sense for them to not give him the password to his Linkedin account. They don't want him to log in and delete his chats. Obviously Microsoft has backups, but it's just easier to ignore him.
- knorker 4y agoYeah. Imagine the risk that would be for them, if it caused evidence to be lost. There's nothing to gain, and everything to lose. Even if there's minimal chance of anything being there, the mere perception that evidence could have been lost would be damning.
- sgammon 4y agoCZ's message to Sam is downright fascinating.
- sgammon 4y agoI wonder why he warned him and pulled back so hard on detail. I wonder why Sam pressed him to put it in writing.