7 ms·
You're Being Lied to About Electric Cars
- cable2600 4y agoI heard that California's electric grid could not handle charging them all at once. They had to say don't charge your EV. It takes a lot of lithium to make batteries for the EVs. Which ruins the environment. Might as well drive a gas powered car until they can fix the problems with EVs.
- eesmith 4y agoFrom the first paragraph of the article: > You've probably heard it all, too: A Prius is worse for the planet than a Hummer. EVs are coal-powered cars. Electric cars produce more CO2 than internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles. Lithium mining is uniquely bad for the environment. Cobalt mining relies largely on slave labor, if not child slave labor. Actually, that last part is sadly true. But the rest? Lies. Later: > Sure, more EVs will mean more batteries, but unlike gasoline, which always has to be burned, battery production can become (and is becoming) greener. Another way to look at it is the energy required to produce an average EV's battery is equivalent to about 74 gallons of gas.
- blacksmith_tb 4y agoWas that intended as irony? Those are exactly the kind of arguments the article is debunking - so I think we'd at least need to see references... Clearly the grid in Cali couldn't handle charging all the EVs if every ICE vehicle on the road today was magically replaced with an EV, but that will take decades to happen, during which the grid will be built up.
- jleyank 4y agoBut who will pay for the upgrade in today’s economic climate? Do politicians have the will or even the interest to put their seat on the line?
- ehutch79 4y agoHow does this have anything to do with politicians? The grid is run by private companies. If there's profit, it will happen.
- lttlrck 4y agoYou have too much faith in PG&E and SDGE. They have, through politics, gained long term contracts, increased prices, plenty of profit yet maintenance is still poor and flex alerts are frequent. And are squeezing the benefit of solar to customers that bear to cost to benefit themselves.
- ehutch79 4y agoI mean, i don't think we're disagreeing? It's all about the profits?
- twelve40 4y agoPG&E is a monopoly that went through multiple bankruptcies. I'm grateful that they are not completely dead and there is still power, but this is about as far from a free-market goldmine as it gets.
- phs318u 4y agoYou(we) are already paying right now by delaying, deferring and not acting. We are all paying in terms of environmental climate and all the consequences of that, to the environment, human health and yes, the economy too.
- melling 4y agoI heard that all you have to do is skip the facts and offer innuendo on the Internet. What happens when everyone pulls into a gas station “all at once?”
- jleyank 4y agoHey, google before commenting: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/01/us/california-heat-wave-flex-alert-ac-ev-charging.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/01/us/california-heat-wave-f... Throwing a load on a system at max is a bad thing. Switzerland is trying to make preparations: https://www.electrive.com/2022/12/02/switzerland-rumoured-to-ban-evs/ https://www.electrive.com/2022/12/02/switzerland-rumoured-to.... There’s only so much power out there right now and it’s often “elsewhere” than the major population centres (or mountain fastnesses).
- Retric 4y agoIt’s way overblown as air conditioning was a larger issue for the electric grid than EV’s will be. Average demand for an 15k mile per year EV is only 430 watts, and people don’t all fast charge them at the same instant. Generally people charge when costs are low because demand is low to save money. Meanwhile everyone’s AC is going full blast at noon on a hot summer day meanwhile EV’s generally charge when rates are cheap.
- jleyank 4y agoThere’s a units problem, as googling this finds : Generally, electric cars charged at home use about 7,200 watts (W) of electricity, which can vary depending on the mode and home charger. Most electric car chargers use between 32 and 40 amps, and connect to a 240 volt outlet in your home's breaker box. A microwave takes 1000+ watts.
- Retric 4y agoThat’s peak not average, 7,200 W is only while actually charging. EV only need about one and a half hours at that rate per day and can be scheduled for low demand periods. 7,200 W * 1.5 hour/day = 7.2 kW * 1.5h * 4 miles per kW hour * 365 days ~= 15,768 miles per year. 7,200 W * 1.5 h / 24h/day = 450 W on average. Plenty of EV home chargers are already internet connected and let you schedule when to start charging. Tesla for example let’s you specify to wait for low rates or use a specific time. https://www.tesla.com/ownersmanual/models/en_us/GUID-BEE08D47-0CE0-4BDD-83F2-9854FB3D578F.html#SCHEDULEDCHARGING https://www.tesla.com/ownersmanual/models/en_us/GUID-BEE08D4... This level of flexibility let’s EV’s maximize the use of the grids existing infrastructure which will likely lower average costs per kWh.
