4 ms·
I'm a finitist, and believe the integers have the same cardinality as the reals
- _kulang 4y agoDude doesn’t believe in infinite sequences, but how many reals are between zero and one?
- floxy 4y agoIs there a finite or unbounded amount of mass-energy in our universe?
- smaddox 4y agoHe clarifies that infinite sequences are valid, but all infinites are countable. It's an appealing view. Rather than the reals being uncountably infinite, they're countably infinite. Irrational numbers are uncomputable, but all rational numbers can be described, and therefore counted.
- feoren 4y agoThe integers don't have the same cardinality as the reals, full stop. It comes from the definition of real numbers, and if you don't accept it, then you're not talking about the same real numbers that everybody else is. What this person is actually saying is "I don't believe real numbers exist". Okay, and? Does the number 4 really exist? Like, really exist? Who cares!? It's useful! Most mathematicians actually don't care whether something "exists" in some absolute-truth sense, and certainly not whether it physically exists in our universe or not. They use the word "exist" a lot, but in a slightly different way; the use it to mean something like "can this set of constraints ever be satisfied?" All models are wrong, but some models are useful. Whether those models exist in any real sense is pointless philosophical masturbation.
- dTal 4y agoObligatory: https://qntm.org/pseudomathematics https://qntm.org/pseudomathematics >>Point nine recurring equals one because the people who operate under the assumption that point nine recurring equals one are real mathematicians who accomplish real maths, and the people who believe otherwise are to a man gawking, wrong-headed bystanders who have no business playing with concepts they don't understand, and who have accomplished no significant mathematics. At all. The people who are right are the people whose beliefs haven't led to the undermining and collapse of all mathematics. The people who are wrong do not matter. Be quiet. Adults are working.
- vba616 4y ago"The people who are right are the people whose beliefs haven't led to the undermining and collapse of all mathematics." If this is a criterion for determining who is right, then it implies there is an imaginable alternative. There has to be a counterfactual in order to make a meaningful statement about a fact. If we say "X is blue" then there must be such a thing, at least hypothetically, as a color that is not blue. But I can't imagine beliefs leading "to the undermining and collapse of all mathematics" much less those beliefs being "right". (now I looked at the link, and I think I wish whoever this is would focus their venom more squarely at the "placebo effect" which, when explicitly studied or invoked, is an anti-scientific cancer)
- kelipso 4y agoYou get to a contradiction if you assume a/b = sqrt(2) where a,b integers using just algebra no? No bijection between rationals and real, so uncountable. Not sure where other assumptions come in but don't remember Cantors diagonal argument.
- floxy 4y agoYou may, or may not enjoy chapter 5: https://arxiv.org/pdf/math/0404335.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/math/0404335.pdf ..."Why should I believe in a real number if I can’t calculate it, if I can’t prove what its bits are, and if I can’t even refer to it? And each of these things happens with probability one! The real line from 0 to 1 looks more and more like a Swiss cheese, more and more like a stunningly black high-mountain sky studded with pin-pricks of light."
- magic_hamster 4y agoYou can reject Cantor, but ultimately, it doesn't matter. The question is which problems does it solve if you do. If rejection of the diagonal argument leads you to a massive discovery, science will follow, this is the scientific method. But so far, nobody was able to do anything impressive by going this way.