10 ms·
Bill to ban social media for Texans under 18
- clircle 4y agoThe problem to me is how do you legally define social media? Eg, Whats the legal difference between twitter and a mailing list?
- warning26 4y agoThis…actually seems like a good idea, at least in principle. Pretty much all research seems to be more or less unanimous that social media, as bad as it is, is even worse for younger users. My key concern would be that this legislation could effectively outlaw any anonymous account on any website.
- p_j_w 4y ago>My key concern would be that this legislation could effectively outlaw any anonymous account on any website. It would. First line of the article: State Rep. Jared Patterson wants social media sites to require photo identification for users.
- LatteLazy 4y agoYou might want to cite some decent quality research for that, so far the only things I have seen are vague association studies or anecdotal examples... The BBCs conclusions: >It’s clear that in many areas, not enough is known yet to draw many strong conclusions. However, the evidence does point one way: social media affects people differently, depending on pre-existing conditions and personality traits. >As with food, gambling and many other temptations of the modern age, excessive use for some individuals is probably inadvisable. But at the same time, it would be wrong to say social media is a universally bad thing, because clearly it brings myriad benefits to our lives. https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20180104-is-social-media-bad-for-you-the-evidence-and-the-unknowns https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20180104-is-social-media-...
- Shared404 4y agoI can see the argument, but in TX social media/The Internet are pretty much the only way that many marginalized people have to socialize with each other, as well as the first exposure people get to ideas outside of their parents beliefs. (Am LGBT raised and living in TX)
- amf12 4y ago> This…actually seems like a good idea, at least in principle. Let parents do the banning. No reason for government to dictate that. Make laws which ensure moderation on social media so that children aren't abused, groomed. If mental health is a concern - which it rightly is - spend more on mental health so that every kid has access to mental health practitioners.
- jleyank 4y agoTV? Radio? One could argue that some stations/networks are quite comparable to social media.
- eppp 4y agoIn what way? Those are pull only and almost never directly attack children.
- jleyank 4y agoDepends on what you’re protecting the kids from. Ideas, actions, …
- Minor49er 4y agoFTA: > In a statement, Patterson compared social media to cigarettes. > "Once thought to be perfectly safe for users, social media access to minors has led to remarkable rises in self-harm, suicide, and mental health issues." Patterson said. "The Texas legislature must act this session to protect children because, thus far, the social media platforms have failed to do so." TV and radio have not been able to claim these same effects Edit: Formatting
- flavius29663 4y agoTV and radio are not interactive. The interactive nature of social media makes is so damaging: you write a comment or post a video, and then you get a dopamine injection every time there is a like, reply or re-share. I used to think TV is bad, social media is 10x worse.
- neilv 4y ago> A North Texas Republican wants to ban social media for Texans under the age of 18. But wait, there's more: > State Rep. Jared Patterson, R-Frisco, filed House Bill 896 this week that would require social media users to show two forms of photo identification to verify their age. Now all services considered social media would have to collect two forms of photo ID from all users, if they didn't want to be illegal in Texas? This might not only be about protecting the children.
- warbler73 4y ago> This might not only be about protecting the children. When you have verified name and address of every user you can charge a lot more for ads.
- gannonburgett 4y agoAlternatively, those without identification (who are most often marginalized individuals and groups) won't be able to use these platforms with this requirement.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoAlso a positive for advertisers, marginalized individuals generally aren't flush with disposable income either.
- falcolas 4y ago> This might not only be about protecting the children. Sadly, it never is about protecting the children. It's always about pushing other agendas that are, at best, tangentially aimed at protecting children. For example, holding back Texan teens (aka Gen Z, who had a huge impact on the recent midterms) from being a part of the broader political discussion; from informing themselves before they're able to vote.
- Shared404 4y agoThis x1000. I live in TX, and it is many people's greatest fear that their kids might start to think differently than their parents.
