3 ms·
The concern over the "highly processed" nature of plant-based meat-alternatives seems really disproportionate to all the other problems common in American diets
by xnx 4y ago
The concern over the "highly processed" nature of plant-based meat-alternatives seems really disproportionate to all the other problems common in American diets: high sugar, low fiber, etc.
- jethro_tell 4y agoStick with the healthy stuff like unprocessed arsenic and hemlock teas . . .. The act of processing or modifying our food is not in and of itself unhealthy. Nuance is important and you are correct that there are tradeoffs here. The most unhealthy vegetable calories are almost certainly better than a soda.
- forgetfulness 4y agoThe issue is that we began utilizing a lot of ingredients that just weren't available, or edible at all, until the advent of modern industrial processes. Eating as much refined flour, sugars and novel vegetable oils turned out to have some pretty negative outcomes, and we wouldn't have made those choices without economic incentives to do so; we developed the technology to make them cheaper, at a scale, and durable to be stored for long periods of time and remain saleable, and much of it is stuff that you wouldn't have eaten as much if not. It was an uncontrolled experiment. Now, picking apart peas and rice, isolating their proteins, putting them together with refined coconut oil in a cellulose matrix, none of these things you would even be able to cook yourself, you can't make any assumptions that they'd have an effect in you similar to eating peas, rice or sauteeing something in coconut oil, it's not a valid inference.
- no-dr-onboard 4y ago> The concern over the "highly processed" nature of plant-based meat-alternatives seems really disproportionate Well we're dealing with two separate audiences now, aren't we? The people who care about their health and have moral quandries about eating meat are likely a separate group from those who engage in the typical "American diet". Based off how the article is written, it seems that the intended audience is more of the former than the latter.
- zen_nerd 4y agoNot really. People who are health-minded choose these products with the intention of being healthier, while that choice is diametrically opposite of anything concerning health. They're full of linoleic acid which will fuck your metabolism and gut health beyond repair for years, provide little nutritional value and are even more expensive than meat at times.
- forgetfulness 4y agoNew ones at least often use refined coconut oil, which is known to have little linoleic acid. We can well argue from uncertainty about how suitable for human health these products made from various isolates put together are, but not from that particularly certainty about the harmfulness of certain ingredients.
- colordrops 4y agoIt's caused by a mix of defensiveness from those who prefer to eat meat, and propaganda by the meat industry.