12 ms·
No one reads the terms of service. Lawmakers want to fix that with 'TLDR' bill
- version_five 4y agoI don't think easy-to-digest summaries change anything. It should just not be possible to apply conditions as a click-through. A contract is supposed to be a meeting of the minds, and a mindless way to accept it is not that. Same goes for like car rental contracts imo. It's clear that a normal person is agreeing to the obvious stuff, but anything weird slipped in should just be unenforceable. So I guess what I'm saying is there should be a "standard contract" based on common sense that click though providers are deemed to be entering into, and anything else slipped in is invalid.
- walterbell 4y agoAny real-world examples of this being achieved in any business domain and jurisdiction?
- tty74 4y agoYep, that’s how it works in Germany. There are laws that cover many cases for, i.e., lease contracts, online shopping, digital services. The terms of service just cover the specifics and cannot contain “surprising” or “unusual” things. The general idea is that a normal consumer neither have the knowledge nor the time to understand in depth legalese. As one example, which is a quite similar case, the standard lease contract for apartments in Germany is 4 pages. In the USA I’ve had between 21 and 27 pages so far.
- 015a 4y agoIn the US: they are long, but in my experience they're also extremely usual. Every apartment I've rented (5 in my city) has used the exact same template; with some blank lines and checkboxes where they write in "You'll pay this much in rent" "for this long" "pets are allowed" "garage: n/a" "satellite dish: n/a" etc.
- ethbr0 4y agoThe point being: there are no consequences for a landlord slipping one extreme condition into that template. Maybe on page 17. And, as long as it doesn't breach any explicit laws, that condition is equally enforceable. The German system above appears to specifically address that issue with US law.
- Invictus0 4y agoI don't pity anyone that can't be bothered to read their lease before signing. If we can't read 30 page contracts as a society then the contracts are not the problem, we are.
- ethbr0 4y agoI'm as much a fan of caveat emptor as any libertarian, but that doesn't mean we can't make it easier. Parsing 20+ pages of legalese, when it could be shipped as a diff instead, is simply inefficient.
- kube-system 4y ago100% of people need housing but well <100% of people can read and fully understand a legal document. Contracts don't bind society, they bind individual people.
- version_five 4y agoAnd it's not just about being able to read and understand. It's power dynamics. How often are you in a position to negotiate the boilerplate contract that gets put in front of you when you're doing most normal stuff. It's "sign here and here and here, etc", not "read this over and come back with your edits". I negotiate contracts as part of my job, and we go back and forth and make sure parties agreed and understand. As someone else pointed out, such contracts almost certainly should be enforceable, even with unusual terms, because they were expressly co-written and agreed to. An uneditable document drafted by and in favor of one party is not the same thing at all, regardless of the signer's capacity to understand
- SoftTalker 4y agoWhen I lived in Chicago, there was a standard residential apartment lease that to my understanding was written by the city. If you were leasing residential property in the city, you had to use that lease, and you could not change it. I won't swear that this is correct, or that it still works that way, but that was my impression. I'm also sure that a lot of people still rented apartments on handshake, unwritten, or under-the-table deals for a variety of reasons.
- texasbigdata 4y agoI believe Texas is like this as well [1]. https://eforms.com/rental/tx/texas-standard-residential-lease-agreement-template/ https://eforms.com/rental/tx/texas-standard-residential-leas...
- barbariangrunge 4y agoYou never used to need a lease to rent an apartment. Also, purchasing is a form of implied standard contract
- rlpb 4y agoMore like the opposite of what you asked, but a car park with a traditional pay machine didn't have much in the way of terms and conditions. Now that they have apps, suddenly there are pages and pages. But they managed before, so they should be able to manage now. I mention this because it's sort of an example of it "having been achieved" in the past, albeit not in the lawmaking sense.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- GuB-42 4y agoI am a landlord in France, and from what I've seen, rental contracts are essentially not worth the paper they are written on. Either what you put in the contract is a law, so it is effective no matter if you write it or not, or it isn't and in this case, there is a high chance it is considered abusive and therefore not legally enforceable. In fact, you might as well not write anything at all! If someone lives on someone's property and pays money in exchange, there is an implicit contract with standard clauses between the two parties. I think the only additional right a written contract can give a landlord is to increase the rent, but by no more than the inflation rate.