- cokeandpepsi 4y ago"would require social media users to show two forms of photo identification to verify their age" sweet
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- amadeuspagel 4y agoThis would make it harder to make a social media account, make it harder for people to try out new platforms thereby cementing the monopoly of the current ones, make it impossible to make an account without giving your real name to the social media platform — something which people will also be especially reluctant to do with new platforms.
- superkuh 4y agoThis is a terrible proposal in it's intent and it's even worse in how it could be implemented. I see everyone here boldly claiming that a particular type of website is "bad" (???) for people but I've never seen that causal link backed up in any reputable journal. What does "bad" (???) even mean? Websites are not drugs. Websites do not directly manipulate incentive salience and throw the brain's motivations out of wack like, say, cocaine or methamphetamine or tobacco do. Websites have to actually be enjoyable intrinsically before they alter your motivations. This is very unlike drugs. Trying to pass legislation like this that pretends people are without volition signals a far deeper danger: that the state no longer considers people to have volition and that it will force them to make the "correct" decisions. That's appropriate re: some drugs but entirely unjustified here.
- barbariangrunge 4y agoWhich social media? Does that include discord and forums? Reddit? Those are all social media too
- GoOnThenDoTell 4y agoLikely anything that accepts user generated content and makes it available to others without human editorial review
- chomp 4y agoFrom our business and commerce code: (1) "Social media platform" means an Internet website or application that is open to the public, allows a user to create an account, and enables users to communicate with other users for the primary purpose of posting information, comments, messages, or images. The term does not include: (A) an Internet service provider as defined by Section 324.055; (B) electronic mail; or (C) an online service, application, or website: (i) that consists primarily of news, sports, entertainment, or other information or content that is not user generated but is preselected by the provider; and (ii) for which any chat, comments, or interactive functionality is incidental to, directly related to, or dependent on the provision of the content described by Subparagraph (i).
- dpkirchner 4y agoI'm looking forward to the Big Government apparatus necessary to identify which sites are and are not "consisting primarily of news, sports, et al", and monitor such sites to ensure they don't change their feature set unnoticed. The GOP motto is the more government the better, right?
- kayodelycaon 4y agoWhat is a social media site defined as? In California, the definition includes any online forum and majority of sites allowing user-submitted content. (Granted, California has a minimum revenue requirement.) Under a similar definition, this block anyone under 18 from having any accounts on the vast majority of popular sites. Also, if you squint at it, this could equally apply to any video game company allowing communication between players.
- daveslash 4y agoNot to mention, what does it mean to use? Is passively consuming content without contributing or even creating an account using? Because, if so.... this means that YouTube gets turned upside down in this case.
- LegionMammal978 4y ago> Not to mention, what does it mean to use? Presumably, to use a platform is to be a user of that platform, where a user is "a person who posts, uploads, transmits, shares, or otherwise publishes or receives content through a social media platform" [0]. Since YouTube is unambiguously a social media platform by Texas law (it primarily consists of user-generated content), the bill as written would prohibit receiving YouTube videos without logging in with an age-verified account. I strongly doubt the bill will go anywhere. [0] https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/BC/htm/BC.120.htm https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/BC/htm/BC.120.htm
- LegionMammal978 4y agoFrom earlier in that chapter [0]: > (1) "Social media platform" means an Internet website or application that is open to the public, allows a user to create an account, and enables users to communicate with other users for the primary purpose of posting information, comments, messages, or images. The term does not include: >> (A) an Internet service provider as defined by Section 324.055; >> (B) electronic mail; or >> (C) an online service, application, or website: >>> (i) that consists primarily of news, sports, entertainment, or other information or content that is not user generated but is preselected by the provider; and >>> (ii) for which any chat, comments, or interactive functionality is incidental to, directly related to, or dependent on the provision of the content described by Subparagraph (i). > (2) "User" means a person who posts, uploads, transmits, shares, or otherwise publishes or receives content through a social media platform. The term includes a person who has a social media platform account that the social media platform has disabled or locked. [0] https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/BC/htm/BC.120.htm https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/BC/htm/BC.120.htm
- recursivedoubts 4y agoSome folks on HN will hate this idea due to the genetic fallacy, but I think we'll end up feeling about social-media the way we currently feel about smoking: it is something that obviously requires protections for minors.