- jleyank 4y agoCouple of things have to be solved for EV’s: battery recycling, power transmission and power generation infrastructure. There’s only so much of the funky metals in batteries and we can’t just use it once. Switching from chemical to electrical energy will take a significant investment that the nimby’s and the conservatives have to permit. And we need more amps without burning carbon. There has to be some help transitioning “everybody” from ice to Ev. That’s way easier than pulling and making the power. But this, too, must be paid. I hope the political will is there.
- drdunce 4y agoI'd add to that: - Sensitivity to environmental conditions (current batteries only really work well at around room temperature, which isn't realistic real world outside) - Energy density (huge weight of the thing vs. the energy it has)
- Tagbert 4y agoBattery recycling is coming. Several groups are working on it, but it will not get beyond the prototype stage for several years yet mainly because there are relatively few batteries available to recycle. EVs have only existed in their modern form for about 10 years and very few batteries are at end of life yet. The volumes are starting to pickup as non-Tesla manufacturers ramp up production. Maybe in another 10 years enough of the early generation will have aged out and some of the new cohort will have wrecked and need to be recycled. Until then, this is not a significant problem to worry about.
- originalvichy 4y agoIt’s worth reiterating the author’s short point about the future of EVs. ICE vehicles have been refined for decades now and no technological leap has been found that increases their efficiency. EVs have a greater amount of foreseeable improvements from improvements in battery tech to improvements in the recycling and reusing of the batteries. It is a worthy investment to steer more money to EV production due to the simple fact that the stagnating effect innovation was not gonna go away. We should save petrochemicals for actual long term usage or actual critical uses like air travel. It would be absolutely devastating for our future development if a major chunk of our fossil fuels was quite literally wasted on routine traffic when we could be using it to create novel materials out of it in 200 years’ time.
- drdunce 4y agoThere's been significant improvements in ICE efficiency in recent decades. Some of the biggest leaps include turbo charging, variable valve control and electronic fuel injection and there's still a lot more scope.
- Tagbert 4y agoAnd the result has been only very small, incremental improvements in efficiency.
- drdunce 4y agoAverage fuel economy for cars has improved by about 30% since 2005. I wouldn't call that small.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoIs that only ICE or could it include hybrids?
- drdunce 4y agoHonestly, not sure. But I believe hybrids only represented around 3% of cars in 2013? So unlikely to be a big effect. Especially when you consider how much bigger cars are now, and how much more they weigh.
- labrador 4y agoModern gas powered auto engines are a marvel of engineering, so I can understand why some enthusiasts are sad they are going the way of the Dodo bird. Skilled workers to design and build gas engines will eventually be hard to find. But cheer up, there's a lot of opportunity for them to build rocket engines. 10 Greatest Car Engines Currently In Production https://www.hotcars.com/best-car-greatest-engines-in-production/ https://www.hotcars.com/best-car-greatest-engines-in-product...
- bubblematrix 4y agoDid you really just try to do an SEO boost here...
- black_13 4y ago
- oceanplexian 4y agoI don’t like these comparisons because they’re super reductionist about what “The Environment” is supposed to be. Apparently the only form of pollution is CO2. There are lots of types of pollution and secondary effects from manufacturing that are worse than CO2. Industrial mining activities leach chemicals into the soil, cause lead and mercury contamination, groundwater contamination, habitat destruction, and so on. Using dirty coal plants to power assembly lines puts smog into the air, ruining people’s quality of life, causes lung cancer and birth defects. The list of secondary effects is a mile long. On the other hand, driving a used car might produce more CO2 (Which the author is alluding to as being dirtier after X years of ownership) but has none of these secondary effects.
