7 ms·
LTA Research’s Pathfinder 1
- Waterluvian 4y agoI keep hearing that helium acquisition is getting trickier and trickier. Would these airships meaningfully impact that further? Or is it not actually a problem at scale yet?
- photochemsyn 4y agoThat's what I was thinking too. Seems to be an ongoing issue: (May 2022) "Helium shortage 4.0" https://qz.com/2171115/the-world-is-facing-helium-shortage-4-0 https://qz.com/2171115/the-world-is-facing-helium-shortage-4... The major uses include for cooling magnetic resonance imaging equipment at hospitals, and for weather balloons (critical data for short-term weather forecasts). However, small drones may take over from weather balloons for data collection soon. Lab research and manufacturing processes seem to be in third place. I suppose if airships can hang onto their helium long-term, it'd be less of an expense. Interestingly hydrogen though flammable provides more lifting power... maybe hydrogen-filled drone airships would be an option for delivering goods, if not people. https://www.airships.net/helium-hydrogen-airships/ https://www.airships.net/helium-hydrogen-airships/
- worik 4y ago>and for weather balloons (critical data for short-term weather forecasts Why not use hydrogen for weather balloons?
- 082349872349872 4y agoOn the green side, a book I'd read about the Zeppelin world circumnavigation said that wayfinding was much closer to sailing to take advantage of/avoid the weather than to "pick a geodesic". TFA mentions intermediate between air freight and ocean freight; I wonder how these airships compare to trucks and trains?
- jeffreyrogers 4y agoThe article doesn't mention weather which seems to be one of the biggest reasons these never took off.
- PhasmaFelis 4y agoOr, sometimes, took off dramatically at inconvenient times and velocities.
- devonallie 4y agoNice.
- bediger4000 4y agoAirships are like fusion and flying cars, always N years in the future. Why should we believe it this time?
- Ekaros 4y agoI think more like they don't really make sense. Not that technology isn't ready. Which is entirely different from fusion. On other hand flying cars are combination of both, they don't make sense and technology isn't ready.
- ajmurmann 4y agoWhy do flying cars not make sense, assuming the technology was perfect? Cars could go more direct routes to their destinations and we could give so much ground area that's currently dedicated to cars back to pedestrians and other modes of transportation.
- Ekaros 4y agoI just don't believe the math on efficiency. Wheels are darn good in efficiency. Wings sure can work in some scenarios, but most flying cars I see are some type of quadcopter or like which I find questionable. And anti-gravity is not happening.
- mrkeen 4y agoIt would take too much energy to keep them off the ground.
- danhor 4y agoAside from technical concerns, they're loud as hell during takeoff and landings, making their use inside populated places a bit controversial.
- ajmurmann 4y agoLike most other objections better this sounds like the technology isn't ready.
- prox 4y agoI think I read these articles for the past decade. Although Pathfinder 1 will actually start tests in the beginning of next year, so that’s pretty good. It’s pretty green as a vehicle though once build.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- orangeplus 4y agoIt's a rocket jetpack for your self-driving flying car powered by blockchain!
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y ago> LTA expects Pathfinder 1 to carry approximately 4 tonnes of cargo, in addition to its crew, water ballast, and fuel. The airship will have a top speed of 65 knots, or about 120 kilometers per hour—on par with the Hindenburg—with a sustained cruise speed of 35 to 40 knots (65 to 75 km/h). This is the big problem with airships. Over land, they are competing with large trucks which can carry 25 tons of cargo at similar speeds. Over water, they are competing with cargo ships that can carry 1000’s of times that amount of cargo, again with roughly similar speeds.
- deafpolygon 4y agoBut what they can do is carry cargo over terrain that is unsuitable for both.
- 082349872349872 4y agoSaid terrain is almost by definition not on established trade routes. But maybe Russia will want to massively increase their southeastern trade?
- foobarbecue 4y agoYes, in theory. I remember when Lockheed took over the US Antarctic program support contract and claimed they would use an airship to transport stuff to S Pole. It was obviously ridiculous given the weather. If it weren't for that it might make sense.