- ketralnis 4y ago> HN will hate this idea due to the genetic fallacy That's extremely condescendingly reductionist. Surely I'm allowed to hate this idea because it's a bad idea.
- recursivedoubts 4y agofair, updated to "Some folks on HN..."
- daveslash 4y agoWell, the idea in the link is total bunk (IMHO), but I agree with you. Social Media's turned out to be something with an ugly side, but Pandora's Box is open now and it's here to stay. I would completely agree that we need some protections for minors. Hell - some protections for all of us! I just have no real, viable, solutions come to mind.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- recursivedoubts 4y agosmoking was out of the box too, and we did something about that
- allenrb 4y agoFiling this under "even a stopped clock is right twice a day."
- LatteLazy 4y agoTexas has no lower limit on the age to possess a firearm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_laws_in_Texas#Firearms_possession https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_laws_in_Texas#Firearms_pos...
- lostapathy 4y agoNeither do a lot of states.
- LatteLazy 4y agoI was interested so I looked it up. Apparently 42 states set a minimum age for handguns and 21 states have minimum ages for rifles and shotguns https://maps.everytownresearch.org/navigator/states.html?dataset=minimum_age https://maps.everytownresearch.org/navigator/states.html?dat... Of course, none of them want a minimum age for social media access...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- blurbleblurble 4y agoI thought Texans loved freedom
- martin1975 4y agoThey love their children too...
- abeppu 4y agoDoes anyone with legal credentials care to comment on whether this would be likely to be blocked on a first amendment basis? Fundamentally "social media" does seem to be about an ability to post (communicate/publish) and read messages/content. I know in loose terms that in various contexts rights for minors are abridged (e.g. public schools can punish students for speech), but I don't know how far those are allowed to go.
- orwin 4y agoLet's be charitable and say the identification is done on a governmental website and the data isn't tracked or used further, nor correlated with voters database. Big assumption What does using mean? If it's posting publicly on social media? Why not. I mean, if facebook default privacy settings were "private" for the kids and only ascendants (IE parents or legal guardians, and main professor (to allow children withing a class to interact with each other)), its not a great idea, but at least it does "protect the children". If it's using altogether, i mean, tough luck.
- adamsmith143 4y agoI'd be for this but the way you implement it is by completely destroying online anonymity.
- hobbitstan 4y agoIf we lived in a sensible society, this would already be the case. The amount of damage social media has inflicted on younger generations is unsurpassed.
- jleyank 4y agoI don’t know. Cable news, network tv and religions have done damage to teens and younger in the past and it probably still continues. Sports coaches aren’t always pure, nor are families. Seems there’s lots of bad actors and influences. Unmonitored activity seems to be the concern, suggesting strong parental actions?
- yamazakiwi 4y agoUntil the Parent is the bad actor and then strong parental actions exacerbate the issue.
- pmdulaney 4y ago
- thot_experiment 4y agoLemme tell ya, if I grew up with this antagonistic a relationship with adults I would be even less inclined to support the right.
- pmdulaney 4y agoWhich antagonistic relationship with adults are you referring to?
- thot_experiment 4y agoIf adults wanted me not to use some of the greatest resources available to humans in order to "protect" me it would cause me to constantly be wasting time I could be using to do something fun or useful on circumventing idiotic protections. I don't like having my time wasted and I would certainly never vote for the people who want to waste my time. And that's the best case scenario, some people wouldn't be able to circumvent the ban and they'd be stuck atrophying. The idea that twitter/facebook/4chan/instagram/discord etc aren't essential to existing in a world that's changing as fast as ours is laughable. In the last 2 weeks I've gone from novice to expert in using stable diffusion to create animations purely off discussions on social media, this information doesn't exist anywhere else in a field that's being upended every few weeks by new developments. That's not something that's going to change going into the future, the rate of change is increasing and we need to PREPARE our youth for that, not deny them the only way to stay relevant.