- 4RealFreedom 4y agoI don't know if I like that or hate it. Having the simplicity that everything is equal is great. What about pet clauses, garage access, and such? Seems like those would need to be respected.
- zaarn 4y agoI'm in Germany not France but Pet Clauses aren't generally valid. Garage access is only an issue if you pay for it. If you pay for a garage, the landlord has to ensure you have access and depending on the type of contract, ensure you are the only one with access (re; shared vs solo garages). The Pet Clause thing only concerns big pets. Anything the size of a normal house cat or smaller (except actual house cats and exotic/unusual pets) requires no special permission. If larger pets are banned, this is only valid if there is a contract condition to allow the tenant to get special permission to have a cat or dog. A total and general ban of all pets is considered too disadvantageous for the tenant and thus not allowed. When asking for permission, the denial must have an explanation attached. "Pet can cause damage" isn't allowed for example, since the owner could just buy a pet insurance to cover any claims. Noise and dirt aren't either, since the landlord can require the owner to take care of that. Basically the explanation of why you deny a pet has to be something that the owner doesn't have the power to change easily, such as that the landlord is allergic and living in the flat above you or similar things. This kinda stuff is usually added at the end of the template contract, there isn'T a lot to read so they tend to be obvious.
- dangrossman 4y agoYes: the Uniform Commercial Code which is the standard contract that governs virtually all commercial transactions in the United States. When you buy something at Wal-Mart, your sales contract is the UCC. When you order something online or by phone, and neither of you specify details of things like form of payment, warranties, shipping... those details are filled in by the UCC. And it's called "uniform" because all of the states have individually codified the same default contract into their state laws. https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/table_ucc https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/table_ucc This uniform contract is also where several warranties arise that people take as a given precisely because the UCC inserts them into every sale that doesn't disclaim them: the warranties of merchantability and fitness for a purpose. Those are your guarantees that when you buy something from someone, the goods will do the thing they're supposed to do and there's nothing significantly wrong with them. It's why you have a right to a refund/return when the thing you bought is broken, or doesn't do what it says it does.
- Danieru 4y agoThis is also why releasing code without a license is dangerous. Without a license your code defaults to the UGC and thus you become liable for "fit for purpose". Instead even basic open source licenses must disclaim the default clauses if the UGC like warranty and fit for purpose.
- musicale 4y agoI'm not sure about software that is given away for free, but "fit for purpose" liability certainly sounds like a sensible idea for any software that is sold, whether or not it includes free or open source components. This makes even more sense as software becomes a key component of more products.
- saagarjha 4y agoIf you don’t license your code then other people don’t default to getting the rights to use it.
- labster 4y ago
- Animats 4y agoMedicare supplement policies. Those are rigidly standardized. Insurers hate that, because all they can do is compete on price.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoI'd also things to be explicitly unenforceable in certain contracts like binding arbitration or gag clauses. If these are challenged in court the company automatically loses and has to pay a substantial fee for even having them in the contract in the first place.
- mLuby 4y agoWhat if there were no terms, it's just "if you can, you may." Of course subject to laws (like fraud or vandalism) and the company's moderation efforts, of course.
- underwater 4y agoTo add to that, how is it a meeting of the minds of the contract cannot be altered by one of the parties? If it is a EULA, a rental contract on an iPad, or an employment contract delivered through DocuSign then I can't strike or amend any clauses I disagree with.
- EntropyIsAHoax 4y ago
- remus 4y ago> To add to that, how is it a meeting of the minds of the contract cannot be altered by one of the parties? I think that's a mis-interpretation of 'meeting of minds'. The point is that when you sign the contract both parties are in agreement, but if either party is not happy with the agreement then they can either alter the terms until everyone is happy or they can simply not accept the agreement. You could try suggesting changes to the agreement (e.g. with google when you sign up for an account), but they'll almost certainly just say they're not interested in making such an agreement. Perhaps if there was a few million dollars on the table they'd be more interested in adjusting the terms, but as it is they're offering a largely free service so most people have very little bargaining power.
