4 ms·
> What I'm worried about is if the next time we open WhatsApp we see a splash message that says "Instagram, Facebook, and WhatsApp are moving to the Meta Store!
by satvikpendem 4y ago
> What I'm worried about is if the next time we open WhatsApp we see a splash message that says "Instagram, Facebook, and WhatsApp are moving to the Meta Store! Please restart your phone and follow these easy steps to continue using these apps."
Why do people continue to tout this as some sort of gotcha? Android has multiple app stores yet this doesn't occur.
However, what I do like is that if I want to download some other client for Instagram from F-Droid for example, I can, unlike in the Apple App Store. Currently I use one that blocks apps, enhances image quality on upload and download, etc. Not really possible on iOS.
- slg 4y ago>Why do people continue to tout this as some sort of gotcha? Android has multiple app stores yet this doesn't occur. Maybe not yet specifically with Meta, but it absolutely does happen. Fortnite is the most obvious example.
- satvikpendem 4y agoHonestly, that's fine by me. Epic made the game, they process the payments, they're not using the Google Play Store's services and storefront at all (not to be confused with Google Play Services), so why would they pay 30% simply to be on a store they don't use? Same as on a computer, I use Windows, but it'd be absurd for me to download software only through the Microsoft Store app.
- slg 4y agoCouldn't Meta follow the same path as Epic? Doesn't that have potential to create a situation that is worse off for consumers because their device theoretically would be less protected in terms of both security and privacy?
- Apocryphon 4y agoThey could, but I argue that Meta requiring users to use a third party app store would likely be self-defeating for them. It could conceivably alienate a lot of users who don't want to deal with managing yet another account, let alone subject themselves to an environment run by Meta. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30808926 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30808926
- judge2020 4y ago> let alone subject themselves to an environment run by Meta. Why would EU Lawmakers be satisfies with some crazy process that requires rebooting the device or going through 10+ steps to enable sideloading? These EU laws will likely require low-friction alternate app stores, which means actually installing Facebook via an alternate method might mean something as low-friction as meta.com/store -> "trust Meta store" -> open and install Facebook.
- Apocryphon 4y ago1. I don't think EU lawmakers would be opposed to sensible user flows from Apple that properly disclose the risks and provide disclaimers about the potential dangers of side loading. 2. The current Settings menu in iOS is already a jumbled mess as it is, thanks to years of layers upon layers of options added into it. Even simply getting into developer mode would cause some friction. 3. Even on Android, it's somewhat out of the way: https://www.lifewire.com/how-to-enable-developer-mode-on-android-4684044 https://www.lifewire.com/how-to-enable-developer-mode-on-and... 4. I'm talking about the existence of alternate app stores themselves adding friction. Meta forcing users to use their store would be adding an additional wrinkle as it is. Think about the current streaming space. Many many users are already forced to deal with multiple services and managing their accounts just to get into content. And now they're going to be doing it on their iPhones? It's quite likely that a substantial amount would just forego dealing with a Meta app store and just start using the the mobile website - or just abandon Facebook on their phones altogether, which is even worse than Meta. 5. A point I mention in the link but not above: EU lawmakers, who are already suspicious of Meta, will likely scrutinize any third party app stores launched by them or other big tech companies anyway. So it's not as if it would be unpoliced for privacy violations and the like. If anything, such app stores would be a treasure trove for regulators to inspect.
- judge2020 4y ago> so why would they pay 30% simply to be on a store they don't use? The argument for this on Apple's side is that you're not paying just for the payment processing, but you pay it as a fee for benefiting from the user base that Apple attracts via their investment into their R&D from the hardware, to the UI design, to the APIs that enable your app itself to run.
- albert180 4y agoPaying 1400$ for a phone is more than enough to recoup R&D, UI Design and API costs
- judge2020 4y agoSo, let's say Apple drops the cost of the 14 Pro Max down to $506[0]. Does it suddenly become legal? What if it's a more reasonable profit margin of $100 perhaps - at what point is it "you cannot make money off your software on the backend"? and, importantly, what makes consoles any different now that they also (A) sell either close-to-cost or at a loss, (B) tend to contain a web browser, and (C) charge a large percentage fee on third-party titles bought for the console? 0: https://www.notebookcheck.net/iPhone-14-Pro-Max-production-is-found-to-cost-46-of-its-base-retail-price-per-unit.660355.0.html https://www.notebookcheck.net/iPhone-14-Pro-Max-production-i...
- stale2002 4y agoYou were the one who brought up the idea of "but you pay [it for] their R&D from the hardware, to the UI design, to the APIs". If you want to back to take back that argument, great. So, the whole idea of "Well you are paying for all this other stuff" is completely off the table, and you can't use it, because people pay 1400$ for the phone. So lets all just completely ignore that idea, and lets stop pretending like Apple is "owed" anything for the phone that belongs to the user. The phone belongs to the user, and they paid a fair price for it, so no Apple is not owed money for any of other stuff. > at what point is it "you cannot make money off your software on the backend"? Apple can keep doing that if they want. By competing in the free market. They just can't force people onto that anymore. They will have to actually make a better product, and hope users go to that store, instead of alternatives.
- _carbyau_ 4y ago> it'd be absurd for me to download software only through the Microsoft Store It'd be absurd for me to download software through the Microsoft Store
- heavyset_go 4y ago> Fortnite is the most obvious example. And? There are plenty of apps that are exclusive to F-Droid, as well, and the sky still hasn't fallen. Meanwhile, two companies have kept a stranglehold on all mobile app sales and mobile app payments, ensuring that businesses can't exist that can't afford a 30% cut into their margins. It's been over a decade of this insane profiteering on behalf of Apple, and in some respects Google, it's about time that the mobile app distribution market and mobile app payments market are allowed to compete and flourish.
- pwinnski 4y agoApple is blamed by Facebook publicly for a $10 million drop in ad revenue due to a change in iOS policies. Google is not.
- bilbo0s 4y agoJust a nit-pick, but I think you meant USD10 BILLION.
- Sirened 4y agoWould this change though if they were out of reach of the apple App Store? The "ask app not to track" feature is a component of the OS. The only difference is then that Facebook would be allowed to violate the user's consent with impunity, which they can already practically do given the App Store's relative inability to stop malicious software
- kilburn 4y ago> Why do people continue to tout this as some sort of gotcha? Android has multiple app stores yet this doesn't occur. It is very possible that this hasn't ocurred because google has not enforced the same level of privacy-related restrictions that apple has (which reportedly costed facebook ~10 billion dollars [1]). I'm a strong supporter of device owners being able to do what they please with their devices, but the risks are there and are very real. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/kateoflahertyuk/2021/11/06/apples-new-iphone-privacy-features-cost-facebook-10-billion/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/kateoflahertyuk/2021/11/06/appl...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Spivak 4y agoThis will absolutely occur on iOS there's too much money on the line for it to not happen. On Android it doesn't matter because Facebook can largely do what they want.
- Apocryphon 4y agoIt will not because it's the sort of underhanded tactic that will just bring regulators to Meta's door. Right now it's open season on all of Big Tech, not just Apple.
- ncr100 4y agoThis WILL happen with https://store.epicgames.com https://store.epicgames.com