- jaclaz 4y agoYes, I remember some 20 years ago there were projects for even larger airships (please read as carrying bigger loads) aimed at supplies to otherwise inaccessible places/construction sites/mines, called Cargolifter: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airship#Heavy_lifting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airship#Heavy_lifting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CargoLifter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CargoLifter
- subradios 4y agoWell, sort of - fuel costs are real. Being able to transport 5 to 10 tonne point to point (you do not need an airfield to land an airship) while using very little or no fuel that produces another avenue of competition. Cargo ships also run at a third of the speed, their advantage is fuel efficiency by weight and number of human crew by weight. If you could get capacity to something like 10 or 25 ton, it could directly compete with cargo by being slightly faster and more fuel/manpower efficient
- oefrha 4y ago> The company sees a natural fit for airships in humanitarian and relief missions. Doesn’t sound like a big market, and it has to compete with cargo planes (faster, more capacity than this Pathfinder 1 with only 4 tons) and helicopters (more nimble).
- simplotek 4y ago> Doesn’t sound like a big market, and it has to compete with cargo planes (faster, more capacity than this Pathfinder 1 with only 4 tons) and helicopters (more nimble). Some companies manage to be successful by tapping a market whose demand comes up rarely but is highly inelastic. We're talking about stuff like sea lifters that can handle ocean liners, or even mobile power stations. I'm sure that some deep-pocketed organizations whose know-how focuses on subcontracting and commissioning work, like the UN, would willingly pay a premium to be able to transport large volumes of cargo throughout regions with little to no transportation infrastructure and where roadway traffic is a major volnerability. Being able to secure logistics without having to control routes or have to police anyone would be worth a small fortune.
- thenoblesunfish 4y agoI like it because I think airships are super cool, but I have no idea why I feel that way. Seeing as this, unlike some other solutions-looking-for-problems these days, is cheap and benign enough for some rich guys to tinker with even though it's a little whimsical, have fun, y'all and watch out for the Rocketeer.
- batman-farts 4y agoInteresting that LIDAR is one of the sensors used to monitor the helium cells. One thing that isn't clear: is there any appreciable helium loss through their fancy triple-layer skin? Or can this just be filled once with helium from the factory and then forgotten about for the life of the airship?
- bagels 4y agoTechnology may not be as big a challenging as the businesses model.
- kentlyons 4y agoI wonder about airship based (inland) cruises. The cruise industry is on the order of $20b annual and I could imagine a similar experience by air, going no where fast, and opening up a very unique tourism experience to very different types of places.
- bombcar 4y agoThis is where it will come back if it does. Since lifting empty space is “free” you can have absolutely huge rooms in a cruise ship of the skies.
- alpos 4y agoLifting an enclosed space is not free. Gravity is still in play so "huge rooms" means more floor space. Floor space is surface area and material costs by the square foot or meter both in terms of construction costs and in terms of weight. On top of that, any time you're moving through a fluid your speed is determined by your thrust/drag ratio. When adding more space internally you have parasitic drag and induced drag working against you. Parasitic drag increases as you add surface area and when you grow your forward facing profile. Induced drag increases with the amount of lift you need to fly, more sq.ft, more material weight, more lift needed, more induced drag. Airships mostly fly with lifting gas but still generate a lot of body lift once they start moving. So if you'd like to go anywhere once you get off the ground, you're going to need to balance cabin size against the size of the engines needed to produce enough thrust to travel at a reasonable speed along with the fuel weight required to travel any distance.
- brudgers 4y agoWhile possible, amenities, staff, food, water, and human waste are likely to require most of the lift capability. The cruise industry is constantly retooling for economy of scale.
- PeterHolzwarth 4y agoThese articles have been periodically popping up since the 1990's - I seem to notice them on average about once a year. I assume it happens each time a company has got some funding together to start some early prototyping.
- failbuffer 4y agoYep, it's a perennial. Naieve entrepreneurs and investors love the romance of these vessles, but they will never carry enough payload fast enough to compete with the vast array of existing options. All they're good for is suckering grant money and writing clickbait.
- Apocryphon 4y agoHeaven forfend research into an area beyond adtech, blockchain, or surveillance
- Animats 4y agoThe payload is only four tons. That's only about twice the capacity of a Huey, and less than a Super Puma. Both of those are widely used utility helicopters. Fly by wire airships are not new. DARPA had the Lockheed Skunk Works develop one. That was nicely maneuverable; it could taxi out of a hangar and take off, fly around, then land and taxi back home. Fans on multi-axis gimbals for control.[1] Worked fine, nobody could find a use for it. The Zeppelin NT airships (remember Airship Ventures flying over Silicon Valley) worked quite well. Not quite as maneuverable as the Skunk Works craft, but far easier to dock than traditional airships. The guy behind that used to speak at steampunk conventions. When the price of helium doubled and the tourist business collapsed in 2008, they had to shut down. The big cost item with these things is replenishing helium leakage. There may be a market for flying yachts. [1] https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x4cnc6 https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x4cnc6
- clhodapp 4y agoFour tons but you don't burn fuel like crazy just to stay up.