- chii 4y agoWhich is why a contract is insufficient as a form of consumer protection. Think GDPR - i think despite the disruptions as a result from it, GDPR has done a fairly good job in forcing rules so that companies complying is considered to have provided sufficient privacy and data protection. Why not produce such a set of rules for consumer protection?
- avnigo 4y agoStandard contracts make a lot of sense to my non-lawyer mind, almost like having the different kinds of open source licenses for software that have become recognizable.
- izacus 4y ago> So I guess what I'm saying is there should be a "standard contract" based on common sense that click though providers are deemed to be entering into, and anything else slipped in is invalid. This is usually the consumer (protection) law isn't it? That sets up expectations and obligations between consumers and manufacturers of such items - everything from warranty periods to allowed discrepancy and defect rates. TOS/EULAs are there usually to modify and take away rights from consumer laws.
- anigbrowl 4y agoHad Napoleon remained alive long enough, he might have added that 'America is a nation of lawyers.' This proposal is laudable enough on its face, but imo the US legal system is unlikely to rule against the very complexity and nuance that generate so many economic rents.
- adxl 4y agoWhile you’re at it please abolish the massive tags that seem to be attached to all clothing. I’m sure tons of legalese is clogging landfills and enriching some of our most ambitious legal scholars.
- Eleison23 4y agoPerhaps legislators should put their own house in order first. Have they considered how an ever-growing corpus of laws and policies and guidelines and regulations places an enormous burden on corporations and ordinary citizens? "Ignorance of the law is no excuse" but it would take many lifetimes for any of us to study all laws that apply to us, much less to understand them! If legislators wish to ease compliance, enforcement, and awareness, they will winnow down this corpus on an annual basis by removing, deleting, merging, and summarizing.
- maxerickson 4y agoCorporations are regulation.
- notamy 4y agohttps://archive.ph/CVhku https://archive.ph/CVhku Article is from January 2022, does not seem to have any recent updates.
- imoverclocked 4y agoI really hope they work with a technical body on this so that we avoid repeating the same horrible "what cookies do you accept/not accept/maybe accept/accept because you didn't click customize/..." nonsense we see everywhere today. As a consumer, I would really like to see something like this bill. I would also like there to be a standard by which I can say to my browser, "I don't want to be bothered by any site who only wants to X,Y,Z" and then be prompted only when the site wants more than that. This requires cooperation between a standards body and the legislation being produced and would be an actually huge win for the cognitive load of the consumer.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Qwertious 4y ago>I really hope they work with a technical body on this so that we avoid repeating the same horrible "what cookies do you accept/not accept/maybe accept/accept because you didn't click customize/..." nonsense we see everywhere today. Those shitty cookie/GDPR prompts aren't actually compliant with the law. They need to either A) give an explicit single-click opt-out, or B) opt-out by default. If the pop-up requires you to click "customize" then untick a list of ticked-things then click "accept", that violates the GDPR and the fault lies with the company who is breaking the law, not with the law itself.
- imoverclocked 4y agoYet another reason to push for a standard mechanism that browsers might natively support rather than allow each and every website to implement their own solution.
- dunreith 4y agoAt the very least, it would be nice to have an easy-to-consume standard high-level infographic. Take the "Nutritional Information" table that's been standardized on the side of most American foodstuffs. If we could get Terms of Service with a table at the top with the most important info standardized, it would go a long way.
- walterbell 4y agoThis is coming for IoT "cybersecurity", e.g. routers.
- photochemsyn 4y agoRelevant, and a good read (Nov 3 I Fought the Paypal): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33462658 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33462658 > "Virtually every modern-day service comes with a gargantuan boilerplate contract that governs everything from privacy policy and liability indemnification to which one of your children you agree to sacrifice. Since you are reading this online, you have likely hit AGREE on hundreds of these without reading a word of them..."
