4 ms·
"The Department of Energy plans to announce Tuesday that scientists have been able for the first time to produce a fusion reaction that creates a net energy gai
by cratermoon 4y ago
"The Department of Energy plans to announce Tuesday that scientists have been able for the first time to produce a fusion reaction that creates a net energy gain"
Oh, just like this time in 2013, https://www.science.org/content/article/fusion-breakthrough-nif-uh-not-really https://www.science.org/content/article/fusion-breakthrough-..., and this one in 2021 https://www.sciencealert.com/for-the-first-time-a-fusion-reaction-has-generated-more-energy-than-absorbed-by-the-fuel https://www.sciencealert.com/for-the-first-time-a-fusion-rea...
Which definition of breakeven are they using this time? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JurplDfPi3U&t=3s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JurplDfPi3U&t=3s
- avalys 4y agoYes, they have been working on this for years and making progress, what's your point?
- riku_iki 4y agothe point is that "first time" happened several times before already according to references.
- sgc 4y agoWell, if the definition of "net energy" keeps expanding to include more of the experimental infrastructure, that is progress and we are just splitting hairs about wording - which is a real waste, considering they are one of the few groups with consistent tangible experimental improvements. In 2021, that was 1.3 megajoules, or net in comparison to the energy absorbed by the fuel. This is a bigger milestone at 2.5 megajoules, since it is in reference to the energy in the lasers themselves.
- riku_iki 4y ago> that is progress and we are just splitting hairs about wording - which is a real waste we (those who don't have deep expertise) trying to understand what is "breakthrough" and "net energy" in this case comparing to previous claims. Your explanation added some value on this, thank you.
- sgc 4y agoI have been following this work for a few years but I am no expert. Both numbers, and both explanations as to their significance, are from the articles linked in this thread. The next step will likely be net energy in respect to the entire system - or unqualified net energy. From there it is work on improving efficiency and scaling to commercial usefulness, which of course might be just as hard.
- FBISurveillance 4y agoThis is just popular scientific journalism/clickbaiting, they also claim it "provides unlimited, cheap, clean power" which is also not true precisely speaking.
- hindsightbias 4y agoNIF will suck research dollars from programs more likely become powerplant platforms. Click-bait wins. Not that it really matters, it will always be 30 years away.
- killjoywashere 4y agoNIF is not for power plant research. It's an end run around the nuclear test ban treaty. The US signed a treaty promising to not conduct any nuclear weapons tests. So the NIF creates a functional equivalent by smashing energy from 192 high energy lasers into a very small space, the interior of a hohlraum. At the center of the hohlraum is a tiny capsule of deuterium and tritium. And under all that energy, for a brief moment, some of the tritium and deuterium fuse.
- salawat 4y ago...you realize that has nothing to do with conventional nuclear weapons other than being a neutron source for more complete fission of a fissile primary right? Most of the energy in "fusion" weapon is all fission based. You aren't going to turn a hohlraum into the basis of a bomb.
- CarbonCycles 4y agoTo add another point to the above post, the lab in question a year ago made the following statement regarding fusion. The hype circle continues... https://www.cnbc.com/2021/08/17/lawrence-livermore-lab-makes-significant-achievement-in-fusion.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/08/17/lawrence-livermore-lab-makes... Excerpt copied for emphasis: Hurricane, however, is more cautious about seeing fusion as an answer to a need for clean energy. “While our team is very excited about this result, because it is a hard won science/engineering achievement, I don’t see it as being useful for a clean energy source. The learning from our result may, however, be relevant,” Hurricane tells CNBC. “I am very concerned, in general, about fusion being hyped as a solution for climate change,” he says. “My personal opinion is that fusion energy is still a future technology, so it would be foolish for people bet the planet on fusion addressing the immediate climate concerns.” Also noteworthy, research at the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory National Ignition Facility is part of the Stockpile Stewardship Program, a government effort born in 1995 to study aging nuclear weapons without nuclear testing. “One of the original visions for the NIF was for it to be a substitute for underground nuclear testing, keeping weapons scientists tethered to the reality of experiment so that the Nation can depend upon their skills, knowledge, and most importantly judgement,” said Hurricane. “This new result helps support that vision.”