- pmdulaney 4y agoYou make a strong case.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- alexb_ 4y agoAs great as it would be to never have to see the opinion of a 14 year old again >Under HB 896, social media sites would also be forced to verify a user’s age with a photo ID Throw the bill in the garbage.
- noasaservice 4y ago
- dang 4y agoPlease don't take HN threads into regional flamewar. It leads hellward, and is easily avoidable. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Edit: you've been breaking the site guidelines repeatedly lately: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33821967 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33821967 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33766363 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33766363 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33682063 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33682063 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33671032 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33671032 ... and we've already asked you more than once to stop: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32808611 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32808611 (Sept 2022) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31520523 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31520523 (May 2022) Would you mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and fixing this? I don't want to ban you, but if you can't or won't stop posting abusively, we'll end up having to.
- noasaservice 4y agoDo what thou wilt. I'll abandon this account and create another. It's not hard to game the "community" here. And especially since you don't allow deletion of accounts, it's actually a good thing to regularly get new. Thank you for reminding me.
- dang 4y agoYes, I know. But why contribute to destroying this place? If it's interesting enough for you to be here at all, it's worth protecting, no?. More here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33806797 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33806797
- thot_experiment 4y agoIs this a real thing even worth discussing or just some silly performative stunt? Nobody is seriously considering this as a real thing we want to implement in society right? Right??
- celestialcheese 4y agoThe negative effects of social media on children are absolutely something we should be discussing. Kids spend an unbelievable amount of time online in these networks, and it's having a real consequences. We already require by law blocking access to kids under 13 in certain situations, so it's not without precedent. Why would you think this is something that is so far outside the reasonable to not warrant discussion here or in govt?
- modzu 4y agohaving photo ids floating around the internet is its own set of problems
- loeg 4y ago> We already require by law blocking access to kids under 13 in certain situations The COPPA age-gating on 13 years old is trivially bypassed by most 13 year olds. It definitely won't keep teens off social media. But adding ID verification to enforce it is dystopian.
- modzu 4y agocf: the december amendments to bill c-11 currently being debated in canada including age verification to access online media
- jfengel 4y agoThe issue is real, but the bill is a stunt. It's not actually going to pass or even get any real time in committee. It won't make it out of committee; if somehow it did, it would be voted down. It gets people talking about the issue, and it puts the guy on the social calendar for talking with other people about the issue. That's how politics works: people talking with each other. The actual votes are only the final stage, and really the least important.
- tibbydudeza 4y agoNever knew freedom of speech in the US has an age restriction - seem to vaguely recall some Supreme Court case involving a school board that limited the rights of their students in some case - think the SC said it was ok in some cases.
- NationalPark 4y agoChildren can't enter into contracts either, we actually do not give them many of the same rights we give adults. This is because children are considered immature and unable to act in their own self interest. There have been "childrens rights" movements in the past though, it's not an uncontested subject...
- iamthirsty 4y ago> Never knew freedom of speech in the US has an age restriction Freedom of speech is freedom from Government intervention. Social Media companies are private companies, and you can absolutely regulate what products & services have age limits, as the government isn't technically restricting speech.
- vikingerik 4y agoThis comes up in every such discussion: freedom of speech as a legal construct applies to governments, but freedom of speech as an ideal and principle is something that private platforms can support and encourage, or censor and deny. We need a distinction for this, like "free as in legal" speech versus "free as in voice".
- LegionMammal978 4y agoHow wouldn't this bill constitute government intervention? The government would be making it illegal for any person or business to run a social media platform that transmits the speech of minors, even if they want to run such a platform.
- loeg 4y agoThere are huge limits on the rights of minors in the US, unfortunately. Tinker won, but students have lost more recent first amendment battles (e.g., Frederick).