- mjevans 4y agoThere should be reasonable standard terms for widely used contracts. Unit transfer of ownership / sale, rental of the same, etc. The standard contract should reference that current framework of agreement, and fill in only the variables that matter, possibly with an appendix of penalty fees if applicable. (E.G. like https://www.gsa.gov/travel/plan-book/per-diem-rates https://www.gsa.gov/travel/plan-book/per-diem-rates has a cost metric for meals and room rates for each given area; notably this list of fees MUST be from a 3rd party or government source. It must be common use.) A list of expected payments (quantity and date), transfer events, etc, as well as a summary for anything remotely complex. It should nominally fit on one single sheet of standard paper (letter or A4). An itemized bill of incidentals E.G. for room charges / etc would be a different type of expense, that would be an add on of additional services.
- Proven 4y ago
- bickfordb 4y agoEnd all contracts of adhesion.
- maxbond 4y agoIn the meantime, there's this website that summarizes & rates ToS: https://tosdr.org/en/frontpage https://tosdr.org/en/frontpage
- ummonk 4y ago“We will do anything we want and we will collect all data” - every site’s tl;dr if this passes.
- alanbernstein 4y agoWhy don't we have standard examples for terms of service, privacy policy, etc, in the same way we already do for licenses? I understand that more flexibility might be necessary, so maybe a ToS could be composed of standard modules, which would be much easier to digest.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoDon't bother. Just ban/declare invalid any surprising clauses, with a regularly updated list of prohibited abusive terms that people try to slip in. Germany has an explicit rule like that (§ 305c BGB): terms that are so unusual that the counterparty didn't have to expect them are null and void, and any ambiguities are interpreted against the side using reusable T&C's. Terms are further invalid (§ 307 BGB) if they unfairly disadvantage the other party against good faith etc. The real meat starts in 308 and following, explicitly banning many terms - for example arbitration requirements (309 item 14).
- rkagerer 4y agoGood in theory, but how do you deal with slow shifts from unusual to common? eg. I bet arbitration clauses were unusual at one time before the activity became popular.
- epicureanideal 4y agoFantastic idea. I don't think it's reasonable to expect every individual to pay $1000 to a lawyer to review every agreement they ever sign, when they're asked to sign a 10-page document full of legalese multiple times a week for ordinary purchases.
- qwertox 4y agoYou still would need to get a lawyer if the counterpart doesn't share your view, and lawyers are expensive in Germany. For some reason I believe that it's easier to sue in the US than in Germany, from what I get to read online, since I've never got sued or sued anyone.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoI think the missing part of the puzzle might be the Verbraucherzentralen, consumer rights organizations that can sue on behalf of all consumers (not in the sense of a class action suit, but in the sense of making a company stop an abusive practice). Edit: Completely forgot - your competitors can also sue you/get an injunction to stop you from engaging in unfair business practices.
- vivekv 4y agoHopefully a gpt based summarizer of the t&c and point out to any nuanced items in there
- spoils19 4y ago> No one reads the terms of service. This is false. Some of us actually do, and I imagine most enlightened HN readers do as well.
- pabs3 4y agoHow long does it take you to do that?
- efitz 4y agoWhy don’t lawmakers pass a law enacting two or three sets of terms of service that companies can choose from, or a set of a la carte terms. E.g. “who owns user data” could be “we do” or “the user does but licenses it to us” or “the user does”. Etc. With home purchases (for example), the terms are usually standard in the state. Why the heck does every single web site need its own terms?
- hn_go_brrrrr 4y agoWhen I purchased my house, we used the standard form...with half the paragraphs crossed out and about five pages of riders attached. I guess it gives a good starting place for the negotiation, but it sure felt silly.
- asah 4y agosorry, doesn't work... having been on the other side a number of times, different services really do need different terms. also, residential real estate ain't the example you want to use! True, 99% of it is standard, but every freestanding home differs substantially in: - what's included/excluded, e.g. furniture - seller disclosures including the history of maintenance, special needs, etc. - title search and property maps - environmental issues (soil, etc) - hyperlocal regulations affecting that property, incl HOA rules (apartments are simpler but then HOA rules are more complex) what might work is to start with a gigantic-but-standard ToS, and then the per-service ToS is just the diffs and additions. Many legal docs use this method, including residential real estate.
