5 ms·
Former Apple Executive Says Company Blundered by Firing Him After TikTok Video
- smittywerben 4y agoLots of layoffs happening right now. Not that I agree but it might have been low hanging fruit.
- ksec 4y agohttps://archive.ph/lgSIP https://archive.ph/lgSIP
- kirykl 4y agoHoisted with his own petard, by the same devices he helped create
- jerpint 4y agoThis is pretty dystopian, the article states he was with his wife, making a joke based on some obscure reference, and most importantly, not on the job and in his private life . Is the joke in bad taste? Perhaps. But it Seems like a weird reason to nuke an exec’s 22-year career over
- acdha 4y agoI'm curious whether there's any backstory — sometimes things like this are more of a “last straw” situation where someone went with a straightforward policy violation because it's harder to sue over.
- sct202 4y agoIt does seem like they already had reasons to not want him or his role considering his org was broken apart and his role wasn't backfilled according to the article.
- lazyeye 4y agoI wonder what those reasons were such that they couldn't be stated openly and instead they needed some unrelated pretext to sack him?
- jjtheblunt 4y agomaybe it's not the reason, just convenient timing?
- throwayyy479087 4y agoIt's not even that obscure! It was a pretty big hit with big names for the time. It's also hilarious, strong recommend if you haven't seen it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Rebelgecko 4y agoIf you haven't seen it, Apple will also happily license you permission to watch the movie.
- _8j50 4y agoHe posted it in a public platform and he is an executive. You can sneeze wrong and get fired for an exec role, that's why they get paid the big bucks, so they represent the company and lead , no such thing as clocking out. They don't get paid because they work hard. A senior apple engineer doing the same thing wouldn't get fired.
- amf12 4y ago> He posted it in a public platform and he is an executive. He didn't post it. Another tiktoker did, but the exec was in the video. I think execs should be more mindful of what they say, even outside of work because of the potential reputational damage to the company. However, firing the exec for something like this is a bit much. Everyone makes silly, dark, sexual jokes privately - outside of work. They should have warned him and given him more training about conduct outside of work.
- throwaway23597 4y agoThis situation is so stupid that it seriously breaks my brain. A 22 year career ruined over some dumb movie quote uttered outside of work, for a video that didn't even go viral... Who the hell even was offended by this? If this sort of thing happened to someone who wasn't already financially secure, they'd probably go postal. I genuinely wonder if some of cancel culture is driven by foreign influence operations? Seems like a pretty effective way to attack an open society. Like this guy apparently was one of Apple's top negotiators with China... seems directly in the Chinese interest to get him canned.
- Seanambers 4y agoThe more important question is - is it right that certain groups wield such power? The outrage culture is insane. Apple fires a top negotiator who have worked there for 22 years because someone somewhere is 'offended'. Most probably someone who at the outset was set on finding something to be offended about. Yeah thats so much power that any foreign interest would be stupid not to attempt to use that influence. And that influencer kid not even replying to the man..
- teawrecks 4y ago> is it right that certain groups wield such power? What groups? Randos on the internet? What power? Boycotting? > The outrage culture is insane. Was there outrage? Seems like apple just prematurely cut him loose before anyone actually cared. It sounds like you think there's some nefarious shadow league of extraordinary gentlemen who can bend the largest corporations to their will. They can't. Apple did what it thought would yield them the most profits in the long term, that's it. Apple could have instead just ignored this and it likely would have blown over in a day. That's not what they did.
- jmeister 4y agoThis is woefully simplistic Check out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Burnham#The_Managerial_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Burnham#The_Managerial_R...
- lazyeye 4y agoNever forget Apple is the company that provides support for the CCP in the oppression it's citizens. But at least they take a stand on dumb movie quotes though...
- footility 4y agoI think it’s worth noting that Apple has a reputation within the media of being well, even if ruthlessly so, managed. It is plagued by fewer instances of manager misbehavior, and in exchange it gets a pass for not meeting other goals like low gender diversity. All it takes is one instance of misbehavior and a big payout to keep the person quiet and Apple looks less well-managed/ becomes a target for people to dig around for other evidence that Apple isn’t as wholesome as it seems.
