7 ms·
Tianeptine, or ‘gas station heroin,’ causes intense withdrawals
- warning26 4y agoThe total lack of regulation for "supplements" is kind of bizarre. Seems to me people shouldn't be able to sell any compound they like as a pseudo-medicine.
- Spooky23 4y agoIt shouldn’t be surprising. It’s the typical self-interested “freedom” debate. Senator Orrin Hatch of Utah essentially neutered the ability of the federal government to take most any useful action against supplements unless they are proven to cause harm. The rationale is pretty simple. Utah is the center of the MLM universe, and they are big supporters of the Senator. Supplements attract scammers like the flies to light. Herbalife is the best known of these products, but there are dozens of these schemes selling everything from powered bone material to herbal viagra. It’s a common pattern that effective in selling bad ideas.
- gruez 4y ago>Senator Orrin Hatch of Utah essentially neutered the ability of the federal government to take most any useful action against supplements unless they are proven to cause harm. Would you rather that the federal government can shut down any company they want without having to prove harm?
- Spooky23 4y agoI think I’d you’re selling me a cure, you should prove that it cures something and is safe. Safe needs to be defined as well. As we learned during the pandemic, there’s a spectrum of risk tolerance that individuals have.
- gruez 4y ago> I think I’d you’re selling me a cure, you should prove that it cures something and is safe. Are these marketed as a cure? The pictures in the article doesn't seem to indicate that they're claiming to cure something, just a vague label of "dietary supplement".
- Spooky23 4y agoYes. They’ve lawyered up after “Airborne” was marketed as developed by a teacher to prevent the cold, and subsequently sued. Now, they say “developed by a teacher” and use social media influencers to make or imply health claims. These companies make millions ripping you off. People don’t take blood pressure meds they need, but drop $75 on CoQ10 and cod liver oil.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> Would you rather that the federal government can shut down any company they want without having to prove harm? No, not "any". Is that really what you meant to ask? Supplements, though? Whether extracts or synthetic chemicals that don't have evidence of being safe in that form? Yeah probably.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoThere is plenty of middle ground. Create a safe harbor for small producers and anyone who voluntarily gets certain certifications, with increased liability and maybe disclosure requirements for those who don’t. Or maybe require a safety study without needing to prove efficacy, et cetera.
- pessimizer 4y agoYes. They should be able to take action against false claims of efficacy or purity.
- jfengel 4y agoIn theory, they can. Supplements are required to have labeling that "This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease." And they can't have advertising that says otherwise. In practice, the FDA doesn't even begin to enforce this rule. Even if the company is careful in its language, they're not going to monitor stores to ensure that the staff isn't pushing the product, or contradict social media posts. Smaller companies will just plain defy the rules. If it comes to the FDA's attention, they'll send a letter -- at which point the company will go bankrupt, and a new company will appear selling exactly the same product. The FDA does take a fair bit of action, especially after somebody has gotten hurt, but they don't have anywhere near the budget required to monitor the $40 billion supplement market.
- fabian2k 4y agoSupplements are not really all that different from drugs. And for those you have to prove they're safe before you can sell them. For supplements you have to prove nothing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- burritas 4y agoWe could look at it as a problem, but if we keep idiots safe from this bullshit, they'll just go do something equally as stupid. If we get rid of this it'll be one less thing we have to thin out the herd. I look at it as a solution. .../s
- cpleppert 4y agoI'm confused about what is actually going on here. The FDA claims [1] that Tianeptine can't be used as a supplement ingredient so selling it should be illegal. That was from 2018 so there is no reason it should still be able to be sold. Notwithstanding, The FDA could simply put Tianeptine on the controlled substances list. 1: https://www.fda.gov/food/dietary-supplement-products-ingredients/tianeptine-dietary-supplements https://www.fda.gov/food/dietary-supplement-products-ingredi...
- jimbob45 4y agoDrug regulation is typically done from the benefit side: prove that your drug has the benefits you say it does or you’re not going to market. I’d be okay with supplements taking the opposite stance: prove that your supplement doesn’t inflict serious harm on your test group and we’ll let you go to market.
- outside1234 4y agoAll of the "supplements" should be banned by default and have to pass some sort of regulatory check to be sold. Just insane that after the opioid epidemic that we are still allowing this.
- eindiran 4y agoThe war on drugs (and prohibition at large) has caused externalities in the form of weird, experimental drug cocktails being marketed in this legal grey area since they aren't on the naughty list yet. Instead of treating the root cause (that prohibition has largely failed everyone except pharmaceutical drug companies and the companies that sell military gear to the police and DEA), we're going to expand the naughty list to include everything that hasn't been whitelisted by regulators and the pharma companies?
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoI am really not sure how you look at this story about drugs which are just subject to no prohibition at all (those you can literally buy at a gas station) and the trouble they're causing for people, but your take-away is "the war on drugs is bad".
