6 ms·
> A North Texas Republican wants to ban social media for Texans under the age of 18. But wait, there's more: > State Rep. Jared Patterson, R-Frisco, filed Hou
by neilv 4y ago
> A North Texas Republican wants to ban social media for Texans under the age of 18.
But wait, there's more:
> State Rep. Jared Patterson, R-Frisco, filed House Bill 896 this week that would require social media users to show two forms of photo identification to verify their age.
Now all services considered social media would have to collect two forms of photo ID from all users, if they didn't want to be illegal in Texas?
This might not only be about protecting the children.
- warbler73 4y ago> This might not only be about protecting the children. When you have verified name and address of every user you can charge a lot more for ads.
- gannonburgett 4y agoAlternatively, those without identification (who are most often marginalized individuals and groups) won't be able to use these platforms with this requirement.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoAlso a positive for advertisers, marginalized individuals generally aren't flush with disposable income either.
- falcolas 4y ago> This might not only be about protecting the children. Sadly, it never is about protecting the children. It's always about pushing other agendas that are, at best, tangentially aimed at protecting children. For example, holding back Texan teens (aka Gen Z, who had a huge impact on the recent midterms) from being a part of the broader political discussion; from informing themselves before they're able to vote.
- Shared404 4y agoThis x1000. I live in TX, and it is many people's greatest fear that their kids might start to think differently than their parents.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoThis is terrible logic, as when does a corporation performing highly influential campaigns ever have the public interest at heart? In which case, the easiest way to show why this is a bad idea, is imagine if the roles were reversed (i.e. social media was instilling values you didn't agree with and thought were backwards). I don't have to agree with either side to think that allowing a corporation to have such influence over the formation of children is a terrible idea. Especially when said corporations have a long history of scandals (TikTok bowing to CCP, Facebook and Cambridge Analytics, Twitter...) The only reason I can think of, for why we would be OK with this, is not a principled stance - rather, you just support the political views social media is instilling.
- Shared404 4y ago> rather, you just support the political views social media is instilling. People being able to see ideas outside of what their parents and communities see, particularly with respect to human rights (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33924352 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33924352)? I suppose I do agree with that. To be clear - facebook? Trash. Twitter? Trash. Instagram? Trash. But it is important for people to learn that things they've been told their whole life are not necessarily true, and social media is sometimes the only way for that to happen.
- hobotime 4y ago
- Shared404 4y agoWhile these jokes are funny, they unfortunately lend credence to people who need to be convinced that their conspiracies are true. To be clear to anyone else watching this - there is no "indoctrination" going on, only people being exposed to new ideas. Sorry for taking this overly seriously. It gets tiring dealing with people at least once or twice a week who actually, fully believe this.
- ivan_gammel 4y ago1. Show != collect 2. It doesn’t say who should see the ID, could be a specialized and regulated 3rd party as well.
- version_five 4y agoWhat does this change? If anything, supporting a specialized 3rd party that exists to collect IDs seems even worse
- GoOnThenDoTell 4y agoNext up: id.me signs exclusive no-bid contract with Texas
- frob 4y ago> ...two forms of photo ID... I have one valid photo ID. Most people have only one valid photo ID. How is this supposed to work?
- Dalewyn 4y agoFor some governmental (aka official) examples: * State-issued ID card (aka the lesser equivalent to a driver's license card) * Federal-issued passport * Federal-issued passport card (yes, these are a thing) For some informal examples (if they have a photo): * Company ID card/documentation * Library card * Medical card ---- Everyone always has access to a state-issued ID card (or driver's license) and a passport issued by the federal government. Most people satisfy the "two forms of identification" requirement found in many situations with them.
- wlesieutre 4y ago> Everyone always has access to a state-issued ID card (or driver's license) and a passport issued by the federal government. Most people satisfy the "two forms of identification" requirement found in many situations with them. Most Americans don't have a passport, so that can't possibly be true
- Dalewyn 4y agoThat is by choice, and if someone doesn't want to obtain a passport then that's their problem. The opportunity is there, should they wish to pursue it.
- 0xffff2 4y agoPassports aren't free.
- Dalewyn 4y agoSo? Passports aren't expensive either. EDIT: I looked up the fees, it is $130 USD for a passport book, both for first-time issuance (plus separate fee of $35) and renewals. Most passports are valid for 10 years. That is not expensive, and practically free. Source: https://travel.state.gov/content/dam/passports/forms-fees/Passport%20Fees%20Chart_TSG_JAN%202022.pdf https://travel.state.gov/content/dam/passports/forms-fees/Pa...
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoThis is a galaxy-brained idiot who is known for coming up with ridiculous, non-starter bills. Here's another recent hit: https://www.dallasobserver.com/news/state-rep-for-frisco-has-big-ideas-for-a-proposed-district-of-austin-15299922#:~:text=Texas%20state%20Rep.%20Jared%20Patterson,Austin's%20mayor%20and%20city%20council https://www.dallasobserver.com/news/state-rep-for-frisco-has.... That's right. Since Austin is a big city and left-leaning, the clear and logical thing to do is to take away all representation and agency from its residents. /s
- scifibestfi 4y agoThe only problem here is collecting photo ID. Someone just needs to educate legislators on zero-knowledge proofs. Or Apple or Twitter could proactively show how it's done. The app is already 17+ in the App Store.
- foxyv 4y agoIt's a WHATTABOUT. You go "Hey, children are starving to death..." Then they respond: "WHATABOUT the drag shows!" It has nothing to do with the children, it's just attempting to avoid the fact that they don't want to do anything about all the other actual problems.
- sys_64738 4y agoShow two forms of ID to whom?
- taylodl 4y agoUnintended consequence should this bill ever pass (it likely won't) - every 18 year old would have everything they need to register to vote!