7 ms·
Organ donations, transplants increase on days of largest motorcycle rallies
- daVe23hu 4y agoguess riders should wear helmets to avoid shock trauma
- radu_floricica 4y agoI'd guess most of the difference comes from drinking. I mean, you can hardly expect large events like these to be dry, but the combination is absolutely horrible from a safety point of view.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoBike rallies are generally large, crowded events that take place in rural areas or small towns with traffic infrastructure intended for much smaller populations and far less traffic, the researchers noted... The seven motorcycle rallies in the study each draw more than 200,000 visitors over the course of several days. Hardly surprising to me. I paid accident claims for a few years. One vehicle, low speed car crash and people wanted us to pay their physical therapy/chiro treatments. One vehicle, low speed motorcycle crash and people wanted us to pay their surgery. I will note once again that I wish we would do more to find other answers. Organ donation gets called "the gift of life" but some people reject the donated organs and die slowly and gruesomely over a period of weeks. If they don't reject them, it's crazy expensive, very hard on the body and you will be on anti-rejection drugs the rest of your life. I'm not against saving lives and giving people a second chance. I just think this is a procedure that gets a lot of hype and it takes away from us pursuing something that might be better overall but just can't compete in the click-bait headline department.
- waterhouse 4y ago> I just think this is a procedure that gets a lot of hype and it takes away from us pursuing something that might be better overall Growing organs from your DNA seems like the thing that would clearly work, if it could be done. Seems people are working on it. Some google results talk about growing those organs in genetically-modified pigs (!). Don't know how far away it is.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoThat's not at all the kind of alternative I have in mind and would be of essentially zero use in cases of organ transplant for people with genetic disorders. (Edit: For example, cystic fibrosis accounted for a third of all adult lung transplants in the US and half of all pediatric lung transplants last I checked.)
- waterhouse 4y agoWould it really? If you're doing genetic engineering already and you know what the genetic disorder is, it seems like you could then engineer a version of your DNA without the disorder and grow an organ from that.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoIt would, by definition, at that point no longer be identical to your DNA. I have no idea if at that point you risk rejection, etc.
- pkaye 4y agoI think if the new DNA kept the DNA encoding for the HLA markers there wouldn't be any rejection risk. HLA markers allow the immune system to tell which cells belong to your own body. When they do transplants, they check for HLA compatibility much as possible.
- andrewflnr 4y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThere is a reason doctors call them "donor cycles".
- andrewflnr 4y agoI wonder how many if those accidents have alcohol involved, and if that matters to a transplant. Do they even check? I don't remember the number, but some ludicrous fraction of motorcycle crashes are caused in part by a rider who was drinking.
- blaaaaa99a 4y agoA typical organ donor has a severe head injury causing brain death, however generally the liver and kidneys are intact and metabolize alcohol fine. Even if they didn't, alcohol in the organs/blood is unlikely to have a signficant effect for the beneficiary.
- kelnos 4y agoNot surprising. I remember a friend trained to be an EMT many years ago, and the textbook had a (long) chapter specifically about motorcycle crashes. Put a bunch of motorcycles in one area (probably an area with roads that aren't designed for that kind of traffic) and you're bound to see more crashes than usual. And because they're motorcycles, expect more of them to be fatalities than you'd expect with cars. I also expect there's alcohol involved in many of these rallies, regardless of the legality or official policy of the organizers, with a lot of people in no condition to be on their bikes.
- davidthewatson 4y agoThe statistical pattern noted at large rallies is likely repeatable at places like the dragon in the Smokies on a busy summer weekend. No rally necessary - the combination of roads, terrain, and participants predicts the result. In a similar way, a simple query of participants would predict the result: 1. Do you drink alcohol on days when riding a motorcycle? 2. Have you had professional training on your motorcycle, sponsored by your state or otherwise? 3. Have you read a motorcycle safety book by David Hough? 4. Do you follow published guidance on motorcycle safety gear? https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/what-we-wear-p1-david-l-hough/?forceNoSplash=true&src=aff-ref&trk=aff-ir_progid.8005_partid.10078_sid._adid.449670&clickid=0ChVe71mPxyNT-KyI53LzzeXUkAxH5zZI2C10g0&mcid=6851962469594763264&irgwc=1 https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/what-we-wear-p1-david-l-hough... The one downside to state training programs is that if the populace senses that completion of the program is a rubber-stamp license, safety behavior that follows will not match expectations. There were at least a few accidents during licensing at my state-subsidized training and licensing twenty years ago that didn't bode well for the required performance, the safety of the rider on public roads, or the system that licenses people.