- stevesearer 4y agoDidn’t someone introduce a law a few years ago to require laws to be short enough to be easily readable and/or not voted on before there is a reasonable enough time in which to allow the law to be read/reviewed?
- gdw2 4y ago> No one reads the terms of service. Lawmakers want to fix that with 'TLDR' bill Also and ironically, many bills aren't read by lawmakers. Maybe they're sympathetic.
- robomartin 4y agoReminds of the time when I was handed a 12 page NDA to sign for a six month consulting contract. I did my best to explain, in a nice and non-confrontational manner, just how difficult it was to even begin to consider such a beast. I would have to spend a thousand dollars with an attorney to have something like that deciphered and even more to reply to it with edits, etc. That's what TOS feel like today. Even if you did read them, you probably need an attorney to fully comprehend what you are accepting. The agreement was created by one or more attorneys, sometimes a highly paid law-firm. The asymmetry in legal knowledge between reader and author is massive. Perhaps the metric should be that an agreement should not require an attorney for interpretation by, say, the average high school graduate. Hey, maybe that's a way to improve our system of education! Can you imagine what an agreement would look like if that was the metric?
- sonicrocketman 4y agoFrom the Bill Text, services must include: > (E) Historical versions of the terms of service and change logs. This alone is a big improvement. https://trahan.house.gov/uploadedfiles/tldr_act.pdf https://trahan.house.gov/uploadedfiles/tldr_act.pdf Edit: adds link
- hollosi 4y agoThe European Union has this for a few years now for electronic communications service providers, and it works well! https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/faqs/contract-summary-template-questions-and-answers https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/faqs/contract-summa...
- drewcoo 4y agoThe solution to complex legalistic language is . . . more laws adding to the complexity? Somehow I think this is trying to solve a symptom rather than a problem.
- JohnFen 4y agoThere's little point to reading ToS unless you are an attorney with experience in contract law. If you just assume the terms are "you have no rights, and you will be spied on with impunity" you'll be right far more often than not anyway.
- BeetleB 4y agoThis is both defeatist and wrong.
- JohnFen 4y agoIt's not wrong with ToSes that I have read, but I don't claim to have read them all. Defeatist? Perhaps. But if my experience shows a strong pattern, I'd be a fool to ignore that.
- icedchai 4y agoI mostly agree. Also, the terms can often be changed at any time, sometimes without any notice what-so-over. So what's the point?!
- astrange 4y agohttps://oag.ca.gov/privacy/ccpa https://oag.ca.gov/privacy/ccpa
- JohnFen 4y agoThat's great if you're in California, but even there, it only addresses privacy, not the problem with interpreting contracts.
- astrange 4y agoAll US states are actually California, just like all countries are actually America. No company has enough time to give extra rights to only Californians and Europeans.
- maria2 4y agoHave terms of service ever rigorously been tested in court? My daughter created an Uber account for me, and she agreed to the terms of service, not me. Despite having no contractual relationship with me, Uber continues to render services. I wonder what would happen if we were to get into a contractual dispute.
- bell-cot 4y agoInteresting... What if, instead of signing up for a service myself, I paid my neighbor's 11-year-old kid a few Christmas cookies to sign me up, while I washed my car? Neither I, nor any legal adult, was around when she was skipping past the legal junk, or clicking "I agree" when required.
- MerelyMortal 4y agoWhat if I use developer tools to edit the contract before I click "Accept"? I doubt there is a single website in the world that takes whatever text is displayed and saves that for each individual account. I could print out a copy before I click accpet so that there would be a record of it, if I went to court. Is it a contract if I don't sign it, but merely click accept, and if they don't sign it either and then provide a copy with both signatures?
- bruckie 4y agoLooks like this bill was referred to the senate commerce committee in January 2022 (https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/3501 https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/350...), and hasn't moved from there since. Doesn't seem likely to become law anytime soon.