- TechBro8615 4y agoGood, this is the ideal operational state of a company controlling the most personal data of billions of people. Meanwhile Facebook allows its employees to post jokes on TikTok, but also allows its security guards to read private messages of arbitrary users. Twitter lets its support engineers do CNN interviews, but also gives them a tab in the admin panel for every user called "Direct Messages." I've got a lot more confidence that a security guard at Apple HQ won't read my iMessage threads than I do that a security guard at Facebook HQ won't read my Messenger threads (that actually happened!). If the price of that security comes at the freedom of highly paid executives to make jokes on TikTok, then so be it. I guess Apple is ruthless. That's why I trust them to guard my personal data.
- MaxikCZ 4y agoI think people here might be missing something... I think it's pretty clear to say the person was not fired for this, but this was used as the reason for sacking. What baffles me is the precedence, the signalling, that sacking person for something like this is not just a dark joke.
- Dig1t 4y agoFrom the article: >In the early morning phone call, an Apple executive told him that he had to get the video removed immediately. >Mr. Blevins, 55 years old, said he stayed up all night trying to contact the TikToker I mean, they told him that this is why he was being fired. He thought that is why he was being fired, all the evidence points to that. How is it pretty clear that he was NOT fired for the video??
- solarkraft 4y agoThe main argument is that it doesn't seem plausible. As in "they can't be this crazy". Maybe they are, but a lot of commenters seem to have had experiences making the "they already wanted him gone" scenario seem more likely. Of course he's going to exploit this given reason even if he doesn't believe it either because it's the best way to get attention and even fame. Quite a few people have become prominent alt-right figures after such situations.
- LeroyRaz 4y agoIt is not inclusive to fire people for making jokes or writing books outside of work. It is active exclusion. It might be justified as trading one exclusion for another. But the act of firing like that is exclusionry, and think that that is rarely acknowledged. There is no consistency in "I tolerate all but intolerance." Rohan Atkinson has a wonderful speach on this.
- mandeepj 4y ago> "I tolerate all but intolerance." Rohan Atkinson "Rowan" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BiqDZlAZygU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BiqDZlAZygU
- EricE 4y agoEliminating racism via Noble Bigotry.
- _8j50 4y agoOr private company didn't want a goofball representing them as a public figure. Perhaps it should be illegal to fire people when their mistake is racism related?
- _8j50 4y agoYes, yes... not for an executive. This is like my third comment on this thread explaining this simple fact. Public company figures can get fired for doing anything at all that doesn't feel right to their bosses/shareholders because that is the nature of their job. Even if this wasn't a public platform post with his consent and someone broke into his home and caught him making a terrible dad joke, c suite or the board can say "nah, we don't want this guy representing us, he is goofy" and fire him. And for those that whine about how execs are paid too much, now you know one more reason why.
- Dig1t 4y agoYeah I have to agree that this is pretty egregious. This is the very definition of the chilling effect people are worried about with cancel culture. Now that everyone has a camera in their pocket we all have to make sure any joke or movie quote we utter is censored and politically correct.
- cmiller1 4y agoCancel culture is just a rightwing buzz word for "people on twitter said I was a racist because I was screaming the N word at arby's and it hurt my feelings"
- Dig1t 4y agoWell dismissing someone because they use a phrase that's associated with people you don't like is not a very constructive way to have a discussion. (note: I am not a right winger, just think its absurd to dismiss a statement like that) Do you really believe that every time someone has been cancelled that they were screaming the N word at Arby's? There's a massive list of people who have been cancelled for doing something far less egregious than screaming slurs in Arby's, making a bad joke, phrasing something incorrectly, phrases taken out of context are all examples of things that have happened to people who were cancelled. Most of the time these people who are cancelled very obviously do NOT have malicious intent. There's an episode of Family Guy where Brian the dog gets cancelled for making a bad joke on Twitter, it very neatly demonstrates what people mean when they say "cancel culture". The death threats, calls for him to kill himself, "bigot", "fascist", harassment at home/work, though an exaggeration in the show, are all examples of things that happen in real life to people who have made mistakes I'm talking about. I would be happy to list people who have been cancelled for saying the wrong thing, even when they obviously did not have malicious intent, though I think it's very easy to find using Google. If you honestly believe that only hateful Nazis get cancelled please to tell me and I will respond with a follow up message listing people who are obviously NOT Nazis that have been cancelled.
- _8j50 4y agoOnly if you're a public figure.
- ThePowerOfFuet 4y agohttps://archive.ph/lgSIP https://archive.ph/lgSIP