- JasonFruit 4y agoI agree with the premise of this bill — that social media are harmful to young people — but disagree with the conclusion that therefore there must be a law. There are lots of things that can be harmful to children, like television, busy streets, caffeinated sugary sodas, and weight training, and we trust parents and other adults to guide children through those dangers, teaching them wise self-restraint along the way. I don't see that social media belong to a different category of danger that requires legislation. Parenting is hard, and not everyone succeeds, but that doesn't mean that we need to legislate away all danger, especially at the cost of privacy and potentially beneficial engagement with friends and family.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoThe definition of social media in this bill defines all websites with comment sections as social media. This means they don't want your kids to even have access to the news on the web.
- chriscross 4y agoI agree with you except that weight training/exercise has not only been shown to be safe, but also healthy in kids with normal health and development. There are extremes for sure, but the old adage that weight lifting will hurt you if you’re too young hasn’t held up to current research on the topic.
- JasonFruit 4y agoThat may well be. I was trying to illustrate the broad range of activities in which we accept some risk to children, and may have been ambitious beyond my knowledge.
- edgyquant 4y agoProper weight training won’t hurt. But I got (and a lot of kids into sports/athletics get) hernia(s) because teenage hormones and physical reality are often at odds.
- paroneayea 4y ago
- outside1234 4y agoGood news - it is part of my family's religion to use social media
- abawany 4y ago"And on the 49th day, this Lord of thine commands that thee shall have a LinkedIn account with all annoying notifications turned on, and thee shall click on all these notifications and appreciate them for wasting the remaining moments of your life on this 'ere planet."
- anigbrowl 4y agoIn all seriousness, a Christian could marshal a legally credible argument that such a restriction impinges upon their freedom to proselytize, which is widely considered to be a core duty of that religion notwithstanding that this is in conflict with the prescriptions of its founder.
- dathinab 4y agoThis is most likely harming children more then it's helping them as it makes it way harder for children with rural problems of all kind (domestic abuse, child grooming, religious sects, bullying due to being different) to get into contact with people which provide emotional assistance and help. While there are "official" institutions which are meant to provide help they are often in practice inefficient and out of reach for various reasons. Additionally I have herd more stories about peoples live being saved due to social media then about people dying due to social media and that is even through stories about someone dying due to social media get propagated a tone while stories where the opposite happens tend to not. (I mean scandals and other bad news and hate just do get more attention in general, not just in social media but also TV and news). Lastly a restriction of 18+ is ridiculous high.
- gamblor956 4y ago
- runako 4y agoFor context: there is not any age requirement for a minor to own a firearm in Texas.
- Minor49er 4y agoWhataboutism != context
- martin1975 4y agoSounds like a mental health preserving bill.
- tedunangst 4y ago> require the social media platform ’s users to use an account to access the social media platform Man, people hate the twitter login wall just to view a tweet. Wait until it's legally required. That's one way to drive user signups.
- tedunangst 4y ago> require the social media platform ’s users to use an account to access the social media platform Man, people hate the twitter login wall just to view a tweet. Wait until it's legally required. That's one way to drive user signups.
- tinglymintyfrsh 4y agoIs this one of those (insert absurdity to make the news) bills?
- newaccount2021 4y agoRelax TX is about to start its legislative session and reps can suggest literally anything This will never even make it to the debate floor
- babypuncher 4y agoI think it's important to know what crazy ideas your elected representatives try to push forward, no matter how unlikely they are to actually pass. It helps you identify the crazies.
- sieabahlpark 4y ago
- bruceb 4y agoShould the gov't do this? No. Should many parents restrict what their kids from social media, yes. Yes I realize has no chance of passing. But lots of social media is toxic for adults maybe more so for kids.
- greggarious 4y agoKeeping kids off social media is good -- I signed up for Gamefaqs with a pormanteau of my first and last name and some of the evil people I met follow me across the net to this day. But forcing children to present more ID to use the net than in the PRC is not a step in a positive direction. The real solution is to put the computer in a semi public place, but that works less well than it did back before gift cards, burner phones, and ubiquitous wifi -- too many times I've had to tell a kid something to the effect of "You shouldn't be in this application, I am not going to call the school since I've met your teachers and they'll just smell blood in the metaphorical water and victimize you, but dear lord treasure this time rather than try to meet weird 30 something year olds on the net who might literally murder you".