- awinter-py 4y agosemi-related, the case law on intent to contract in click-wrap is all over the place if you read ericgoldman's blog, you already know this, but various factors affect whether a contract is considered formed, including: - whether the 'agree' text appears on the user's screen - the text of the button ('continue' vs 'agree') - whether the tos link is before or after the button and different courts have different takes. (I'm not a lawyer)
- exabrial 4y agoIt’d be a lot easier to make lawmakers and lawyers illegal
- hakfoo 4y agoThe current model of civil law doesn't seem like it's designed to serve the public any more. It feels like we're trying to preserve some very quaint 1700s ideas of how business is negotiated. The idea of "here's a meeting of more or less equals who are free to negotiate with minimal state interference" might have made sense in an era when the largest business entity would be an estate/plantation/farm/factory with a few dozen workers. We have far too many contracts which are presented in scenarios with huge asymmetry of parties-- both in terms of "how much flexibility they have to negotiate and back out" and "how much legal knowledge and resources they can marshal to get a good deal." There's a subtle difference between the armies of lawyers negotiating the Microsoft-Activision deal and a bank presenting a 15-screen-long account agreement written well above the average reading level as a fait accompli, but I'm not sure I can quite put my finger on it. There's also the matter of rework and iteration power. A typical human might open 10 or 20 bank accounts, for example, in their lifetime, but a bank will go through tens of thousands every year. This gives them both the opportunity and incentive to be constantly re-iterating and optimizing their strategy, allowing toxic terms to spread wildly from industry to industry. Remember when arbitration or anti-class-action clauses were rare and exotic? These factors mean that well-lawyered, rich parties are usually in a position to ask for the moon. Most people won't balk, and they can start asking for Phobos, Deimos and Ganymede in the next few years. This might be a viable negotiating tactic, except that an important balancing factor is missing. We can hardly rely on the courts to help prevent abuse. A wealthy party can use the threat of a suit as a bludgeon-- "finish this disputed obligation or we'll sue; even if you win it's gonna cost you ten years and $300k to get your way", but many people can't afford to effectively use the courts to challenge toxic, socially destructive, misleading, or illegal contract terms. If there isn't big money in there, you're not going to get help on contingency. Class-action suits (when they're allowed) are a limited remedy-- they rarely end with a strong "nobody do this anymore" precedent or establishment of wrongdoing; they just serve as a "no wrongdoing was admitted" settlement, effectively liquidating your grievance in terms of dollars. I'd love to see all permissible contracts be published in Mad Lib format in a standard government document. Nothing else is valid, no matter what story you can craft of "meeting of the minds." This would massively streamline the legal practice-- there'd rapidly be very little new under the sun to argue, so the case law could be documented and explained at a level lay people could understand. This would also make for a huge opportunity for oversight-- if someone wants a new clause to be added to the Standard Contract Book, it has to go through a review and comment process, which could easily become a public shaming moment: Why is company XYZ trying to introduce an anti-disparagement clause in the standard employment contract? What do they want to block and hide.
- qwerty456127 4y agoI do read terms of services and agreements and they usually contain things I don't want to agree to but have little choice so I just hope they won't really affect me.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoInstead, realise that the "average person" does not have capacity to consent to terms and conditions of technical services - even if they were written in the simplest possible summary.
- otikik 4y agoThe un readability of it was the point. This will only have meaningful enforcement on countries which already defend their citizens from corporations.
- szastamasta 4y agoFor me it simply should be forbidden to have any contract like this between consumer and company. All relations should be regulated by law and no exception should be allowed. If you sell a product all warranty and obligations should be regulated. If you sell subscription, you should only be allowed to declare what’s included, price and duration. All else should be in common law. I also see no sense in reading through these contracts if you’re not a lawyer. You will probably miss or interpret wrongly a sentence or two. And this might be the most critical part of the contract. Let’s stop this madness that newsletter subscriptions and printer cartridges have a license and you should employ a lawyer to read it. This is all shady business. Let’s focus on building bridges, writing books and growing crops. This is what human being need, not million of law firms, accountants and other useless jobs.