- eindiran 4y agoHow much have you followed along with the progression of grey area drugs over the last 30 years? Who was it that started the opioid epidemic again? Yeah, I'm thinking the solution is ban more stuff and then hand the reigns back to the regulators who have definitely not been subject to regulatory capture by the companies that started the opioid epidemic.
- whatshisface 4y agoWhy should the companies that pushed opioids be allowed to push anything else? All those doctors who knew they were overperscribing opioids to addicts knew what they were doing, and they would do it with any other drug too.
- belval 4y ago> He said he plans to move back to Alabama, where tianeptine is banned. Despite the difficulty of his withdrawal, he said he celebrated his 10-day detox by taking 12 pills. But he doesn’t believe it will override the detox. Man these addiction stories are hard to read.
- eddiequinn 4y agoI'm not going to get into specifics of this, mainly because they aren't my stories to tell, however I do allot of work with addicts to help them to recover. You would be amazed the amount of people how do something similar to this. They get past the first week (typically the hardest part), and because they can see the light at the end of the tunnel they assume they are "cured". They then relapse to celebrate. Usually it takes several attempts for someone to understand that the voice telling them that they are cured is still just the addiction. It takes even more attempts for someone to understand that you are never really "cured", because the fact is drugs are awesome, more awesome than life itself. That's why they're so dangerous because logically why would you'd choose life in that scenario (esp if your life is already pretty crap) Quitting an addition is difficult - but staying clean in the long term makes the quitting part look easy
- symlinkk 4y agoThought this was going to be about Kratom.
- DueDilligence 4y ago.. state certified harm reduction counselor here .. yet another inflamed fear-inducing shite article not rooted in science or reality. Stablon [tianeptine] is a valid tri-cyclic, in use since the mid-80's and quite effective under proper guidance. And while it indeed nudges all three opiate receptors - it by no means is anywhere near as addictive [physiologically] as heroin. VICE, one step above The National Enquirer. Why this garbage makes it way to HN is beyond me.
- Waterluvian 4y agoThanks for sharing your comments. I have a flurry of thoughts on all of this: - Vice is often very hyperbolic - but these sure sound like real stories - the medical community is kind of famous for telling people their symptoms aren’t real, so I’m cautious of any claim - but maybe you’re not saying it’s not addictive, and while it might be able to destroy lives, it’s just not “heroin” magnitude. - maybe the “heroin” label is a term developed by the community and not Vice itself - how this isn’t controlled in the US and Canada is beyond me. Ignorantly this makes me wonder if it truly is that dangerous. Then again there sure are a lot of chemicals out there…
- kvetching 4y agoAs someone that has used and been extremely hooked on it, it is as bad psychologically as heroin. I drained my bank to use it, came up with extremely clever ways to get more. I was on a 10g+ per day habit. I had to get on methadone to stop.
- belval 4y agoI think you are using the most uncharitable reading here. I had never heard of tianeptine before this article and yes if my doctor was to prescribe it I'd have concern now, but the article is not about it being worst than heroin. It's about the fact that a substance which can cause significant physical and psychological addiction is being sold in gas stations without any indication that it might be addictive. If you look at the label in the picture, this is terrifying stuff that is marketed as a dietary supplement while causing enough symptoms that people are going to detox over it. Even if it's half or a tenth as bad as heroin, that's way too much considering how it's marketed.
- species9606 4y ago“VICE News reached out to several manufacturers and retailers that sell tianeptine to ask for comment on the health concerns surrounding the drug but did not receive a response.” Name them. Why not?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sterlind 4y agoI don't understand how these pills end up in gas stations. they're not legal! legal to buy, sure, because they don't contain scheduled drugs (and tianeptine isn't an analog of a scheduled opioid), but you can't sell synthetic chemicals as dietary supplements without FDA approval! like, kratom is fair game because it's a plant, and natural products aren't regulated. but tianeptine doesn't grow on trees. it just seems so brazen that the company is up front about it being tianeptine and selling it commercially on a gigantic scale. how are they not shut down?
- meepmorp 4y agoTianeptine isn't a recognized drug in the US (though it is in Europe, iirc), but it's been available from online RC/nootropic vendors for years. It's not the first time something like this has happened, either - a while back it was found that several brands of "herbal viagra" sold in gas stations actually contained pharmaceutical PDE5 inhibitors. Make a quick buck and run, I guess. Edit: apparently tianeptine is a full mu-receptor agonist
- floren 4y agoI posted this link elsewhere in the thread, but basically "herbal viagra" products are consistently found to include actual drugs (usually the active ingredient of the real thing): https://www.fda.gov/drugs/medication-health-fraud/tainted-sexual-enhancement-products https://www.fda.gov/drugs/medication-health-fraud/tainted-se...
- Jerrrry 4y agoA jocular saying is that, in England, "everything which is not forbidden is allowed", while in Germany, the opposite applies, so "everything which is not allowed is forbidden". This may be extended to France—"everything is allowed even if it is forbidden".
- snehk 4y agoBut that's not true for Germany.