- dsfyu404ed 4y ago>The one downside to state training programs is that if the populace senses that completion of the program is a rubber-stamp license And if the license isn't just a rubber stamp people will ride without them. People who self select to ride a motorcycle are not as unquestionably law abiding to their own inconvicnence as the general public let alone subsets like HN.
- citboin 4y agoDonorcycles.
- Gatsky 4y agoIf you were designing a vehicle to help harvest organs, you would want a high chance of causing blunt head trauma but avoid major organ damage. You would also want the victim to be thrown well clear of the vehicle to enable quick access for resuscitation, and to avoid smoke inhalation or conflagration. You would also want this vehicle to be highly attractive to fit and healthy young people. Namely, a motorcycle.
- jgilias 4y agoWhen I did my bike license the instructor outlined how different the approach to safety is between my EU country and the States. Here a helmet is required to drive. But not glasses. In US glasses are required, but no helmet. Meaning, the US cares about you not endangering other people, but you do you, whereas here they care about you not dying. From a purely utilitarian perspective, the US approach actually makes more sense. And more donors. Win-win.
- pferdone 4y ago> the US cares about you not endangering other people Through their rigorous license process to operate road vehicles…yeah right.
- lazyasciiart 4y agoThe US cares about you not damaging or inconveniencing cars.
- nirui 4y agoAnd this, makes all the dark humor in this thread even more dark.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoDriving is state regulated. Most states require a helmet on a motorcycle. In general anyone making "in the US" type generalizations about stuff regulated at the state level is either misinformed and blowing smoke up your ass (more common in real life) or lying in order to support a point or agenda (more common on the internet).
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoI know it's a bit offtopic, but why is being a donor an opt-in instead of an opt-out process? In our country, every employee has to pass a medical exam every ~3 years, and the same for college students. We could implement the opt-out option, give a grace period of eg. 5 years, where everyone could be explicitily asked if they want to opt-out (just sign this form) at a medical institution (or mail in, or sign a form online), and after that, everyone not opted out would become a donor. I don't care what happens to my organs after I die, but I'm one of the many who are to lazy to actually go to a proper place to fill out a proper form to become a donor.
- brigandish 4y agoBecause opt-out implies that my body is not my property nor my heirs but the property of the state upon my death (and possibly before), whereas the opposite is true for opt-in. Like most rights and freedoms, opt-in protects me legally better than opt-out but makes life more difficult for the group if people use their freedoms selfishly. I would never opt-in to opt-out because I value freedom and want humans to do the difficult bit of persuasion and education instead of coercion and the nasty ramifications that can come of the state getting even a camel's nose inside the tent of owning my body (and thus the right to do things to that body). Pick any freedom/right you like and it'll be like this, whether it's speech or guns or right to silence or right to a lawyer, bodily autonomy against vaccine mandates or bodily autonomy in getting abortions… freedom is just so inconvenient for those who want what's best for the collective, but never mind the individuals who get crushed along the way to utopia. So no thanks (and that includes your generous offer of a time limited opt-out).
- saiya-jin 4y agoWell no, if you are actually truly in your heart subscribed to any major religion, after your death its not 'your' body anymore, just some leftover soon-to-rot garbage on the level of trimmed nails or cut hair, nothing more. In fact, its rotting garbage regardless of your beliefs, nature doesn't care about those pesky things. The other side is about saving actual lives in no small numbers, so what OP describes are tons of lives saved by just amending bureaucracy slightly, while preserving all those 'freedoms' that people like you keep repeating ad nausea anytime anything worthy is discussed. If you actually really care about those freedoms, doing 2 minute bureaucratic work (or 5 seconds) every 5 years is no brainer. But if you just have knee jerk reactions to any change, well thats another problem on your side that is no concern to rest of society.