- vidarh 4y agoI tend to agree. I grew up in Norway, and now live in the UK, and one of the big shocks to the system on moving to the UK was that in Norway even most employment contracts - contracts which has a very substantial impact on peoples lives -, are often a page or less. Exceptions are very senior staff and sometimes multinationals who don't know better (half the time most of their extra verbiage is null and void due to legal restrictions in employment law). The most complex Norwegian employment contract I had was a couple of pages, mostly just spelling out terms which were covered by the law anyway. The reason is simple: There are presumed legal defaults for almost everything, such as duration of notice periods (typically 3 months) and other terms, and except for clauses that have little impact on the employee the defaults are good enough that few companies want to go above and beyond, and trying to deviate the other way (offer less than the default; such as e.g. a 1 month notice period) is often difficult, sometimes impossible, and almost always requires consideration that makes it unattractive (before I moved from Norway I'd never once had an employment contract where someone tried to pay me less than 3 months notice, but I had one where they wanted to retain the right to pay me in lieu of notice) The irony is that while Norway is often seen as complicated for businesses, in this respect things are easy unless you try to make it hard on yourself: You can draft a valid employment contract yourself in less than a page. A well regulated environment can reduce a lot of friction even if the regulated terms are not exactly how you'd like them to be. But for employment the importance is at least significant enough that you can expect people to read the contract even if it's longer. For things like subscriptions etc. there's even less reason there can't be reasonable defaults and why you can't make it hard or unattractive to deviate from those defaults, such as by requiring the contract to offer concessions in return.
- politelemon 4y ago> Terms-of-service Labeling, Design, and Readability Act I notice a lot of puns and memes make their way into act names in the US. I never imagined they'd take an ancient internet meme (tl;dr) and come up with an official sounding wording for it.
- throwaway22032 4y agoThe problem with ToS is not that they are long, it's invariably that they are nonsense. I don't care what the terms of service are for 99.9% of the things that I do. You don't want me to download your videos? Ok, don't care.
- petodo 4y agoAs someone who is writing I can understand why nobody reads them. If you actually read them you will find out company is not responsible for anything and can do whatever they want with your data, so it's kinda pointless to read them since your options to fight the company are basically non-existent besides the very basixc rights like right to erasure, data portability etc.
- yalogin 4y agoIt doesn't matter what the intention is to begin with. None of these will ever happen. It will never be approved and even if it does, it will be extremely watered down and more or less be like what it is today. 90% of the politicians exists to not let things happen. Some times it's good but mostly it's bad.
- prego_xo 4y agoThis cynicism is justified, but maybe if we weren't so quick to dismiss good things they'd happen more often.
- yalogin 4y agoI get the overall sentiment and agree with it. However, politicians themselves don't listen to praises or criticism for the most part. Once they are elected, they don't have to work on making things better for their constituents. It's much easier to find a boogeyman or an issue to rouse the mob than do things. That is what our politics have become. Anything good needs years of cajoling and convincing to do and unfortunately the lingering positives for the politicians who did that will be quickly overpowered by a negative sentiment/boogeyman issue. The way things are at this point, only negatives have rentention power and we stopped dealing with positives anymore.
- prego_xo 4y agoThat's true, but I just think it doesn't have to be that way. The only thing politicians care about more than money is being re-elected, so perhaps if more people took note of the good, populace-serving things that politicians at least supported and made it a point to say that that's the cause of their vote, then maybe politicians would be more inspired to do similar things. As soon as people begin to discount good actions as flukes and uplift negatives as the reason why they aren't voting for someone, both sides get jaded very quickly and lose sight of their purpose. Voters exist to reinforce positive behaviors in politicians, and politicians exist to exhibit those positive behaviors. You can't teach someone with punishment alone.
- prego_xo 4y agoIn the end, even if companies made their deceptive/evil practices abundantly clear, I'm not sure it would stop many people. If Microsoft told people setting up Windows 11 that every ounce of profitable data will be used against them, most people would still accept it because the alternatives are less convenient.