- Slighted 4y agoHydrogen instead of helium is clearly the elephant in the room. Helium is expensive, limited, and not easily produced, whereas hydrogen is readily available almost anywhere, has no quantitative limits, and provides far superior lift than helium. Of course, hydrogen is extremely flammable and explosive. If there was a way to minimize or completely mitigate this problem then airships would certainly become more viable than they currently are. The article mentions the use of fire-retardant materials as part of its covering. Perhaps this in combination with tens of thousands of isolated gas "sacs" and an outer helium buffer (To isolate the hydrogen from external heat sources, laser-based weapons, static electricity, etc.) could make hydrogen a viable choice?
- sandworm101 4y agoThe realworld differences are slighter than many think, on the order of 20% more lift. The mass of the h/he isn't a significant factor compared to that of the displaced air. And hydrogen is harder to contain, which further limits available lift. Another less-discussed option is hot air/helium combos, which at large sizes have some distinct advantages.
- bombcar 4y ago20% is huge and you don’t really worry about containment if you’re setup to just replace the hydrogen as it escapes.
- sandworm101 4y agoA leaky bag of hydrogen in bad weather. What could possibly go wrong?
- alpos 4y agoIf you're set up to replace the hydrogen as it escapes then your lifting gas is a fuel you have to buy for every flight in addition to the fuel for your engines and now you're paying an energy tax to haul fuel and lifting gas in addition to cargo. This makes the entire setup an even worse competitor against planes, trucks, and ships. Many of the ideas we all come up with for airships technically will work and the fact that we keep thinking of these things over and over again through the years speaks to how fascinating the concept of an airship is; however, we've never had a problem making an airship that works. That's the easy part. Making one that anyone would want to use for everyday transport is the hard problem.
- alpos 4y agoStill not seeing anything that addresses the counter-points made here the last time the tech was supposedly good enough to win: https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/helium-hokum-why-airships-will-never-be-part-of-our-transportation-infrastructure/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/helium-hokum... Airships occupy an unfortunate gap in the cross-section of mass moved over distance per time and energy space. Unless they build one that goes faster than a plane for the same fuel or consumes less fuel to get the same amount of cargo across the same distance, it will always be better time/money spent to clear a dirt runway or build a road. New materials don't get us there. At best, the new envelope saves on how much helium needs to be bought in addition to fuel...but that's competing against other tech that doesn't need to buy helium at all. And going all electric doesn't do it either. That only forces the trade off between cargo capacity and energy generation/storage. We already know batteries are not more energy dense than jet fuel so that will continue to be a losing trade until batteries equal chemical fuels. This is made even worse by the fact that fuel burns off in flight, making fueled engines more efficient during the flight while batteries are just as heavy empty as they are full.
- xphos 4y agoI think less fuel is exactly what the goal is and not to mention types of fuel if you could move 100 tons across the Pacific ocean on electric turbines powered by solar you'd certainly could amortization the speed of delivery by just scaling the pipeline with more airship. The unknown is the lifting gas helium is expensive and hydrogen can leak and go boom. But the speed does not necessarily matter if the cost is much lower and sustainable
- alpos 4y agoThing is you're never going to beat the lift/drag ratio of a cargo ship doing that. Cargo ships already play the slow but chonky game. The only limits to their size is space at the ports and the number containers that can be loaded/off-loaded per day. Technically you could build an airship that only uses power to get into a jet stream then floats across the Atlantic on the wind saving tons of fuel, but then you've reinvented a sailboat in the sky and the buoyant force of water always beats that of air. So you might as well put your cargo in an actual sailboat and get there faster (see ocean currents v wind above them) without needing to "fuel" the thing with hydrogen or helium. This is just one example of the cross-section we can't escape. It is as tyrannical as the rocket equation is to space travel. For anything to be a viable transport, it needs to go faster, use less fuel, or carry more cargo than other modes of transport.