- roryisok 4y ago> driving a used car might produce more CO2 (Which the author is alluding to as being dirtier after X years of ownership) but has none of these secondary effects. You're comparing a new EV to a used ICE car. Brand new ICE cars have similar pollution to brand new EVs. Sure, second-hand cars are better. Second-hand everything is better for the planet. But the world is full of people who will continue to buy brand new cars off the production line, and for those people, an EV is ultimately cleaner. And for you and me, there are second-hand EVs out there which are even cleaner again than a second-hand ICE that continues to pollute with every mile it drives.
- comte7092 4y ago>Industrial mining activities leach chemicals into the soil, cause lead and mercury contamination, groundwater contamination, habitat destruction, and so on. And the alternative is oil drilling and fracking. Not only co2 emissions. Oil production is an extremely dirty process itself, and oil spills aren’t uncommon. It’s pretty laughable that you frame it as though oil is only about co2 emissions. Reading your comment makes one wonder why you left out the “windmills kill birds” comment. Not to mention in a lot of places coal is being phased out entirely, in my state coal is a fairly small component of the energy mix.
- upsidesinclude 4y agoAbsolutely! The largest of American mines are no longer even owned by US companies! That may not be a concern to many, but keep in mind that for the entirety of mining in the US, these companies have had devastating effect on the ecology and local resources, such as water (possibly the single greatest commodity in the future dystopia of earth).
- cramjabsyn 4y agoMaybe…. But full self driving is just one more quarter away, I promise.
- noogle 4y agoOne problem emerging with EV, at least in the US, is that they don't seem to be economically sustainable at a price affordable by the middle-class. Useful vehicles cost >$50K, and a reliable fast-charging network seems to be feasible only as a loss-leader for a high-margin luxury manufacturer (Tesla). No fuel savings in the world can justify paying extra $20K for a car.
- renewedrebecca 4y agoIt's not the fuel savings that makes it worth it. It's the reduction in CO2.
- agentwiggles 4y agoI don't think it's realistic to expect middle class families to double their investment in what is probably their second most expensive purchase because it's good for the environment. Prices are going to have be driven down before electric vehicles see wider adoption.
- fooblaster 4y agoChevy bolt is selling for under 30k. For what it's worth, I like mine.
- neon_electro 4y agoI am paying $27k and change this week for a 2023 Chevy Bolt. Tell me again there aren’t EVs at a lower price than $50k?
- noogle 4y agoAFAIK the Chevy Bolt does not support fast charging (like Tesla or Hyundai Ioniq). This makes it a different product to an ICE with respect to mobility.
- neon_electro 4y ago50kW DC fast charging is still ”fast” charging, please educate yourself better on EV capabilities. Tesla and Hyundai support faster fast charge rates than the Bolt. This does not disqualify the car from being useful to most folks who would otherwise consider an ICE car.
- eulgro 4y agoHow about a third option: don't buy a stupid car. Take public transit or your bike. Much better than ICE or EV.
- drdunce 4y agoPublic transport just doesn't scale, neither does cycling. - You can't have a bus/train stop everywhere, being serviced multiple times a day when many of those locations would be visited by one or two people. - Bicycles are a fun toy, not serious transport. They are very slow and have a severely limited range for even the fittest of individuals
- readonthegoapp 4y agoTilting at windmills is an English idiom which means "attacking imaginary enemies", originating from Miguel de Cervantes' novel Don Quixote. such a weird article. i didn't know we were being propagandized to death with anti-EV articles. i thought it was just the opposite. the headline of the NYT article he cites seems insightful and correct, and does not support his assertion of anti-EV bias or "lies". that said, i do believe enough that, due to Jevons Paradox, we're all doomed -- with or without EVs -- as long as we allow the existing oil to come out of the ground. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- lsaferite 4y agoPerhaps your bubble isn't being "propagandized to death with anti-EV articles", but others are?
- frumper 4y agoI have a lot of family and friends that, between them, have told me every single one of the things in the article. I've also heard about more outlandish things about EVs. People believe memes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]