- imoverclocked 4y agoI would love to see a vacuum based airship! Stop filling the void with anything and recoup the some of the added structural weight by (nearly) complete absence of mass. Then the game is just keeping all gasses out instead of keeping a special gas in. Implosion hazards would be interesting to mitigate though…
- xphos 4y agoIt's really really hard to pull a vacuum on a large area the internal stress of not having a fluid is way way more than a less dense fluid occupying the space
- imoverclocked 4y agoYeah, but exotic materials like graphene aerogel might allow for static pockets to fill the void. We (humanity) have developed some pretty insane materials since we really explored the airship space originally. It would at least be interesting to explore.
- golemotron 4y agoThe imminent airship revival has been going on at least since the 1970s according to Popular Mechanics. It's an evergreen magazine topic, like six-pack abs on the covers of men's fitness magazines.
- Apocryphon 4y agoOr reusable rockets? Electric cars?
- brudgers 4y agoReading the article, I got the feeling technology hasn’t been the limitation, infrastructure has. It wasn’t surprising that the first picture was at Moffit Field. There’s an airship hanger there you can see from the freeway. But what fired my neurons is the mention of Akron, because there is an airship hanger there because that’s where Goodyear was/is headquartered. [1] These are specialized buildings with non-trivial structural requirements…when buildings get that big holding them down is at least as hard as holding them up. Not technically, all it takes is concrete. [2] Physically it takes a lot of concrete and the more efficient the superstructure the more concrete it takes. Cover a skeleton with fabric and you have a very very large sail. This makes staging for humanitarian missions more difficult than ordinary alternatives like a C130. A minimum viable airstrip can be constructed in days (i.e. weeks), an airship hanger will take months (i.e. years). That’s not to say there’s no possible niche in humanitarian missions. Just that it is no more obvious to me than to the article’s author (and presumably it was not clearly delineated by the company to the author). But I am being presumptive and recognize I may well have missed something. [1]: Too lazy to research tire industry consolidation. [2]: and steel to transfer all the uplift and sheer forces to that concrete and more steel to distribute those forces —- and no, Roman concrete doesn’t avoid this…and besides the Tufa makes it less dense and therefore would require more volume even if unreinforced concrete is brittle and therefore terrible in tension and fails catastrophically. But I digress.
- JumpinJack_Cash 4y agoWould you take a "cruise" through the Grand Canyon aboard the gondola of an airship?
- ttepasse 4y agoSomething these articles never mention is the cargo conundrum: If one of these cargo airships puts down its heavy cargo in a remote location the airships whole mass balance changes – the airship is suddenly far lighter because it doesn’t contain the mass of the cargo anymore. To keep the airship from rising into orbit of the mass of the cargo must be replaced (or the expensive helium let go). The german Cargolifter startup back in the late 90s intended to do this with pumped water and I remember a prototype demonstrating that successfully by lifting and lowering a tank. But: To transport your cargo to that remote, inaccessible location you’ll need to transport the airship ground support to that remote, inaccessible location: infrastructure for anchoring, a pump, a generator for that pump, fuel, and possible the same mass of water as the cargo. And if you can transport all that mass by conventional means to that remote, inaccessible location, chances are high that you can already transport the cargo to that location.
- imoverclocked 4y agoYes, but once there, it doesn’t have to move again.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Loquebantur 4y agoYou could solve this by compressing the helium onboard, replacing it with air filling a balloon inside. Of course this complicates matters. Another way would be to ditch gases altogether and go for containers able to hold a vacuum against air pressure. Something along the lines of an aerogel with an airtight membrane around it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- latchkey 4y agohttps://www.bauercomp.com/products/helium https://www.bauercomp.com/products/helium """ Compressing Helium requires special purpose-built compressors. Helium gas has a density that is 86% less than air. This means that the compressor has to be built to extremely tight tolerances to effectively compress helium gas without excessive blow-by. Furthermore, helium releases large amounts of heat when compressed, which the compressor must be able to absorb and shed. Therefore, for larger helium compressors, BAUER uses water cooling for the compressor for increased cooling efficiency. Typical helium applications include recovery and compression systems for liquid cooling used in research institutions, particle accelerators, nuclear medicine, aerospace, and military missile applications. Helium recovery and compression is also used in general industrial applications, commercial merchant gas filling plants, heliostat applications, and helium mining. """